Home | News Online | Publications | Analyses | Observatories | Database | SEMDOC | Journal | Support our work | Join Statewatch news e-mail list
What's New on the Statewatch website - archive
What's New archives:1999 | 2000 | 2001 | 2002 | 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015: Jan-Jun, July-Dec | 2016: Jan-Jun, Jul-Oct, Nov-Dec
Carries all items that have been added or updated from News Online, News Digest and Observatories
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (30.6.16)
GERMANY: Far-right violence rising sharply in Germany
"The number of violent crimes committed in Germany by far-right extremists has risen by over 40 percent in one year, the nation's internal intelligence agency says. In particular, asylum seekers have been targeted...."
CIA RENDITION: Lawyer: CIA gave Romania millions to host secret prisons (New Europe, link):
"The CIA paid Romania millions of dollars to host secret prisons, a rights lawyer said Wednesday as the European Court of Human Rights heard accusations that Romania allowed the agency to torture terrorism suspects in a secret renditions program under President George W. Bush.
Amrit Singh told the court on the opening day of the case that CIA prisons were in Romania from 2003-2005 with the governments acquiescence and connivance, something authorities have denied.
Romanian government representative Catrinel Brumar countered that it takes more than hints and speculation to establish the states responsibilities. She said an investigation was ongoing.
The court said it would rule in a few months on whether Romania knowingly allowed CIA secret prisons where torture occurred, and whether it failed to prevent the torture of Singhs client."
EU-USA: PRIVACY SHIELD: Adoption coming soon
"The European Commission has sent the final draft of the EU-US Privacy Shield to national representatives and expect to get a yay or nay next Monday with a view to adopting the implementing act one day later on July 5.
Sources from the Article 31 group told Ars last week that they did not want to be rushed, but the Commission clearly has other ideas. The text, seen by Ars, has also been sent to the European Parliament who can give their opinion, but cant actually block it."
BREXIT: UK-FRANCE: What will Brexit mean for migrants, Calais and the Franco-British border? (RFI, link):
"Following Britain's vote to leave the European Union some French politicians are challenging the Le Touquet agreement, which in 2003 moved Britain's border with France to the French side of the Channel. So what will Brexit mean for the Franco-British border and the migrants camped on it?
Does Brexit changes anything regarding the Le Touquet agreement?"
BREXIT: UK-IRELAND: The English have placed a bomb under the Irish peace process by Fintan O'Toole (Guardian, link):
"Recklessly, casually, with barely a thought, English nationalists have planted a bomb under the settlement that brought peace to Northern Ireland and close cordiality to relations between Britain and Ireland. To do this seriously and soberly would have been bad. To do it so carelessly, with nothing more than a pat on the head and a reassurance that everything will be all right, is frankly insulting......
What will now happen is not that the old border will come back. Its much worse than that. The old border marked the line between neighbouring polities that had a common travel area and an intimate, if often fraught, relationship. It was a customs barrier. The new border will be the most westerly land frontier of a vast entity of more than 400 million people, and it will be an immigration (as well as a customs) barrier."
LUXEMBOURG: LuxLeaks whistleblowers guilty verdicts 'a disgrace' (The Parliament, link):
"Antoine Deltour and Raphaël Halet, the whistleblowers who lifted the lid on the 'LuxLeaks' scandal, have been found guilty of stealing documents, revealing business secrets and violating trade secrets."
Facebook wins privacy case against Belgian data protection authority (Reuters, link):
"he Belgian data protection authority on Wednesday lost a legal battle with Facebook in which it sought to stop the social network from tracking the online activities of non-Facebook users in Belgium who visit the social network's pages.
The Belgian Privacy Commission said the Brussels Appeals Court had dismissed its case on the grounds that the regulator has no jurisdiction over Facebook Inc, which has its European headquarters in Ireland."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (28-29.6.16)
Terrorism Database Used by Governments and Banks Leaked Online (VICE, link):
"A researcher has obtained a copy of Thomson Reuters' World-Check confidential intelligence database, which is used by governments, intelligence agencies, banks, law firms and more to scope out risks including suspected terrorists. It was likely left exposed on the open internet by a third party....
We monitor over 530 sanction, watch and regulatory law and enforcement lists, and hundreds of thousands of information sources, often identifying heightened-risk entities months or years before they are listed. In fact, in 2012 alone we identified more than 180 entities before they appeared on the US Treasury Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) list based on reputable sources identifying relevant risks....
It includes the categories political individual, corporate, military, crimenarcotics, and terrorism."
See: Thomson Reuters World-Check (link)
Background: VICE News Reveals the Terrorism Blacklist Secretly Wielding Power Over the Lives of Millions (link)
EU: GERMANY & FRANCE PUSH FOR EU DRIVE AGAINST "ITINERANT CRIME GROUPS": German and French delegations: Draft European initiative to prevent and combat organised domestic burglary (LIMITE doc no: 6876-15, pdf):
"In recent years, there has been a considerable increase in property crimes committed in Europe by highly mobile organised crime groups. The interim SOCTA for 2015 estimates 1.000 offences per day.
The following can be said about the situation regarding domestic burglary in Europe:
The increase in the number of domestic burglaries is attributable to itinerant crime groups originating mainly from South-Eastern and Eastern Europe. They belong to the field of organised crime or are considered one step away from organised crime.
They have transnational organisational structures. They are flexible and able to adapt to countermeasures taken by individual states. To fight these networks effectively concerted action at European level is necessary.....
Itinerant crime generates a sense of insecurity for European citizens that leads them to doubt the ability of EU law enforcement
authorities to effectively tackle this scourge....
The new technology of predictive policing delivers promising new results and contributes to a better use of resources"
This is not the first time that the EU has targeted "itinerant" crime groups: See: Targeting Roma: How the EU security apparatus is mobilised for the "fight against itinerant crime" (Statewatch News Online, March 2012)
EUROPE: Stop evictions of Roma and Travellers - International organisations stress human cost of evictions and recall standards in a joint statement
"Strasbourg, 29 June 2016 Traditionally, summer holidays coincide with the eviction of Roma and Travellers throughout Europe, which takes place almost unnoticed. The Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) and the OSCEs Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights (OSCE/ODIHR) join the Council of Europe, the European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights (FRA), the European Network of European National Human Rights Institutions (ENNHRI) and the European Network of Equality Bodies (Equinet) in a statement to condemn the recent evictions of Roma and Travellers in Europe."
New Europol regulation due to enter into force from May 2017 oversight is likely to remain superficial (Matthias Monroy, link)
"On 1 May 2017, the new regulation on Europol will enter into force. The compromise agreed on in the framework of the trilogue procedure lays down new more detailed provisions on oversight of the activities of Europol by the European Parliament. Article 88 (2), sentence 3 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union provides for the national Parliaments to be more closely involved with this scrutiny. Article 51 of the regulation mentions the establishment of a Joint Parliamentary Scrutiny Group (JPSG). The European Parliament had lobbied hard during the trilogue procedure to achieve this. The Group is to consist of Members of the European Parliament and the national Parliaments. Yet it is unclear how this will work in practice."
UK: Draft undercover policing guidance published
"The draft guidance says undercover operatives can only work once they have been accredited by the professional body, which involves going through a selection process and undergoing vetting and specialist training.
There are two types of undercover operative:
An undercover foundation operative carries out low-level infiltration that does not require the ability to withstand intense scrutiny by people who are potentially suspicious. For example, buying drugs on the street.
An undercover advanced operative is trained to undertake deployments involving higher-level infiltrations and they must be able to withstand intense scrutiny from anyone who may be suspicious. For example, counter terrorism work.
The draft guidance sets out clearly the roles and responsibilities of police officers from those who are deployed on operations, to those who supervise and manage undercover officers and authorise operations."
UK: Hate crime is unacceptable in any circumstances say police (National Police Chiefs Council, link):
"The vast majority of people are continuing to go about their lives in safety and security and there have been no major spikes in tensions reported but we are monitoring an increase in reports to our online reporting website...
There has been an of 57% increase in reporting to True Vision since Friday compared to this time last month"
UK-EU: Why EU data protection will still apply to post-Brexit UK (Computer Weekly, link):
"The General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) is expected to come in to force for EU member states in early 2018. It could be some time later that year that the UK finally severs its links with the EU. So for UK citizens will the GDPR be a short-lived regulation that can largely be ignored? The answer is no and the reasons fairly obvious; they are commercial, legal and moral."
European Council: 28-29 June: Draft Conclusions (LIMITE doc no: 8471-16, pdf):
"the return of migrants to Turkey in full respect of the provisions on inadmissibility under the Asylum Procedures Directive..."
Comment: The problem with the Asylum Procedures Directive is that is based on the lowest possible standards and does not requite third countries to implement the 1951 Geneva Convention standards and protections.
"In the Central Mediterranean, flows of predominantly economic migrants remain at the same level as last year..." [emphasis added]
Comment: People arriving from north Africa are refugees.
"fast and operational returns of irregular migrants, including by applying temporary arrangements, pending the conclusion of full-fledged readmission agreements."
Comment: To be based on the use of "leverage", that is, threats to withdraw development aid and trade if not compliant to EU demands
UK-EU: Brexit and the Northern Ireland border (New Europe, link):
"In preparation for the UKs departure from the European Union, British Prime Minister David Cameron said talks are to begin with the Irish government on the challenges over the border.
As reported by The Belfast Telegraph, Cameron also said the EU exit negotiations will involve Northern Ireland, alongside the Scottish and Welsh administrations. But since he announced his resignation, the negotiations will be undertaken by his successor."
German lawsuit accuses Turkey of 'war crimes' in military operations against Kurds (DW, link):
"The lawsuit accuses top Turkish officials including President Erdogan of 'war crimes.' While largely symbolic, the lawsuit adds to a growing list of contentious issues between Turkey and Germany."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (27.6.16): NGOs call for EU migration plan rethink; unaccompanied minors in hotspots; EU travel document and boder guard deals; refugee centre on Lesvos closed down; Hungarian referendum on relocation quotas to go ahead; and more.
Over 100 NGOs to European Council: don't try to curb migration at the expense "of fundamental values and human rights"
"The European Union is set to open a dark chapter in its history unless it rejects the European Commissions proposal on migration, a coalition of more than 100 NGOs warned on Monday. Shifting towards a foreign policy that serves the single objective of curbing migration, the EU and its member states risk further undermining their credibility and authority in the defence of human rights, the organizations say. They call on European leaders to reject the Commission proposal that would cement this approach, making deterrence and return of people the main objective of the EUs relationship with third countries."
See the statement: Joint NGO statement ahead of the European Council of 28-29 June 2016: NGOs strongly condemn new EU policies to contain migration (pdf)
EU: Eurojust continues work on "judicial response to the phenomenon of foreign terrorist fighters"
"On 22 and 23 June, Eurojust gathered for the fourth consecutive year its national correspondents for terrorism matters to continue exchanging views on the best way forward in building an effective judicial response to the phenomenon of foreign terrorist fighters. Participants at the tactical meeting also included specialised counter-terrorism prosecutors from the Member States and third States, the EU Counter-Terrorism Coordinator, the head of the European Counter Terrorism Centre at Europol and the Director of the EU Intelligence and Situation Centre (INTCEN). The meeting was chaired by Ms Michèle Coninsx, President of Eurojust and Chair of Eurojusts Counter-Terrorism Team."
SWITZERLAND: Anti-torture Committee calls for prison reforms and an end to police drug squad brutality
A report on a visit to Switzerland in April 2015 by the Council's of Europe's anti-torture Committee calls for the country to question the use of life imprisonment, to improve conditions in a number of prisons - particularly for remand prisoners in Champ-Dollon prison, who spend "23 hours a day in their cell" - and for an "in-depth and independent investigation" into the work of the Geneva canton drugs task force. The Committee found that the task force has been accused of violence including "punches, kicks and even truncheon blows, sometimes to blindfolded persons."
Report (French only): Rapport au Conseil fédéral suisse relatif à la visite effectuée en Suisse par le Comité européen pour la prévention de la torture et des peines ou traitements inhumains ou dégradants (CPT) du 13 au 24 avril 2015 (pdf) and: Government response (French only, pdf)
Council of Europe: Parliamentary Assembly calls for more EU transparency
The Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) has adopted a resolution calling for transparency in EU institutions to be improved in a number of ways: ensuring full access to documents; joining the Council of Europe's anti-corruption body; and better tracking of lobbying efforts.
Resolution 2125 (2016): Transparency and openness in EU institutions (pdf)
EU: Border and coast guard: consolidated text of proposed Regulation
This is the text agreed in an informal deal between negotiators from the Parliament, Council and Commission last week. The Parliament's Civil Liberties Committee will vote on the text today.
See: REGULATION (EU) 2016/ OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL of on the European Border and Coast Guard and repealing Regulation (EC) No 2007/2004, Regulation (EC) No 863/2007 and Council Decision 2005/267/EC and amending Regulation (EU) 2016/399 (pdf)
UK: Brexit: Wave of hate crime and racial abuse reported after EU referendum (The Independent, link): "More than a hundred incidents of racial abuse and hate crime have been reported since the UK voted to leave the European Union.
Many of the alleged perpetrators cited the decision to leave the EU explicitly.
One video, purportedly filmed in Hackney on the morning after the referendum, shows a man arguing with someone in a car before yelling: Go back to your country.
A Facebook album entitled "Worrying Signs" has been created to document alleged incidents in which people have been targeted with xenophobic comments."
See also: Racist Incidents Have U.K. Worried What Referendum Wrought (Bloomberg, link) and Hate Incidents After European Referendum Results: A Compilation (The Muslim Council of Britain, link)
News Digest: round-up of news stories from across Europe (24.6.16)
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (23.6.16)
EU: New handbook on European law and access to justice
The EU's Fundamental Rights Agency has published a new handbook that "summarises the key European legal principles in the area of access to justice, focusing on civil and criminal law." It:
"seeks to raise awareness of the relevant legal standards set by the European Union (EU) and the Council of Europe, particularly through the case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union and the European Court of Human Rights. The handbook is designed to serve as a practical guide for lawyers, judges and other legal practitioners involved in litigation in the EU and in Council of Europe member states, as well as for individuals who work for non-governmental organisations and other entities that deal with the administration of justice."
See the report: Handbook on European law relating to access to justice: English and French (pdfs) and: the Fundamental Rights Agency webpage (link).
UK: Supreme Court finds migrant workers not protected by discrimination laws (Free Movement, link): "In short the court concludes that immigration status as a domestic worker is not a protected characteristic under the Equality Act 2010. The court suggests that the law should be amended to remedy this protection gap and refers to the particular vulnerability of migrants on tied visas and the review of the type of visa in 2015"
See: Supreme Court press summary (pdf): "The issue in these appeals is whether the mistreatment of migrant domestic workers who are vulnerable because of their precarious immigration status amounts to direct or indirect race discrimination."
And: Judgment: Taiwo (Appellant) v Olaigbe and another (Respondents) - Onu (Appellant) v Akwiwu and another (Respondents) (pdf)
UK: UNDERCOVER POLICING: Police must say if dead children's identities stolen, say parents (The Guardian, link): "Bereaved parents have demanded that police reveal whether the identities of their dead children were stolen by undercover officers who spied on political groups.
One of the parents told a public inquiry on Wednesday she had been left quite sick by the uncertainty over whether police had used the identity of her son who had died at the age of 15-months. Another parent whose son had died at two-days-old said she had suffered profound emotional turmoil and anger.
In a practice that was kept secret for decades, undercover officers stole the identities of dead children to help develop the fictitious personas that they used when they spied on political groups. This was done without the consent or knowledge of the parents."
And see: Met's undercover unit 'exaggerated its success to secure funds' (The Guardian, link) and: 460 groups spied upon ? (Undercover Research Group, link)
EU: European Border and Coast Guard: Parliament and Council compromise position
On 22 June negotiators from the European Parliament and the Council of the EU reached an "informal agreement" on the text for a Regulation establishing a European Border and Coast Guard, which will upgrade the Frontex agency with an increased role in returns, greater access to technical equipment, more powers for liaison officers and new possibilities for the Council to reintroduce border controls where states refuse to accept asssistance from the new agency.
A leaked copy of the text (pdf, html) sets out the positions of the institutions and the compromise text, which will be voted on by the Parliament's Civil Liberties Committee on 27 June and, if they agree to it, by the full Parliament in July.
Macedonia charges protesters in 'Colourful Revolution' (Al Jazeera, link):
"When dozens of angry demonstrators ransacked the presidential office in the Macedonian capital in early April, the windows were shattered and furniture set ablaze.
Zdravko Saveski, a 39-year-old member of the leftist Levica party's presidential committee, insisted that he did not participate in damaging the building or the furniture.
Yet he was charged with participation in a mob and destroying state property and placed under house arrest for more than 50 days during the police investigation.
A former political science professor and trade unionist-turned-organiser, Saveski is among at least 34 demonstrators who have been dealt charges since mass anti-corruption protests broke out in early April, according to local activists."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (22.6.16)
European Court of Human Rights: Grand Chamber hearing concerning the confinement and return to Tunisia of irregular migrants who arrived in Italy by sea (Press release, pdf):
"The case concerns the detention in a reception centre on Lampedusa and subsequently on ships moored in Palermo harbour, as well as the return to Tunisia, of clandestine migrants who had landed on the Italian coast in 2011 during the events linked to the Arab Spring....
The applicants, Saber Ben Mohamed Ben Ali Khlaifia, Fakhreddine Ben Brahim Ben Mustapha Tabal and Mohamed Ben Habib Ben Jaber Sfar, are Tunisian nationals who were born in 1983, 1987 and 1988 respectively. Mr Khlaifia lives in Om Laarass (Tunisia) and Mr Tabal and Mr Sfar live in El Mahdia (Tunisia)....
On 1 February 2016 the case was referred to the Grand Chamber at the request of the Italian Government"
See also Statewatch Analysis: ECtHR/Italy: Khlaifa judgment reveals illegal detention and collective expulsion practices in Italys treatment of Tunis ians in 2011 (pdf)
EU: Border Guard: European Border and Coast Guard agreed: European Commission - Press release: The European Parliament, Council and Commission have reached an agreement, endorsed by the Council today, on the Commission's proposal on a European Border and Coast Guard (Press release, pdf):
"The European Parliament, Council and Commission have reached an agreement, endorsed by the Council today, on the Commission's proposal on a European Border and Coast Guard, paving the way for the reinforced Agency to be up and running starting this summer. The European Border and Coast Guard will combine a new reinforced Agency, building on the foundations laid by Frontex, with the ability to draw on a reserve pool of people and equipment."
See: Background documentation: Regulation on a European Border and Coast Guard Agency (Statewatch SEMDOC)
EU: Rightwing 'lone wolves' kill more than Islamists acting alone, says report - Thinktank says far-right lone attacks present bigger threat despite media and public focus on Islamist extremists (Guardian, link):
"he Royal United Services Institute (RUSI) in London says in its report Countering Lone Actor Terrorism that rightwing extremists across Europe present a substantial threat to the public that should not be overlooked.
It details the cases of 94 people who were killed and 260 who were injured in attacks by far-right terrorists acting on their own between the start of 2000 and the end of 2014. In contrast, religiously inspired lone attacks killed 16 and injured 65 people."
European Parliament: Plan to check EU citizens at external borders backed by civil liberties MEPs (Press release, pdf)
"An EU Commission plan to systematically check all EU citizens entering or leaving the EU was endorsed by Civil Liberties Committee MEPs on Tuesday. Members amended the proposal to enable member states to run targeted checks, as an exception, in the event of lengthy delays and provided that security is not at risk."
See: Civil liberties MEPs back border checks for EU citizens (New Europe, link): "The text, drafted by European Conservatives and Reformists (ECR) MEP Monica Macovei, was approved by 48 votes to 6 with 0 abstentions. It notes that systematically checking all EU citizens, as well as family members with third country nationalities, against EU-wide and national internal security databases, or those listing lost or stolen travel documents, would make it easier to apprehend travellers trying to hide their real identities. The databases include Interpols Stolen and Lost Travel Documents database (SLTD) and the Schengen Information System."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (21.6.16)
Rosa Luxembourg Stiftung: A love-hate relationship - Far-right parties and the European Union (link)
"This publication analyzes the success and danger posed by the right-wing populist parties in the EU. It outlines the broad spectrum of parties on the right of the conservative European People's Party (EPP) and lights their organization in the EU Parliament and networks. What are the weaknesses and problems of the right-wing parties in the formation of a stable alliance? What are their effects and what are their electoral promises and topics? The EU, by contrast, is presented as the embodiment as everything politically negative and as such has become the chief reference framework of right-wing populism. Sometimes there are overlaps between right populists in the EU and representatives of the Russian establishment."
See: The full report (pdf) by Thilo Janssen
And see: European support for far right extremism reaches 1930s scale by Nafeez Ahmed (link)
UK: House of Commons report: Cyber Security: Protection of Personal Data Online (pdf):
"Although the TalkTalk cyber-attack in October 2015 was the trigger for this inquiry, it is essential to put this attack in context. Cyber-crime is a significant and growing problem and affects all sectors with an on-line platform or service. As the British Business Federation Authority said in their evidence to the Committee:
The TalkTalk incident is one of many that have happened and continue to happen. To consider it in isolation of others would be misleading. The overall context is complex and changing fast... The problem space is international."
EU-TURKEY: New information platform on EU-Turkey migration policy launched: A critical monitoring of the EU-Turkey deal is absolutely necessary (pdf): "While the EU is intensifying its cooperation with Turkey regarding border surveillance and deterrence, there is a lack of independent analysis and information on politics and practices onsite. The critical civil society of Turkey is facing practices of intimidation, making independent research and media reporting more and more difficult. At the same time, the importance of Turkey for the European border regime is growing rapidly.
In the situation we are facing right now, we feel that it is crucial to establish a critical and free source of information, which aims at strengthening the power of civil society, explains Lülüfer Körükmez. Activists and the interested public, as well as researchers and journalists should use the information provided by HarekAct to follow, initiate and comment on recent debates, discourses and activities around migration policies."
See: HarekAct (link): "This blog-project is the collective work of a group of researchers and (no border) activists from Turkey, Austria and Germany active in networks such as kritnet (Network for Critical Migration and Border Regime Studies), GAR (Migration Researchers Platform, Turkey), Mülteci-Der, borderline-europe, and bordermonitoring.eu."
And see: Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (20.6.16): Greece "enlightened" on asylum appeals committees by other EU governments; EP Foreign Affairs Committee opinion on EU safe third countries list; Austria to help Hungary "secure" border; and more.
EU Annual Report on Human Rights and Democracy in the World in 2015 Thematic Part (10255/16, 20 June 2016, pdf): "Delegations will find in the annex the EU Annual Report on Human Rights and Democracy in the World in 2015 Thematic Part, adopted by the Council at its 3477th meeting held on 20 June 2016."
EU: Improving "information management and the cross-border exchange of information, including interoperability of systems"
"The security and migratory challenges are complex and interconnected. Efforts to tackle them are already undertaken between the various JHA domains for example, an effective border-management as an integrated part of the EUs security architecture to address illegal immigration, terrorism and crime.
The Presidency has taken the ambitious initiative to set up a Roadmap with necessary actions to improve information management and the cross-border exchange of information, including interoperability of systems. The purpose is to support operational investigations, especially in counter-terrorism - realising there is a close connection between terrorism and crime - and to swiftly provide front-line practitioners such as police officers, border guards, public prosecutors, immigration officers and others with comprehensive, topical and high-quality information to cooperate and act effectively.
This Roadmap, being a living document, provides a coherent framework for a more integrated EU information architecture7 in the JHA area, and includes an analysis of key JHA broad challenges, principles and horizontal guidelines and a way forward to monitor and follow-up on the actions in the Roadmap (Chapter 1). It also includes dedicated information exchange and information management actions in the following domains taking into account the differences in legal framework of those areas:
law enforcement including judicial cooperation in criminal matters (Chapter 2),
detection of persons involved in terrorism and their travel movements (Chapter 3),
border management and migration (Chapter 4);"
See: Council of the European Union: NOTE from: Presidency to: Council: Roadmap to enhance information exchange and information management including interoperability solutions in the Justice and Home Affairs area (9368/1/16 REV 1, 6 June 2016, pdf)
EU: Operation Sophia: Anti-smuggling operation extended for a year and given two new tasks
The EU's Foreign Affairs Council has approved a one-year extension of the mandate of Operation Sophia, the EU military mission in the Mediterranean that was launched with the aim of hampering migrant smuggling. Following the approval of a UN Security Council Resolution last week, the operation will now also take on two new tasks: training the Libyan coastguard and navy and implementing a UN arms embargo on the high seas off the Libyan coast.
EU: International operation CICONIA ALBA kicks off to crack down on organised crime (Europol press release, pdf): "The EU Member States, EU bodies and third partners have once again joined forces with Europol in this years Operation CICONIA ALBA to counter organised crime networks involved in the priority crime areas.
Following the successful 2014 Archimedes and 2015 Blue Amber operations, Operation CICONIA ALBA is the third series of joint action days (JADs) covered by the 2013 2017 EU Policy Cycle targeting serious international and organised crime. Operation CICONIA ALBA focuses on key crime hot spots and key criminal infrastructures in the EU and beyond."
EU counter-terrorism chief: Understanding of radicalisation has changed (The Parliament, link): "He was speaking on Thursday at an event in the Committee of the Regions in Brussels on efforts to tackle radicalisation.
De Kerchove said that understanding of radicalisation and what drives young Muslims to join groups like Isis has changed.
He said, "In the past, we thought it was a long process and that radicalisation couldn't take place simply online, but now we are seeing teenagers being radicalised on the internet and leaving for Syria after just 15 days."
In a speech, he emphasised the role of criminality in the process, saying, "If we look at the perpetrators of Paris and Brussels, most of them have a criminal past."
He also said that, "perhaps the most interesting part of the Commission's [recent] communications" is that "we need to mainstream counter-violence extremism in many policies, not to be driven by it.""
See: Committee of the Regions press release: Policing alone will not stop terrorists, Europe's cities say (CoR, link): "The political leaders of the European Union's cities and regions have called for greater investment in policies to prevent radicalisation, as well as urging local, national and European authorities to "beef up" border controls and target areas where "various forms of organised crime are rife"."
And: DRAFT OPINION: Combatting radicalisation and violent extremism: prevention mechanisms at local and regional level (pdf)
European Parliament study: Openness, Transparency and the Right of Access to Documents in the EU (pdf): "Upon request of the PETI Committee, the Policy Department on Citizens' Rights and Constitutional Affairs commissioned the present analysis, which examines the situation in relation to openness, transparency, access to documents and information in the EU. Case law and developments in the jurisprudence of the CJEU are examined, notably for legislative documents, documents relating to administrative proceedings, to Court proceedings, infringement proceedings and EU Pilot cases, protection of privacy and international relations. Current and future challenges, as well as conclusions and policy recommendations are set out, in order to ensure compliance with the Treaties and Charter of Fundamental Rights requirements aimed at enhancing citizens participation in the EU decision-making process, and consequently stronger accountability and democracy in the EU."
EU-US: EU biometric data collection welcomed by US
According to the minutes of the most recent EU-US justice and home affairs ministerial meeting, held in Amsterdam on 1 and 2 June, the US: "commended the EU collection of biometric data which had facilitated the fight against terrorism and the work of US law enforcement."
The minutes then note that: "The US offered to cooperate closely with European partners on collected data."
UK: The encroaching border: international students (Right to Remain, link): "The Immigration Act 2016 builds on measures implemented in the Immigration Act 2014 to further incorporate ordinary British citizens into performing the roles of border agents as part of their daily lives. The Acts intend to make migrants feel the presence of the border not just at boundaries between nations, but in the places we occupy on a daily basis: in our banks, places of worship, schools and universities, even our homes. Critical attention must be paid to the ways this Government continues to co-opt the public into covert and pernicious surveillance roles that demand citizens manage, monitor and report on migrants to the Home Office."
And see: A duty to inform? The outsourcing of state surveillance responsibilities to the British public by Max Rowlands (Statewatch Journal; vol 23 no 2 August 2013)
EU: The far-right in the European Parliament: what have they done?
A new analysis by VoteWatch Europe examines the European parliamentary efforts of the far-right group Europe of Nations and Freedom between 1 August 2015 and early June 2016. The group is made up of the National Front (France), Flemish Interest (Belgium), the Northern League (Italy), the Austrian Freedom Party, the Party for Freedom (Netherlands), and the Congress of the New Right (Poland).
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (18-19.6.16)
UK: Mainstream politicians clueless on migration debate, says Jo Cox's husband - Brendan Cox vows to continue work on building international alliance to combat populist rights focus on publics fears (Guardian, link)
"The husband of Jo Cox plans to continue with a project that aims to build an international alliance to combat the dangerous breeding ground of economic insecurity on which the populist right has fed across European politics.
Brendan Cox has let it be known that he is determined to continue with the work in memory of his wife, who was killed on Thursday, but believes this will only succeed if lessons can be learned from why the right has so far taken the initiative on the migration issue."
FRANCE: La Cimades Charter Awards highlight unlawful practices enacted by prefectures against migrants which subordinate the law to immigration policy objectives (pdf): "Detention and expulsion: prefectures awarded prizes for their illegal and abusive practices."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (17.6.16)
News Digest: Roundup of news stories from around the EU (17.6.16)
Illegal detention of migrant children in Switzerland: a status report (Terre Des Hommes, link):
"Children in the context of migration, whether accompanied, separated or unaccompanied should never be remanded in custody. Migratory status should not be considered as an offence and should not justify the detention of children as such. Jean Zermatten, Founder and former director of the International Institute for the Rights of the Child (IDE) and former President of the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child."
Full report: English, German and French (links)
USA: CIA Torture Revelations: Newly Released Documents Show Need for Accountability (HRW,link):
"The recent release of documents related to the US Central Intelligence Agencys detention and interrogation program provide excruciating new details about CIA torture, Human Rights Watch said today. On June 16, 2016, Human Rights Watch sent a letter to President Barack Obama urging him to provide greater accountability for CIA abuses before the end of his term in office.
The newly released documents underscore the brutality and illegality of the CIA program, said Laura Pitter, senior national security counsel at Human Rights Watch. President Obamas failure to take concrete action to address these crimes will leave a stain on his legacy, undermine respect for the rule of law, and weaken US effectiveness in advocating against torture globally."
See: Letter to Obama (pdf):and see Documents Related to the Former Detention and Interrogation Program (link)
European Parliament: Press release: State of emergency in France debated in Civil Liberties Committee (pdf):
"Whilst France is indeed grappling with a difficult security situation, it needs to find adequate long-term solutions, because the terrorist threat is likely to last, argued most MEPs in a Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs Committee debate on Thursday with Ambassador and Frances Permanent representative to the EU Pierre Sellal...
MEPs hoped that the French experience would stimulate reflection allowing sustainable measures, other than exceptions to the state of law which cannot be an end in themselves, and warned against the impact that they have on society."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (16.6.16)
UNDERCOVER POLICE: Inquiry urged into undercover British agent Mark Kennedy Detective suspected of gathering intelligence on environmental groups for superiors in UK (Irish Times, link):
"The Government has been urged to set up a public inquiry into the actions of an undercover British detective who operated in Ireland, spending time with people protesting against Shells construction of a gas pipeline in Mayo.
Belfast legal firm KRW Law has written to the Department of Justice on behalf of its client Sarah Hampton asking it to confirm whether the Garda has ever investigated the actions of the police officer, Mark Kennedy.
Mr Kennedy served with the United Kingdoms National Public Order Intelligence Unit between 2004 and 2010, and operated undercover inside several environmental groups. "
Comment: This adds to ongoing calls for its extension to Scotland and the recent demands for UK officers' activities in Germany to be examined by the inquiry as well.
Appeal for the closure of Detention Centres and HOTSPOTS in Europe! (pdf):
"There are 393 Administrative Detention Centers in Europe. Their purpose is to keep foreigners who have an irregular administrative status locked up before they are expelled from the territory. ...
We demand that the European states close those places, that serve to establish differences between human beings, those who have rights and those who are considered as «undesirable foreign objects» in violation of articles 1, 2 and 3 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. We demand that the European states adopt reception policies that respond to the urgency of the humanitarian situation at the external borders and within the territory of the European Union...
Antirazzista Catanese (Italia), Askavusa Lampedusa (Italia), ATMF (Association des Travailleurs Maghrébins de France), BAAM (Bureau daccueil et aaccompagnement des migrants - France), CISPM (Coalition internationale des Sans Papiers et Migrants), CISPM New Haven (USA), CSP93 (Coordination 93 de lutte pour les Sans Papiers - France), CSP75 (Coordination 75 des Sans Papiers - France), Fondation Frantz Fanon (France), Intégration 21 (France), Kâlî (France), MAFED (Marche des Femmes pour la Dignité - France), Tanquem els CIEs (España), UNSP (Union nationale des sans papiers et des migrants - France), Union syndicale Solidaires (France)
UPDATED: For immediate release: Thursday 16 June: French border police ban aid convoy from sailing from Dover (Peoples' Assembly)
"Last night we were contacted by the Metropolitan Police who informed us that the French authorities have decided to ban the Convoy to Calais from entering France and, as things stand at the moment, we will not be granted permission to cross the border.
We are doing all in our power to get this overturned. It is more important than ever that we go ahead and show the strength of feeling and support for refugees. If the authorities still refuse to let us cross the channel we will be holding a protest in Dover.
We will still assemble the convoy on Whitehall at 8:30am and will drive to Dover.
We are in negotiations to get the ban lifted and are putting political pressure here and in France to allow the convoy to cross the French border.
How you can help: Sign and share the petition Calling for a reversal of the ban and demanding that the UK government gets involved. Sign the petition here"
EU: Meijers Committee: Note on the proposed reforms of the Dublin Regulation (COM (2016) 197), the Eurodac recast proposal (COM (2016) 272 final), and the proposal for an EU Asylum Agency (COM(2016)271 final) Comments on the Dublin recast proposal (pdf):
"The Meijers Committee would like to take this opportunity to comment on the proposed reform of the Dublin Regulation, as set forth in the 6 April 2016 EC communication to the EP and Council (COM (2016) 197) and the 4 May 2016 proposal for a regulation of the EP and Council establishing the criteria and mechanisms for determining the Member State responsible for examining an application for international protection lodged in one of the Member States by a third-country national or a stateless person (recast) (COM (2016) 270). The latter proposal will be further referred to here as Dublin III recast."
European Parliament Briefing: Towards an EU humanitarian visa scheme? (pdf)
"With large numbers of protection seekers continuing to risk hazardous sea crossings to reach the European Union, there has been considerable focus on the need for legal entry channels, notably resettlement. Humanitarian visas represent one such legal channel. This briefing provides a succinct overview of what humanitarian visas are, the rationale for their use, how they function, how they are regulated in EU law and the scope for future development of a fully-fledged EU
humanitarian visa scheme."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (15.6.16): EU-Turkey deal progress report; Commission on Greece's asylum system; new EU-funded projects in Africa; IOM report on dead and missing migrants; Amnesty on EU-Libya cooperation; a convoy from the UK to Calais; and more.
UK-FRANCE: Press release - Convoy to Calais, Saturday 18 June 2016
Hundreds of vehicles will be leaving Whitehall on Saturday 18th June as part of a Convoy to Calais in what will be the largest display of solidarity with refugees this country has seen for generations. As the biggest humanitarian crisis since the Second World War unfolds across the channel, lorries, cars and minibuses will be making the crossing, taking aid donations and with the aim of pressuring the UK government to provide safe passage to those fleeing desperate situations and sending a clear message that refugees are welcome here.
The Convoy was initiated by the People's Assembly, Stop the War Coalition and Stand Up to Racism and is supported by trade unions including UNISON, Unite, CWU, PCS, ASLEF, TSSA, FBU, faith groups including the Muslim Association of Britain, and charities including Humanitas and Care4Calais who work in the camp.
EU-TURKEY: Commission publishes second progress report on the implementation of EU-Turkey deal
"This Second Report sets out the considerable further progress made in implementing the EU-Turkey Statement since the First Report, and identifies the next steps required to consolidate this achievement so as to maintain the momentum. These are needed given that the context remains difficult and geopolitical risks continue to exist, while all aspects of the EU-Turkey Statement are not yet established on a firm footing."
EU-GREECE: Asylum: Commission calls on further efforts from Greece to allow resumption of Dublin transfers
The European Commission has today adopted a second Recommendation setting out requirements that Greece must meet to allow the resumption of transfers of asylum-seekers to the country under the Dublin system. Dublin transfers to Greece were suspended following judgements in the European Court of Human Rights case M.S.S v Belgium and Greece and the European Court of Justice case NS v Secretary of State for the Home Department.
The new Recommendation follows one adopted in Februay this year and provides more detail on "the significant amount of progress" that Greece must make in seven areas: reception conditions and facilities; access to and resources for the first instance asylum procedure; appeals authority; legal aid; treatment of unaccompanied minors and vulnerable persons; use of EU funding under national programmes; and reporting on actions taken.
EU-AFRICA: The Valletta process gets going: 125 million for border control and security; 21 million for training and job programmes
Six projects worth a total of 146 million have been approved by the European Commission as part of the follow-up to the Valletta Summit. Four of the projects - worth a total of 125 million - focus on policing, security and border control, while two - worth a total of 21 million - focus on education and training opportunities for "young Chadians in vulnerable situations" and "job and training opportunities for returnees and people most likely to migrate" from the Gambia.
UK: When Things Go Wrong in the Court of Appeal: Harsher Criticism Reserved for Shortcomings of Home Office Presenting officers (UK Immigration Justice Watch Blog, link): "I am yet to take instructions on the point, Sir, should hopefully never be heard uttered again in the Tribunal by Home Office Presenting Officers upon a Judge making enquiry about relevant changes in the law or current Home Office policy. I say this following the Court of Appeals judgement in Koori & Ors v The Secretary of State for the Home Department  EWCA Civ 552. The Courts view in effect was that although both Appellants and the Secretary of State should attend appeal hearings fully prepared in terms of the law, however, in particular where matters of statutory changes are concerned, the greater responsibility lies upon the Home Office Presenting Officers. This surely is correct and it is surprising that it has taken so long for this to be stated in a judgement."
See the judgment: Koori & Ors v The Secretary of State for the Home Department ( EWCA Civ 552 (14 June 2016), pdf)
POLAND: New counter-terrorism bill to give "unchecked power" to Internal Security Agency
A briefing by Amnesty International outlines the "unchecked power" that will be given to Poland's Internal Security Agency by a new counter-terrorism bill.
The bill includes provisions that would introduce a 14 day "pre-charge detention regime" for a newly-invented category of persons, "terrorism suspects". This will drag Poland down to the level of the UK, which currently has the longest maximum period of pre-charge detention in the EU.
USA: RENDITION: Barbaric Conditions That Led to a Detainee's Death Are Laid Bare in CIA Reports (Vice News, link): "The CIA black site prison had 20 cells. Described as "stand-alone concrete boxes," the cell block was outfitted with stereo speakers that played music 24 hours a day to prevent captives from communicating with each other. Captives, who first arrived there in September 2002, were often held in total darkness. Some were subjected to mock executions.
Four of the cells at the black site it was located in Afghanistan and code-named COBALT, but it was also referred to as the Salt Pit had "high bars... to which prisoners can be secured." These four cells were designed specifically for sleep deprivation.
The prison is where a 34-year-old Afghan militant and suspected al-Qaeda operative named Gul Rahman froze to death in November 2002 after undergoing a brutal torture regimen that included being beaten, doused with cold water, and left half-naked while chained to the floor of his cell. Several of the techniques CIA interrogators used on Rahman were unauthorized; in August 2002, a Department of Justice attorney named John Yoo had written a legal memo sanctioning nearly a dozen torture methods for use on high-value captives."
And see a series of documents recently released by the CIA related to the rendition and torutre programme: Documents Related to the Former Detention and Interrogation Program (CIA, link)
EU: New measures against radicalisation: research funding, policing the internet, prisons, schools and security measures
The European Commission has published its latest plans on how it aims to help EU Member States combat "radicalisation", focusing on research; policing the internet; radicalisation in prisons; schools and education; various security measures and more.
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (14.6.16): increase in deaths in the Mediterranean; Parliament position on a European Border Guard; reports on unaccompanied minors; and more.
Mediterranean: 2016 data shows massive increase in deaths compared to 2015
Recent International Organization for Migration statistics paint a grim picture of the ongoing tragedy in the Mediterranean:
"International Organization for Migration reports an estimated 207,260 migrants, including refugees entered Europe by sea in 2016 through 8 June, arriving in Italy, Greece, Cyprus and Spain. Deaths so far this year are 2,856, compared with 1,838 through the first six months of 2015. In other words, fatalities in the Mediterranean in 2016 are over 1,000 more than last years mid-year total, although we now are some three weeks shy of 2016s mid-year point." (emphasis added)
EU: European Border Guard Agency: European Parliament position for negotiations with the Council
On 30 May the European Parliament's civil liberties, justice and home affairs committee (LIBE) adopted its position on the proposed Regulation for a European Border and Coast Guard Agency, which would significantly expand the powers of Frontex. The text adopted by LIBE will be used as the basis for the Parliament's negotiations with the Council in the secret "trilogue" procedure.
UK 'grassroots' anti-extremism campaign produced by Home Office (Middle East Eye, link): "A high profile campaign encouraging Muslim women in the UK to make a stand against terrorism was covertly produced by the Home Offices communications unit in order to transmit counter-extremism messages into communities and hard to reach audiences, Middle East Eye can exclusively reveal.
The #MakingAStand campaign was launched by Inspire, a womens counter-extremism organisation, in September 2014, and described by Inspire founder Sara Khan as a jihad against violence.
Earlier this year, Khan and Inspire co-director Kalsoom Bashir said in evidence submitted to a parliamentary inquiry into the governments counter-extremism policy: All decisions in relation to Inspires remit and work are made solely by the directors; all projects and activities are led and carried out by the Inspire team.
But an internal government document seen by MEE lists #MakingAStand as a RICU Product, referring to the Research, Information and Communications Unit (RICU), the Home Offices strategic communications unit responsible since 2011 for disseminating counter-extremism narratives as part of the governments Prevent strategy.
The March 2015 document, produced by the Home Office-based Office for Security and Counter Extremism, is titled Prevent Strategy: Local delivery best practice catalogue and marked Not for public discourse."
This follows earlier revelations that RICU was behind other campaigns supposedly organised and run by civil society organisations. See: UK government 'running covert counter-extremism propaganda campaign' (Middle East Eye, link) and: Inside Ricu, the shadowy propaganda unit inspired by the cold war (Guardian, link)
EU: Justice and Home Affairs Council, 9-10 June 2016: adopted conclusions and action plans
At the EU Justice and Home Affairs Council meeting on 9-10 June 2016, EU interior and justice ministers adopted numerous sets of conclusions, a number of which are provided here. The conclusions on financial investigation and the creation of a European Forensic Science Area also include action plans setting out proposed activities for Member States and EU agencies and institutions.
UK: Home Office refuses to reveal whether women in Yarl's Wood have been raped in case it 'damages the commercial interests' of companies (The Independent, link): "The Home Office is refusing to reveal how many detainees have been sexually assaulted or raped inside Yarls Wood Immigration Removal Centre in Bedfordshire in case the information becoming public knowledge harms the commercial interests of private companies that are involved in running it, The Independent can reveal.
Like all Government departments, the Home Office is subject to legislation that requires public bodies to disclose information that is in the public interest. However, since The Independent submitted a request for information about sexual violence against detainees in the centre in March, the Home Office has refused to disclose this information. A member of Home Office staff argued this was on the grounds that: disclosure would, or would be likely to, prejudice the commercial interests of people involved with running Yarls Wood."
Some background on Yarl's Wood and the controversies and scandals associated with the detention centre: Yarl's Wood: migrant detention centre condemned again (Statewatch News Online, August 2015)
UN: Special Rapporteur on freedom of association: "states which claim to be fighting terrorism yet restrict civil society are playing with fire"
A new report from a UN Special Rapporteur examines the effect of fundamentalism - in the form of market, political, religious, cultural and national fundamentalisms - on the rights to freedom of peaceful association and assemly.
The report also examines the role of those rights in "the context of rising extremism and radicalisation," arguing that "a major contributing factor" to the growth of extremism worldwide is "the on-going global crackdown on democratic freedoms."
The Special Rapporteur, Maina Kiai, argues that:
"States which claim to be fighting terrorism yet at the same time restrict civil society are playing with fire. The existence of a robust civil society and respect for human rights in general is critical in combatting extremism, and in channelling dissent and frustrations in a legitimate way through the system."
UK: Officers accused of framing Cardiff 3 fail in attempt to sue police
A group of police officers have failed in their bid to sue Cardiff police for false imprisonment, malfeasance in public office and malicious prosecution after they were accused of framing the 'Cardiff Three' in a trial that eventually collapsed.
In 1990 three men - the Cardiff Three - were imprisoned for the murder of Lynette White but their convictions were quashed on appeal in 1992. In 2000 the case was reopened: Jeffrey Gafoor confessed to the crime and was subsequently imprisoned.
Numerous police officers involved in the original investigation were subsequently arrested and tried on various charges, but the prosecution's case collapsed for a number of reasons - for example, the intentional destruction of evidence by South Wales Police.
15 police officers subsequently attempted to sue the force for the case against them, an attempt which has now failed.
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (13.6.16)
EU: Council of the European Union: Information sharing in the counter-terrorism context: Use of Europol and Eurojust (LIMITE doc no: 9201-16, pdf):
"There is great political momentum to improve information sharing... Unprecedented levels of information (of over 16.7 TB) have been shared with the Taskforce Fraternité, established at Europol
One Member State where the security service carries out the initial CT investigations, stressed that the operational risk to share outweighed the operational value for CT: CT information was classified secret and above. To share it with Europol was perceived as not possible at that classification level given that this also meant that police agencies at the national level would receive/transmit the information which would normally not have access....
Member States that do not share or share few FTF with Interpol have concerns with regard to data protection and human rights (what may happen to a terrorist suspects in a third country with a less advanced track record on human rights)....
4,129 foreign travelling terrorist fighters (including supporters) are now shared by 27 contributing parties in the EIS (19 MS, 8 third parties) - of which 1,700 are contributed by EU MS (in May 2015, there were 1,163 entries overall (17 contributing parties overall, 13 MS, 4 third parties), compared to 4,129 now)....
25,353 person entities overall (in May 2015, 6,044 person entities)."
EU: Council of the European Union: Draft Council conclusions on the application of the Charter in 2015 (pdf)
"The actions of EU institutions, bodies and agencies as well as Member States, when implementing Union law, have to be fully in line with the Charter. Article 51 of the Charter states that the institutions and bodies of the Union and the Member States shall respect its rights, observe its principles and promote its application in accordance with their respective powers..."
See also: Coherence and consistency between internal and external EU human rights policy - Presidency discussion paper (LIMITE doc no: 6256-16, pdf)
"The EU and its Member States ensure high standards of human rights protection internally.....
The Council Conclusions of May 2014 recognise the importance of consistency between internal and external aspects of human rights protection and promotion in the Union framework in terms of enhancing the Unions credibility in its external relations and leading by example in the area of human rights.
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (11-12.6.16)
UK-Germany: Undercover police: German calls to be included into Pitchford Inquiry: The case of Mark Kennedy: Cross-border operations of undercover police officers should be investigated in Germany as well (link):
"I therefore welcome the fact that, following our numerous petitions, queries and open letters, the German Federal Ministry of the Interior has decided to call for an extension of the Pitchford Inquiry into the undercover activities of British police officers in Germany. This secret policing scandal has been discussed at Parliament and Minister level in Iceland and the Republic of Ireland.
The Scottish and Northern Irish governments have officially requested the initiation of investigations covering their territories. The requested extension will be decided by the British Home Secretary Theresa May. I call upon the German Federal Government to go beyond merely penning a request and to exert the necessary pressure to ensure the Pitchford Inquiry is extended to other countries."
Backgound: Police Spies Out of Lives have produced two new briefings on issues related to secrecy and openness a the Pitchford Inquiry, which is due to examien the undercover police work in England and Wales since 1968:
- Secrets beyond lies: the police and state's requests for secrecy (pdf). An overview of the secrecy requests made by the police and state bodies to the Public Inquiry into Undercover Policing.
- Open Inquiry, Open Justice (pdf). A guide to the submission by non-police non-state Core Participants [those affected directly by undercover police officers, campaign groups, and so on] to the Public Inquiry into Undercover Policing, in response to police and state requests for secrecy.
See also: some background on the time when the Met Police were happy to help spread public information about the work of spying on "subversives": BBC True Spies series: police happy to disclose information when it suits them (Special Branch Files Project, link)
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (10.6.16)
ITALY: Italy/Ventimiglia: Statement by PHM Italy in solidarity with migrants in transit and the No Borders network (pdf):
"As the Peoples Health Movement Italy, a network of activists working to promote health, we express full solidarity and political support to the migrants in transit who are blocked at the Italian-French border and to the activists of the international No Borders network, particularly with regards to the serious events which are taking place in these hours in the territory of Ventimiglia....
The visit by interior minister Alfano which took place just over three weeks ago contributed to making a situation which was already intolerable harsher, leading to the closing of the centre set up by the Red Cross near to the station, to an increase in police control activities and to the creation of a tent city below the bridge of a highway which runs along the river Roia."
European Court of Human Rights: Violation of the right not to be tried twice for the same offence and breach of the presumption of innocence in cases involving accusations of smuggling (pdf)
"In todays Chamber judgment in the case of Sismanidis and Sitaridis v. Greece (applications nos. 66602/09 and 71879/12) the European Court of Human Rights held, unanimously, that there had been:
a violation of Article 4 of Protocol No. 7 (right not to be tried or punished twice) to the European Convention on Human Rights as regards Mr Sismanidis, and
a violation of Article 6 §§ 1 and 2 (right to a fair hearing within a reasonable time and presumption of innocence) of the Convention as regards Mr Sitaridis.
The case concerned the institution of proceedings against each of the applicants for smuggling despite the fact that the criminal courts had already irrevocably acquitted them of the same offence."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (9.6.16)
ITALY: Any hotspot to identify migrants at sea is illegal
It will be impossible to effectively guarantee rights in an adequate manner on the high seas. ASGI asks the interior ministry and the Italian government to immediately abandon this course, considering the unlawful aspects listed below, and it invites UNHCR to carefully monitor the situation in order for effective access to the international protection system in Italy to be guaranteed.
EU: Justice and Home Affairs Council meeting, 9-10 June 2016:
- Background Note (pdf)
- List of 'A' items (pdf, non-legislative and adopted without discussion)
- Agenda: Legislative deliberations (pdf)
- Provisional agenda (pdf)
- Press release (pdf)
Included in the list of 'A' items to be adopted: Draft Council Conclusions on addressing trafficking in human beings (THB) for labour exploitation (9373/16, pdf)
News Digest: Round-up of new stories from across the EU (9.6.16)
EU-TURKEY: Council to Greece: forget judicial independence and individual assessment, tell your judges Turkey is safe for Syrians
"The European Council on Justice and Home Affairs is applying pressure on Greece over a recent statement about the EU-Turkey migration deal. They are urging Athens to recognise Turkey as a safe third-country.
We have to make clear to Greece that the vast majority of member states consider Turkey a safe country for Syrians to be returned to, stressed one diplomatic source on June 8, prior to the Justice and Home Affairs Council that is slated to be held in Luxembourg on June 9-10.
The Council also urged Greeces government to explain to the countrys judges that Turkey is safe for Syrians and to review the composition and role of the appeal committees since people from civil societies are not neutral."
See: EU Council: Why Greece should consider Turkey safe for Syrian refugees (New Europe, link)
EU: European Parliament study: Follow-up to the European Parliament's resolution of 8 September 2015 on 'The situation of fundamental rights in the European Union (2013-14)' (pdf): "This study was commissioned by the European Parliament's Policy Department for Citizens' Rights and Constitutional Affairs at the request of the LIBE Committee. With a view to support the preparation of the report on the situation of fundamental rights in the European Union (2015), it examines the follow-up given to the European Parliament resolution of 8 September 2015 on 'The situation of fundamental rights in the European Union (2013-2014)'. It considers the conditions that should be established for the establishment of an EU fundamental rights strategy, as well as the recent developments related to the issues of concern and proposals made in the resolution of 8 September 2015."
See: European Parliament resolution of 8 September 2015 on the situation of fundamental rights in the European Union (2013-2014) (pdf)
EU: RENDITION: MEPs want full investigation into CIA rendition operations on EU soil (New Europe, link): "European Parliament has adopted a non-binding resolution calling on European Union officials to investigate the multiple fundamental rights violations and torture that took place in CIA rendition operations on European soil between 2001 and 2006.
In the resolution, passed by 329 votes to 299, with 49 abstentions, MEPs call on EU member states to investigate, insuring full transparency, the allegations that there were secret prisons on their territory in which people were held under the CIA programme.
The MEPs are concerned that undue classification of documents leads to de facto impunity for perpetrators of human rights violations."
See: European Parliament: Follow-up to the resolution of Parliament of 11 February 2015 on the US Senate report on the use of torture by the CIA (pdf) which, amongst other things:
"Recalls that transparency is the absolute cornerstone of any democratic society, the sine qua non for a governments accountability to its people; is therefore profoundly worried by the increasing trend for governments to unduly invoke national security with the sole or primary aim of blocking public scrutiny by citizens (to whom the government is accountable) or by the judiciary (which is the guardian of a countrys laws); points to the great danger of deactivating any democratic accountability mechanisms, effectively absolving the government of its accountability."
NORTHERN IRELAND: Police Ombudsman: "I have no hesitation in unambiguously determining that collusion is a significant feature of the Loughinisland murders"
The Police Ombudsman of Northern Ireland has released a report responding to complaints made by the families of those killed and wounded in the Loughinisland murders in June 1994, in which six people died and five were wounded by gunmen from the loyalist Ulster Volunteer Force.
The Ombudsman's report concludes that the original police investigation into the attacks "was characterised in too many instances by incompetence, indifference and neglect," and that collusion between Special Branch, the police and the UVF "was a significant feature of the Loughinisland murders."
IRELAND: Garda 'Big Brother' cameras to identify and track criminals (Irish Indepenent, link): "CCTV cameras with facial recognition capabilities are to be rolled out across the country as part of a major 200m overhaul of how gardaí tackle crime.
Garda stations are also to be equipped with an 'Enterprise Content Management System', which will allow CCTV to be shared by officers around the country.
The system is part of a major modernisation plan to be outlined by Garda Commissioner Nóirín O'Sullivan today.
The plan includes a 200m upgrade of the force's out-of-date technology and comes after a report from the independent Garda Inspectorate revealed how some Garda computer systems are 30 years out of date.
The new CCTV cameras will be able to identify wanted persons and alert gardaí, meaning that if a suspect for a crime in one area is picked up on CCTV in another, gardaí in both locations will be notified automatically."
UK: Rendition: no charges for UK involvement in Belhaj case
"Prosecutors are set to announce that they are bringing no charges following a police investigation into MI6s involvement in the kidnapping of two families who were rendered to the late Libyan dictator Muammar Gaddafis prisons, despite protests by the victims and their lawyers that the evidence against the agency is overwhelming.
Documents that described the UKs involvement in the abduction of Abdel Hakim Belhaj and his pregnant wife, and fellow Libyan dissident Sami al-Saadi along with his wife and four young children, were uncovered during the 2011 revolution that led to the overthrow and murder of Gaddafi."
UK: Torture fears as Durham policing college trains Saudis how to ID suspects (Chronicle Live, link): "Saudi Arabian officers are being taught skills to ID suspects at a Durham college that could lead to the torture and execution of prisoners back in the Middle East country, a human rights charity has said.
The College of Policing, which has centres across the UK including Harperley Hall in Crook, has been teaching staff from the Saudi Arabia interior ministry about high-tech forensics since 2009.
A report by the Colleges international liaison officer and its manager for the gulf co-operation council, both based at Harperley Hall says there is a risk the skills being trained are used to identify individuals who later go on to be tortured or subjected to other human rights abuses."
See the International Policing Assistance Board referral form: Five year strategic partnership with Kingdom of Saudi Arabia Ministry of the Interior - Continuation Training across multi-disciplinary activities (pdf)
And: UK minister passes buck over Saudi police training during Westminster debate (Reprieve, link): "The government today refused to answer questions from MPs about its controversial police training programme with Saudi Arabia."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (8.6.16)
EU Court of Justice: The Return Directive prevents a national of a non-EU country who has not yet been subject to the return procedure being imprisoned solely because he or she has entered the territory of a Member State illegally across an internal border of the Schengen area (press release, pdf): "That is also the case where that national, who is merely in transit on the territory of the Member State concerned, is intercepted when leaving the Schengen area and is the subject of a procedure for readmission into the Member State from which he or she has come"
See: Judgment: Full-text (pdf)
And: Imprisoning woman trying to illegally enter UK was wrong, EU rules (Guardian, link): "European court of justice says France acted wrongly after Ghanian woman was found with false passport at Channel tunnel... France was wrong to imprison a Ghanian woman who was arrested at the Channel tunnel during an attempt to enter Britain illegally using a false passport, the EUs most senior court has ruled. The European court of justice said on Tuesday that the EU directive on returning irregular migrants prevents any member state imposing a prison sentence on a non-EU migrant who is in the country illegally, and whom they have not attempted to return."
USA: The FBI Wants to Get Your Internet Records Without a Warrant (HRW, link):
"This week, a broad coalition of rights groups, Internet companies, and trade associations have issued a letter urging the US Senate to reject proposed legislation that would empower the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) to obtain your Internet records without a warrant including your browsing history and records of whom you have emailed and when."
EU: An EU identity card?
A new study for the European Parliament asseses the possibility of setting up an EU-wide identity card and attempts to asses "the role a European ID card might play in enhancing the participation of EU citizens in decision-making processes at the EU level."
From the executive summary:
"Every person holding the nationality of a Member State is automatically a European Union (EU) citizen. EU citizens are granted important rights, commonly referred to as EU citizenship rights. The European Commission has highlighted that the lack of harmonisation of national identity cards (national ID cards) creates some obstacles for the enjoyment of EU citizenship rights. According to the 2012 European Citizenship Eurobarometer Survey, 18% of respondents would welcome the introduction of a European identity card (European ID card) as an addition to national ID cards.
Against this background the current Study aims to:
- assess the added value of setting up a European ID card;
- analyse the legal and political feasibility of and challenges for setting up an operable European ID card given the current legislative and political context;
- put forward recommendations as regards the legal and technical components required for the setting up of an operable European ID card.
This Study mainly focuses on the exercise of EU political rights in that it assesses the role a European ID card might play in enhancing the participation of EU citizens in decision-making processes at the EU level."
See the study: The legal and political context for setting up a European identity document (pdf)
EU: New proposals on migration: "partnerships" with third countries, Blue Card reform, integration plan
The European Commission has published a series of new "migration management" proposals that foresee new "partnerships" set up with non-EU states; the reform of the 'Blue Card Directive' on the entry into the EU of highly-skilled workers; and an action plan on "the integration of third-country nationals and their economic and social contribution to the EU."
And see: Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (7.6.16)
EU: Operation Sopia: from human smuggling to arms smuggling?
"The European Union yesterday (6 June) proposed expanding a United Nations Security Council mandate for a European naval operation to allow it to crack down on arms smuggling in the high seas off war-torn Libya, though Russia voiced concerns about the idea.
Britain circulated a draft resolution to approve the measure to the 15-member council. A copy of the draft, seen by Reuters, expressed concern that smuggled arms may be used by terrorist groups operating in Libya, including by ISIL (Islamic State). In October, the council authorized the European naval operation to seize and dispose of boats operated by human traffickers.
Now once again, we are asking this council to adopt a resolution on authorizing Operation Sophia to enforce the UN arms embargo on the high seas off the coast of Libya, European Union foreign policy chief Federica Mogherini told the council."
See: UN mulls allowing EU to search boats for illicit arms off Libya (EurActiv, link)
EU: Crunch time for European net neutrality rules
"EU telecoms regulators said yesterday (6 June) that a new net neutrality law would give Europe stronger internet traffic rules than the United States, where a year-old regulation is facing legal challenges.
In Europe we have a regulation that is more robust and a more legal-based approach. So from our point of view Europe is far ahead on the issue, said Wilhelm Eschweiler, the vice president of Germanys telecoms regulator Bundesnetzagentur and current chair of BEREC, the group of European regulators."
See: Europe will have stronger net neutrality rules than the US, regulators say (EurActiv, link)
Background: Make-or-break summer for EU Net Neutrality First stop: Vienna (EDRi, link): "Vienna, city of diplomacy and birthplace of countless international deals, will soon host crucial negotiations on the future of the open internet. On 3 June, EU Telecom regulators will gather in Vienna to discuss the implementation of new EU Net Neutrality laws. Following mass mobilisation in India and the USA, the expectations to deliver real net neutrality are high."
Sweden: Yet more surveillance or real evidence-based decision-making? (EDRi, link): "In Sweden the government is rapidly advancing an agenda for more online surveillance. Two public investigations have been launched to look into new rules for search warrants and the introduction of new secret means of surveillance, namely remote equipment and software interference.
Both the search warrant investigation and the the use of trojans for investigation have big implications for Swedish individuals. Regardless of whether law enforcement tampers with an electronic system over a network, or while they are in its physical proximity, the end result is that law enforcement gets an operational incentive to be less diligent about fixing security issues that can cause big problems for individuals."
UK: Facing Data Deluge, Secret U.K. Spying Report Warned of Intelligence Failure (The Intercept, link): "A secret report warned that British spies may have put lives at risk because their surveillance systems were sweeping up more data than could be analyzed, leading them to miss clues to possible security threats.
The concern was sent to top British government officials in an explosive classified document, which outlined methods being developed by the United Kingdoms domestic intelligence agency to covertly monitor internet communications.
The Security Service, also known as MI5, had become the principal collector and exploiter of digital communications within the U.K., the eight-page report noted, but the agencys surveillance capabilities had grown significantly over the last few years.
MI5 can currently collect (whether itself or through partners ) significantly more than it is able to exploit fully, the report warned. This creates a real risk of intelligence failure i.e. from the Service being unable to access potentially life-saving intelligence from data that it has already collected."
See the documents from the Snowden archive: Digint Narrative and Digint Imbalance (The Intercept, links)
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (6.6.16)
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (2-5.6.16)
UK: Snoopers charter: Most Britons unaware of Tory plans, survey finds (Observer, link): "Poll by Liberty finds widespread ignorance of move to strengthen surveillance powers that is heading for Commons battle"
See: Draft Investigatory Powers Bill (pdf)
Meijers Committee: Note on the Reform of the Common European Asylum System (pdf):
"In its communication of 6 April 2016 (COM(2016) 197 final), the European Commission announced reforms of EU legislation in respect of the qualification for international protection, asylum procedures and reception conditions. In this note the Meijers Committee would like to make the following comments with regard to the proposed reforms."
EU-USA "UMBRELLA AGREEMENT" of the exchange of personal data for purposes of law enforcement
- Enhanced data protection rights for EU citizens in law enforcement cooperation : EU and US sign "Umbrella agreement" (pdf):
"On 2 June 2016, the European Union and the United States of America signed the so-called "Umbrella agreement" which puts in place a comprehensive high-level data protection framework for criminal law enforcement cooperation...
"Next step: After the signature and before the agreement can be finally concluded, the European Parliament will need to give its consent."
The "Umbrella Agreement" on the exchange of personal data - its Scope (Art 1): covers:
"The purpose of this Agreement is to ensure a high level of protection of personal information and enhance cooperation between the United States and the European Union and its Member States, in relation to the prevention, investigation, detection or prosecution of criminal offenses, including terrorism."
Note: the Scope covers all crimes however, minor.
- Agreement between the United States of America and the European Union on the protection of personal information relating to the prevention, investigation, detection, and prosecution of criminal offenses (Full-text, pdf) - Draft Council Decision - Adoption (pdf) - Council Decision (pdf)
The Agreement expressly excludes the security and intelligence agencies.
And: Marc Rotenberg President, EPIC Adjunct Professor, Georgetown Law Hearing: ""The Judicial Redress Act does not provide adequate protection to permit data transfers and it does not address the many provisions in the Privacy Act that need to be updated."
- Council of the European Union: Joint EU-U.S. press statement following the EU-U.S. Justice and Home Affairs Ministerial meeting of 2 June 2016 (pdf)
- European Commission: Joint EU-U.S. press statement following the EU-U.S. Justice and Home Affairs Ministerial meeting (pdf)
UK: Auditioning for justice: Unless claimants can justify why they think they have been spied on, secretive surveillance Tribunal refuses to review 650 claims of unlawful spying (Privacy International)
"Despite Government attempts to stop 650 claims about surveillance being investigated, the Investigatory Powers Tribunal has today ruled that the cases can be heard However, the Tribunal is requiring the 650 claimants to submit further information demonstrating that they are "potentially at risk" of unlawful surveillance, prior to investigating their claims of unlawful spying
The Tribunal has said that people outside the UK have no legal right to find out if British intelligence agencies violated the European Convention on Human Rights by spying on them."
See Full-text judgment (pdf)
Italy: FROM THE HUMANITARIAN BLACKMAIL OVER FOOD TO TODAY'S VIOLENCE
Permanent NoBorders Monitoring Post in Ventimiglia - May 24, 2016 | Presidio Permanente No Borders - Ventimiglia·Tuesday, May 24, 2016
"The mayor of Ventimiglia withdraws the order on the provision of food and drinks
When Ventimiglia's mayor Enrico Ioculano issued a mayoral order forbidding the provision of food and drinks to migrants who were in transit in the town's territory last July, various voices were heard criticising what in effect amounted to a criminal offence of solidarity. While the self-managed kitchen at the border monitoring post continued working at full speed, the only people who bore the brunt of this measure were some Islamic associations from Nice which went to distribute food to the people in the station every evening.
The order had two main objectives: to discourage solidarity towards the people who were travelling and to designate the Italian Red Cross as the only body responsible for managing the emergency. In the camp, its effects were the opposite: the self-managed kitchen's capacity was increased and the migrants decided not to accept any more food from the same organisation which was cooperating with deportations from Ponte San Luigi to the reception centre in the station. "
Migszol: Migrant solidarity group of Hungary: Solidarity with the people protesting against poor conditions in the closed asylum detention center in Kiskunhalas, Hungary (link):
"People imprisoned in the closed refugee detention center of Kiskunhalas organized a protest yesterday, June 1st 2016. Today, the protest continues. They are demanding freedom to leave the prison and live in an open camp, a faster asylum procedure and better living conditions in the camp. According to Julia Ivan, a lawyer at the Hungarian Helsinki Committee, many of the protesters are people that Hungary is trying to deport to Greece with the Dublin regulation, despite the fact that the European Court of Human Rights has ruled against such deportations.
Kiskunhalas is one of the asylum detention centers, where asylum seekers are kept imprisoned up to six months, without ever having committed a crime..."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (1.6.16)
Council of Europe: State of democracy, human rights and the rule of law: A security imperatve for Europe (link):
"The Council of Europe will help Europes governments promote inclusion by making sure that domestic legislation relating to migrants and refugees meets international standards, by training public officials and law enforcement in the human rights of these groups, and by assisting with special safeguards for unaccompanied children. Social rights will remain at the top of our agenda, in particular securing more ratifications of the revised European Social Charter and the Protocol on Collective Complaints. Across Europe, we will support teachers to equip young people with the skills and understanding needed to operate as democratic citizens in diverse societies."
EU-POLAND: Commission adopts Polish rule of law report (euobserver, link):
"The European Commission has adopted an opinion concerning the rule of law in Poland, the latest step in a procedure launched in January over constitutional reforms. The text was endorsed by the college of commissioners during their weekly meeting on Wednesday (1 June), but has not been made public.
"Despite our best efforts, it has not been possible to find solutions to the issues at stake," said commission vice president Frans Timmermans, who is leading negotiations with the Polish government. ...
Polands government must reply to the commissions concerns within reasonable time. If they do not, or if they fail to answer the questions raised, the commission can issue recommendations - marking the second of three steps in the rule of law procedure."
See: Commission adopts Rule of Law Opinion on the situation in Poland (Press release, pdf) and Commission Opinion on the Rule of Law in Poland and the Rule of Law Framework: Questions & Answers (pdf)
European Parliament: Study: The Implementation of the Common European Asylum System (pdf):
"This study was commissioned by the European Parliaments Policy Department for Citizens Rights and Constitutional Affairs at the request of the LIBE Committee. It provides an overview of the current implementation of the Common European Asylum System (CEAS) from both a legal and practical perspective. Against the background of large inflows of seekers of international protection, the study covers the CEAS instruments as well as the EU policy responses brought forward in 2015 until May 2016....
Reception conditions represent a very difficult field of harmonisation. Standards set by EU law cannot erase the economic differences between EU MS, implying that prospects in some EU MS remain better than in others. As evidenced in the study, the reception conditions vary significantly in EU MS. The shortcomings in the EU reception conditions trigger secondary imovements and consequently thwart any distribution mechanisms."
European Parliament: Press release: Fighting terrorism: share criminal records of non-EU nationals, too, urge MEPs (link):
"The European Criminal Records Information System (ECRIS), which EU countries use to exchange information on the criminal convictions of EU citizens, should be extended to include non-EU nationals, Civil Liberties Committee MEPs said on
Monday. MEPs also want the system to be used to check the criminal records of people seeking to work with children.
The committee backed an EU Commission proposal to expand the ECRIS system to include information, of non-EU citizens by 45 votes to 2, with 4 abstentions. The new directive is a key measure under the European Agenda on Security and an important tool for fighting cross-border crime and terrorism.
We need to restore public confidence that we are able to monitor who comes into the EU, and to find people who could represent a threat. Checking people against our existing criminal records databases, and making exchanging that information much easier, will go a long way towards showing that we can find those people who mean us harm, amongst the vast majority who do not", said Parliament's lead MEP on the file Timothy Kirkhope (ECR, UK).following the vote."
European Data Protection Supervisor (EDPS): Privacy Shield: more robust and sustainable solution needed (Press release, pdf):
"Giovanni Buttarelli, EDPS, said: "I appreciate the efforts made to develop a solution to replace Safe Harbour but the Privacy Shield as it stands is not robust enough to withstand future legal scrutiny before the Court. Significant improvements are needed should the European Commission wish to adopt an adequacy decision, to respect the essence of key data protection principles with particular regard to necessity, proportionality and redress mechanisms. Moreover, its time to develop a longer term solution in the transatlantic dialogue." [emphasis in original]
See: Opinion: Full-text (pdf)
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (31.5.16)
EU: European Parliament: Motion for a Resolution: further to Question for Oral Answer B8-0705/2016 pursuant to Rule 128(5) of the Rules of Procedure for an open, efficient and independent European Union administration (pdf), Heidi Hautala, Pavel Svoboda on behalf of the Committee on Legal Affairs:
"Invites the Commission to consider the annexed proposal for a regulation;
Calls on the Commission to come forward with a legislative proposal to be included in its work programme for the year 2017;
Instructs its President to forward this resolution to the Commission."
EU: Patent lack of transparency: Giegold: Many member states avoid European transparency like the plague (euractiv, link):
"Back in 2014, Jean-Claude Juncker prioritised transparency as a crucial point of his Commissions mandate. EurActiv Germany spoke with Sven Giegold about the future of transparency in the institutions....
The official statement that accompanies your draft report says that the EU institutions are more transparent and clean than most at national level. Nevertheless, EU citizens have less trust in the Brussels machine. So could you argue that the problem is one of perception, not reality, and that more transparency isnt really going to do anything?"
News Digest: Round-up of news stories from across the EU (30.5.16)
HOTSPOTS: ITALY: Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) applicable to ITALIAN HOTSPOTS (pdf): "The SOPs for ITALIAN HOTSPOTS have been drafted by the Italian Ministry of the Interior, Department for Civil Liberties and Immigration, and Department of Public Security. The European Commission, Frontex, Europol, EASO, UNHCR and IOM provided valuable contributions to the preparation of this document. The procedures indicated in this document should be used as an operational guide for activities organised within Hotspots. In the event of discrepancies between this document and current legislation, the latter shall apply."
Official document on how the "hotspots" in Italy are supposed to function in practice, which agencies and institutions are involved, and what their different roles are. See also the same document in Italian: STANDARD OPERATING PROCEDURES (SOP) applicabili agli HOTSPOTS ITALIANI (pdf) and a presentation on how the relocation scheme is supposed to work (also in Italian): Lhotspot approach e la relocation (pdf)
And see: Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (30.5.16)
EU: Annual reports for 2015: Fundamental Rights Agency and European Ombudsman
The EU's Fundamental Rights Agency and the European Ombudsman have both recently released annual reports detailing their work and areas of interest in the course of 2015.
EU: Action on pre-trial detention?
"A cross-party group of four MEPs has written a letter to Vera Jourová, the EU Commissioner for Justice, Consumers and Gender Equality, to urge action on pre-trial detention practices within the EU.
In the letter, the MEPs (Dennis de Jong, MEP, Birgit Sippel, MEP, Judith Sargentini, MEP, Nathalie Griesbeck, MEP) highlighted some of the problems around the practice of pre-trial detention in the region, including the issues raised in the recent Aranyosi and Caldararu cases. The letter concluded by urging the Commissioner to take a number of steps:
- The submission of a legislative proposal on pre-trial detention, as requested by Parliament in its resolution of 15 December 2011;
- Publicly repeat the Commissions long-standing position that in the application of the Framework Decision Member States should respect human rights and fundamental freedoms and that mutual recognition should not in any way undermine this principle;
- The submission of legislative proposals clarifying the Framework Decision on the European Arrest Warrant, as requested by Parliament in its resolution of 27 February 2014."
See: MEPs and Fair Trials call for end to unjustified pre-trial detention (Fair Trials, link) and Fair Trials' recent report: Policy Report: Pre-Trial Detention in the EU (link)
EU Commission under investigation for EU Internet Forum documents (EDRi, link): "In the past year, EDRi made numerous formal requests to get more information about the EU Internet Forum. This Forum was set up by the EU Commission to persuade companies to do more to fight terrorism. After months of obstruction from the European Commission, EDRi made a maladministration complaint to the European Ombudsman. As a result, a formal inquiry has been launched.
The problem: The action points agreed with online companies in secret meetings of the Forum may have a direct negative impact on our freedom of expression. Why? Because one of the topics that is being discussed is the censoring of online content by private companies without any judicial process."
See: The Commission wrongly refused full access to the note of 10 June 2015 and to the concept note (access request GestDem 2015/3658) (European Ombudsman, link)
EU: Ombudsman to examine Commission evaluation of Special Advisers (European Ombudsman, link): "The European Ombudsman, Emily O'Reilly, has opened a strategic inquiry into how the European Commission carries out conflict of interest assessments for its Special Advisers.
The Commission has approximately 40 Special Advisers, chosen because they can provide particular expertise, as it is needed, directly to a Commissioner. This high-level access, coupled with the fact that many of the advisers have outside interests, heightens the importance of anticipating any possible conflict.
The aim of the inquiry, opened following individual complaints related to Special Advisers, is to ensure that rules are sufficiently robust in order to avoid inappropriate influence on policy-making. An Adviser's mandate and their outside activities should be fully clarified before appointment, while conflict of interest assessments should be updated if the person takes up a new outside activity."
And see: Letter to the European Commission opening the European Ombudsman's strategic inquiry OI/6/2016/AB concerning rules and practices to prevent possible conflicts of interest of Special Advisers (link)
UK: UNDERCOVER POLICING: Police chief leading Operation Herne unfit for role (The Ferret, link): "The policeman leading an internal investigation into the undercover policing scandal at the Met Police is unfit for the role because he once oversaw disgraced police spies who abused their powers, according to a research group.
Mick Creedon, Chief Constable of Derbyshire Police, was appointed to lead Operation Herne in 2013 by Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe, the Metropolitan Police Commissioner.
At the time, Home Secretary Theresa May welcomed the appointment saying there must be independent scrutiny of the review at the Met.
Chief Constable Creedon was chosen because of his lengthy experience as a detective, having joined the police in 1980 at the age of 22 years old. Hes been in his present role at Derbyshire Police since 2007.
However, campaigners seeking the truth about the undercover Met Police scandal say he should not have been appointed to lead Operation Herne because of his past links to the disgraced units currently under investigation."
And see: the Powerbase entry on Chief Constable Mick Creedon (Powerbase, link)
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (28-29.5.16)
Europol to cooperate with new European intelligence service center (digit.site36.net, link):
"European intelligence services are establishing a Counter Terrorism Centre in the Dutch city The Hague. The centre belongs to the Counter Terrorism Group (CTG) that was founded by the so called Club of Berne in 2001. It consists of domestic intelligence services from all European member states plus Norway and Switzerland. France and Italy are participating with two different authorities. ....
The proposal for the intelligence centre, which according to a Europol report will start its services on the 1st of July, came up after the Paris attacks from 13th November last year. A few days later the heads of the services met for an extraordinary session and concluded to set up a common platform in The Hague...."
See: Enhancing Europols counter terrorism capabilities: European Counter Terrorism Centre (ECTC) at Europol (LIMITE doc no: 8881-16, pdf)
UK: The Undercover Policing Inquiry: institutional failings and the urgent need for reform (Manchester Policy Blogs, link): "Public concern with policing has continued to gather momentum in recent years: instead of questioning whether British police services are fit for purpose, it may now be more pertinent to ask what is to be done about it. Despite repeated warnings by the Home Secretary about ineffective and inadequate police performance amidst a raft of reforms intended to professionalise and create a new cadre of leaders, public criticism has risen to a crescendo.
The signs are that the Pitchford Inquiry will contribute significantly to the growing clamour for reform of a police service that has become toxic.
The Home Secretary appears determined not to deviate from her by now well-trodden path as she broadened her call for a more caring and sensitive service in her address to the Police Federation last week. On their own, Ministerial addresses are unlikely to result in meaningful change and the time is ripe for a broad coalition to demand root and branch reform of the police and a criminal justice system designed for Victorian times."
UK-MIDDLE EAST: UK covert ops in Middle East can't stay secret forever, says top Tory MP (Middle Easy Eye, link): "A senior Conservative MP has told Middle East Eye that parliament should have oversight of covert military operations in the Middle East, after news emerged that elite SAS troops have been battling the Islamic State group in Libya.
Crispin Blunt said he understood why the British public may think the UK is engaged in a secret war across the region, as more and more reports emerge of covert military operations against IS.
The longer it goes on you cant keep these things secret forever, he said. If youre running a strategy and youre using special forces to do it and youre doing it over a prolonged period youll get into the position were getting into now, which is that there is a consistent pattern of open source reporting on it.
Over the past year the UK has been reportedly carrying out covert military operations in Yemen, Syria, Iraq, and Libya - with the latest report on Thursday by the Times.
The newspaper reported that SAS troops were spotted by local Libyan fighters earlier in May blowing up an IS vehicle laden with explosives near the port city of Misrata.
The Times report came just two days after Defence Secretary Michael Fallon said the UK had "no plans" to deploy troops to Libya in a combat role."
And see a new briefing by the Remote Control project: We need greater transparency on UK military operations in Libya (pdf) by Emily Knowles: "Official government statements suggest that the UK military operation in Libya both began and ended with the 2011 NATO mission. However, research undertaken and commissioned by Remote Control suggests that this is only true if you take a very narrow view of what counts as a UK military operation. Since 2011, information has been slowly surfacing about the extent of ongoing covert UK engagement, including several waves of special force deployment, the presence of undisclosed numbers of military advisers, intelligence gathering operations, potential drone operations, and the recent approval of the use of UK air bases in US air strikes against ISIS."
EU: Wording of whistleblower provisions in Trade Secrets Directive changed at last minute behind closed doors
"Today, unfortunately, the controversial Trade Secrets directive was formally adopted by the Council, but only after several delays due to disagreements over how specifically to translate a key provision in the text: the word "wrongdoing". This confusion at such a late stage in the democratic process clearly shows that specific EU legislation to effectively protect those that disclose public interest information, is desperately needed."
European bar and law societies demand protection of professional secrecy, citizens' rights and the rule of law
From the press release: "On 20 May 2016, at its Plenary Session in Lyon, the CCBE published its recommendations on the protection of client confidentiality within the context of surveillance activities. These recommendations aim not only to protect and ensure the fundamental principles of professional secrecy and legal professional privilege, but more importantly to protect citizens rights and the rule of law.
Client confidentiality is a core component of the legal profession, as highlighted in the CCBE Code of Conduct, which says that the lawyers obligation of confidentiality serves the interest of the administration of justice as well as the interest of the client. It is therefore entitled to special protection by the State.
The purpose of this paper is therefore to inform legislators and policy makers about the standards that must be upheld in order to ensure that professional secrecy and legal professional privilege are not undermined by surveillance practices undertaken by the state."
Press release (pdf): English, French and: CCBE Recommendations on the protection of client confidentiality within the context of surveillance activities (pdf): English, French
The recommendations cover: 1. Overarching principle; 2. Need for legislative control; 3. Scope of admissible interception; 4. Judical and independent oversight: Nature of oversight - Mandate of the oversight body - Powers of the oversight bodies; 5. Use of intercepted material; 6. Legal remedies and sanctions.
Council of Europe: PACE condemns human rights violations during peaceful protests (PACE, link): "The PACE Standing Committee, meeting today in Tallinn, expressed its concern at the frequent use of excessive force against peaceful demonstrators and at the recent legal restrictions on the right to freedom of assembly in several member States, in particular:
- in Turkey, where a security law was enacted, extending police powers and allowing them to use fire arms;
- in Spain, with the adoption of a law on citizens security, which institutes heavy fines against organisers of spontaneous protests;
- in the Russian Federation, with an amendment to the law on public gatherings which permits the detention of any person participating in an unauthorised public assembly.
It is also concerned at the lack of legislation on freedom of assembly in some countries, for example Ukraine."
And: Resolution 2116(2016): Urgent need to prevent human rights violations during peaceful protests (pdf)
News Digest: round-up of news stories from across the EU (27.5.16)
GREECE: Idomeni evacuation: process denounced, consequences and next steps
Major NGOs and numerous independent voices have criticised the clearance of the Idomeni camp in northern Greece, whilst others have highlighted the consequences of the decision and the Greek government makes plans to clear the Elliniko camp in Athens next.
And see: Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (27.5.16)
CROATIA: Remove revisionist policies from the Croatian Government! (European Alternatives, link): "The European Grassroots Antiracist Movement, in collaboration with Croatian artists and intellectuals, drafted a call to denounce the presence of Mr Hasanbegovic in the Croatian government as the Minister of Culture. The call already collected 183 signatures from 35 countries, including Beate and Serge Klarsfeld, Judith Butler, Annette Wieviorka or Ursa Raukar and some of the main European newspapers (Libération in France, Neues Deutschland in Germany or The Guardian) have responded to the call.
Croatia has been expected to respect and promote the core values of democracy, such as equality and social inclusion, which have been key in guaranteeing stability and peace in Europe.
However, the new Croatian Government is evidently failing its obligations and responsibilities to these very basic values. The Croatian Prime Minister Mr. Tihomir Orekovic named Mr. Zlatko Hasanbegovic to the post of Minister of Culture. Mr. Hasanbegovic is a historian well known for his controversial, revisionist views of the recent Croatian history throughout his 20 years of public work. He recently publicly claimed that the defeat of Ustasha in 1945 was the greatest national tragedy and has also publicly glorified and advocated rehabilitation of Husein ef. Ðozo, who served in the 13th Waffen Mountain Division of the SS Handschar. It has been recently discovered that he was an external contributor to the magazine Independent State of Croatia (a Quisling regime run by the Ustaa), praising Nazi values and heroes. In 1996, Hasanbegovic wrote at least two articles for the monthly which propagated the work and the political ideas of Ante Pavelic and systematically denied the crimes committed by the fascist Independent State of Croatia. Last year, Hasanbegovic labelled anti-Fascism as an empty phrase."
EU: Rethinking security... or not
The Ammerdown Group, which "brings together peacebuilding practitioners and academics concerned about the effects of geopolitics on the security of people worldwide," argue in a new discussion paper that a "more secure future for all depends on finding new answers to fundamental questions: what does security mean, whom should it benefit, how is it achieved, and whose responsibility is it?" Meanwhile, the 2016 edition of the EU's annual Security Research conference is coming up soon, displaying very little - if any - sign of the type of discussions that the Ammerdown Group argue are necessary.
UK: Unlawful imposition of curfews on migrants overturned by courts
"Officials for the Home Office said during the case that they had assumed they had the power to impose curfews. When it was shown that they dont have this power, they instigated a change in policy while the case was ongoing, by which they would ask the judge in the bail hearing to impose the curfew. However, it is not clear if the Home Office ever did this in practice. Now that the judgment in Gedi has been handed down, it has confirmed there is no legal authority to impose curfews as part of bail conditions."
SPAIN: Andalucian Association for Human Rights confirms an increase in arrivals and deaths at the southern border during 2015
Last month the Andalucian Association for Human Rights released a report, 'Human Rights at the Southern Border 2016', which documents and analyses the situation for migrants and refugees at the southern borders of Spain. The organization condemns the increasing number of deaths "resulting from the immoral migration policies than confine people in countries immersed in war and hunger."
And see: Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (27.5.16)
EU: MEPs call for virtual currency watchdog to combat money laundering and terrorism (press release, pdf): "The EU Commission should set up a taskforce to monitor virtual currencies, like Bitcoin, to prevent their being used to launder money or finance terrorism, said Parliament in a non-binding resolution voted on Thursday.
The proposal, set out in a resolution drafted by Jakob von Weizsäcker (S&D, DE) suggests that the taskforce, which would be overseen by the Commission, should build expertise in the underlying technology of virtual currencies. It would also be tasked with recommending any necessary legislation, but the text warns against taking a heavyhanded approach to this new technology which, it says, can offer significant opportunities for the consumer and economic development.
"To avoid stifling innovation, we favour precautionary monitoring rather than pre-emptive regulation. But IT innovations can spread very rapidly and become systemic. That's why we call on the Commission to establish a taskforce to actively monitor how the technology evolves and to make timely proposals for specific regulation if, and when, the need arises", said Mr von Weizsäcker."
The resolution: European Parliament resolution of 26 May 2016 on virtual currencies (2016/2007(INI)) (pdf)
EU: Terrorist material online: further successful removal requests by Europol (Die Linke, link): "Europols Internet Referral Unit is more active than had previously been known. The partnership with the internet industry is now to be expanded further, with the aim of establishing a Joint Referral Platform for the police and private companies and developing counter-narratives."
See the document in question: NOTE from: Europol to: Standing Committee on Operational Cooperation on Internal Security: Enhancing Europol's counter terrorism capabilities: European Counter Terrorism Centre at Europol (8881/16, 13 May 2016, pdf)
UK: POSTnote on "Islamic extremism, radicalisation and deradicalisation, and the policy responses to violent and non-violent extremism"
- Research is limited but indicates that there is no typical extremist or typical pathway to extremism.
- A key gap in the evidence is why some who hold similar views as extremists do not engage in violence.
- Despite wider concerns about online radicalisation, studies suggest that friends and family are a more important source of radical ideas.
- There is limited research on what deradicalisation or counter-radicalisation interventions are most effective.
- The UK Government has taken a "value-based" approach to tackling extremism. This seeks to support moderate Islamic voices.
- The Government's Counter-Extremism and Safeguarding Bill, due to be introduced this year, will also target non-violent extremism."
See: POSTnote: Addressing Islamic Extremism (pdf)
UK: Criminal justice system in serious trouble
"The criminal justice system in England and Wales is failing victims and witnesses and is close to "breaking point", MPs have warned.
The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) said the system was "bedevilled by long-standing poor performance, including delays and inefficiencies".
The committee's report also warned that cutbacks were affecting the ability of courts to deliver justice.
The Ministry of Justice said it would "reflect on the recommendations"."
See: Criminal justice system near breaking point, MPs warn (BBC News, link)
Full report of the Public Accounts Committee: Efficiency in the criminal justice system (pdf)
EU: Council of the European Union: Justice and Home Affairs info exchange and cyberspace investigations
Leaked documents from the Council of the EU show detailed plans for enhancing justice and home affairs information exchange - including by possibly inserting DNA data into the Schengen Information System - as well as ongoing plans for ensuring "effective operational cooperation in criminal investigations in cyberspace".
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (26.5.16): Including outrageous and disturbing reports from the Idomeni "clear-out"
European Parliament Study: Cross-border placement of children in the European Union (pdf):
"This study, commissioned by the Policy Department for Citizens' Rights and Constitutional Affairs at the request of the JURI Committee, explores the range and nature of problems linked to the cross-border placement of children and to the application of article 56 of the Brussels IIa Regulation. Based on an analysis of the practice in 12 Member States and European case law, it identifies a number of shortcomings in the current legislative framework. Looking ahead to the recast of
Brussels IIa, the study sets out recommendations to remedy some of the weaknesses, such as clarifying the respective tasks of the Member States involved in cross-border placement cases and facilitating the recognition and enforcement of cross-border placement orders."
SPAIN: Fined with the Gag Law for carrying a bag with the face of a cat and the abbreviation A.C.A.B.
Belén Lobeto was returning to her house in Madrid last Sunday when she was stopped by two police officers who asked for her documentation and subsequently said they were going to fine her. The motive: a black fabric shoulder bag bearing the face of a cat and the abbreviation A.C.A.B, along with the words "All Cats Are Beautiful". The police's report stated that the abbreviation signifies "All Cops Are Bastards".
EU-USA: DATA PROTECTION: Model clauses in jeopardy with Irish DPA referral to CJEU (The Privacy Adviser, link):
"International data flows between the U.S. and EU may have taken yet another hit late Tuesday with news that the Irish Data Protection Commissioner is planning to refer a case to the Court of Justice of the European Union to determine whether Facebook can use standard contractual clauses, also often called model clauses, to transfer data out of the EU....
According to a press release from Europe-v-Facebook the Max Schrems-led group that brought both the Safe Harbor and current complaint to the Irish DPA, Under current CJEU case law, it is highly unlikely that Facebook Ireland could continue sharing data with the U.S. authorities.
See: Press Release: Facebook & NSA-Surveillance: Following Safe Harbor decision, Irish Data Protection Commissioner to bring EU-US data flows before CJEU again (pdf): "Yesterday night, we were informed that the Irish Data Protection Commissioner (DPC) is planning to refer to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) to determine if Facebook can continue to transfer data from the EU to the US after the invalidation of the Safe Harbor system by the Court on October 6th 2015 and given continues application of US mass surveillance laws."
EU: SHIPPING AND FISHERIES INDUSTRIES CO-OPTED INTO BORDER SURVEILLANCE & INTERCEPTING "SUSPECTED" BOATS Frontex, EMSA and EFCA extend cooperation (Frontex, link):
Frontex, the European Maritime Safety Agency (EMSA) and the European Fisheries Control Agency (EFCA) signed bilateral interagency agreements today to extend their cooperation. The three agencies will continue to work together in their respective areas of border surveillance, interception of vessels suspected of engaging in criminal activities, cross border crime, support for search and rescue at sea and illegal fishing.
European Parliament confirms that Privacy Shield is inadequate (EDRI, link)
"The European Parliament has adopted a Resolution on the Privacy Shield. This is the new agreement to permit data to be transferred from the EU to the USA. The previous agreement Safe Harbour was overturned by the European Court of Justice in October 2015. The Parliaments resolution confirms that the new agreement has no chance of being upheld, if challenged at the Court of Justice of the European Union, said Joe McNamee, Executive Director of European Digital Rights.:"
European Commission: Infringement Notices: Commission requests HUNGARY to put an end to the discrimination of Roma children in education (link)
"The European Commission is requesting Hungary to ensure that Roma children enjoy access to quality education on the same terms as all other children and urges the government to bring its national laws on equal treatment as well as on education and the practical implementation of its educational policies into line with the Racial Equality Directive (Council Directive 2000/43/EC). This Directive prohibits discrimination on grounds of racial or ethnic origin in education. The Commission has a number of concerns in relation to both Hungarian legislation and administrative practices which lead to the result that Roma children are disproportionately over-represented in special schools for mentally disabled children and also subject to a considerable degree of segregated education in mainstream schools. The aim of the Commission's action is to ensure for Roma children an equal access to education which is a determining factor for employment opportunities and thus an indispensable component of working towards full Roma inclusion.
The Commission has sent letters of formal notice to two other Member States, the Czech Republic and Slovakia, in relation to similar issues in the recent past. If Hungary fails to reply in a satisfactory manner within two months, the Commission may send to the Hungarian authorities a reasoned opinion."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (25.5.16)
Hillsborough: how one academic kept the truth from being hidden (bellacaledonia.org.uk, link) by Margaret Malloch and Bill Munro:
"How can academics put their research at the service of correcting great injustices? Phil Scraton and his work for the Hillsborough campaign offers a powerful example, write Margaret Malloch and Bill Munro.
There has been a justifiable amount of attention on the recent outcome of the inquests into the 96 men, women and children who lost their lives as a direct result of events at Hillsborough Football Ground on 15 April 1989. However, claims that at last, the truth is out leave us somewhat troubled.
The truth of what happened on that day has always been known not least by the bereaved families, the survivors and many more besides. That truth, until now, has been officially erased, or at least hidden and replaced by a carefully constructed and long maintained lie."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (24.5.16)
UK: Judge rejects CPS attempt to overturn DSEI arms fair protesters acquittal (ibtimes.co.uk, link)
"A judge dismissed charges against protesters at an arms fair in east London who felt they were attempting to stop a "greater crime".
The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) appealed against the acquittal of eight activists who demonstrated against the Defence Security and Equipment International (DSEI) event at the ExCel centre in London's Docklands in 2015. The protesters, accused of wilful obstruction of the highway after attempting to block entrance into the annual arms fair, believed they were preventing the sale of weapons that would abuse human rights in countries such as Yemen and Bahrain.
District Judge Hamilton has now rejected the CPS' appeal to have the acquittals overturned on the basis their argument was "frivolous" and "misconceived". He added: "The CPS application repeatedly significantly misrepresents the contents of the judgement delivered at the end of the case and therefore seeks to challenge the decisions reached on wholly erroneous bases.
"The very least the CPS should do is read the judgement fully and, if appropriate, frame their application based on what was actually decided rather than what they seem to believe was decided."
EU: Counter Terrorism: Council of the European Union: Strengthening cooperation on counter-terrorism threat analysis (LIMITE doc no: 8409-16, pdf): There is concern about the legal basis for sharing intelligence:
"The discussion showed divergences between Member States as to which role to give the EU in view of national positions and Article 4(2) TEU, in particular in relation to the sharing of intelligence information. Many delegations were positive towards the idea, whereas a number of delegations requested additional information and more details on a number of issues, such as the legal basis for such a joint threat assessment, methodology and which personal data would be exchanged. Others underlined the importance of avoiding duplication. The EU Counter-Terrorism Coordinator (CTC) supported the idea of a joint threat assessment."
and also where to draw the line between intelligence-gathering, analyses and operational roles: See EU INTCEN (pdf):
"EU INTCEN is the exclusive civilian intelligence analysis function of the European Union... EU INTCEN is not an operational agency and does not have any collection capability. The operational level of intelligence is the Member States responsibility. EU INTCEN deals only with strategic analysis...".
at the same time EU INTCEN "compliments" Member States' input by monitoring open sources:
"EU INTCEN deals only with strategic analysis. Its analytical products are mostly based on information provided by Member States security and intelligence services, but can also be complemented by open sources (media, websites, blogs etc.), diplomatic reporting, consular warden networks, international organisations, NGOs, CSDP missions and operations, the EU Satellite Centre, visits and field trips." [emphasis added]
See also: EU to enhance terrorism "threat assessments" as Counter Terrorist Group moves towards "real time information exchange"
EU: European Data Protection Supervisor (EDPS): Data protection for the digital generation: the countdown to the GDPR begins (Press release, pdf):
"Giovanni Buttarelli, EDPS, said: "The GDPR is one of the EU's greatest achievements in recent years and a document of which it should be proud. However, our job is not yet complete. We must ensure that the GDPR is fully and effectively implemented and that we close the package with equally effective agreements on Regulation 45/2001 and the ePrivacy Directive. Only then will we be able to ensure that the EU upholds its promise of effective data protection for the digital age."
and Annual Report 2015 (pdf)
DENMARK: European Court of Human Rights: Danish legislation on family reunion is discriminatory (Press release, pdf):
"The case concerned the complaint by a naturalised Danish citizen of Togolese origin, Ousmane Biao, and his Ghanaian wife that they could not settle in Denmark. Notably, the Danish authorities refused to grant them family reunion as the couple did not comply with the requirement under the relevant domestic law (the Aliens Act) that they must not have stronger ties with another country, Ghana in their case, than with Denmark (known as the attachment requirement). They also omplained that an amendment to the Aliens Act in December 2003 lifting the attachment requirement for those who held Danish citizenship for at least 28 years resulted in a difference in treatment between those born Danish nationals and those, like Mr Biao, who had acquired Danish citizenship later in life."
and Judgment Full-text (pdf)
Austria elects Green candidate as president in narrow defeat for far right (Guardian, link):
"Alexander Van der Bellen, a former Green party leader running as independent, pips the Freedom partys Norbert Hofer. A leftwing, independent candidate has narrowly prevented Austria from becoming the first EU country to elect a far-right head of state after a knife-edge contest ended with his opponent conceding defeat.
Alexander Van der Bellen, a retired economics professor backed by the Green party, defeated Norbert Hofer, of the anti-immigrant, Eurosceptic Freedom party, a day after polling closed and only when more than 700,000 postal ballots about 10% of available votes were taken into account."
Detecting foreign fighters: the reinvigoration of the Schengen Information System in the wake of terrorist attacks (eumigrationlawblog.eu, link) by Niovi Vavoula, Queen Mary, University of London:
"Overall, there is no doubt that the terrorist attacks of 2015 helped to unblock a number of measures that would otherwise meet resistance and the SIS II is a prime example of the over-reliance to technological means. However, the nature of these measures fosters and deepens the intertwining of criminality with mobility and blurs the distinction between a citizen and a foreigner since immigration-type measures are increasingly favored to regulate their movement. In the past, such efforts found resistance (e.g. the inclusion of EU citizens to the PNR system), however, in the light of the recent events such objections evidently may be more easily curtailed. The conduct of systematic checks at the external borders for everyone may be only the first in an array of measures and perhaps signifies a shift from securitisation of migration to securitisation of mobility and the end of citizenship as we know it."
EU and Poland in last minute talks on rule of law (euobserver, link):
"European commissioner Frans Timmermans is making a last minute trip to Warsaw on Tuesday (24 May), where he will meet with prime minister Beata Szydlo.
The two are expected to discuss possible solutions to the legal crisis that erupted last year in Poland. The Law and Justice (PiS) government had tried to appoint new judges to Polands constitutional court and pass a reform curtailing its powers. The court judged the steps to be unconstitutional, but the government hasn't recognised that ruling.
The European Commission had given Poland until Monday (23 May) to solve concerns over the rule of law. "
The shifting terrain for suspects rights in Europe the right to legal assistance saga in the Netherlands (Fair Trials, link):
"On 22 December 2015, the Dutch Supreme Court handed down a judgment in which it held that, as of 1 March 2016, all suspects should have the right to be assisted by a lawyer when questioned by the police. In earlier decisions in June 2009 and April 2014, the Court had recognized a right to consult with a lawyer prior to questioning, but stopped short of recognizing a right to have a lawyer present during questioning. The transition from the earlier judgements to the December 2015 one merits attention, as it sheds light on the shifting terrain for suspects rights in Europe, particularly as a result of the increasing grip of EU Roadmap Directives and ECHR jurisprudence upon national conceptions of fair trial rights."
UK: Metropolitan Police try to escape liability for shooting and death of Cherry Groce despite admitting "irreparable harm"
"The Metropolitan Police Commissioner is to argue that the family of Cherry Groce should not be permitted to pursue any claim against him for the irreparable harm caused to them as a result of the raid by armed police officers on their family home in 1985.
Mrs Groce was shot and seriously injured in front of her young children during the 1985 raid, and she died 26 years later in 2011 as a result of those injuries. In July 2014, an inquest jury found that the shooting and her death was the result of serious and multiple police failures on the part of officers across the ranks.
In the wake of the inquest, the Metropolitan Police Commissioner offered a personal apology for those failures. He said:
Today, I apologise unreservedly for our failings... we, as an organisation, failed to meet those responsibilities and in doing so caused irreparable damage to a mother and her family.
Notwithstanding that apology, the Commissioner is now seeking to avoid liability for the admitted irreparable damage caused to this family.
The hearing of his attempt to do so is due to take place before Mr Justice Jay at the High Court in the Royal Courts of Justice, London, commencing at 10.30am on Tuesday 24 May 2016."
See: Press release from Bhatt Murphy solicitors: Met Police seek to avoid liability to Cherry Groce's family for 1985 shooting (pdf)
UK: Police and faith alliance attacks counter-extremism bill (The Guardian, link): "David Camerons new counter-extremism legislation has been condemned by a powerful coalition of opponents, including the former police chief in charge of the governments anti-radicalisation programme, who warns that it could actually fuel terrorism.
The multi-faith alliance of 26 organisations and prominent individuals includes Liberty, Index on Censorship, the National Union of Students, Runnymede Trust and the Muslim Council of Britain, along with individuals including Peter Fahy, ex-chief constable of Greater Manchester and a former policing lead for the Prevent programme."
See the statement: Counter-Extremism Bill: Leading civil liberties campaigners raise concerns with proposals (Big Brother Watch, link): "We are a cross section of British society who believe in the necessity of keeping our nation safe and secure.
To defeat the scourge of terrorism we need a strategy underpinned by a soaring confidence in our values and the society we seek to build together. As such, we are gravely concerned that the proposed Counter-Extremism and Safeguarding Bill will feed the very commodity that the terrorists thrive on: fear. We must instead put forward proposals that show those who seek to undermine us that we value our freedom more than they cherish fear.
Terrorism in all its forms is already prohibited by the criminal law, as is speech that incites violence or promotes hatred. This Bill would provide the Government with the power to exclude those they disagree with from many parts of the public space. These proposals will serve to alienate communities and undermine free speech, but there is scant evidence that they will tackle the terrorism we all want to confront.
The fact that the Government is struggling to define the extremism it wants to ban should be a clear indication that this legislation has no place in a liberal democracy."
News Digest: round-up of news stories from across the EU (23.5.16)
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (23.5.16): supporting Sudan's post-Valletta Summit projects; condemnation of Germany's parliamentary voting for Tunisia, Morocco and Algeria as safe countries; ongoing ramifications of the EU-Turkey deal; and more.
EU: Europol report on the work of the European Counter Terrorism Centre
A report on the "state of play" of the European Counter Terrorism Centre, which started work in January this year. The report highlights the political background and context and moves on to the activities of the ECTC: a "continuous" increase of information on "foreign fighters" being inserted into FP Travellers and into the Europol Information System (EIS), along with an increased number of users (MI5 and the FBI are both highlighted as new users of the EIS); and 15,572 leads stemming from the EU-US Terrorist Finance Tracking Programme between 2015 up to April 2016.
The report also discusses: operational support activities (Taskforce Fraternité, EU Internal Referral Unit (IRU), Joint Liaison Team, secondary security checks in the migration hotspots in Greece); and "key strategic issues".
See: NOTE from: Europol to: Standing Committee on Operational Cooperation on Internal Security: Enhancing Europol's counter terrorism capabilities: European Counter Terrorism Centre at Europol (8881/16, 13 May 2016, pdf)
EU: Migration and border security top INTERPOL European meeting agenda (INTERPOL press release, link): "Addressing the border security challenges posed by an unprecedented number of migrants travelling to Europe is a key issue for senior law enforcement officials gathered at the 44th INTERPOL European Regional Conference.
Following the publication of the joint Europol-INTERPOL Report on Migrant Smuggling Networks earlier this week, delegates at the conference will hear from countries including Austria, Germany, Slovenia and the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia as well as from the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees on their experiences in tackling this phenomenon.
With the report highlighting that border controls influence key routes for migrant smuggling, ensuring frontline officers have access to INTERPOLs capabilities in order to access vital policing information, particularly within the Schengen area, is an essential part of enhancing national, regional and global security."
See: MIGRANT SMUGGLING NETWORKS Joint Europol-INTERPOL Report (pdf) and speeches from the conference: Opening address by Jürgen Stock, INTERPOL Secretary General (pdf) and Closing speech by Mr Alexander PROKOPCHUK, INTERPOL Executive Committee Delegate for Europe (pdf)
UK: Can Inspection Produce Meaningful Change in Immigration Detention? (Global Detention Project, link): "Abtract: Although prison inspection in the United Kingdom has a long history, inspection of immigration detention was properly established only in 2004. Her Majestys Inspectorate of Prisons (HMIP), a government-appointed independent human rights-based monitoring institution, holds this responsibility. In this GDP Working Paper, a lead HMIP inspector discusses the nature and impact of the Inspectorate's work, examining both the theory and practice of inspection. The paper places the discussion in the broader context of prison reform and debates on migration and border controls. The author argues that in liberal-democratic societies there are two broad approaches to promoting human rights reforms and challenging abuses: working from the inside to achieve progress with the risk that principles may be compromised and good intentions confounded; or promoting change from the outside, which is more uncompromising but less influential, at least in the short-term. This is a dilemma that confronts human rights based inspection of immigration detention in the UK. The main focus of HMIP is on improving the treatment of detainees and conditions in detention, not challenging the system of detention, even if immigration detention policy arguably lacks legitimacy in a way that criminal imprisonment does not. The author explores the effectiveness of detention inspection and whether inspection can be said to have promoted meaningful change."
French airports to test EU passenger data system (The Straits Times, link): "A European Union-wide passenger data sharing system aimed at helping in the detection of militants will be tested at two of France's busiest airports this month, a senior interior ministry official said yesterday.
The Passenger Name Record (PNR) system, approved by the European Parliament in April, will be tested at Charles de Gaulle Airport in Paris and at the Nice airport in the south-east before the tests are extended to all French airports, the official said.
He said the system should be fully operational by the end of the year, although EU countries were given two years to turn the measure into national law.
The idea was to "gradually link all the airlines" operating in France, the official said."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (21-22.5.16)
UK: Home Affairs Select Committee: Report: Police diversity (pdf):
"Urgent and radical action needed to tackle police services consistent failure on diversity .
In a report published today, Saturday 21 May 2016, the Home Affairs Select Committee (HASC) says urgent and radical action is needed to tackle the gross under-representation of black and minority ethnic people in the police forces of England and Wales, which police have consistently failed to address over several decades."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (20.5.16)
African Civil Society condemns the hunt for migrants on the continent (pdf):
"African civil society condemns these hunting policies for migrants that grow everywhere on the African continent with the support of the European institutions under the guise of the fight against "irregular" migration. The current situation in Libya is a sad illustration with anti-immigration brigade heavily armed, with the support of the European Union, which tracks day and night the sub-Saharan migrant workers cram in detention centers instead of effectively combating traffickers and Libyan smugglers...
The lure of European financial aid to fight against migration transforms the African political authorities in real persecutors of their brothers and sisters who are looking for work to live and feed their families. This could recall the time of slavery abolished there only two centuries. The European Union, at the expense of its humanist values, and shamelessly, in African countries outsources its security migration policy.
African civil society calls for the African Union commission, the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS) and all African heads of state to listen to the voice of their people and engage resolutely in a real regional integration process. Only a true African integration could prevent our countries to always be the instrument of European policy and will prevent brave young hope of tomorrow's Africa, being killed in other countries on the continent seeking win their daily bread."
Signed by: The West African Observatory on Migrations (WAOM), The Pan African Network for the Defense of Migrants' Rights (PANiDMR), Caritas - Migration and Development Network (MADE) Africa, Moroccan Transnational Network on Migration and Development (RMTMD), Samir ABI, Visions Solidaires.
EU: Justice and Home Affairs Council, 20 May 2016: Final press release (pdf)
"B" Points Agenda (for discussion, pdf), "A" Points (legislative, adopted without discussion) and "A" Points (non-legislative, adopted without discussion). See Background Note (pdf)
Among the "non-legislative" items to be adopted without discussion are: the EU-USA data protection "Umbrella Agreement" on the exchange of personal data - the Scope (Art 1): covers:
"The purpose of this Agreement is to ensure a high level of protection of personal information and enhance cooperation between the United States and the European Union and its Member States, in relation to the prevention, investigation, detection or prosecution of criminal offenses, including terrorism."
Note: the Scope covers all crimes however, minor.
- Agreement between the United States of America and the European Union on the protection of personal information relating to the prevention, investigation, detection, and prosecution of criminal offenses (Full-text, pdf) - Draft Council Decision - Adoption (pdf) - Council Decision (pdf)
Exclusive: Nick Clegg calls for inquiry into the Battle of Orgreave (Yorkshire Post, link):
"NIck CLEGG backs calls for a public inquiry into Battle of Orgreave during the 1980s miners strike.
The former Deputy Prime Minister has said the time is right to investigate the 1984 violent clash between police and miners in South Yorkshire that led to the arrests of 93 pickets.
Backing calls from the Orgreave Truth and Justice Campaign he said: With each passing day there are more questions to be asked. The more people are peeling back the events and the personalities involved, the more I think we will have to revisit the events surrounding Orgreave."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (19.5.16)
European Commission: Commission reports on state of fundamental rights in the EU (Press release, link) and see: 2015 Report on the Application of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights (Com 265-16, pdf): The report opens with:
"The EU faced numerous challenges in 2015: security threats, unprecedented arrivals of refugees and migrants, a rise in populism and xenophobia. These put EU values and solidarity to the test. Facing such challenges, it is vital to uphold the EU's common values of democracy, fundamental rights and the rule of law."
Statewatch comment: In regard to the refugee crisis EU values were certainly put to the test and blatantly failed. As to upholding "fundamental rights and the rule of law" they were thrown out of the window by the EU-Turkey "dodgy deal."
EU: Data protection: New Regulation boosts the roles of EDPS and Europol (pdf):
"The European Data Protection Supervisor (EDPS), Giovanni Buttarelli and the Director of the EU Agency for Law Enforcement Cooperation (Europol), Rob Wainwright, welcomed the recent adoption by the European Parliament of the new Regulation on Europol.
Speaking at the Privacy in the Digital Age of Encryption and Anonymity Online conference hosted at Europols headquarters in The Hague, Mr Buttarelli and Mr Wainwright said that the new Regulation boosts Europol's powers to fight terrorism, serious and organised crime and enhances its role as the central hub for information exchange."
EU-UK: Government: Background Note: The UKs cooperation with the EU on justice and home affairs, and on foreign policy and security issues (pdf)
UK: House of Commons Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Committee: Democracy Denied: Appointment of the UKs delegation to the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe: Government Response to the Committees Second Report of Session 201516 Ninth Report of Session 201516 (pdf):
"We do not accept this Government Response, which fails to address the importance of democracy in appointing the UKs Delegation to the Council of Europe. This is democracy denied. We call upon the Government to amend its process from Prime Ministerial announcement of a list of names decided in concert with party leaders, to free, fair and open election of the Commons element of a delegation by the whole House of Commons. If the House agrees to the principle of the change we propose, the Procedure Committee could consider how this reform should be implemented.
At the same time, we suggest that the Procedure Committee should consider whether the other delegations sent by Parliament to international assemblies, namely the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE), the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) Parliamentary Assembly and the British-Irish Parliamentary Assembly, should also be appointed by free, fair and open elections. We ask that the Government reconsider its response to our Report and produce a further response."
Greece: Refugee Hotspots Unsafe, Unsanitary (HRW, link):
"(Athens) Police are failing to protect people during frequent incidents of violence in closed centers on the Greek islands known as hotspots, Human Rights Watch said today. The centers were established for the reception, identification, and processing of asylum seekers and migrants. None of the three centers Human Rights Watch visited on Samos, Lesbos, and Chios in mid-May 2016, separate single women from unrelated adult men, and all three are unsanitary and severely overcrowded.
In Europes version of refugee camps, women and children who fled war face daily violence and live in fear, said Bill Frelick, refugee rights director at Human Rights Watch. Lack of police protection, overcrowding, and unsanitary conditions create an atmosphere of chaos and insecurity in Greeces razor wire-fenced island camps."
Pregnant women in detention centres kept hidden by the Home Office (Politics.co.uk, link):
"The Home Office puts a lot of work into making sure no-one finds out how many pregnant women they hold in their immigration detention centres.
For years they keep no central data on it at all. You can imagine why. Their guidelines state that pregnant women should only be held in exceptional circumstances. But if we can't find out how many pregnant women are in detention, or what happens to them, it's impossible to work out whether they're sticking to it."
ITU: Maintainting trust in digital connected society (pdf) This paper was prepared by Douwe Korff, Emeritus Professor of International Law, London Metropolitan University, Associate, Oxford Martin School, University of Oxford:
"The development of the global digital connected society requires trust and security, based on sound regulation of the use of personal data. However, this is hampered by conceptual differences between states as concerns privacy in a narrow sense and data protection in a broad sense, and by different views on the application of the basic norms to non-nationals and to people outside a states territory (the issue of universality of human rights).
The answer can only be found in global acceptance of a broad human rights-based concept of data protection that states must apply to everyone affected by their actions, irrespective of nationality or legal status or the place where they live. The global digital connected society can only develop in and between states that accept this fundamental principle."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (18.5.16)
Council of Europe: Parliamentary Assembly: PACE committee denounces abuse of administrative detention
"Expressing concern that administrative detention has been abused to punish political opponents, obtain confessions in the absence of a lawyer, or for stifling peaceful protest, the Committee on Legal Affairs and Human Rights calls for other solutions than those undermining the protection of the right to liberty and security.
Adopting a report on administrative detention by Lord Richard Balfe (United Kingdom, EC), the committee calls on all member states to refrain from using administrative detention as a migration management tool; for placing political opponents, human rights activists or journalists in administrative detention with a view to coercing them into confessing a criminal offence; or to prevent people from taking part in a given protest."
See: Committee on Legal Affairs and Human Rights: Administrative detention in Council of Europe member states legal limits and possible alternative measures (pdf)
UK-Council of Europe: Memorandum on surveillance and oversight mechanisms in the United Kingdom (pdf) and UK response to the Council of Europe Human Rights Commissioner - Memorandum on surveillance and oversight mechanisms in the UK (pdf)
"Whilst welcoming a number of positive developments, such as the creation of a single unified Investigatory Powers Commissioner with responsibility for surveillance oversight, the Commissioner expresses his concern about certain issues such as the compatibility of the bulk interception and equipment interference powers proposed in the above Bill with the European Convention on Human Rights. He also stresses that greater protection needs to be provided in the Bill for legal professional privilege and for communications of politicians and journalists. In addition, the Commissioner highlights the need for oversight bodies and systems to be periodically evaluated to assess whether or not they possess the necessary attributes to be effective."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (17.5.16)
Report Launched for "Mapping Refugee Media Journeys" project (Open University, link):
"The Open University has released a groundbreaking research report on how refugees use smartphones. It was led by Prof. Marie Gillespie and was carried out in partnership with France Medias Monde....
The report, Mapping Refugee Media Journeys: Smart Phones and Social Media Networks explores the benefits and risks of mobile phones for refugees. It calls for action from the European Commission and Member States to fulfill their responsibilities under the 1951 UN Refugee Convention to provide relevant, reliable and timely information and news for refugees."
See report: Mapping Refugee Media Journeys Smartphones and Social Media Networks (pdf) and Website (link)
SURVEILLANCE: More files from Edward Snowden's collection released
"From the time we began reporting on the archive provided to us in Hong Kong by NSA whistleblower Edward Snowden, we sought to fulfill his two principal requests for how the materials should be handled: that they be released in conjunction with careful reporting that puts the documents in context and makes them digestible to the public, and that the welfare and reputations of innocent people be safeguarded. As time has gone on, The Intercept has sought out new ways to get documents from the archive into the hands of the public, consistent with the public interest as originally conceived.
Today, The Intercept is announcing two innovations in how we report on and publish these materials. Both measures are designed to ensure that reporting on the archive continues in as expeditious and informative a manner as possible, in accordance with the agreements we entered into with our source about how these materials would be disclosed, a framework that he, and we, have publicly described on numerous occasions."
See: The Intercept Is Broadening Access to the Snowden Archive. Heres Why (The Intercept, link)
FRANCE: State of emergency: activists banned from attending protest against labour law
"The French authorities have used the anti-terror state of emergency to ban several activists from joining demonstrations against the government's labour reform this week. Unions have planned two days of protest and called strikes in the air transport, road freight, rail and oil sectors.
About a dozen members of two far-left organisations, Action Antifasciste (AFA) and Mouvement Interluttes indépendant (Mili), have received orders banning them from entering Paris's sixth, seventh, 14th and 15th arrondissements on 17 May, the day that a march against the controversial labour bill will pass through those areas."
And see: French government to bypass parliament to introduce controversial labour law
UK: Videos from The Monitoring Group's conference on political policing and racism in the UK
"On the weekend of 16th and 17th April 2016, a seminal conference took place in London, and, as the title suggests, it had two central themes to discuss and confront:
- the nature of State racism the bedrock for institutional, popular and sometimes violent racism and policing policies that target or create notions of suspect communities and their damaging impact of British Society
- the evolution and practice of political policing in UK:. Building on a hugely successful conference in 2015, participants at the conference explored the history and disastrous impact of the policing of social and justice movements, in light of the upcoming Undercover Policing Inquiry, and demanded the Inquiry adopts an open and rigorous approach."
See: Watch the videos from our conference : Subversion, Sabotage and Spying: Political Policing and Racism in the UK (The Monitoring Group, link)
News Digest: round-up of news stories from across the EU (16.5.16)
European Commission letter to Greek asylum authorities: all is well in Turkey
A letter from the European Commission to the Greek authorities setting out why Turkey should be considered a safe third country has been condemned by a Greek human rights group as an attempt "to establish standardized reasoning for systematically denying the asylum claims of Syrian and non-Syrian nationals as inadmissible in Greece."
And see: Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (16.5.16)
UK: Parliamentary committee: safety in prisons continues "to deteriorate significantly"
A new report from the House of Commons Justice Committee examines "the Government's response to the ongoing and rapid deterioration in prison safety in England and Wales which began in 2012" and concludes that "overall levels of safety in prisons have not stabilised as the Ministry [of Justice] hoped, let alone improved and continue to deteriorate significantly."
UK: Hillsborough, Orgreave and South Yorkshire Police: the cover-up connections
"The central elements of both disgraces are chillingly similar. First contrary to media coverage which demonised the victims, cheer-led in both cases by the Sun the police were at fault.
Second, as they did in 1989 after the Hillsborough semi-final descended into horror, the South Yorkshire police created their own narrative about the Orgreave battle, blaming the miners in an apparently concerted campaign of vilification.
Third is the allegation that both South Yorkshire police operations were followed by a concerted falsification of evidence, and a cover-up."
See: Orgreave inquiry calls grow after damning Hillsborough verdict for police (The Guardian, link)
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (14-15.5.16)
EU Referendum: Boris Johnson compares EU's aims to Hitler's (BBC News, link):
"Boris Johnson has compared the EU's aims to Hitler's, saying both involved the intention to unify Europe under a single "authority".The pro-Brexit Tory MP said both the Nazi leader and Napoleon had failed at unification and the EU was "an attempt to do this by different methods".
David Miliband's refugee aid group in corruption probe (Daily Telegraph, link):
"The United States is investigating an international aid group headed by David Miliband over allegations of corruption in projects intended to help Syrian civilians and refugees. The International Rescue Committee (IRC) is one of three international groups to have had millions of pounds in funding withdrawn over alleged bid-rigging and bribery....
Allegations relate to the organisations systematically overpaying for goods in Turkey. A senior USAID official, speaking on condition of anonymity, said private Turkish companies had sold cut-rate blankets and other basic materials at vastly inflated prices and pocketed the difference...."
Refugees: German police chief concerned at growing anti-refugee violence (DW, link):
"Germany's federal police chief says there have been 45 arson ttacks on refugee shelters so far this year. He warned of the potential threat posed by organized right-wing extremist crime....
Speaking to newspapers of the Funke media group, Münch said the "increasing level of violence was especially of concern," adding that 45 arson attacks had been carried out on refugee shelters so far this year.."
Médecins Sans Frontières/Doctors Without Borders (MSF): Europe, don't turn your back on asylum: #TakePeopleIn (link)
"Meanwhile the welcome offered by Europe to those in Greece often erases what little hope people had left. In island hotspots there are virtually no safeguards in place. Women fear to go to the toilet once darkness falls, mothers beg for formula milk to feed their babies, and men of all ages lose their dignity fighting over scraps of food or who is next in line.
European countries, people are in need of your help and protection not just your money. Is World War II so long ago that you no longer recall the basic human need to flee from violence and persecution when left with no other choice? We understand that meeting the huge challenges of the global displacement crisis has become a controversial political issue, but for us it is first and foremost a humanitarian one, and it should be for you too.
"Many of your citizens have risen to this challenge by volunteering to help others, but your leadership has lagged behind for fear of potential political consequences. We appeal to you, the leaders of Europe, to rise to the challenge: use your substantial resources to welcome and offer protection to those who need your help."
UK: Immigration Bill becomes law: The Bill becomes an Act: whats been won, and whats been lost (Right to Remain, link): "Yesterday (12 May 2016), the Immigration Bill 2015-16 received Royal Assent, which means it now becomes the 2016 Immigration Act.
In those words, a great deal is bound up.
As we have written previously, the Act involves a hardening and an extending of the measures designed to create a Hostile Environment for migrants brought in by 2014 Immigration Act, including:
Cutting access to justice... Extending internal border enforcement... Criminalising irregular migration..."
Drone warfare: the cost of progress (openDemocracy, link): "What is clear is the determination of the United States and its coalition partners to avoid committing large ground forces to the war. The deep failures in Afghanistan and Iraq inflicted harsh lessons which have been learned, at least in respect of the need to avoid deploying tens of thousands of "boots on the ground". There may by contrast be plenty of special forces, airstrikes and armed drones; these represent the changing nature of the wars now being fought by the west.
As this kind of war intensifies, though and with every prospect of major operations against ISIS in Libya there are clear indications that the move to remote warfare carries unexpected consequences (see "The drone-war blowback", 29 September 2011). Nowhere is this more clear than with the proliferation of armed drones, which are still seen as weapons of choice in Washington, Paris, London and Tel Aviv."
News Digest: round-up of news stories from across Europe (13.5.16)
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (13.5.16)
UK-EU: House of Lords committee says EU's Operation Sophia deals with "symptoms, not causes" and "cannot deliver its mandate"
A new report from the UK House of Lords' European Union Committee has commended the EU's "anti-smuggling" military operation in the Mediterranean for its efforts at search and rescue, but notes that it is ultimately unable to meet its aims of deterring migrants, disrupting smugglers' networks and thwart smugglers' business models as it deals with "symptoms, not causes".
Key document: European External Action Service: Planning for a possible non-executive Civilian CSDP mission in Libya (LIMITE doc no: 7491/16, 1 April 2016, pdf):
UPDATE: The mandate that the European Union Committee considers "cannot be delivered" has been extended by a year, with new tasks given to the mission
EU to enhance terrorism "threat assessments" as Counter Terrorist Group moves towards "real time information exchange"
The Dutch Presidency of the Council of the EU has offered Member States two options on how "a fuller, more coherent, comprehensive and future-oriented picture of the terrorist threat" could be established at EU level: either by increasing cooperation between Europol and the EU Intelligence Analysis Centre (INTCEN), or by inviting the Council's COSI committee (operational cooperation on internal security) to develop "common conclusions" based on work undertaken by Europol and INTCEN.
Key document: Strengthening cooperation on counter-terrorism threat analysis (LIMITE doc no: 8409-16, pdf)
EU: Clarifying the Euro-jargon: Terminology to be used in the agendas of the Council and Coreper (8338/1/16 REV 1, 25 April 2016, pdf)
LATVIA-ESTONIA-RUSSIA: ECJ: Article 19 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights: Advocate-General's opinion on extradition of a non-national
"2. The present case concerns an extradition request issued by the Russian Federation to the Republic of Latvia in relation to an Estonian national who had been arrested on the territory of the Republic of Latvia.
3. In essence, the Court is asked to rule on whether the protection against extradition which Latvian nationals enjoy under national law and under a bilateral agreement with the Russian Federation must, under the rules of the FEU Treaty on citizenship of the Union, be extended to nationals of other Member States.
4. A number of Member States, including the Republic of Latvia, recognised, in their national law and also in the international conventions to which they are parties, the principle that they refuse to extradite their nationals. When an extradition request is addressed to a Member State and that request concerns a citizen of the Union who is not a national of the requested Member State, such a principle establishes a difference in treatment between the nationals of that State and the nationals of the other Member States. I am of the view, however, that such a difference in treatment does not constitute discrimination on the ground of nationality contrary to the first paragraph of Article 18 TFEU, provided that it is shown that those two categories of nationals are not in a comparable situation in the light of the objective of combating the impunity of persons suspected of having committed an offence in a third State."
See: OPINION OF ADVOCATE-GENERAL BOT delivered on 10 May 2016 in Case C-182/15 (Alexsei Petruhhin) (pdf)
BELGIUM: Army deployed to help run prisons
"In the face of the current chaotic and potentially explosive situation in jails, the Belgian government has decided to use the army as its new trump card to tackle issues arising from its lack of political action and public investment." See: Should the Belgian Army Be Used to Resolve Social Issues? (Liberties.eu, link)
And: Council of Europe worried about Belgian prisons crisis (EurActiv, link)
EU: Legal aid in European Arrest Warrant proceedings: Council report on latest trilogue with Parliament
The European Parliament and the Council of the European Union are coming closer to an agreement on the text of a Directive that sets out provisions on access to legal aid for persons subject to a European Arrest Warrant.
A document produced by the Dutch Presidency on 4 May 2016 provides an overview of discussions that took place in a secret "trilogue" meeting on 3 May, at which the topics of discussions were articles 5 (European Arrest Warrant), 6 (timely and diligent procedures), 7 (quality of legal aid services and training) and 8 (remdies) of the proposed Directive and the forthcoming European Parliament impact assessment.
EU: Human trafficking: European Parliament says Member States not supporting victims
"EU member states should do more to protect victims of human trafficking, especially women, and take gender-specific prevention, assistance and support measures to help them, say MEPs in a resolution voted on Thursday. The text points out that EU legislation to protect victims of trafficking is not being properly enforced."
UK: Birmingham pub bombings coroner has 'significant' new information (The Guardian, link): "A significant piece of information relating to advance warning about the IRAs Birmingham pub bombings has been sent to the coroner who is considering whether to reopen the inquest into the 1974 atrocity.
Louise Hunt, the senior coroner for Birmingham and Solihull, told a hearing on Thursday that the new material had been sent to her office on 27 April from an undisclosed source.
Hunt said it related to an allegation that the security services had advance notice.
Its significant and does raise concerns in relation to potential advanced notice, thats as much as I can say, Hunt said. "
Number of people arriving on Greek islands dropped dramatically in April
"The number of migrants arriving on the Greek islands in April plunged by 90% compared to the previous month, reaching fewer than 2 700. The drop is a result of several factors, including The EU-Turkey agreement and stricter border policies applied by the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia at its border with Greece.
The drop in the number of arrivals on the Greek islands was dramatic. The total for all of April is well below the number of people we often saw reaching just the island of Lesbos on a daily basis during last years peak months, said Frontex Executive Director Fabrice Leggeri.
Syrians again accounted for the largest share of the migrants coming to the Greek islands, trailed by nationals from Pakistan, Afghanistan and Iraq."
Press release: Advocate General: IP addresses are personal data
The EU's top lawyer today answered a question that seems to be as old as the Internet. In his opinion, IP addresses are personal data and may be collected only where allowed by data protection law. The opinion concerns the case of German pirate party politician and privacy activist Patrick Breyer who is suing the German government over logging all visits to government websites (Case C-582/14).
News Digest: round-up of news stories from across Europe (12.5.16)
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (12.5.16): EU plans to ease expulsions; continuation of internal Schengen border controls; new studies on the role of the European Investment Bank, the functioning of hotspots and the situation in Greece and Macedonia; discussions on returns to Afghanistan; protecting the rights of irregular migrants; and more.
Draft Council conclusions call on Member States to "reduce administrative burdens" that hinder expulsion of third-country nationals
EU Member States will be "invited" to ease the expulsion of expelling "illegally staying third-country nationals" by reducing "administrative burdens" - such as "the suspensive effect of return and asylum decisions" and "multiple and last minute asylum applications and appeals" - if a set of draft conclusions being prepared for the Justice and Home Affairs Council meeting on 20 May remain in their current form.
Schengen: Greece and Slovenia unhappy with continuation of internal border controls
The Council of the EU has today (12 May 2016) adopted a decision that permits the continuation of the internal border controls adopted by Austria, Germany, Denmark, Sweden and Norway. Greece and Slovenia have submitted statements disagreeing with the decision.
EU: European Parliament adopts new rules on Europol and migration of students, researchers and interns
Europol: Police cooperation: MEPs approve new powers for Europol to fight terrorism (EP press release, pdf)
Students/researchers/interns: New rules to attract non-EU students, researchers and interns to the EU (EP press release, pdf)
EU: CONSULAR COOPERATION: Council of the EU: Consular Cooperation Initiatives - Final Report (8347/16, 29 April 2016, pdf): "The overarching objective of the Consular Cooperation Initiatives (CCIs) was to optimize the consular support to all citizens of the European Union in third countries and to strengthen consular cooperation at the Union level. The specific objective was to further explore possibilities for developing the role of EU Delegations in facilitating and supporting coordination between Member States in their role of providing consular protection to citizens of the Union in third countries as agreed in the Council Conclusions on the EEAS review of 17 December 2013.
A Core Team of interested MS was established to manage the initiative under general supervision of COCON. CCI projects were implemented in 5 countries: Cambodia, Dominican Republic, Nepal, Nigeria and Tunisia. In each country a MS assumed the role of Chef de File and developed a project plan on the basis of a common template (Annex). The EEAS acted as secretariat of the group and supported the harmonised approach. The Commission and the Council Secretariat attended the discussions. The projects ran from January to December 2015. After that, the CCI Core team continued to convene under the Netherlands presidency to compile all data, draw up the relevant conclusions and recommendations and prepare for recommended follow up.
This report first presents the overall conclusions and recommendations emanating from the detailed evaluation per country. The country evaluations are added to the report, as well as the joint EU Crisis Preparedness Framework that was drawn up as part of the Consular Cooperation Initiatives, a copy of the common template for the project plans and the global statistics on consular assistance to non-represented EU-citizens compiled by EEAS."
See also: Annex I to the Final Report: Joint EU Consular Crisis Preparedness Framework (8347/16 ADD 1, pdf) and: Consular demárches: Toolkit on procedural issues (8280, 26 April 2016, pdf)
UK: Exclusive: UK Government and Police Are Getting Information From 'Shadowy' Terrorism Database (Vice News, link): "A "shadowy" private database that has wrongly linked individuals to terrorist activity is being widely used by British police, intelligence, and the charity regulator, a VICE News investigation has found, amid growing anger among British and European parliamentarians about its effect on people's lives.
The confidential World-Check database profiles individuals and organizations under various categories, using open-source information to uncover their "hidden risk" for government agencies and banks. An adverse profile on the database, which is used by 49 of the 50 top global banks, has been linked to account closures and blacklisting."
Background: VICE News Reveals the Terrorism Blacklist Secretly Wielding Power Over the Lives of Millions (link)
And: questions to the European Commission from Sophia in 't Veld MEP (ALDE) and Jan Philipp Albrecht (Greens/EFA): World Check database listing individuals as linked to terrorism (10 February 2016, pdf). The Commission has not yet responded.
EU: Facial recognition to accompany fingerprints in transnational databases
"Last week, the European Commission published its proposal to recast the EURODAC Regulation, which includes plans for longer storage periods, an expansion of data categories and comparison capabilities, and mandatory fingerprinting and photographing. To date, EURODAC has been used for comparison of fingerprints.
Now the system is also to store facial images and facial recognition capabilities are to be added. There are two different search options. When checks are taking place, peoples images can be compared with available personal data to verify their identity (known as 1:1 matching). However, it is also possible to search for a face in the entire database (1:n)."
UK: The long road to justice (New Law Journal, link): "Patrick Roche examines the lessons to be learnt from Hillsborough.
The jurys conclusion that the 96 Liverpool fans who died at Hillsborough on 15 April 1989 were unlawfully killed marked the culmination of a remarkable 27-year campaign for justice by the families of the 96. The inquests, which lasted over two years, were both the longest inquests and the longest jury case in legal history.
Responding to 14 questions relating to the causes of the disaster and a further questionnaire for each of the deceased, the jury delivered trenchant and carefully reasoned answers setting out the failures of South Yorkshire Police (SYP), Sheffield Wednesday FC and the architects Eastwoods, which caused the disaster, and the blunders by the police and ambulance service, which meant that the emergency response failed to save many of those who died."
BELGIUM: Council of Europe worried about Belgian prisons crisis (EurActiv, link): "The Council of Europe, the continents oldest organisation specialised in human rights, has visited prisons in Belgium where a large number of staff were absent due to strike and therefore did not provide services to inmates.
Belgium faces a growing crisis in its prisons, with the army called in to help and inmates stuck in their cells 24 hours a day as the government struggles to end a strike by prison staff.
The Council of Europes anti-torture committee, the CPT, has made an ad-hoc visit from 7 to 9 May to look at the situation in the prisons of Huy, Ittre and Jamioulx and the social defence establishment of Paifve.
At the end of the visit, the delegation presented its preliminary observations to Koen Geens, Minister of Justice, and senior officials of the Ministry of Justice, and held consultations on the measures taken by the Belgian authorities to establish a guaranteed minimum service, with a view to preventing inhuman and degrading treatment of inmates."
See: Council of Europe anti-torture Committee visits prisons affected by strikes in Belgium (European Committee for the Prevention of Torture, link)
Information on the CPT's 2013 visit to Belgium: Council of Europe anti-torture Committee publishes report on Belgium (link); full report (French only, pdf) and government response (pdf, also in French)
News Digest: round-up of news stories from across the EU (11.5.16)
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (11.5.16): New report from the UN Secretary-General, strict new asylum measures in Hungary, EU-Turkey visa waiver talks halted in Parliament and more.
EU: Fight against terrorism: Parliament to vote on updated powers for Europol (press release, pdf): "MEPs vote this week on new powers for Europol. These would allow the agency to set up specialised units more easily so that it can respond faster to emerging threats. They would also set clear rules for centres, such as the European Counter Terrorism Centre that started on 1 January 2016. In some cases Europol would also be allowed to exchange information with private companies. For example, Europol would be able to ask Facebook to remove pages run by Islamic State.
These new powers would be accompanied by strong data protection safeguards and democratic oversight rules.
Negotiators from the Parliament and the Council reached a deal on this on 26 November 2015, which was endorsed by Parliament's civil liberties committee on 30 November.
However, before the agreement can enter into force, it will still need to be formally approved by Parliament.
MEPs debate the deal on Wednesday 11 May from 9.00 CET and vote on it at about 12.30 CET."
'Risks of inaction are considerable', says Ban, urging new compact on refugees and migrants (UN, link): " Despite bold efforts, responses to the large movements of refugees and migrants which will continue or possibly increase due to such issues as conflict, poverty and disasters have been largely inadequate, United Nations Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon said today in a new report, calling for the adoption of a global compact on responsibility-sharing that collectively ensures the human rights, safety and dignity of all refugees and migrants.
Away from the daily headlines and stark images, strains are quietly accumulating on refugees and migrants, as well as on countries and communities that receive them, sometimes for many years, Mr. Ban stressed in his report to the UN General Assembly, entitled In safety and dignity: addressing large movements of refugees and migrants.
If one lesson can be drawn from the past few years, it is that individual countries cannot solve these issues on their own. International cooperation and action to address large movements of refugees and migrants must be strengthened, he added.
Any approach should uphold the safety and dignity in large movements of both refugees and migrants, Mr. Ban said, urging Member States to, among other things, address the root causes of such movements, protect people en route and at borders, and prevent discrimination and promote inclusion."
Full report: Report of the Secretary-General: In safety and dignity: addressing large movements of refugees and migrants (pdf)
EU-TURKEY: Visa liberalisation for Turkey: EU critieria must be met, say MEPs (press release, pdf): "The EU should make sure that all its requirements are met before granting Turkey visa-free access to the Schengen area, stressed Civil Liberties Committee MEPs in a debate with the EU Commission on Monday. Most MEPs criticised the Commission for proposing a visa waiver for Turkish nationals even though the country has not yet fulfilled all the criteria. Turkey should not be discriminated, but neither should it receive preferential treatment, they agreed."
And see: EP stops work on Turkey visa waiver (EUobserver, link): "MEPs have stopped work on plans to give Turks visa-free access to the EUs Schengen zone, putting a wider migrant deal in doubt.
Group leaders in the European Parliament's conference of presidents quietly suspended work on the file last Wednesday. Some of the lead MEPs on the dossier, the group coordinators in the civil liberties committee (LIBE), found out about the suspension on Monday (9 May).
"They [EP group leaders] decided to stop the whole thing," the German centre-left coordinator Birgit Sippel told this website on Tuesday.
Judith Sargentini, a Dutch Green MEP, said EU parliament chief Martin Schulz suspended it because Turkey had not yet met all EU visa-free criteria.
Schulz said we will only start processing the file when the 72 criteria have been met, she said."
French government to bypass parliament to introduce controversial labour law
"France's government announced Tuesday that it would empower Prime Minister Manuel Valls to bypass parliament and push through controversial labour reforms by decree despite widespread public demonstrations against the bill.
The decision follows weeks of sometimes violent protests against the proposed reform, which among other changes seeks to make hiring and firing easier for companies.
Because the country must move forward ... the cabinet has authorised me to act on behalf of the government, Valls told lawmakers, to loud boos and heckling from some deputies and applause from others."
EU: Migration: discussions on the "Central Mediterranean Route", EU Travel Information and Authorisation System; Visa Code negotiations
A leaked document produced by the Dutch Presidency of the Council of the EU proposes various ways to deal with a possible summer increase in people crossing the Mediterranean towards Italy. The Dutch Presidency has also issued a discussion document seeking Member States' views on a possible "EU Travel Information and Authorisation System (ETIAS)". Meanwhile, the Council has adopted its position for negotiations with the European Parliament on the EU's Visa Code.
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (10.5.16)
CIA-RENDITION: European Parliament: MOTION FOR A RESOLUTION further to Questions for Oral Answer B8-0367/2016 and B8-0368/2016 pursuant to Rule 128(5) of the Rules of Procedure on follow-up to the European Parliament resolution of 11 February 20015 on the US Senate report on the use of torture by the CIA (2016/2573(RSP)) Claude Moraes on behalf of the Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs (pdf):
"Expresses, one year after the release of the US Senate study, its serious concerns about the apathy shown by Member States and EU institutions with regard to recognising the multiple fundamental rights violations and torture which took place on European soil between 2001 and 2006, investigating them and bringing those complicit and responsible to justice."
Turkey: Border Guards Kill and Injure Asylum Seekers - Border Lock-Down Puts Syrian Lives at Risk (HRW, link):
"(Istanbul) Turkish border guards are shooting and beating Syrian asylum seekers trying to reach Turkey, resulting in deaths and serious injuries, Human Rights Watch said today. The Turkish authorities should stop pushing Syrian asylum seekers back at the border and should investigate all use of excessive force by border guards....
While senior Turkish officials claim they are welcoming Syrian refugees with open borders and open arms, their border guards are killing and beating them, said Gerry Simpson, senior refugee researcher at Human Rights Watch. Firing at traumatized men, women, and children fleeing fighting and indiscriminate warfare is truly appalling."
UK: Drones: parliamentary report takes aim at controversial targeted killing policy
"The Joint Committee on Human Rights (JCHR) has today published its report on the Governments policy on the use of drones for targeted killing, following its inquiry in the wake of the killing of suspected terrorist and UK national Reyaad Khan by an RAF drone strike in Syria. The Government states that the UK military action taken against Reyaad Khan on 21 August 2015 was armed conflict, as part of the same armed conflict in which the UK was already involved in Syria, and the Committee accepts this. However, the report also establishes that it is the Governments policy to be willing to use lethal force abroad, outside of armed conflict, when there is no other way of preventing an imminent terrorist attack against the UK."
UK: Chilcot report on Iraq war to be published on 6 July (Guardian, link): "Security checks on the 2.6m-word report have been completed without the need for any redactions, Sir John Chilcot tells PM."
News Digest: round-up of news stories from across the EU (9.5.16)
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (9.5.16): Reports of a Syrian woman shot at the Hungarian-Slovakian border; reactions to and analysis of new EU asylum proposals, a map of refugee camps on mainland Greece, and a round-up of news stories.
EU: Commission Proposals for tougher Dublin system, more data collection under Eurodac and the birth of a new Asylum Agency
"The proposed reform of the Dublin Regulation will not revisit the responsibility criteria of the current mechanism, which in the majority of cases lead to Member States of first entry being designated as responsible for asylum seekers. The weight placed on the irregular entry criterion could be further exacerbated given that the 12-month time-limit, after which the responsibility of the country of entry ceases under the current rules, is to be removed. The proposal includes a corrective fairness mechanism of relocation, to be triggered in Member States facing particular pressure, similar to a reform proposed last September. Under that mechanism, asylum seekers will be subject to a relocation scheme from the country in question only after their claim has been deemed admissible, namely after the potential applicability of the safe third country concept has been ruled out in their case. Member States refusing to relocate asylum seekers will have to pay 250,000 per person to the country in which he or she is relocated."
GREECE-EU: Greek Govt Votes in Favor of Tough Pension-Tax Reforms (Greek Reporter, link): "Greek Parliament debated a set of tough economic pension and tax reforms on Saturday and Sunday. The 300-strong Parliament voted for the bill with 153 in favor, 143 against.
Ruling leftist SYRIZA Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras pointed to the hard work that his government has done in order to ensure the viability of the social security system and also made reference to social justice, pointing out that tax restructuring had been taken with vulnerable groups in mind when sharing out the burden of reforms.
Main opposition conservative New Democracy Party Leader Kyriakos Mitsotakis pointed to a historic need to speak the language of truth. You never spoke the language of truth, Mr. Tsipras, he said from the podium of Greek Parliament. You didnt do it when you said you would abolish the Memorandums of Understanding nor when you said you would bring back the 13th pension payment. Furthermore, he said the convergence package of 3.6 bln euros that creditors called for lacked credibility."
And see: Police fire tear gas at protestors outside Greek Parliament (France 24, link) and Reactions: Greek MPs Vote on More Austerity Amid Strikes, Sit-Ins and Suspensions (Greek Reporter, link)
EU: The fight against terrorism in Europe: What the EU does (not do) and what it should do (European Area of Freedom Security & Justice, link): "This was the title of a discussion seminar organised by Fondazione Lelio e Lisli Basso on April 18, 2016, attended by leading criminal judicial cooperation experts as well as by Emilio DE CAPITANI, Executive Director of the FREE Group,at the end of which the following document was drafted, which we submit to the attention of all concerned and in particular those responsible for policy in this sector."
Google and Microsoft have made a pact to protect surveillance capitalism (The Guardian, link): "Microsoft and Google, two of the worlds greatest monopolies, have been bitter rivals for nearly 20 years. But suddenly, in late April, they announced a startling accord. The companies have withdrawn all regulatory complaints against one another, globally. Rather than fighting their battles in public courts and commissions, they have agreed to privately negotiate.
Zuboff is a leading critic of what she calls surveillance capitalism, the monetization of free behavioral data acquired through surveillance and sold on to entities with an interest in your future behavior. As she explained to the Guardian: Google discovered surveillance capitalism. Microsoft has been late to this game, but it has now waded in. Viewed in this way, its agreement with Google is predictable and rational.
And here the most sinister upshot of Microsofts decision to stop needling Google with legal disputes becomes clear. A key theme I write about is that surveillance capitalism has thrived in lawless space, says Zuboff. Regulations and laws are its enemy. Democratic oversight is a threat. Lawlessness is so vital to the surveillance capitalism project, she continues, that Google and Microsofts shared interest in freedom from regulation outweighs any narrower competitive interests they might have or once thought they had. They cant insist to the public that they must remain unregulated, while trying to impose regulations on one another."
UK: INVESTIGATORY POWERS BILL: The Home Office Only Listens When We Dont Want Them To (Medium, link): "Today the latest version of the Investigatory Powers Bill was published. The Government might want some credit for being transparent and publishing the document with tracked changes so we can see how it has changed since the Bill was published in early March. But more so than transparency, it indicates their brazen approach to consultation. Why? Because the Bill has barely changed: a spelling and grammar tidy up e.g. intellegences services changed to intelligence services; A few provisions made even more draconian than they already were e.g. If it is not reasonably practicable for an instrument making a major modification to be signed by the Secretary of State, the instrument may be signed by a senior official designated by the Secretary of State for that purpose. This new provision means that major modification to a bulk warrant that may lead to greater intrusion into thousand or even millions of peoples personal information could now be signed off not by a Secretary of State, not a judge, not even a Minister but by a civil servant."
View all the changes made to the Bill by the Home Office: Is the Home Office Listening? (link), or in pdf format: Investigatory Powers Bill (as amended in Public Bill Committee) and see the Privacy International campaign: Don't Bug my Computer (link)
Protests against immigration detention centres
See: Hundreds take part in protest calling for end of immigration detention centres (ITV, link): "Campaigners from across our region have joined simultaneous protests around the world - against the use of detention centres for immigrants.
Thousands are thought to have staged demonstrations - including outside Morton Hall in Lincolnshire today."
In Scotland: Hundreds join Dungavel detention centre protest (BBC News, link) and: From Campsfield to Calais protests demand end to deportations (Socialist Worker, link)
UK-EU-ECHR: British Bill of Rights: Government should "think again" says parliamentary committee
The Conservative government's proposal to replace the Human Rights Act with a 'British Bill of Rights' has been heavily criticised by the House of Lords European Union Committee in a report that says there is "a forceful case for the Government to think again before continuing with this policy."
See: House of Lords European Union Committee: The UK, the EU and a British Bill of Rights (9 May 2016, pdf)
UK: A Significant Blow to Deportation with Assurances (One Small Window, link): "On 18 April, in a judgment that is now final, as Home Secretary Theresa May chose not to appeal within the 10-day period granted, judges at the Special Immigration Appeals Commission (SIAC) in London ended the long-running deportation case of six Algerian terrorism suspects. The appeal against deportation, lodged over a decade ago in 2005, concerned safety on return to Algeria.
Having spent almost the whole of this century subject to some form of detention, they have never been charged or convicted of terrorism offences in the UK, or know what they are suspected of.
The British government has failed to deport anyone on the basis of assurances given by the five countries it has concluded agreements with. One of the special advocates in the case, Martin Goudie, a security-vetted barrister who represented the appellants in the closed case, stated, This does not bring an end to DWA, but [ ] is a significant blow to it. Later this year, such assurances will come under scrutiny again when SIAC hears the deportation to Jordan case of N2."
See the judgment: Special Immigration Appeals Commission: Appeal between BB, PP, W, U, Y and Z and The Secretary of State for the Home Department (18 April 2016, pdf)
UK: Major court victory for blacklisted construction workers
"Workers who say they were blacklisted by construction companies have won millions in compensation after a long-running legal battle finally ended.
The union Unite has reached a settlement with construction firms that will mean 256 workers share more than £10m in compensation.
The amount will depend on factors such as loss of income.
In some cases, the blacklist included details of worker's political views, competence, and trade union activities.
The list had been used by dozens of construction firms to vet those applying for work on building sites."
UK-EU: Judicial Power: 50 Problematic Cases (Judicial Power Project, link): "One of the aims of the Judicial Power Project is to stimulate debate about the proper bounds of the judicial role. As visitors to this website will know, our concern is that the judicial role is expanding in ways that threaten constitutional self-government and the rule of law. A particular concern is to draw attention to the many different ways in which judges fail to respect the limits of their role. Criticism about judicial overreach often focuses on the decisions of the European Court of Human Rights and the EUs Court of Justice. Equally important are the many cases in which domestic judges have improperly ventured beyond the limits of their role. Ascendant judicial power is often most visible in the context of questions about how to protect human rights, but it also extends much more widely than this."
See: 50 Problematic Cases (link)
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (7-8.5.16)
The Orbanisation of EU asylum law: the latest EU asylum proposals (EU Law Analysis, link):
"The Commissions proposals are not a done deal, of course. Some Member States and Members of the European Parliament have misgiving about a visa waiver for Turkey, on migration control or human rights grounds. MEPs fought for years for many of the provisions in the Dublin III Regulation (on family members and unaccompanied minors in particular) which the Commission now seeks to overturn. As I pointed out above, some of the proposed changes to the Dublin rules are highly vulnerable to challenge in the CJEU, if adopted. The red herring of a 250,000 sanction is already floating on the surface of the pond. And the whole EU/Turkey deal might anyway be overturned at the whim of Turkish President Erdogan the only politician whose ego makes Donald Trumps look small by comparison."
Inside the Assassination Complex - Whistleblowing Is Not Just Leaking Its an Act of Political Resistance (The Intercept, link) by Edward Snowden:
"I've been waiting 40 years for someone like you. Those were the first words Daniel Ellsberg spoke to me when we met last year. Dan and I felt an immediate kinship; we both knew what it meant to risk so much and to be irrevocably changed by revealing secret truths.
One of the challenges of being a whistleblower is living with the knowledge that people continue to sit, just as you did, at those desks, in that unit, throughout the agency, who see what you saw and comply in silence, without resistance or complaint. They learn to live not just with untruths but with unnecessary untruths, dangerous untruths, corrosive untruths. It is a double tragedy: What begins as a survival strategy ends with the compromise of the human being it sought to preserve and the diminishing of the democracy meant to justify the sacrifice.
But unlike Dan Ellsberg, I didnt have to wait 40 years to witness other citizens breaking that silence with documents..."
Turkey: Cumhuriyet journalists sentenced to five years for revealing state secrets (link):
"An Istanbul court sentenced Cumhuriyet journalists Can Dündar and Erdem Gül to five years in prison for leaking state secrets on May 6, hours after Dündar escaped unharmed from an armed attack in front of Istanbuls Çaglayan courthouse.
Dündar, the dailys editor-in-chief, was given five years and 10 months for "leaking state secrets" while the papers Ankara bureau chief, Gül, was given five years on the same charge. However, the duo will not immediately go to prison....
Dündar and Gül were on trial for leaking state secrets due to stories published about Turkish intelligence trucks bound for Syria with hidden weapons in early 2014. They were arrested on Nov. 26, 2015, and released on Feb. 26 following a Constitutional Court decision."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (6.5.16)
NETHERLANDS: Dutch dragnet surveillance bill leaked: our analysis (Bits of Freedom, link): "At the end of April, an updated draft for the Dutch dragnet surveillance bill was leaked. It turns out that minister of the Interior Ronald Plasterk persists on granting the secret services the power to carry out bulk interception of innocent citizens communications.
How did we get here?
Ever since the law was announced in 2013, one of the main concerns of the debate has been how the dragnet will function and how extensive it will actually be. It led to a squabble between Plasterk and members of parliament. The latter werent keen on the idea of a dragnet, so Plasterk decided to rename it. Bulk interception became purpose-oriented interception. It sounded different, true, but we were afraid the meaning had been left unchanged.
Squabbles be squabbles
The bill remained vague. Based on the draft that was released for public consultation in September 2015, a dragnet could definitely be in our future. The explanatory memorandum didnt do much towards clearing things up. We werent alone in voicing harsh criticism about what was being proposed. After all, the government has to be clear about their plans and the extent of their reach."
Trapped in the new Greek archipelago with no way out (OpenDemocracy, link): "Its all lies, Massoud (not his real name) taps angrily on his smartphone screen; there are dozens of failed calls to the Skype address of the Greek Asylum service. In Greece you register an asylum claim by Skype. Massoud is from Syria and has been in Idomeni camp for 2 months and 10 days.
People have been blockaded in Greece since Macedonia shut its border with Greece entirely for refugees on 9 March this year. At the same time many people are finding it impossible to lodge asylum applications in Greece - and therefore have no chance of relocation to another EU country. The EU plan to relocate refugees to other EU countries appears to be bogged down.
By 17 April, UNHCR said some 46,000 refugees are stranded in Greece in an archipelago of camps from Athens to the Macedonian border in the North. Meanwhile, in the islands the deportations to Turkey under the one-for-one deal between the EU and Turkey started on 4 April."
See also: Migration Minister: Greece Will Keep 30,000-40,000 Refugees (Greek Reporter, link): "Greek Deputy Migration Minister Yannis Mouzalas said that 30,000-40,000 refugees will stay in Greece for a long time.
Mouzalas headed a meeting on the migration issue in Thessaloniki. He said that the makeshift migrant camp in Idomeni, on the Greek-FYROM border, will be evacuated by May 30."
And: Greece: Police clash with refugees as they clear Idomeni train tracks (Ruptly TV, link to YouTube)
More stories and updates: Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (6.5.16): laetst Commission statistics, update on the situation in Hungary and more
UK: Immigration detention: a tale of two reviews (IRR, link): "Two recent reviews of immigration detention offer a contrast in their approach to the fundamental injustice of immigration detention and in their usefulness to campaigners.
It has been four months since the publication of two key reviews of immigration detention: the Review into the Welfare in Detention of Vulnerable Persons undertaken by former Prisons and Probation Ombudsman Stephen Shaw, and the Serco-commissioned Independent Investigation into Concerns about Yarls Wood Immigration Removal Centre conducted by Kate Lampard and Ed Marsden. Both reviews have been broadly welcomed across the refugee sector. Although the remit for Shaws review excluded the issue of detention in and of itself, he advocated banning the detention of pregnant women and suggested there should be a presumption against detention of sexual violence victims, victims of FGM, people with learning difficulties, those with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder and transgender people. In all, Shaw made sixty-four recommendations, while the Yarls Wood review made thirty-five recommendations, Serco agreeing thirty-two of them."
South Yorkshire interim police chief welcomes Orgreave inquiry (The Guardian, link): "A major step has been taken towards an inquiry into the tactics of South Yorkshire police at the 1984 Orgreave confrontation with striking miners, and alleged perjury by officers in collapsed prosecutions a year later, after the forces acting chief said he would welcome it.
Dave Jones, the newly appointed interim chief constable of the force which is reeling after the verdicts in the Hillsborough inquests last week, said in a statement : The Hillsborough inquests have brought into sharp focus the need to understand and confront the past and give people the opportunity to explore the circumstances of such significant events.
I would therefore welcome an appropriate independent assessment of Orgreave, accepting that the way in which this is delivered is a matter for the home secretary."
UK: Rainsbrook: more children being failed (Frances Crook's blog, link): "The latest inspection of Rainsbrook secure training centre has been published this morning. At the time of the inspection it was being run by G4S but MTCNovo took over this week.
The child jail held 61 boys and 13 girls.
This is the third inspection report in the space of a year following the disastrous inspection last spring and the follow-up that found some improvements.
Overall the findings are pretty damning, illustrating how the experiment of secure training centres has failed children for two decades. It has, however, succeeded in providing profits to the security companies running them, although, as G4S has found, that comes at the price of reputation."
See the full report by the Care Quality Commission, Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Prisons and Ofsted: Inspection of Rainsbrook Secure Training Centre (pdf)
France outraged at film showing police officers 'harassing and humiliating man with no legs and one arm' (The Independent, link): "France has been shocked by a video which appears to show three policemen harassing and humiliating a man with no legs and one arm.
More than 100,000 have watched the short film posted on Facebook, which shows the man being abandoned by the police officers after being made to remove his artificial legs and strip to his underpants.
As the policemen walk away, a passer-by who filmed the scene on his smartphone is heard shouting: Officer, officer, we need you. Officer, turn back please. This is humiliation, It is not normal."
Irelands ad-hoc approach is failing stateless persons: Dublin seminar highlights shortfalls and need for formal procedures (European Network on Stateless, link): "While Ireland has not yet established a formal statelessness determination procedure, France has one of the longest established procedures in Europe and the UK introduced a new procedure three years ago. French and UK officials accordingly agreed to come to Ireland to share their experiences in establishing and operating such procedures in their respective countries at a seminar 'Statelessness Determination Procedures: Policy Options, Practical Experiences and Challenges', jointly hosted by jointly hosted by EMN Ireland and UNHCR Ireland in Dublin yesterday. The seminar followed a conference hosted by the Luxembourg EMN National Contact Point (NCP) last month, and covered on this blog."
Overview: Turkey meets 65 of 72 requirements for visa liberalisation (pdf): "On 4 May the Commission published the Third Report on progress by Turkey in fulfilling the requirements of its visa liberalisation roadmap.
The roadmap has 72 requirements grouped under five headings.
Here we provide an overview of the requirements and information on whether or not they have been fulfilled, as set out in the working document that accompanied the Commissions communication.
The working document provides more detail on what Turkey has done with regard to each of the individual requirements. It also contains an 11-page annex setting out an assessment of the security impact of visa liberalisation."
See also: Commission Staff Working Document accompanying the Third Report on progress made by Turkey in fulfilling the requirements of its visa liberalisation roadmap (SWD(2016) 161 final, pdf): Detailed overview of the 72 requirements and progress made.
Further documentation: EU opens door to visa waiver as part of legally "dodgy deal" with Turkey and plans Dublin III
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (5.5.16) including "dodgy visa deal" with Turkey and Dublin III
European commission faces challenge to grant visa-free travel to Turks (Guardian, link):
"EU executive gives provisional blessing to key scheme in deal with Ankara, as asylum rules overhaul also hits trouble...
In another important caveat, visa-free travel would only be available to those Turks with biometric passports that include fingerprint recognition chips. Such passports do not exist in Turkey, although the government plans to introduce them from 1 June....
The final decision on whether Turkish citizens will get visa-free access to the Schengen Area for stays of up to three months rests with the EUs 28 member states and the European parliament....
But five conditions still need to be cleared, including passing anti-corruption laws, rewriting domestic law on terrorism to avoid conflicts with freedom of expression, and bringing data protection rules in line with EU standards."
UK: PREVENT, Islamophobia and Civil Liberties National Conference Prevent Conference: Saturday, 4 June 2016 from 11:00 to 18:00 (BST): Central London location to be confirmed.
UK: Former chief constable calls for public inquiry into Orgreave clashes and beyond (Guardian, link):
"Sir Peter Fahy joins call for public inquiry over 1980s police army of occupation and agenda of Margaret Thatcher government...A public inquiry should examine the way Margaret Thatchers government used the police to occupy communities during the 1980s miners strike, a former chief constable has said."
UK: Inside Ricu, the shadowy propaganda unit inspired by the cold war (Guardian, link):
"The Guardian unravels the secretive workings behind a campaign to stop UK Muslims from falling prey to Islamic State.
The shadowy Whitehall unit at the heart of the British governments covert strategic communications campaign was inspired by a clandestine cold war propaganda programme. But while the cold war offensive targeted communism, trade unionists and newspapers in developing countries, the current operations are aimed at Muslims, both in Britain and the Middle East.
The British-based element of the campaign is part of the Prevent counter-radicalisation programme and is run by the Home Offices Research, Information and Communications Unit, or Ricu."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (4.5.16) including important court win
EU: An EU Institutions Google Maps? Six years after Lisbon Treaty still the quest for a common compass (ASFJ, link):
"As a preliminary disclaimer I have to say that the following observations could not be seen as neutral as I have been an official of the European Parliament for 26 years and it is more than likely that I have been influenced by that experience. That having been said what I will say echoes a direct experience in some crucial moments of the interinstitutional relations since the negotiation of the Single European Act until the entry into force of the Lisbon Treaty. I have to say that the evolution of the role of the European Parliament has not been linear even if its importance was growing Treaty after Treaty but also with some stops, not to say, some regressions, as I am afraid it is happening, quite surprisingly, since the entry into force of the Lisbon Treaty."
UK: Independent Reviewer of Terrorism Legislation: Citizenship removal leading to statelessness (link):
"The Immigration Act 2014 revived the Home Secretarys power to remove citizenship from UK nationals, even when they have no other citizenship. Such a power existed prior to 2003, though it had not been used since 1973.
So controversial was this power (which in its application to single nationals exceeds powers recently introduced or debated in Australia, Canada and France) that Parliament insisted on provision being made for the independent review of its operation. The Immigration Minister, James Brokenshire MP, asked me to conduct the first review.
The first report on the new power was laid before Parliament on 21 April. The power has not so far been used, so strictly speaking there was nothing to report on. But I took the opportunity in my report to explain the historical and comparative background to the power, and to set out some reasons for scepticism as to its utility in the global fight against terrorism."
See: FIRST REPORT OF THE INDEPENDENT REVIEWER ON THE OPERATION OF THE POWER TO REMOVE CITIZENSHIP OBTAINED BY NATURALISATION FROM PERSONS WHO HAVE NO OTHER CITIZENSHIP (pdf)
And see: Citizenship Deprivation: 21st Century Banishment (One Small Window, link)
EU-UK: House of Lords Select Committee on the European Union Report: The process of withdrawing from the European Union (pdf):
"EU Member States would retain significant control over the withdrawal negotiations, despite the Commission having responsibility for their conduct. (Paragraph 28)
The European Parliaments right not to give its consent to the adoption of the withdrawal agreement would give it considerable influence. (Paragraph 29)
One of the most important aspects of the withdrawal negotiations would be determining the acquired rights of the two million or so UK citizens living in other Member States, and equally of EU citizens living in the UK. This would be a complex and daunting task. (Paragraph 30)...
The Member States would retain significant control over the negotiations on a future relationship. We note the potential for groups of Member States vetoing certain elements of the agreement to secure better deals on others. This could mean, in effect, that nothing would be agreed until everything was agreed. (Paragraph 39)."
News Digest: Round-up of news stories from across Europe (3.5.16)
Concern over 'political' use of solitary confinement in European prisons (The Guardian, link): "European prisons are increasingly resorting to solitary confinement to counteract the threat of terrorism, despite warnings about its impact, defence lawyers and human rights advocates say.
France, Belgium and the Netherlands are all deploying solitary and small-group isolation on suspected and convicted terrorists to prevent radicalisation of prisoners.
In Belgium, about 35 people are placed on isolation measures, spending 23 hours a day in their cell and one hour in a small recreation yard, also alone. Four individuals are in solitary confinement on the recently opened de-radicalisation units in the country, with more expected to arrive in the future.
In France, an unknown number of terrorism suspects are being in held in isolation blocks. Over the past year or so, France has also established several dedicated units for deradicalisation, but an apparent lack of rehabilitative or therapeutic programming means prisoners remain in their cells most of the day.
In the Netherlands, where terrorist wings have nearly reached their capacity, men are being strip and cavity searched each time they have contact with a third party or go to court."
Eurostat press release: Almost 90 000 unaccompanied minors among asylum seekers registered in the EU in 2015 (pdf): "In 2015, 88 300 asylum seekers applying for international protection in the Member States of the European Union (EU) were considered to be unaccompanied minors. While their number always stood between 11 000 and 13 000 in the EU over the period 2008-2013, it almost doubled in 2014 to reach slightly more than 23 000 persons, then nearly quadrupled in 2015.
In 2015, a substantial majority of unaccompanied minors were males (91%) and over half were aged 16 to 17 (57%, or 50 500 persons), while those aged 14 to 15 accounted for 29% (25 800 persons) and those aged less than 14 for 13% (11 800 persons). Around half (51%) of asylum applicants considered to be unaccompanied minors in the EU in 2015 were Afghans."
And see: Italy struggles to house migrants in third year of mass arrivals (Reuters, link)
More stories: Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (3.5.16)
EU: Commission denies free pass to Germany and Austria on border controls (Politico, link): "The European Commission plans to let EU countries impose internal border checks for another six months including during the summer tourist season before insisting on a return to free travel in the Schengen zone, according to officials.
In a decision due to be published Wednesday, the Commission will recommend allowing the internal border checks in five countries until November, but Brussels will require oversight of the controls that Germany and Austria, among others, are pushing for. The decision for Wednesday is made, said an EU official familiar with the plans.
According to a draft of the decision, seen by POLITICO, the Commission recommends allowing Austria, Germany, Denmark, Sweden and Norway to maintain proportionate temporary border controls for a maximum period of six months, starting from the day of the adoption of this Implementing Decision at their respective shared borders."
The Commission will include proposals for regular monitoring, according to a quote from the document seen by Politico: Border control should be targeted and limited in scope, frequency, location and time, to what is strictly necessary to respond to the serious threat and to safeguard public policy and internal security."
Such a system would not be entirely unfamiliar - Schengen states already undergo evaluations to assess their conformity with the Schengen Borders Code, as can be seen in these Council documents (pdfs): Schengen evaluation of AUSTRIA: Action plans to remedy deficiencies identified in the 2015 evaluation report in the field of:
- Air borders (6761/16, 3 March 2016)
- Visa (6816/16, 3 March 2016)
- Police cooperation (6817/16, 3 March 2016)
- Return (7258/16, 31 March 2016)
And: Draft Council Implementing Decision setting out a Recommendation on addressing the deficiencies identified in the 2015 evaluation of the application of the Schengen acquis in the field of the Schengen Information System by Austria (5864/1/16 REV 1, 10 February 2016) and Council Implementing Decision (6222/16, 16 February 2016)
More stories: Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (3.5.16)
EU: The far right is weaselling into the mainstream, dressed up in suits (The Guardian, link): "Article 7 of the EU Treaty allows a country to be sanctioned or suspended if it commits a severe breach of fundamental rights. But it needs two-thirds majority in the parliament and has never been invoked. This month it must draw the line in Austria. Europe must make clear it will refuse to recognise a far-right president in Vienna. Its their democratic right to elect a cleaned-up fascist; its ours by treaty to suspend Austria from the EU.
We know the EU can act ruthlessly against a government it does not like because we watched it try to smash the most anti-racist, pro-social justice government ever elected, in Greece last summer. Today the countries that stood alongside Germany in its attempt to boot Greece out of the euro are the same ones who refuse to take refugees, whose media and judiciaries are under threat. As Europe dithers in the face of the authoritarians and racists, the populations in the mature democracies that founded the EU should insist: our grandparents didnt defeat fascism in 1945 to see it weasel back into the mainstream now, dressed in suits instead of uniforms, but trailing the same pathetic victimhood that excused the crimes of the past."
German police arrest 400 protesters outside far-right party meeting (The Guardian, link): "Hundreds of protesters have been arrested outside a conference of the far-right German political party Alternative für Deutschland in Stuttgart after attempting to block the entrance to the event.
Around 400 people were detained outside the venue where up to 2,000 AfD members are expected to pass an explicitly anti-Islam manifesto, according to Agence France-Presse. The party wants to ban the burqa and minarets in Germany.
Riot police reportedly fired pepper spray at several hundred leftwing protesters who had temporarily blocked a nearby highway and burned tyres on the road leading to the venue. Around 1,000 officers are said to have been deployed.
Protesters chanted refugees can stay, Nazis must go, according to local media. Placards at the demonstration reportedly included one that read: Your hate campaign pisses us off. The protests delayed the start of the conference on Saturday."
EU-USA: TTIP leak: nothing to worry about, says Commission
"Just a few hours after the pre-announced the 248 page leak of Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) documents by Greenpeace (Netherlands), Ignacio Garcia Bercero, the EUs Chief Negotiator spoke to the Press in an attempt to change the initial impression left from the leaked documents. An EU source told New Europe that the documents are at least one month old.
Bercero told journalists that all of the EUs positions revealed by the leaks were well known, while this was not necessarily the case for the positions of the United States of America."
IMMIGRATION DETENTION: Interactive map highlights alternatives
"Alternatives are any law, policy or practice by which people are able to reside in the community, without being detained for migration-related reasons.
The IDC has identified over 250 examples of alternatives from 60 countries, including those listed by country below."
UK government 'running covert counter-extremism propaganda campaign' (Middle East Eye, link): "The British government is running a covert propaganda campaign intended to project its counter-extremism message to British Muslims through supposedly grassroots community organisations, a report published on Monday claims.
Several recent high-profile counter-extremism initiatives that appeared to be the work of non-government organisations were actually orchestrated by a media company, Breakthrough Media, with close links to the Home Office's Research, Information and Communications Unit (RICU), the report says.
In some cases, the charities and organisations which fronted the campaigns were not aware of Breakthrough Media's close links to the Home Office, while Breakthough employees were required to sign the Official Secrets Act in order to conceal that relationship, the report says."
See also: David Cameron to announce new extremist crackdown in Queens speech (Politics Home, link) and: Statewatch Analysis: UK: The new governments assault on civil liberties (May 2015, pdf)
UK: Like Hillsborough, Orgreave cries out for justice (The Justice Gap, link): "We seem to be in an age of greater accountability, although it may be said that some people are still more accountable than others.
Its one thing prosecuting 1970s radio DJs for their tendency to regard groping mainly young girls as a perk of the job; but the establishment had to be dragged kicking and screaming to recognise that they could no longer deny justice for the Hillsborough families. It took until 2010 for the government to set up an independent review of all the material.
It was the results of the work done by the Hillsborough Independent Panel that allowed the families to apply to the High Court for the verdicts in the original inquests to be quashed.
The conclusions of the jury in the Hillsborough Inquests serve as a reminder that ordinary people can fight back against the system and given a high degree of cussed determination and a cause that cries out for justice to be done can force a reluctant establishment to do the decent thing and grant them at least a measure of justice.
You might think that that was quite enough to be going on with for now. But for me there is an even bigger unresolved injustice that the establishment has dodged for more than 30 years and currently shows no signs of being willing to face up to.
I speak of course of the miners dispute between 1984 and 1985 in general and the so-called Battle of Orgreave in particular. I have written previously on the Justice gap about Orgreave and the details that prove there was a cover-up and a blatant attempt to pervert the course of justice by senior officers up to and including the then Chief Constable Peter Wright, who was of course still Chief Constable at the time of Hillsborough. The details are as damning as they are comprehensive. Its what police officers and lawyers call an open and shut case."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (30.4.16-2.5.16)
EU: Legal Aid proposal: From Justicia Network: To: Civil Liberties, Justice, and Home Affairs Committee of the European Parliament Council of the European Union, and the Presidency European Commission, DG Justice (pdf):
"The JUSTICIA European Rights Network, which brings together 19 civil society organizations from 18 EU member states, believes that an effective system of legal aid is vital to ensure that everyone, regardless of economic status, is treated fairly by the law.
The Directive on Legal Aid is the last in a series of groundbreaking directives that collectively have the potential to bring about significant improvements on defence rights across the EU. We are encouraged by the progress made on this file under the Dutch Presidency. As you enter the final stages of the trilogue negotiations we urge you to continue to work towards a strong and comprehensive Directive."
Greenpeace: TTIP Leaks (links): "Greenpeace Netherlands has released secret TTIP negotiation documents. We have done so to provide much needed transparency and trigger an informed debate on the treaty. This treaty is threatening to have far reaching implications for the environment and the lives of more than 800 million citizens in the EU and US."
Download All (RESTRICTED documents, ZIP file)
UK: Pressure mounts on Sussex Police to explain involvement in monitoring of MP Caroline Lucas (The Argus, link):
PRESSURE is mounting on Sussex Police to explain whether it was involved in the monitoring of Green MP Caroline Lucas by counter-terror police.
A source close to the force said it was "almost certain" that Sussex officers would have shared information on Ms Lucas from demonstrations. Meanwhile campaigners described the monitoring of the parliamentarian as an "outrageous affront"."
Proposed EU Terrorism Directive Compromises Fundamental Rights (Liberties.eu, link): "The directive is full of broad offenses and threatens people's freedoms of movement and expression, says a group of experts in European law."
And see: EU: Meijers Committee: Note on a Proposal for a Directive on combating terrorism (pdf)
ANOTHER "DODGY DEAL": EU-USA: DATA PROTECTION: "UMBRELLA AGREEMENT": Proposal for a COUNCIL DECISION on the signing, on behalf of the European Union, of an Agreement between the United States of America and the European Union on the protection of personal information relating to the prevention, investigation, detection, and prosecution of criminal offenses (pdf) and Annex (pdf)
And see: Marc Rotenberg President, EPIC Adjunct Professor, Georgetown Law Hearing: ""The Judicial Redress Act does not provide adequate protection to permit data transfers and it does not address the many provisions in the Privacy Act that need to be updated."
And: Statewatch Observatory: EU-USA general agreement on data protection and the exchange of personal data
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (29.4.16)
OMCT: World Organisation Against Torture: Greece: Ongoing crackdown on civil society providing humanitarian assistance to migrants and asylum seekers (pdf):
"The Observatory has been informed by reliable sources about the ongoing crackdown on civil society actors providing humanitarian assistance to migrants and asylum seekers arriving in the Greek islands, even including judicial harassment against several groups and NGOs acting to protect migrants' rights, of Team Humanity Denmark....
on February 21, 2016 a last minute amendment was made to a Law voted by the Greek Parliament, in violation of several provisions of the Parliaments Rules of Procedures. The new provision assigns the supervision and coordination of services provided to migrants and asylum seekers to the Greek Army and Minister of Defence, in newly established army-run facilities. This provision has led to a coordinated effort to stop civil society activities in camps that are not run by the army, through extensive threats of arrest and prosecution]. Moreover, several journalists and NGOs, including the Hellenic Action for Human Rights Pleiades, are often not allowed access to army-run facilities....
The Observatory strongly condemns this crackdown on civil society actors in Greece, calls on the Greek authorities to put an end to the ongoing attempts to criminalise NGOs and volunteers working in the country in the field of humanitarian assistance to migrants and asylum-seekers or otherwise prevent them from carrying out their work and urges them to lift the ban on civil society activists and journalists to enter army-run camps."
See also: Council proposals on migrant smuggling would criminalise humanitarian assistance by civil society, local people and volunteers - Greece: NGOs and volunteers have to "register" with the police and be vetted (Statewatch) and NGOs and volunteers helping refugees in Greece to be placed under state control (Statewatch)
Is the EU-Turkey refugee and migration deal a treaty? (EU law Analysis, link):
"In the European Parliament, questions were asked about the legal nature of the EU-Turkey Statement of 18 March, pursuant to which Greece has started to return asylum seekers to Turkey this week. Apparently, the EUs procedure for negotiating and concluding treaties with third countries, laid down in in Art. 218 TFEU, has not been followed. The European Parliament wants to know whether the Council nonetheless considers the Statement to be a treaty, and, if not, whether Turkey has been informed about the non-binding nature. Importantly, for treaties covering fields to which the ordinary legislative procedure applies (asylum and immigration is such a field), the Council may only conclude a treaty with a third country after obtaining consent of the European Parliament (Art. 218(6)(a)(v) TFEU)......
That the institutional role of the EP has been neglected confirms the worrying trend that intergovernmental decision-making is taking over in the Union, and that national interests increasingly often prevail over the common values of the Union. This is bad for European democracy."
UK: Police anti-extremism unit monitoring senior Green party figures (Guardian, link):
"Division tasked with spying on alleged extremists has been tracking political activities of Caroline Lucas and Sian Berry
A secretive police unit tasked with spying on alleged extremists intent on committing serious crimes has been monitoring leading members of the Green party, the Guardian has learned.
Newly released documents show that the intelligence unit has been tracking the political activities of the MP Caroline Lucas and Sian Berry, the partys candidate for London mayor.
Some of the monitoring took place as recently as last year and seemed to contradict a pledge from Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe, the Metropolitan police commissioner, that the unit would only target serious criminals rather than peaceful protesters."
Fascism and the far right in Europe: country by country guide part one (Dream Deferred, link):
"Europe is witnessing a dangerous revival of fascist and racist populist parties and organisations. Over the next few weeks we are going to publish a series of articles analysing the scale of this threat.
We will focus on the countries where fascist and racist parties have made significant electoral and/or organisational breakthroughs. There are small fascist groups operating in several other countries, but with very small numbers and little impact. We intend to look separately at the situation in Russia at a later date and have not included it here."
Hillsborough families to sue police for 'abuse on industrial scale' (Guardian, link):
"Lawyers acting for hundreds of those affected by disaster launch action against South Yorkshire and West Midlands police
The families of Hillsborough victims are to launch a multimillion-pound high court claim against two police forces for abuse on an industrial scale.
Lawyers acting for hundreds of those affected by the disaster said they had launched proceedings against the South Yorkshire and West Midlands forces.
In a statement, solicitors firm Saunders Law said it was taking the high court action over the cover-up and actions intended to wrongly blame the deceased and Liverpool Football Club supporters for the tragedy, for which there has still been no proper admission or apology.
Exploring the Boundaries of Big Data (288 pages, pdf link):
"This study on the boundaries of Big Data brings together a number of leading academics to describe, analyse and theorize upon issues involved in Big Data from a wide variety of perspectives. As the exact nature and delineation of Big Data is still unclear, the authors explore the boundaries of Big Data rather than go to the core of this new phenomenon. They help us understand the relation of Big Data to areas such as cryptology, predictive policing, profiling, privacy, and regimes of data protection in the United States, Europe, the Netherlands and Germany, and outline some new challenges that lie ahead of us."
Pro-Nazi nostalgia flourishes under new Croatia government (euractiv, link):
Nostalgia for a pro-Nazi past, spurning of ethnic minorities and pressure on the press: Croatian activists say an alarming climate of intolerance is taking hold under a new conservative government.
Since the ruling coalition took power in the European Union country in January, critics say authorities have turned a blind eye and even contributed to concerns over a far-right right surge.
Last week, in response, angry Jewish, ethnic Serb and anti-fascist groups refused to attend a ceremony remembering tens of thousands who died at Jasenovac, the most notorious concentration camp under Croatias pro-Nazi Ustasha regime during World War II.
The boycott was a brave and correct decision in the face of the wave of neo-fascist Ustasha nostalgia which is sweeping Croatia, said Efraim Zuroff at the Simon Wiesenthal Center, an international Jewish rights organisation".
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (28.4.16)
European Commission: Remarks by Commissioner Avramopoulos to the Committee on Federal and European Affairs of the Bavarian Parliament on 26 April (pdf)
"To paraphrase an old saying information is security. We will respond to the terrorist threat effectively when we make our information systems interconnected, interoperable, and searchable..."
The Commissioner argues for a "Single Search Interface" where: "all data is searchable with just one click" - this requires major changes to laws on the book where acess is limited or prescribed. And see: Statewatch Analysis: Commission proposals on migration and internal security databases: a new list of old needs (pdf)
"Both the EU and Turkey need each other, as equal partners. This is a balanced partnership, one where we aim for each side to deliver on its commitments, but without renouncing our principles or conditions."
Many would argue that the EU wanted a deal at any price - even if it means tearing up all human rights and asylum law adopted since 1945.
"We must remember an element of political context: while we are working on these issues, we are witnessing the worrying rise in left and right wing violent extremism."
In context "right wing violent extremism" is carried out by extreme nationalists, racists and fascists. While what is characterised as "left wing violent extremism" is anti-racist and anti-fascist responses to the former - which is a piece of perverse logic.
Council of Europe: Thorbjorn Jagland: Europe's human rights and security are at risk through populist nationalism (Press release, pdf) and Annual Report: State of democracy, human rights and the rule of law: A security imperative for Europe (pdf):
"Europe is currently struggling with many serious challenges, including terrorism, migration andconflict. This is being successfully exploited by nationalists and populists in many places, and trust in national and European institutions is dwindling, said the Secretary General.
At the same time, we still see many important gaps in the laws and practices that our memberstates have in place, and basic human rights including free speech, freedom of assembly and theright to privacy are increasingly being restricted."
Greece: Antifascist Action for Greece (link)
"at a time where the refugee crisis, the austerity agenda, and the rise of racism and neo-fascism in Europe are reaching their peak, at a time when "civilised" Europe is asked to prove whether it has ever had a Renaissance or it never left the Dark Ages,we remain adamant to our ideals and founding statement, and mobilise in whatever way we can to continue our struggle, from our side of history....
If you agree with our aims and modus operandi, then join our struggle for a world where nobody feels it is necessary to tread on others in order to survive. A world emancipated from any source of fascism, totalitarianism, and authoritarianism."
USA: An Opening for Justice for CIA Torture (HRW, link):
"The United States government just opened the door a crack to justice for the torture of scores of men in CIA custody under its infamous detention and interrogation program. For the first time, the Justice Department didnt effectively block a lawsuit by detainees held and tortured by the CIA by invoking, as it had done in previous similar lawsuits, the state secrets privilege.
The privilege requires a court to give great deference to a government claim that litigating a case would risk revealing state secrets that would jeopardize national security...."
Frontex 2.0: The European Unions armed wing - Further reinforced and still untouchable (Migreurop, link):
"By August 2016, the European institutions aim to replace Frontex by a new coast guards and border-guards agency which will further jeopardise the rights of migrants and refugees. This new mandate reinforces the serious concerns expressed by the FRONTEXIT campaign since its establishment: deter, control and keep away men, women and children deemed undesirable while they are exerting their right to leave any country and the right to seek asylum."
Rare Victory for Privacy in Germanys War Against Terror (Human Rights Watch, link):
"Germanys Constitutional Court ruled that parts of the law (BKA-Gesetz) granting surveillance powers to federal police are unconstitutional, because they do not have sufficient safeguards to ensure a balance between the rights of the individual to privacy, and the interests of the state in investigating potential crime. Certain powers the ability to conduct surveillance through recorded conversations or photographs, to carry out wiretaps, or remotely search computers did not have adequate restrictions, including the possibility for judicial review, to guarantee that intrusions on the privacy of German citizens would be justified and proportionate, the court found."
EU: Fundamental Rights Agency: Ensuring justice for hate crime victims: professional perspectives (pdf)
"The 2012 Directive establishing minimum standards on the rights, support and protection of victims of crime acknowledges that hate crime victims are particularly vulnerable and stresses their right to protection in accordance with their particular needs. EU Member States should strive to improve access to justice for such victims, both by supporting victims in reporting their experiences to the police and by improving the police and judiciarys responses. This report aims to encourage such efforts."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (27.4.16)
Caritas Europa: Migrants and refugees have rights - Impact of EU policies on accessing protection (pdf):
"Caritas Europa seeks to contribute to appropriate humanitarian responses by providing evidence about the situations of migrants and asylum seekers, supported by insight from Caritas staff and volunteers helping the people in need. It provides an in-depth analysis of the impact that current EU asylum and migration policies are having on migrants in Europe....
Appropriate responses can only derive from recognising that migrants and asylum seekers are not a flow nor an invasion, but are women, men, and children, whose human rights and needs are being jeopardised."
European experts to probe Polish police law (euobserver, link): "The Venice Commission is travelling to Poland again.
The commission, a body of experts on constitutional law from the human rights watchdog Council of Europe, will visit on Thursday and Friday (28 and 29 April) to gather information on a police law adopted on 15 January. The updated police law is known in Poland as the act of surveillance. "
European Parliament: Briefing: Regulation 604/2013 (Dublin Regulation) and asylum procedures in Europe (pdf)
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (26.4.16): Riot police out in Moria camp, refugee to be re-labeled as "displaced people"
UK: Sheffield: Hillsborough inquests jury says 96 victims were unlawfully killed - Jurors also rule Liverpool fans behaviour at 1989 FA Cup semi-final did not contribute to disaster as verdict vindicates families (Guardian, link):
"The 96 people who died at Hillsborough in 1989 were unlawfully killed due to gross negligence manslaughter, the jury at the new inquests into the disaster has determined.
The verdict represents a vindication for the bereaved families who have fought for 27 years against South Yorkshire police claims that misbehaving supporters caused the disaster, as well as against the 1991 verdict of accidental death.
The jury decided that the behaviour of Liverpool supporters at Hillsborough did not contribute to the dangerous situation that developed outside the football ground, rejecting a claim by South Yorkshire police which the families and survivors of the disaster have relentlessly denounced as a cover-up."
And: Hillsborough disaster: Fans unlawfully killed (BBC News, link)
EU: Council of the European Union: Operational C-T cooperation & "Youth sector" and radicalisation
- Development of a structured approach for operational cooperation on countering terrorist threats (LIMITE doc no: 7796-16, pdf):
"Following the Paris attacks on 13 November 2015, the Council on 20 November 2015 in its conclusions on Counter-Terrorism (CT) called for COSI to liaise with competent Working Parties of the Council and with the Commission and EU agencies to ensure effective implementation of the operational measures agreed. In this context, COSI was asked by the Council to examine the possibility to develop a methodology for a structured and multilateral approach for operational cooperation on countering terrorist threats" [emphasis in original]. It seems extraordinary that the EU is still at the stage of "developing a methodology" for operational cooperation to counter terrorist attacks.
And see: Counter-terrorism: Proposals on information sharing and operational cooperation (Statewatch) including: The Counter-Terrorism Coordinator's report: Systematic feeding and consistent use of European and international Databases - information sharing in the counter-terrorism context (LIMITE doc no: 7726/16, pdf)
- Draft conclusions of the Council and of the Representatives of the Governments of the Member States, meeting within the Council, on the role of [...] the youth sector in an integrated and cross-sectoral approach to preventing and combating [...] radicalisation leading to violent extremism of young people (LIMITE doc no: 7784-16, pdf):
"The process of identity development towards violent extremism can be influenced by many factors such as a multi-problem family background, peers, internet and social media and the position of groups of young people in society often confronted with discrimination, humiliation, exclusion, injustice and a lack of prospects, leading to feelings of frustration...
Young people must have awareness about democracy, equality, democratic principles, and respect for human dignity and human rights, as well as about media and information literacy...." [emphasis in original]
EU: Council of the European Union: PRUM data exchange: Decisions - overview of documents and procedures - overview of declarations - state of play of implementation of automated data exchange (doc no 5017-16, pdf)
EU: European Commission: Online Platforms and the Digital Single Market - Opportunities and Challenges for Europe (pdf)
Privatised law enforcement: "responsible behaviour of online platforms, inter alia to fight against illegal and harmful content and to ensure adequate protection of all and especially vulnerable ?platform users as well as of core societal values" (Page 6)
On Big Data: "Data is the fuel of the digital economy and platforms need to collect data as part of their service and in order to optimise consumers' online experience. Data also underpins marketplace efficiency and innovative uses of data can boost economic productivity. Its importance goes beyond purely economic purposes as the collection and analysis of vast amounts of data can save lives, improve education, and enhance government services. However, large-scale data collection also has the capacity to create new power asymmetries, and potentially reinforce disadvantages faced by low-income and underserved communities, or to unwittingly influence people's behaviour or choices? particularly in the context of purchasing a product or enlisting a service, but also in influencing other choices such as political or societal ones." (Page 11)
NETHERLANDS-TURKEY: Commission on Press freedom: We are following the Dutch journalist case very closely (New Europe, link)
"Almost two days after the Turkish State arrested Ebru Umar, a Dutch journalist of Turkish decent, as she tweeted a very critical piece written for Dutch Metro daily, the European Commission answered to reporters in Brussels that kept pounding the Commission spokespersons for answers.
More generally speaking, the EU has very clearly said that Turkey as a country must respect democratic standards which include freedom of press and that to the highest possible extent. answered Maja Kocijancic, Foreign and Security Policy Spokesperson...Kocijancic avoided to tell more on the case...".
And see: Dutch journalist detained in Turkey slams house burglary as intimidation (hurriyetdailynews.com, link): "A Dutch journalist of Turkish descent who was briefly detained by Turkish police after tweeting critical remarks about the countrys President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has said her Amsterdam apartment has been broken into, denouncing what she described as intimidation.
So there was a burglary in my Amsterdam home. I m impressed. intimidated. o wait... I M NOT, Ebru Umar wrote on her Twitter account in English. In another Tweet, she suggested the break-in was no coincidence.
Police detained Umar on April 23 in the touristic resort town of Kusadasi in the Aegean province of Aydin, after she tweeted an extract from a recent piece she wrote for Dutch daily Metro, critical of Erdogan. Umar said she was hauled out of bed for the arrest." [emphasis added]
USA: Declassified Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (FISC) opinions
"United States government agencies have long conducted warrantless secret surveillance, collecting and searching through electronic data for intelligence purposes. However, a newly declassified opinion by the US Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (FISC) bolsters concerns about the ways in which law enforcement agencies such as the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) may also be sifting through information obtained without warrants.
These searches could have serious consequences for people charged with a crime in US courts."
EU: European Parliament: Liberal and democratic MEPs make last-minute attempt for more Europol powers
"The ALDE Group in the European Parliament has today tabled legislative amendments to the regulation on the European Union Agency for Law Enforcement Cooperation (Europol) aimed at strengthening Europol's mandate and providing it with a genuine European investigation capacity. Given the transnational nature of the threats Europe is facing, especially in the wake of the Paris and Brussels terrorist attacks in France and Belgium, ALDE proposes concrete measures to give Europol a genuine investigation capacity:
- Europol's mandate: Europol has to provide a cross-border investigation capacity in preventing and combating terrorism and serious crime.
- Initiation of a criminal investigation: Europol needs a legal capacity to request the initiation of a criminal investigation.
- Information by Europol National Units: Europol National Units should facilitate cooperation among Member States and provide the basis for a European investigation capacity. National units should be obliged to share information."
EU: Draft Council conclusions on radicalisation and youth work
"The recent terrorist attacks in Belgium, France and Denmark, and similar atrocities in Europe in the past, as well as the rise in incidents of hate-crime, destabilising propaganda and violent xenophobia in Europe, show an urgent need for contributions from all sectors in society, including the youth sector, to fight radicalisation1, maintain social stability and a positive and safe environment for growing up and living in families, communities2 and the wider society in Europe."
See: Draft conclusions of the Council and of the Representatives of the Governments of the Member States, meeting within the Council, on the role of [...] the youth sector in an integrated and cross-sectoral approach to preventing and combating [...] radicalisation leading to violent extremism of young people (7784/16, 20 April 2016, pdf)
EU: Counter-terrorism: proposals on information sharing and operational cooperation
"There are still major gaps in intelligence sharing regarding DAESH fighters that have returned to Europe in the wake of the Brussels and Paris attacks, the EU's anti-terrorism coordinator warned Thursday.
The report, presented by Gilles de Kerchove at an interior ministers' meeting in Luxembourg, comes after repeated calls by European Union leaders for greater cooperation in dealing with extremists that attempt to return from Syria and Iraq.
"There are still significant gaps in the information being fed to Europol," the report indicated, referring to data on so-called foreign terrorist fighters who travel abroad and are then at risk of returning to their countries of origin to carry out more attacks."
CYPRUS-EGYPT: The love-struck hijacker a story of state repression garnished with social media gossip! (KISA, link): "In his letter, Mr Mustafa explained that he hijacked the plane to remind the international community that a dictatorship rules his country, that people are incarcerated without a fair trial and that his demand was the release of many women prisoners detained undemocratically by the regime. He also expressed his wish to receive international protection by the Cypriot authorities because in the event of his return to Egypt, he will not have a fair trial and he will be treated inhumanly.
Unfortunately, the way Cyprus has handled this case is not an isolated incident. The manner in which the Cypriot government recently conducted itself politically in the handling of the extradition of two Russian dissenters denotes its deliberate indifference to violations of human rights in the altar of political expediencies and the protection of its relationship with its strategic partners.""
The article notes that the Cypriot authorities have not permitted Mr Mustafa access to the asylum procedure, nor have they permitted him to access his lawyer or sent him for assessment by a psychologist, despite claims of his "psychological instability". Instead, an extradition order for him to be returned to Egypt was "signed between the two countries on the basis of their collaboration in the fields of energy, drilling and exploitation of hydrocarbons."
UK: Detective sacked over Mark Duggan gun enquiry (BBC News, link): "A detective has been sacked over his failed investigation into an associate of Mark Duggan, whose shooting by police sparked riots in August 2011.
The probe centred on Mr Duggan's associate, Kevin Hutchinson-Foster, who beat a man with a gun in east London.
Six days after the attack he gave the same gun to Mr Duggan, who was shot 15 minutes later by armed police.
The police watchdog found errors in how an officer, named only as DC Faulkner, conducted the initial investigation.
The officer was dismissed without notice."
The report by the IPCC: Alleged MPS failure to investigate an allegation of serious assault on 29 July 2011 (pdf)
UK: Hillsborough Jury Reaches Decisions On Deaths (Sky News, link): "The Hillsborough inquests jury has reached decisions on all questions related to the deaths of 96 football fans.
Jurors have crucially reached a decision on the one question they had not been able to agree on - whether the fans were unlawfully killed.
Last week they indicated they were unable to reach a unanimous verdict, but the coroner said today he would accept a majority verdict.
The jury has indicated that at least seven of the nine members agree."
See also: Hillsborough jury can return majority decision on unlawful killing question (The Guardian, link)
UK: Anti-semitism: thought or deed? (IRR, link): "Significantly, but without much fanfare, an expanded definition of anti-Semitism entered the UKs policy arena this April.
An article by Eric Pickles, former secretary of state for communities and local government, chair of the Conservative Friends of Israel and, since September 2015, UK special envoy for post-Holocaust issues, entitled A definition of antisemitism introduced the governments Combating Anti-Semitism: a British best practice guide just before the announcement of a short Home Affairs Committee inquiry into anti-Semitism. And in it, anti-Semitism, traditionally defined simply as hostility to or discrimination against Jews (Concise Oxford Dictionary) was replaced by an enormously long definition which not only includes attacks (physical or verbal) on Jewish people and community institutions but also manifestations target[ing] the state of Israel, conceived as a Jewish collectivity, such as: denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, eg, by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavour; applying double standards by requiring behaviour not expected or demanded of any other democratic nation drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis..."
See also: UK: New accusations of antisemitism thrown at the left are flimsy (OpenDemocracy, link): "Yet despite the almost comical paucity of supporting evidence, the notion that antisemitism is a growing problem on the Labour left is rapidly congealing into conventional wisdom. Labour rightists and pro-Israel activists have seized the opportunity afforded by the febrile atmosphere to prosecute petty vendettas, wage factional warfare and advance long-held political objectives. The smear campaign against Malia Bouattia, who was last week elected the first black Muslim woman president of the National Union of Students (NUS), must be understood in this context. She is the latest victim of this juggernaut."
European Parliament: In-depth analysis: The application of universal jurisdiction in the fight against impunity (pdf)
Study produced by the Parliament's Directorate-General for External Policies:
"Most international lawyers and liberal internationalists agree that universal jurisdiction exists, but everyone has a different understanding of what it means. Enormous amounts of time and resources have been expended over the last two decades by learned bodies, intergovernmental and non-governmental organisations to study and clarify the principle of universal jurisdiction. Even more resources have been expended to put it into practice. Yet to this day, less than two dozen trials have been conducted on the basis of universal jurisdiction, all but one in Western Europe. Thus after twenty years of fighting impunity for gross human rights violations through universal jurisdiction, the results are meagre at best and far from universal in any meaningful sense. This study examines not only what went wrong and why, but also which role, if any, the European Union (EU) can play to improve the principles application amongst EU Member States and third countries."
News Digest: round-up of news stories from across the EU (25.4.16)
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (25.4.16)
EU: European Parliament briefing: Virtual currencies: Challenges following their introduction (pdf): "Virtual currencies began creating controversy soon after their launch. The nature of virtual currencies is difficult to apprehend, the underlying technology is complicated, their operations are conducted in a decentralised way, and they are almost unregulated. No-one can predict if a particular virtual currency may become a direct competitor for existing currencies in the distant future, or if it might just collapse overnight. What is certain, however, is the high level of volatility demonstrated by todays market leader, Bitcoin."
UK: Immigration Bill: Lords Amendment 84: Immigration detention: time limit and judicial oversight (The Detention Forum, pdf): "Lords amendment 84 introduces automatic judicial oversight of immigration detention for the first time. Contrary to the title, it does not introduce a time limit, but would provide an important judicial safeguard to the Home Office's powers of detention. The amendment would require the Home Secretary to gain the permission of the First Tier Tribunal if she wanted to detain an individual for immigration purposes for longer than 28 days. The automatic judicial oversight would not apply in cases involving people who have either been given a criminal sentence of 12 months or longer or who face deportation."
Turkey widens crackdown on EU free speech (EUobserver, link): "Turkey has detained a Dutch journalist and issued complaints over German and Swedish projects to commemorate the Armenian genocide.
The actions come on top of calls for legal action against Dutch and German comedians, prompting awkward questions for EU leaders.
Ebru Umar, a Dutch journalist of Turkish origin, was arrested while on holiday in Turkey on Saturday (23 April). She was later let go but forbidden to leave the country.
The arrest came after she wrote a story for Dutch daily Metro in which she compared Turkeys effort to crack down on free speech in Europe to NSB practices, referring to the Dutch Nazi party in World War II, and in which she called Turkish president Recep Tayyip Erdogan a megalomaniac dictator.
She also tweeted parts of her story, leading to her arrest in Turkey, where insulting the president is punishable by up to four years in prison."
EU: DNA databases keep growing
A document published in March by the Council of the EU contains statistics for DNA, fingerprint and vehicle registration data exchanged between Member States as part of the "Prüm" framework, set up in 2008.
The DNA database of every EU Member State increased in size over the course of 2015, except for Malta's.
See: Council of the European Union: statistics and reports on automated data exchange for 2015 (10 March 2016, 5129/16, pdf): "The General Secretariat provides herewith a compilation of statistics for 2015 concerning the automated exchange of DNA data, of dactyloscopic reference data [fingerprints] as well as of Vehicle Registration Data (VRD)."
AUSTRIA: Far right on the rise
"Austria's government was licking its wounds Monday after a historic debacle that saw the opposition anti-immigrant far-right triumph in a presidential ballot two years before the next scheduled general election.
According to preliminary results, Norbert Hofer of the Freedom Party (FPOe) came a clear first with 36 percent of the vote, while candidates from the two governing parties failed to even make it into a runoff on May 22.
The result means that for the first time since 1945, Austria will not have a president backed by either Chancellor Werner Faymann's Social Democrats (SPOe) or their centre-right coalition partners the People's Party (OeVP).
"This is the beginning of a new political era," FPOe leader Heinz-Christian Strache said after what constituted the best-ever result at federal level for the former party of the late Joerg Haider, calling it a "historic result"."
UK: The Police Have Used Tasers on Children Hundreds of Times (Vice, link): "On Thursday, the small but robust police-monitoring group Stop Watch released a report that makes concerning reading if you're the kind of bleeding-heart liberal who thinks it's bad for the police to electrocute minors.
The cornerstone of the report, a formal submission to the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child, was the responses to a series of FOI requests on the police use of Tasers against children. Tasers have been deployed which could mean anything from drawn, aimed or fired by the Metropolitan Police 185 times against children during the period Jan 2014-Nov 2015, and 16 of those times against children 14 years old or younger. Tasers were fired against children by the Met ten times, including once at a 13-year-old child. In the rest of England and Wales, 28 of the 43 forces that responded to the FOI request (excluding the Met), deployed Taser guns against minors more than 407 times, including 57 times against those 14 or under. Among these deployments, Tasers were fired 34 times.
As is often the case with FOI responses, the information provided is not complete some forces found ways to avoid or delay replying. But at the very least, we know that 2014 and 2015 saw the police in England and Wales actually fire Tasers at children a minimum of 44 times."
See: StopWatch: UN Submission:The Policing of Children in England and Wales and International Human Rights Standards (link) and The Policing of Children in England and Wales and International Human Rights Standards - Submission to Committee on the Rights of the Child from StopWatch (pdf)
UK: Undercover policing: spycops north of the border
" A SALES engineer from Angus was in charge of a secret police squad being investigated by a public inquiry.
His biography said: Seconded to a National Unit responsible for gathering, assessing and disseminating intelligence relating to domestic extremism, including animal rights, left and right wing extremists and environmental extremism. Attending force areas throughout the UK, I would work with covert assets to assist with the planning, preparation and implementation of any operational policing response to planned demonstrations where there was potential for extremist activity.
In September 2003, his biography said he was promoted to detective sergeant with NPOIU and coordinated the activities of five field officers who had liaison responsibilities across all police forces within the UK.
He claimed to have been involved in policing at the G8 Summit at Gleaneagles in 2005 when undercover Met officers were working in Scotland. They included the most notorious, Mark Kennedy, who was attached to the NPOIU between 2003 and 2010 until being exposed."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (23-24.4.16)
Snowden sues Norway to avoid extradition during visit (The Local.no, link):
"Fugitive US intelligence contractor Edward Snowden has filed a lawsuit against the Norwegian government seeking a guarantee he will not be extradited if he visits to accept an award, a literary rights group said on Thursday.
The Norwegian branch of the PEN Club has invited Snowden, who has been living in exile in Russia since 2013 after revealing widespread US foreign surveillance, to collect the Ossietzky prize for freedom of expression in November."
EU: Justice and Home Affairs Council, 21 April, Luxembourg: Final press release (pdf) and see: Asylum decision practices: The Council approved the following conclusions (pdf)
News Digest: round-up of news stories from across the EU (22.4.16)
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (22.4.16): international law and EU policies of non-assistance at sea; an examination of what happens to those deported from Greece to Turkey; and news articles from across Europe.
EU: Killing by Omission (EJIL: Talk!, link): "On Monday, the Forensic Architecture team at Goldsmith College, London, published Death by Rescue. The report exposes a rather complex set of facts, but the basic argument is as simple as it is alarming.
Operation Triton, facilitated by Europes border security agency, Frontex, began on 1 November 2014 and is mandated to enforce Italys maritime border. Triton replaced an earlier and much wider Italian Navy operation, Mare Nostrum, which began in October 2013 and was mandated to save migrant lives beyond Italys territorial waters. When EU officials decided on the more limited scope of Triton, they knew their decision would result in the drowning of numerous migrants. As one Frontex official wryly noted, the withdrawal of naval assets from the area, if not properly planned and announced well in advance, would likely result in a higher number of fatalities. But the European Commission turned a blind eye leading to a spike in migrant deaths, which the authors, Charles Heller and Lorenzo Pezzani meticulously document.
From a legal perspective, this set of circumstances raises the question whether the migrants rights were violated, and if so, whether EU actors can be held legally accountable. In my view, the report exposes no illegal activity by European agents, either at the operational or at the policymaking level. Perhaps more troubling, the report raises the specter of unaccountable violence ingrained in the very structure of international law. If international law is somehow to blame for circumstances that made these utterly preventable deaths possible, then perhaps it is law itself that should be indicted."
An article examining the legal implications of the Death by Rescue reported released earlier this week. See: Summary of report: Death by Rescue - The lethal effects of the EU's policies of non-assistance at sea (pdf) and the full report (link).
Finnish court suspends Dublin returns to Hungary
"Finlands Supreme Administrative Court recently ruled that returning an Afghan asylum seeker to Hungary was problematic because of the countrys asylum procedures.
The court declared that deporting asylum seekers via Serbia threatened the fundamental rights of people seeking international protection. As a result of the Courts decision the Finnish Immigration Service has suspended asylum seeker returns to Hungary.
The Afghan asylum seeker had come to Finland by way of Hungary and Serbia. The Supreme Administrative Court deemed that there is a risk that the man would be deported from Hungary to Serbia and from there to Afghanistan without having any authorities assess his asylum application or his need for international protection. Hungary is the only EU country that considers Serbia to be safe for asylum seekers and returns them there.
The Court determined that there are major problems with Hungarys asylum procedures. It pointed to large numbers of asylum applications, difficulties in providing legal guidance and other problems facing asylum seekers in Hungary. It said that these factors made it impossible to be clear if the mans return to Serbia and other third countries would be stopped or deferred."
See: Finland suspends asylum seeker returns to Hungary following higher court ruling (YLE, link). Hungary is the second EU country to which asylum-seekers can no longer be returned from Finland. A previous court ruling saw returns to Greece suspended.
Press release: Readmissions from Greece to Turkey: What Happens After Readmission? (Mülteci Der, link): "Mülteci-Der lawyer went to the RC [Removal Centre] in Pehlivanköy-Kirklareli and demanded to meet with the returned detainees. Although the lawyer insisted on her request for 2 days, in the end her request was refused by Kirklareli Provincial Migration Management (PDMM) based on an order given to by the Directorate General of Migration Management (DGMM) in Ankara. The lawyer was prevented from seeing the detainees and the law was violated on the ground that the DGMM has a working group on readmitted people and until they finalize their work, returned people shall not be allowed to meet with lawyers or anybody else. By preventing lawyers from meeting with detainees arbitrarily and without any legal basis, the administration violated the law and once again the rule of law was not respected."
Teaming up: four-country discussions on migration and refugees
Bulgaria, Greece, Albania, Macedonia to Discuss Migrant Crisis (Novinite, link): "Interior and foreign ministers of Bulgaria, Greece, Albania and Macedonia are to meet in Thessaloniki on Thursday and Friday to discuss possible measures to control the migrant inflow into Europe.
The meeting has been called by Greece's top diplomat, Nikos Kotzias.
Bulgaria and other Greek neighbors for their part fear the numbers of migrants trying to enter their territories will rise this spring and summer."
And: CZECH REPUBLIC: PM rejects permanent refugee redistribution mechanism (Prague Monitor, link): "Prime Minister Bohuslav Sobotka (Social Democrats, CSSD) told the Czech Chamber of Deputies yesterday he disagreed with the creation of a permanent mechanism redistributing refugees among EU countries and a transition of the powers relating to asylum to the European Commission.
These are efforts to federalise the asylum policy, Sobotka said.
Sobotka said he wanted to prepare a joint position of the Visegrad Four (the Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland and Slovakia) to the EC proposal.
"There is a big chance of our proceeding jointly," Sobotka said, adding that the Czech Republic would look for other allies, too, in support of its stand."
EU: Onwards to the "Security Union"
"The Commission is today setting out the way forward towards the achievement of an effective and genuine EU Security Union building on the European Agenda on Security presented on 28 April 2015. Whilst responsibility for security lies primarily with Member States, transnational threats such as terrorism cannot be addressed effectively without a common European approach. The necessary tools, infrastructure and environment are being built at European level for national authorities to work effectively together to meet the shared challenge. But the full added value of a Security Union depends crucially on the use that is made of this framework, to close operational loopholes and plug information gaps. This requires a step change at the level of Member States and their law enforcement authorities, working closely with EU Agencies."
European Commission, Delivering on the European Agenda on Security to fight against terrorism and pave the way towards and effective and genuine Security Union (COM(2016) 230 final, 20 April 2016, pdf)
EU: SMART BORDERS: Bulgaria Calls for Equal Access to EUs Entry-Exit System for All Member States (Novinite, link): "Bulgarias Interior Minister Rumyana Bachvarova has called for equal access of all member states to the proposed Entry-Exit System of the EU to boost the efficiency of the fight against organized crime and terrorism.
We all should be able to make full use of the new centralized system whis is being developed, Bachvarova said at a meeting of the Justice and Home Affairs Council in Luxembourg on Thursday, according a statement from the ministry.
Bulgaria, which is not member of the EUs free-travel Schengen area, currently cannot use in full the potential of key information systems of the bloc. At the same time, the country ensures security along one of the most important and vulnerable EU external borders amidst the current migration crisis, Bachvarova said."
See the new proposal for an Entry-Exit System, published on 6 April: European Commission, Proposal for a
REGULATION OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL establishing an Entry/Exit System (EES) to register entry and exit data and refusal of entry data of third country nationals crossing the external borders of the Member States of the European Union and determining the conditions for access to the EES for law enforcement purposes and amending Regulation (EC) No 767/2008 and Regulation (EU) No 1077/2011 (pdf) and Annexes 1 to 2 (pdf)
French 'Nuit Debout' protest movement shows no sign of losing steam (Deutsche Welle, link): " Deep into its third week, France's Nuit Debout - or "Up All Night" - defies easy stereotypes. The social movement that began March 31 to protest government-proposed labor reforms has morphed into a leaderless and hodgepodge citizens' movement aimed to occupy, to recreate and to offer a grassroots voice for at least one slice of the French population.
Some observers compare it to the May 1968 protests in France, when occupied universities, massive demonstrations and crippling strikes left a long-term mark on the country. Others to social movements like Occupy Wall Street in the United States or the Indignados uprising in Spain that gave rise to the leftist Podemos party.
Still others have poked fun at it. French cartoonist Xavier Gore, of "Le Monde" newspaper, depicted a bunch of penguins gathered with the tagline: "Let's meet here every night until we can figure out why."
How it will end is anybody's guess."
How fair are trials at the International Criminal Court? Three examples of concern (Fair Trials, link): "While acknowledging that ICC trials are conducted according to international recognized standards and the governing laws and regulations guarantee the rights of the accused, there are structural limitations. Seven years after the opening of the first trial different patterns have emerged which are of concern from a fair trial perspective. Three common examples:
1. Regulation 55
The ICCs Regulations contain the controversial regulation 55 which allows the judges to recharacterize the facts presented by the parties to enable more focused trials. The provision has been used in various cases and at different stages of the proceedings to make law and facts better fit.
2. Long proceedings
While long trials are common at many international courts, the ICC in addition to the trial has developed an extensive pre-trial phase at the end of which the charges against a person are either confirmed or declined. This means that most suspects are in pre-trial detention for a year or longer before it is clear whether they will go on trial at all.
3. Inherent bias
The defense side and the accused are rarely at the center in international criminal trials. Instead, the focus is often on victims and the fight against impunity for heinous crimes. From such a perspective a conviction is seen as a victory of justice while an acquittal is considered a failure of the court."
EU: Europol joins UK appeal to report extremist and terrorist material online using red "stop" button (press release, pdf): "1 622 media content and social media accounts in 4 languages containing terrorist and violent extremist propaganda hosted by 13 social media and online service providers - were processed for the purpose of referral by Europol.
Europol joined forces with the UK National Counter Terrorism Internet Referral Unit (CTIRU) on a 36-hour operation to secure the removal of the material as quickly as possible. Several teams of Europol specialists, analysts, translators and counter-terrorism experts supported the British colleagues throughout the operation from the Agency's headquarters in The Hague.
The UK CTIRU had previously launched a national appeal for internet users to report harmful extremist and terrorist material when they see it online using the red "STOP" button. All last week, UK police and partners used their social media channels to urge people to report material they suspect is extremist or terrorist by clicking on a distinctive red "STOP" button that can be found on their websites. STOP stands for Stop Terrorists' and extremists' Online Presence."
For more information on Europol's plans for policing the internet, see: Policing the internet: from terrorism and extremism to "content used by traffickers to attract migrants and refugees" (pdf)
UK: UN special rapporteur criticises government policies on return visit
"The UK governments strategy to counter Islamist extremism is affecting the discussion of terrorism, the UNs special rapporteur on the right to freedom of assembly has said.
Attempts to identify and counter Islamist extremism through the Prevent programme had created unease and uncertainty around what can be legitimately discussed in public, said Maina Kiai, at the end of a three-day visit to the UK in which he warned Britain must live up to its human rights commitments.
I heard reports of teachers being reported for innocuous comments in class, for example, Kiai said. The spectre of Big Brother is so large, in fact, that I was informed that some families are afraid of discussing the negative effects of terrorism in their own homes, fearing their children would talk about it at school and have their intentions misconstrued."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (21.4.16)
EU: Childrens' rights: EU strengthens rights of children in criminal proceedings (Council of the EU press release, pdf):
"On 21 April 2016, the Council adopted the final text of a directive strengthening rights of children in criminal proceedings. The directive provides a number of procedural safeguards for children (i.e. individuals below 18) who are suspected or accused of having committed a criminal offence. The directive includes additional safeguards compared to those that already apply to suspected and accused adults.
A core provision of the directive relates to assistance from a lawyer. Member states should make sure that suspected or accused children are assisted by a lawyer, where necessary by providing legal aid, unless assistance by a lawyer is not proportionate in the light of the circumstances of the case. Other important provisions of the directive concern the provision of information on rights, the right to have an individual assessment, to a medical examination, and to audio-visual recording of questioning. It also provides special safeguards for children during deprivation of liberty, in particular during detention.
This final adoption of the directive follows a political agreement between the two legislators in December 2015 and the subsequent approval by the European Parliament on 9 March 2016. Once published in the EU Official Journal, member states will have three years to transpose the provisions into their national laws. Denmark, the UK and Ireland have opted out of this directive and will not be bound by it."
And: Full text of the Directive (pdf)
EU: Legal Analysis: Migrants in Greece are denied the rights to international protection and family unity. The visit to the camps in Idomeni and government-run camps, and a legal analysis of the situation we observed. (pdf) Prepared by ASGI, Italy.
"A delegation of eight participants in the course of the Advanced training school for legal operators specialised in international protection organised by ASGI in Rome alongside legal operators from the ADL Zavidovici association, the K-Pax cooperative, the Idea Prisma 82 cooperative and the Alternata cooperative travelled to Greece within the framework of the #overthefortress caravan organised by Melting Pot and the Ambasciata dei Diritti delle Marche to observe the legal conditions of migrants in the camp in Idomeni and the government-run camps in the vicinity. The monitoring was also carried out with the help of mediators from the caravan.
On 26 and 27 March, we visited the Idomeni camp and interviewed the foreign citizens who were there, as well as some international organisations."
Translation by Statewatch. The original version (in Italian) of the report "Idomeni, un'analisi giuridica sui diritti negati ai migranti" is available on the ASGI website.
Council of Europe condemns EU's refugee deal with Turkey (Guardian, link):
"Human rights body says agreement at worst breaks international law and progress on integrating refugees is shamefully slow...
The EU-Turkey agreement at best strains and at worst exceeds the limits of what is permissible under European and international law, states the report by the Dutch parliamentarian Tineke Strik. Even on paper, it raises many serious questions of compatibility with basic norms on refugees and migrants rights. It has so far given every indication of being even more problematic in practice." [emphasis added]
And see the report by the Committee on Migration, Refugees and Displaced Persons: The situation of refugees and migrants under the EU-Turkey Agreement of 18 March 2016 (pdf). Rapporteur: Ms Tineke STRIK, Netherlands, Socialist Group. And: Press release (link)
European Parliament: Study: Research for TRAN Committee Self-piloted cars: The future of road transport? (pdf):
"The study provides an analysis of the development of automated vehicles inside and outside the EU, including both the technologies which are already on the market and those under testing and research. The EU is giving increasing attention to automated and connected vehicles as they could have huge impacts on road safety, travel behaviour and urban development. The study reports on state of the art key research projects and large scale testing in this area and discusses future pathways and potential impacts of increasing vehicle automation. It concludes with recommendations on aspects that should be considered when shaping policies to sustain the research and development, and bringing to market, of highly automated and connected vehicles."
UK spy agencies have collected bulk personal data since 1990s, files show (Guardian, link):
"Agencies privately concede that intrusive practices can invade privacy and that data is gathered on people unlikely to be of interest...
The files show that GCHQ, the governments electronic eavesdropping centre based in Cheltenham, was collecting and developing bulk data sets as early as 1998 under powers granted by section 94 of the 1984 Telecommunications Act. ...Another MI5 file notes that datasets contain personal data about individuals, the majority of whom are unlikely to be of intelligence or security interest." [emphasis added]
See Privacy International link with all the documents: Bulk Personal Datasets Challenge
and in the Intercept (link): "Elsewhere in the documents, eavesdropping agency Government Communications Headquarters (GCHQ) and domestic intelligence agency MI5 admit that they have obtained the bulk datasets on several occasions dating back more than a decade GCHQ beginning in 1998, and MI5 in 2005 under Section 94 of the 1984 Telecommunications Act" [emphasis added]
Hillsborough inquests jury has reached decisions in all but one topic (Livepool Echo, link): "The jury in the Hillsborough inquests has reached decisions on all but one topic.
The court, in Birchwood Park, Warrington, was today adjourned until Monday after the jury asked for some guidance as they continued deliberations for a 10th day.
Court resumed just after 1.15pm when coroner Sir John Goldring responded to a note the jury had sent."
Europes rule-of-law crisis (New Europe, link):"Two EU members in particular, Hungary and Poland, are now jeopardizing hard-won European democratic norms and thus undermining the very purpose of European integration."
EU: Justice and Home Affairs Council, 21 April, Luxembourg: "B" Points Agenda (for discussion, pdf); "A" Points Agenda (adopted without discussion, pdf); and: Background Note (pdf)
German court: anti-terror laws partially unconstitutional (DW, link) : See Court Press release: Constitutional Complaints Against the Investigative Powers of the Federal Criminal Police Office for Fighting International Terrorism Partially Successful (link) and Decision (link, German)
On 20 April, the German Constitutional Court declared in a landmark decision surveillance powers of the Federal Criminal Police Office (Bundeskriminalamt - BKA) and provisions for information exchange partly unconstitutional.
The powers at stake were introduced in 2008 in order to expand the mandate of the BKA in the field counterterrorism. It authorised among others bugging of homes, online searches of computers and covert interception of communication for the purpose of preempting terrorism. Before, only German state police forces had the mandate of crime prevention. Therefore, critics feared the emergence of a German FBI. Although the constitutional court did not scrap the new powers at all, the judges limited their scope and called for precise regulation, the protection of intimate information, better oversight and more transparency.
Moreover, the judges limit both domestic and international information exchange by the BKA and call for adequate data protection standards in foreign non-EU countries as a prerequisite for data transfers by the BKA. The BKA Act is now to be revised in summer 2018 but is it clear that the decision of the Court is also a message to the intelligence agencies and their information sharing with the NSA and other partners.
Refugee crisis: Statewatch: State of Play: Commission statistics (dated 18 April 2016): Hotspots, Returns, Pledges and Civil Protection
PEGIDA founder dragged before German court (euractiv, link): "Lutz Bachmann, one of the founders of the German xenophobic PEGIDA movement, was put on trial in Dresden yesterday (18 April). The prosecution accuses him of having repeatedly harassed refugees and migrants on social media and inciting hatred. EurActiv Germany reports."
France seeks to extend state of emergency until end of July - Measures brought in after Paris attacks should cover Euro 2016 championship and Tour de France, ministers say (Guardian, link): "The French government is seeking to extend the state of emergency that has been in place since Novembers Paris attacks to cover the period of the Euro 2016 football championship and the Tour de France.
Manuel Valls, the prime minister, said Euro 2016, hosted by France from 10 June, was a security priority.
Faced with an event this big ... which must take place in conditions of security and which at the same time should be a celebration.... we have to ensure security, he told France Info radio. The state of emergency cannot be permanent but for these big events ... we have decided to prolong it. "
UK: Britains scientists must not be gagged (Guardian, link): "A ban on state-funded academics using their work to question government policy is to begin on 1 May. Its either a cock-up or a conspiracy "
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (19.4.16)
UK: House of Commons Briefing: Radicalisation in prisons in England and Wales (pdf):
"This Commons Library briefing describes how the Government is seeking to tackle extremism and, in particular, radicalisation in prisons. It examines
The difference between faith and radicalisation
Why people become radicalised
What is happening within prisons
How radicalisation is being countered in prisons and
Whether the National Offender Management Service is doing enough."
UK: Supreme Court allows appeal against residence test for legal aid (Free Movement, GC, link): "The Supreme Court has allowed the appeal against the residence test for legal aid, overturning the Court of Appeal judgment in favour of the Home Office. The basis for the Supreme Courts decision is that the Lord Chancellor, Chris Grayling at that time, did not have the legal power to introduce the residence test. A second issue was to be argued regarding whether the test was unjustifiably discriminatory and so in breach of common law and the Human Rights Act 1998 but the Court did not hear argument on that question."
Article 29 Working Party Delivers Its Opinion on the EU-U.S. Privacy Shield (Covington, link): Useful summary.
EU-LIBYA-MED: Council conclusions on Libya (pdf):
"The EU stands ready to offer security sector support in response to possible GNA requests. Should a Libyan request be forthcoming and following consultations with the Libyans, a possible civilian CSDP mission could support Libyan efforts inter alia through advice and capacity building in the fields of police and criminal justice including on counter-terrorism, border management, countering irregular migration and smuggling of migrants and trafficking of human beings, as part of broader Security Sector Reform support. This possible mission could draw upon the existing planning capacity of EUBAM Libya. In addition to the possible civilian mission, further consideration will also be given to support that can be provided through EUNAVFOR MED Sophia, by enhancing its capacity to disrupt the business model of human smugglers and trafficking networks and to contribute to broader security in support to the legitimate Libyan authorities, for example through potential capacity building for the Libyan Coastguard, and the implementation of international law."
EU set to upgrade naval mission in Mediterranean (FT, link): "Europes governments signalled they are ready to expand the role of an EU naval mission in the Mediterranean, as the bloc braces itself for an expected surge in the number of asylum seekers seeking to make the dangerous sea crossing from north Africa. The EU is under pressure to find solutions ahead of a likely influx this summer of people setting off for Europe from the coast of Libya and neighbouring countries."
and: EU navies prepare to start work in Libyan waters (euobserver, link): "The EU is to make plans for posting security experts to Libya and for moving its naval operation into Libyan waters following initial talks with the countrys new government. "
EU/Greece: First Turkey Deportations Riddled With Abuse (HRW, link):
"The first round of European Union-sanctioned deportations of 66 people from the Greek island of Chios to Turkey on April 4, 2016 was rushed, chaotic, and violated the rights of those deported, Human Rights Watch said today. In Turkey, the detained deportees lost contact with family and friends held in Greece, and Turkish authorities have not allowed visits by rights groups or the United Nations.
In the mad dash to start the deportations deal with Turkey, the European Union and Greece tossed rights to the wind, including for people who wanted to seek asylum, said Fred Abrahams, Human Rights Watch associate director for program. The abusive deportations expose the fundamental flaws in the EUs expedited mass returns to a country that cannot be considered safe.
EU: Full text of the PNR Directive as agreed
See: DIRECTIVE OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL on the use of passenger name record (PNR) data for the prevention, detection, investigation and prosecution of terrorist offences and serious crime (pdf)
EU: Common Foreign and Security Policy (CFSP): migration control to take more prominence in overseas missions
A paper produced by the European External Action Service in February 2016 provides an overview of current CFSP missions and sets out possibilities for their future development. Key issues are ensuring that missions take into account the requirements of EU migration and counter-terrorism policy, and the paper notes overall that: "there will likely be needs to intensify CFSP actions in support of Third States, either via projects implemented by civilian CSDP missions or through dedicated CFSP projects. This will also require additional staffing, skills and expertise in project management." Several hundred million euros are currently available for ongoing and future CSDP missions.
See: European External Action Service, CFSP budget orientations for 2016 and 2017 (doc. 6383/16, 22 February 2016, pdf) and COR 1 (pdf)
On migration, the paper notes:
"Migration is at the heart of the political debate in the EU and, for a few years now, is one of the strategic priorities of the external relations of the Union. The ongoing refugee crisis has put discussions on refugees and irregular migration on top of political agenda of the EU. The EU has not only set up a military CSDP operation EUNAVFOR MED Sophia, but also taken significant steps together with its neighbours and partners by creating a set of measures and action plans to jointly meet the challenges. Civilian CSDP missions in the concerned regions may need to be further reinforced with migration dimension and experts, as it was the case in 2015 of EUCAP Sahel Niger."
On "radical and terrorist organizations":
"Destabilization by radical and terrorist organizations is already partly addressed through notably CSDP missions assisting with capacity building in Mali and Niger. Pending the evolution of the fragile regional environment, additional experts and assets could possibly be requested to reinforce CSDP missions."
The paper is structured by the following headings: CFSP and CSDP in the changing global security environment; Future CSDP; Conclusions; Annex I - Current CSDP missions and mid-term forecast; Annex II - Possible non-proliferation and disarmament projects.
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (18.4.16)
News Digest: Round-up of news stories from across the EU (18.4.16)
Information exchange for internal security: Council documents
Documents from recent discussions within the Council on how to improve information exchange amongst Europe's law enforcement authorities. The issue has come to the fore (again) following recent terrorist attacks and the movement of refugees towards and within Europe.
EU leaders 'killing migrants by neglect' after cutting Mediterranean rescue missions (The Independent, link): "EU policymakers are guilty of "killing by neglect" by cutting rescue missions in the Mediterranean - potentially costing the lives of more than 1,500 refugees, according to a report.
The Italy-led search and rescue mission, Mare Nostrum, ended in October 2014 and was replaced by Triton, which deployed fewer ships and prioritised deterring migrants over rescue operations, the report says.
Charities and UN officials warned the move could have a disastrous impact and lead to far more deaths at sea.
Documents unearthed by British universities showed the European border force Frontex pushed ahead with the change despite an internal assessment warning that if it was not properly planned it "would likely result in a higher number of fatalities"."
See: New evidence proves EU policymakers knew reduced search-and-rescue operation would cause mass migrant deaths (press release, pdf): "A new investigation accuses EU policymakers of killing by neglect after cutting rescue missions in the Mediterranean in full knowledge of the lethal consequences of their actions. Meeting transcripts and documents unearthed in a report from Goldsmiths, University of London and the University of York show that the EU border agency Frontexs own internal assessment of replacing Mare Nostrum with Triton predicted increased deaths at sea, but the policy was introduced anyway.
Researchers found that a previously unreported 2014 Frontex internal assessment on tackling migrant flows stated:
It has to be stressed that the withdrawal of naval assets from the area, if not properly planned and announced well in advance, would likely result in a higher number of fatalities.
The researchers from the ESRC-funded Precarious Trajectories project argue that because the decision to retreat from state-led search and rescue operations was taken in full knowledge of the risk, EU policy makers and agencies carry a strong degree of responsibility for mass deaths at sea...."
And: Summary of report: Death by Rescue - The lethal effects of the EU's policies of non-assistance at sea (pdf)
The report will be launched on Monday 18 April at 6pm at The Mosaic Rooms, 226 Cromwell Road, SW5 0SW London. For details and to book a ticket click here.
EU: Council of the European Union: FREMP (Working Party on Fundamental Rights, Citizens' rights and Free movement of persons) Summary of discussions (EU doc no: 7551-16, pdf): Important update on EU joining ECHR: "Discussions on mutual trust will be resumed after the ECtHR hands down the judgement in the Avotins case, presumably by summer 2016. As regards CFSP, COM will not present anything until CJEU hands down decisions in two pending CFSP related cases."
EU: Eurostat: Record number of over 1.2 million first time asylum seekers registered in 2015 - Syrians, Afghans and Iraqis: top citizenships (pdf): "In 2015, 1 255 600 first time asylum seekers applied for international protection in the Member States of the European Union (EU), a number more than double that of the previous year.
The number of Syrians seeking international protection has doubled in 2015 compared with the previous year to reach 362 800, while the number of Afghans has almost quadrupled to 178 200 and that of Iraqis has multiplied by 7 to 121 500. They represent the three main citizenships of first time asylum applicants in the EU Member States in 2015, accounting for more than half of all first time applicants."
Council of Europe urges states to protect whistleblowers and journalists (link): A recommendation adopted on 13 April 2016 by the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe (CoE) defined a series of guidelines to ensure the safety of journalists in the 47 member countries: See Recommendation (link)
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (15.4.16)
EU: Council of the European Union: New asylum policy, EU-Turkey resettlement and Visa Code
- Discussion paper on Commission Communication "Towards a reform of the Common European Asylum System and enhancing legal avenues to Europe" (LIMITE doc no: 7861-16, pdf): Discussion on Commission's new asylum paper.
- Draft Council Decision amending Council Decision (EU) 2015/1601 of 22 September 2015 establishing provisional measures in the area of international protection for the benefit of Italy and Greece (LIMITE doc no: 7500-16, pdf) Resettlement issues -EU-Turkey plan
- Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on the Union code on Visas (Visa Code) (recast) - mandate for negotiations with the European Parliament (LIMITE doc no: 7714-16, pdf) Council deal on visa code, no humanitarian clause. Only benefits states agreeing readmission deals
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (14.4.16)
Another bad day for rights and privacy: European Parliament: Parliament backs EU directive on use of Passenger Name Records (PNR) (pdf): The text was approved by 461 votes to 179, with 9 abstentions.
"The new directive regulating the use of Passenger Name Record (PNR) data in the EU for the prevention, detection, investigation and prosecution of terrorist offences and serious crime was approved by Parliament on Thursday. It will oblige airlines to hand national authorities passengers' data for all flights from third countries to the EU and vice versa."
The Press release is disingenuous: It says: "member states could also extend it to intra-EU ones (i.e. from an EU country to one or more other EU countries), provided that they notify the EU Commission" As Statewatch reported in December: Member States circulated a Note following the Justiice and Home affairs Council of 3-4 December 2015:
"Draft declaration by the Member States to the minutes of the Council
"Article 1a of the PNR Directive allows Member States that so wish to apply it to intra-EU flights on a voluntary basis, upon notice to the Commission to that end.
Considering the current security situation in Europe, *Member States declare that by the date of transposition provided for in Article 15 they will make full use of the possibility provided for by Article 1a under the conditions set by the Directive."
See: EU-PNR: European Parliament has "egg on its face"
EU-USA: PRIVACY SHIELD: EU Article 29 Working Party on data protection: Opinion 01/2016 on the EU U.S. Privacy Shield draft adequacy decision (pdf) They rip the Privacy Shield to shreds.
"On 29 February 2016, the European Commission published a Communication, a draft adequacy decision and the annexed texts constituting a new framework for transatlantic exchanges of personal data for commercial purposes: the EU-U.S. Privacy Shield (hereinafter: Privacy Shield), which seeks to replace the previous U.S. Safe Harbour invalidated by the Court of Justice of the European Union (hereinafter: CJEU) on 6 October 2015, in the Schrems case....
With regard to the applicable law, the WP29 highlights that if the Privacy Shield adequacy decision is adopted on the basis of Directive 95/46/EC, it needs to be consistent with the EU data protection legal framework, both in scope and terminology. The WP29 considers a review must be undertaken shortly after the entry into application of the General Data Protection Regulation, in order to ensure the higher level of data protection offered by the Regulation is followed in the adequacy decision and its annexes....
The WP29 also concludes that onward transfers of EU personal data are insufficiently framed, especially regarding their scope, the limitation of their purpose and the guarantees applying to transfers to Agents. As regards the access to Privacy Shield data by law enforcement, especially to foreseeability of the legislation is a concern, due to the extensive and complex nature of the U.S. law enforcement system at both Federal and state level, and the limited information included in the adequacy decision."
EU-USA: EU Article 29 Working Party on data protection: Working Document 01/2016 on the justification of interferences with the fundamental rights to privacy and data protection through surveillance measures when transferring personal data (European Essential Guarantees) (pdf)
"The four European Essential Guarantees that are described in this opinion are no unconditional Guarantees. Also when looking at their formulation, it should be clear that all four require a certain degree of interpretation.Should a third country allow for interferences that go beyond what should be regarded as strictly necessary in a democratic society...,
"The WP29 underlines that the Guarantees are based on the fundamental rights that apply to everyone, notwithstanding their nationality. Furthermore, it should be noted that the Guarantees are based on what is required by the law and not necessarily on what is the current practice in the EU Member States. The WP29 does not maintain a double standard and has therefore already called several times upon the Member States to ensure their surveillance legislation is in line with the jurisprudence of the CJEU and the ECtHR."
The WP has reservtions about the collection of mass data by US agencies and the so-called redress mechanism. Fuirther there are six eceptions allowing the bulk collection of data and on the re-use of data for other purposes or their transfer to third countries.
See also: Sttatement of the Article 29 WP on the consequences of the Schrems judgment (pdf)
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (13.4.16)
EU Cracks Down on Independent Volunteers in Greece (Megaphone Valkyrie, link):
"2016 began with a move to have all volunteers registered with the police. In a crisis where immigration law criminalises vital humanitarian work, this is a recipe for disaster. And it is not just about elbowing out the political activists; to allow authorities time to organise the registration process, entire flights chartered for volunteers have been cancelled. Even Clowns Without Borders were barred from the camps. The same thing is now happening in France, where independent volunteers are being barred from the camps at Dunkirk and Calais, reduced to watching months of work burned to the ground by authorities branding them uncaring and dangerous.
Theres another glaring cause for concern on the Greek front: over half their police are Golden Dawn supporters. So, fifty-fifty chance youre registering sensitive information with an armed fascist. That wasnt an abstract danger to any of us: we had witnessed the racism and brutality. One night, we were so afraid of the police in our building, we slept in the car....
It was the beginning of a crackdown ordered from the highest levels. The Council of the European Union is preparing plans to equate humanitarian assistance with people trafficking, criminalising those saving lives at sea and caring for survivors on land. We feel as if we are in the resistance in World War Two, said Lara. We were randomly checked for papers and passports and told not to feed the hungry. Every move we make is being watched.
See Statewatch coverage: NGOs and volunteers helping refugees in Greece to be placed under state control and Council proposals on migrant smuggling would criminalise humanitarian assistance by civil society, local people and volunteers
UK: GRUNWICKS: Covert police spied on strikers and their supporters in iconic dispute (Guardian, link):
"A police undercover unit obtained intelligence on the tactics of the strikers and their supporters in the seminal Grunwick dispute... One of these could be a dispute that centred on a photo-processing factory in north-west London called Grunwick. It was one of the most iconic industrial disputes since the Second World War.
Now evidence has emerged to show how the controversial Metropolitan police undercover unit, the Special Demonstration Squad (SDS), obtained inside information about the tactics and movements of the strikers and their supporters. Two former policemen have described the intelligence as being important at a time when the Met was struggling to police the dispute."
EU counts cost of US visa war (euobserver, link):
"Imposing visas on US visitors would harm transatlantic relations and cost billions of euros, the European Commission has said. It would be a major disaster, a former EU diplomat added.... It came following talks by EU officials in Strasbourg after a legal deadline expired on non-reciprocity - the fact that US nationals can go to any EU state without a permit, but people from five EU countries still need visas to enter the US.
The five countries are Bulgaria, Cyprus, Croatia, Poland, and Romania".
See: Lack of visa reciprocity with the U.S., Canada and Brunei: European Commissions assesses state of play and discusses next steps (Press elease, pdf) and Communication: State of play and the possible ways forward as regards the situation of non-reciprocity with certain third countries in the area of visa policy (COM 221-16, pdf)
European Parliament: Last-minute amendments jeopardise PNR plenary vote (Parliament Magazine, link):
"Tabling of amendment by ALDE group could 'send the whole agreement back to the negotiating table'... Green home affairs spokesperson Jan Philipp Albrecht argued that "serious doubts" remain about the legality of the planned agreement.
He said, "The landmark ruling of the European Court of Justice in 2014 made clear that the general retention of data without grounds is not compatible with EU law. This has clear implications for passenger data exchange and retention systems.
"Against this background, it would be irresponsible to proceed gung-ho with a PNR exchange system that goes in this direction and the proposed system must be legally assessed.""
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (12.4.16)
EU: INTERNAL SECURITY AGENCIES ACCESS & INPUT INTO SIS: Council of the European Union: Observations of the Presidency on strengthening Information Exchange/Information Systems, especially SIS (LIMITE doc no: 7412-16, pdf)
"Enable direct inserts of alerts in the SIS for security services (possible national legal changes) Member states will ensure that security services have the possibility of entering alerts into the SIS without interference of judicial authorities. Amendments of legal or policy frameworks allowing security services to enter alerts will be made."
Includes: ANNEX: "Indicative criteria to be taken into consideration regarding exchange and sharing of information on individuals involved in travelling to and from jihadi areas of conflict Any transmission and sharing of information about the individuals referred to below is submitted to limitations and safeguards provided in national law." and
"Extend Europols access rights to SIS II (legal change): Europol must have the possibility to access alerts with regard to missing persons and on persons undesirable in or refused entry to the territory of a Member State."
Whats at stake in the EU PNR debate? (papersplease.org, link): My analysis & some arguments for why the proposal should be rejected by Edward Hasbrouck:
"As we said in a submission cited with approval in a report last month by the UN Office Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights concerning the rights of migrants, "screening" and algorithmic travel control regimes are likely to result in systematic discrimination against asylum seekers and refugees: Their nationality or place of origin in a conflict zone may cause them to be deemed "risky" according to the profiling and "risk scoring" algorithms. There may be limited, inconsistent, or nonexistent records pertaining to migrants in irregular situations in the databases used for profiling and risk scoring, and screening algorithms may equate uncertainty with risk.
Controls on access to air travel throughout the EU on the basis of PNR profiling are thus likely to exclude many legitimate asylum seekers from travel by common carrier, forcing them to dangerous means of "irregular" and indirect transportation and compounding the EU migrant crisis. The PNR proposal is the European equivalent of Donald Trump's "proposal to build a wall on the USA-Mexico border, and would be just as disastrous."
And see: Passenger Name Records, data mining & data protection: the need for strong safeguards (CoE, link) by Douwe Korff, Emeritus Professor of International Law, London Metropolitan University Associate, Oxford Martin School, University of Oxford with advice, comments and review by Marie Georges
Council of Europe Expert.
PORTUGAL- USA RENDITION: Ex-CIA agent loses extradition appeal in Portugal (New Europe, link):
"Portugals supreme court has rejected a former CIA operatives appeal against extradition to Italy to serve a six-year sentence for her part in an extraordinary rendition programme.
Sabrina De Sousas only remaining recourse to avoid being sent to Italy would be to appeal to Portugals Constitutional Court, arguing her extradition order is unconstitutional. De Sousa was among 26 Americans convicted in absentia in the case, which also implicated Italys secret services and has proven embarrassing to successive Italian governments.
De Sousa, who was working in Italy under diplomatic cover, faces prison for her role in the 2003 kidnapping in Milan of Osama Moustafa Hassan Nasr, a terror suspect who was under surveillance by Italian law enforcement at the time."
EU Whats DiEM25, really? Reply to an open letter by Souvlis & Mazzolini (Open Democracy, link) by Yanis Varoufakis
"If our analysis is correct (and I sincerely hope we are wrong), we are at a moment in history very much like 1930. Just after the crisis (1929) and in the early stages of a slide toward an abyss comprising deflation, xenophobia, hyper-nationalism, competitive devaluations, jingoism etc. What was the duty of progressives in 1930? It was, I suggest, to reach across party affiliations and borders to create a pan-European movement of democrats (radicals, liberals, even progressive conservatives) in opposition to the forces of evil. I very much fear that this is our duty today too." [emphasis added]
EU: Trade Secrets Directive creates excessive secrecy and must be rejected (euractiv, link):
"The schemed Directive on Trade Secrets Protection is meant to repress industrial espionage, but applies to the whole of society legal remedies that should only apply to businesses, writes a broad coalition of journalists, lawyers, scientists, unions and associations."
European enforcers not sold on privacy shield (politico, link): "Tech companies in last-minute lobbying push to fend off European attack on data pact"
and see: The Commissions draft EU-US Privacy Shield adequacy decision: A Shield for Transatlantic Privacy or Nothing New under the Sun (EU law Analysis, link):
" A recently leaked document reveals that the Article 29 Working Party has difficulties in reaching an overall conclusion on the Commissions draft adequacy decision and supports the view that Privacy Shield does not fully comply with the essential guarantees for the transfer of personal data from the EU to the US for intelligence activities.
Should the Commission nevertheless decide to proceed with the current draft, it is highly possible that the CJEU will be called in the future to judge the adequacy of Privacy Shield in a Schrems 2 line of cases."
FRANCE: The French protest that wants to redefine politics (EUobserver, link): "French police started to evacuate the place de la République in Paris Monday morning (11 April) after a protest movement that started there extended to over 60 towns and city over the weekend in a show of defiance to the government.
The "Nuit Debout" movement, which can be translated by "standing night", started on 31 March as protest against a labour market reform presented by the left-wing government.?? Based on the 2011 Indignados movement in Spain, the Nuit Debout is a made-up camp where people talk about the reform but also about politics and social policies in general in committees and a "popular assembly"."
And see: In pictures: 'Up All Night' protesters march on PM's home (France 24, link): "Hundreds of protesters taking part in the "Up All Night" (Nuit Debout) demonstrations were met with tear gas Saturday night as they tried to make their way to the residence of Prime Minister Manuel Valls. At least eight people were arrested."
How the former head of Blackwater set up operations in Austria and Bulgaria to try to build a private paramilitary airforce: Echo Papa Exposed: Inside Erik Princes Treacherous Drive to Build a Private Air Force (The Intercept, link): "One of the mechanics soon recognized Echo Papa from news photos he was Erik Prince, founder of the private security firm Blackwater. Several of the Airborne staff whispered among themselves, astonished that they had been working for Americas best-known mercenary. The secrecy and strange modification requests of the past four months began to make sense. In addition to surveillance and laser-targeting equipment, Airborne had outfitted the plane with bulletproof cockpit windows, an armored engine block, anti-explosive mesh for the fuel tank, and specialized wiring that could control rockets and bombs. The company also installed pods for mounting two high-powered 23 mm machine guns. By this point, the engineers and mechanics were concerned that they had broken several Austrian laws but were advised that everything would be fine as long as they all kept the secret."
Joint declaration of the prime ministers of Greece and Portugal - 11 April 2016 (pdf): Statement on three themes: 1. A European response to the refugee and migration crisis; 2. European Economic and Monetary Union; 3. Peace and stability in our broader region. On refugee and migration policy it says:
"We believe that the building of walls and fences, the unilateral and uncoordinated implementation of measures or the unwillingness to participate in commonly agreed actions, such as resettlement and relocation schemes, undermine European solidarity as well as the humane and effective management of migrant flows.
Europe must remain open to hosting people in need of international protection, by replacing dangerous, irregular migration routes with legal processes of resettlement of refugees from countries neighboring Syria and by accelerating the relocation processes of refugees already in Greece and Italy. At the same time, the EU must enhance efforts to establish readmission agreements with the countries of origin of economic immigrants."
And see: Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (11.4.16)
Roma on the margins: Housing rights denied (Amnesty, link): "In early 2012, the adoption by the Italian government of the National Strategy for Roma Inclusion (the National Strategy), had the potential to mark a turning point for many Romani families who, for years, had experienced forced evictions, segregation and discrimination in access to housing in Italy.
Promising to overcome large-sized mono-ethnic settlements and increase access to a wide range of housing solutions, the National Strategy brought hope to families and organizations which for years had been denouncing the widespread and systematic human rights violations experienced by Romani women, children and men.
However, as we celebrate International Roma Day on 8 April, it is painfully clear that, four years on, the promises engraved in the ink of the 2012 document have just simply become mirrors and smoke. Life for thousands of Roma in Italy remains as difficult as ever, as they continue to be faced with official neglect and prejudice."
UK: Drones to check planning applications (The Telegraph, link): "Drones are being used by councils in England to fly over the homes of people making planning applications, the Daily Telegraph has learned.
A Freedom of Information survey of hundreds of councils found that a dozen had admitted to using or hiring drones. Two councils Epping Forest and Moray said the drones could be used to check on planning applications.
Other councils had used them to check on conditions of council buildings, to survey dangerous structures and monitor on coastal erosion.
The revelation last night raised questions over privacy. The Liberal Democrats called for a code of practice to govern how councils use drones while the information watchdog said it was concerned by the news and said councils should consider whether drones were necessary and proportionate."
And see: Back from the battlefield: domestic drones in the UK
News Digest: Round-up of news stories from across the EU (11.4.16)
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (11.4.16)
MSF treats hundreds after Greek-FYROM border violence (MSF, link): "On 10 April, after the violent events at the border between Greece and FYROM, Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF) medical teams treated hundreds including around 40 people injured by rubber bullets. At least ten people have reported to MSF teams that they were beaten by FYROM police.
Two extra mobile medical teams were added to the normal activities in Idomeni camp to assist the growing number of people in the camp.
"Today, frustration and a growing feeling of anger are spread among the refugees who have been stranded in Idomeni for over one month. What we see is the inevitable result of thousands being trapped in Greece, a country unable to respond to the humanitarian and protection needs of those in search of safety in Europe, stated Jose Hulsenbek, MSFs Head of Mission in Greece. "What people need is to be treated with dignity, not violence or unpredictable border closures and more uncertainty. This absurd humanitarian crisis created by European states policies is becoming more unbearable by the day. "
And see: Macedonian police teargas, pepper spray refugees at Greek border: Who supplied the "crowd control" equipment? (Statewatch News Online)
EU-AUSTRIA: How will the Austrian presidential elections influence EU's (migration) policy and TTIP? (VoteWatch Europe, pdf): "Austrians will vote for a new President on 24 April. The race is very tight, as the migration crisis is substantially impacting the national political landscape. A victory of a candidate from outside the current grand coalition would seriously undermine the government's policies. The nationalist anti-immigration and anti-EU FPÖ is on the rise and pushes hard to be part of the government."
UK: Press release and new report: Reprieve: Britains Kill List: Government must come clean
The government has been operating a covert 'Kill List' since at least 2001 in countries including Pakistan, Afghanistan and Yemen, research reveals today, despite denials of such a policy.
A new report from human rights organization Reprieve suggests that the government established a Kill List in October 2001 of individuals who were subsequently targeted for assassination by UK and US forces. The list included not only alleged militants, but also people who the government suspected were involved in drug trafficking. According to an anonymous UK serviceman, the list soon extended to include others.
Report: Britain's Kill List: official dissembling in the development of a list of people we want to kill and the need for a full and transparent investigation (pdf)
EU: Long running debate on PNR enters final furlong (EU Today, link): "A long-awaited vote on the EU Passenger Name Records (PNR) legislation is likely to take place next week after months of delays.
The vote has been made possible after officials in the Council of Ministers were able to speed up work on the EUs data protection legislation.
The proposed EU PNR directive would oblige airlines to hand EU countries their passengers data in order to help the authorities to fight terrorism and serious crime."
See: Putting the PNR pieces in place: more EU funding for mass surveillance (Statewatch News Online, March 2016): "The EU Passenger Name Record (PNR) Directive is still yet to be formally approved by the European Parliament, but that has not prevented the European Commission and Member States from setting up the infrastructure required for the mass surveillance of air travel. The latest contribution to this effort is a project led by the Hungarian interior ministry that will investigate ways to make sure that different national systems "are able to communicate with each other," thus facilitating the cross-border exchange of the personal data given by travellers to airlines."
EU-US Privacy Shield in big trouble, may not pass muster, suggests German leak (Ars Technica, link): "Leaked extracts from an imminent assessment of the EU-US Privacy Shield replacement for Safe Harbour suggests that a key group of EU data protection authorities will not support it in its present form.
It is expected that the Article 29 Working Party will say that it is "not yet in a position to confirm that the current draft adequacy decision does, indeed, ensure a level of protection [in the US] that is essentially equivalent to that in the EU." Any transatlantic data transfer scheme that does not provide an "essentially equivalent" level of protection is unlikely to withstand a legal challenge in the EU courts."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (9-10.4.16)
Refugee crisis: Macedonian police teargas, pepper spray refugees at Greek border: Who supplied the "crowd control" equipment?
The EU and Turkey have struck a deal to trade refugees back and forth (video, link). Speaking the blunt truth.
The west's shadow war by Paul Rogers (Open Democracy, link): "The expanding use of special forces to combat ISIS risks repeating the abuse and failure of the campaign against al-Qaida... A new briefing from Oxford Research Group UK Special Forces: Accountability in Shadow War (30 March 2016) provides a summary of the overall picture.".
EU-TURKEY READMISSION AGREEMENT: EU Council of the European Union: Council Decision of 23 March 2016 establishing the position to be taken on behalf of the European Union within the Joint Readmission Committee on a Decision of the Joint Readmission Committee on implementing arrangements for the application of Articles 4 and 6 of the Agreement between the European Union and the Republic of Turkey on the readmission of persons residing without authorisation from 1 June 2016 (pdf)
This Decision brings forward the starting date on the main Agreement adopted in 2014: AGREEMENT between the European Union and the Republic of Turkey on the readmission of persons residing without authorisation (pdf)
First journalist punished over photos under Spains gag law (The Local.es, link): "A Basque photographer has become the first journalist to be punished under Spains controversial gag law for posting images of a police raid on Twitter.."
EU considers restricting visa-free travel for Americans, Canadians - Commission will debate whether to retaliate for restrictions on European citizens.(politico, link): "The European Union may soon require visas from Americans and Canadians traveling to Europe a move that would come in retaliation for restrictions imposed by the U.S. and Canada on some EU countries, according to officials.
The European Commission is planning to discuss the issue next week, ahead of an April 12 deadline the EU had imposed for the U.S. and Canada to lift restrictions on travelers from five EU countries. The EU has tried for two years to get the U.S. and Canada to ensure visa-free travel for all the blocs citizens, but has set no firm timeline on when a new reciprocal ban would take effect."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (8.4.16)
EU-USA: Council of the European Union: Outcome of proceedings of the EU - US Justice and Home Affairs Senior Officials Meeting, 24-25 February 2016, Amsterdam (LIMITE doc no: 7188-16, pdf):
"The US warned of considerable security risks that should not be underestimated. It offered to take a more pro-active look at US-EU cooperation and mentioned the experience of vetting 25.000 resettled refugees to Canada against US databases. This also had a political aspect as it reassured the population that migrants were no risk."
and EU-USA Agreement data protection: "Hopefully, the Umbrella Agreement could be signed in June at the EU-US ministerial meeting and adopted in autumn. However, if an opinion by the ECJ was deemed necessary by the European Parliament, there would be a delay." [emphasis added]
Meijers Committe: Note on Mutual trust and Opinion 2/13 on accession of the European Union to the European Convention on Human Rights (pdf)
"In Opinion 2/13, one reason why the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) found the European Union (EU)-European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) draft accession agreement to be incompatible with the EU Treaties was that it did not avert the risk that accession would undermine the principle of mutual trust in EU law. This principle of mutual trust holds that Member States may be required to presume that fundamental rights have been observed by the other Member States."
Dutch vote highlights EU's problem with voters, UK beware (Reuters, link): "The European Union's long-running problem with voters just got a little worse after the Dutch rejected an agreement on closer EU ties with Ukraine, highlighting the difficulties of further European integration.
Coming less than three months before a British referendum on whether to stay in the EU or leave after 43 years of semi-detached membership, the Dutch vote rang alarm bells in London and Brussels.
Less than a third of the electorate turned out for the consultative Dutch referendum, forced by a grassroots petition launched by eurosceptics. But it was enough to make the ballot valid and oblige Prime Minister Mark Rutte's government to take account of the result.
Jubilant eurosceptic Dutch populist leader Geert Wilders called it "the beginning of the end of the EU". His British counterpart, UK Independence Party leader Nigel Farage, said: "Their 'No' to the EU was a tremendous victory for democracy.""
Statewatch Analysis: Commission proposals on migration and internal security databases: a new list of old "needs" (pdf) by Chris Jones
The Commissions proposal to extend the fingerprinting of short-stay visa applicants to children from the ages of 6 and up is part of a list of possible enhanced functionalities (i.e. expanded uses) of the Visa Information System (VIS). These functionalities will be examined as part of a larger process of trying to beef up EU and national databases and information systems.
In a Communication entitled Stronger and Smarter Information Systems for Borders and Security the Commission sets out its plans for more gathering, exchange and processing of personal data, particularly the data of non-EU nationals. The Commissions long-term plans are extremely similar to those proposed recently by the German Federal Ministry of the Interior (see further below).
The Communication opens by noting the scale of movement into and out of the Schengen area: its external borders were crossed more than 200 million times in 2015, by more than 50 million non-EU nationals. It moves on to conflate refugees with terrorism and to insist upon the need to join up and strengthen the EUs border management, migration and security cooperation frameworks and information tools in a comprehensive manner.
And see: EU calls for the fingerprinting of 6-year-old children
Association Malienne des Expulsés: Statement on expulsions to Mali and EU migration policy (pdf): "Since the end of last year (2015), in Mali we are witnessing waves of expulsions, refoulements and repatriations of our migrants from Asia, Europe and even from the African continent. This recurring problem of refoulements, expulsions and repatriations of Malian migrants worsens on a daily basis and is becoming increasingly worrying. Thus, Malians are mainly expelled, refouled or repatriated from Saudi Arabia, Equatorial Guinea, Gabon, Angola, Libya, Spain and now also from Mauritania.
The fight against so-called illegal immigration represents a priority in the policy implemented by the European Union which presents this form of migration as a dangerous scourge which must be combated. This attitude by the European Union is constituted by focussing on the consequences without worrying about the root causes of the migration phenomenon. Thus, the reasons that push our fellow nationals to leave are well known, as they concern a lack of employment for young people, their difficult economic and professional conditions and, most of all, a lack of any prospects which affects their daily life.
The distinction or categorisation of migrants (between economic migrants and asylum seekers) by the EU is an incorrect reading of the situation which does not contribute to reducing the phenomenon of flows towards Europe."
And see: Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (8.8.16)
GREECE: Amnesty International: "Thousands of people" have been "arbitrarily detained" in detention centres (formerly "hotspots") on Lesvos and Chios
A new report from Amnesty International discusses the situation in Greece, following visits by the organisation to two detention centres (which used to be "hotspots"). It says that thousands of people have been arbitrarily detained pending removal (unless they manage apply for asylum) in the effort to implement the EU-Turkey deal.
Statistics: implementing the EU-Turkey deal: "boots on the ground"
Thousands of state officials from across Europe are supposed to be sent to Greece to help implement the EU-Turkey deal on refugees and migrants. This page gathers the statistics made available by the Commission on the process.
The numbers "pledged" are those offered by Member States, the requesting institution is the European Asylum Support Office or Frontex, as indicated.
6 April 2016: Member States remain either far less keen or far less able to provide interpreters, while the number of asylum officials requested for the operation has increased from 400 to 472. Amnesty International reported that during their visits on the 5 and 6 April, the VIAL detention centre in Moria had one asylum case worker.
EU-USA: Mutual Legal Assistance (MLA) Agreement: draft texts on review of the 2010 MLA Agreement
"The documentation comprises three sections:
I) An introduction to the EU-US MLA Agreement (ANNEX I);
II) An assessment of the key provisions of the Agreement (ANNEX II);
III) Recommendations for improving the practical functioning of the Agreement (ANNEX III).
The Presidency intends discussing this documentation at the COPEN [Working Party on Cooperation in Criminal Matters] meeting on 13 April 2016. After passage through the appropriate bodies it is the intention of the Presidency that these documents will be agreed at the high level EU-US meeting in June."
See: Council of the European Union: Review of the 2010 EU-US MLA Agreement - Examination of draft texts (7403/16, pdf)
Also on EU-US cooperation: Council of the EU: Outcome of proceedings of the EU - US Justice and Home Affairs Senior Officials Meeting, 24-25 February 2016, Amsterdam (7188/16, pdf): Notes of discussions on migration and mobility, visas, security (counter-terrorism and -extremism, border control, TFTP), cybercrime, drugs, wildlife trafficking, data protection, criminal law cooperation, cooperation in international organisations, preparation for the next meeting (Amsterdam, 1-2 June 2016), Slovakian Council Presidency priorities.
UK: Britain Is Making Millions Training Police In 21 Countries That Use The Death Penalty (BuzzFeed, link): "Britains College of Policing, the professional body for police training, has made millions of pounds in the last three years by training forces in countries that use the death penalty.
Among the countries where the college offers training in leadership, forensics and intelligence are Bahrain, China, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, and Uganda. In all, 21 of the countries where the college operates training programmes have the death penalty. Yesterday Amnesty International revealed that executions worldwide are at a 25-year-high, with at least 158 people killed in 2015 in Saudi Arabia alone.
At least 25 of the countries in which the college operates have forces that have been accused by campaigners of human rights abuses and torture."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (7.4.16)
ITALY: The truth about the hotspot system violations and illegality in Lampedusa (pdf):
"Over the last few weeks, dozens of people from Mali, Gambia, Pakistan, Somalia, Eritrea and Nigeria arrived in Palermo, as well as in Catania and other Sicilian cities, in possession of a deferred refusal of entry order which requires that they leave Italian territory from the border crossing in Romes Fiumicino [airport] within 7 days. They all come from Lampedusa, where they arrived after being intercepted at sea and taken onto the island.
These migrants have not been allowed to apply for international protection, although they had managed to contact UNHCR. They tell us that they were informed of the possibility of applying for asylum, without having any way to do so in practice.
Instead, they tell us they were forced to sign a form whose content they did not understand because they did not speak the language it was written in (while at the bottom of the order, absurdly, the phrase the interested party refuses to sign is always present as these forms are prepared and pre-printed in bulk)...."
First signatories: Borderline Sicilia Onlus, Borderline-Europe, Centro salesiano Santa Chiara di Palermo, Circolo Arci Porco Rosso di Palermo, Ciss Cooperazione Internazionale Sud Sud, Comitato Antirazzista Cobas (Palermo), Comitato NoMuos/NoSigonella, Forum Antirazzista di Palermo, La città Felice(Ct) Le città vicine, LAltro Diritto Sicilia, Laici Missionari Comboniani, Palermo Senza Frontiere, Rete Antirazzista Catanese
To sign up: firstname.lastname@example.org
EU: Council of the European Union: ECRIS, EU "returns"document and Visa Code
- European Criminal Records Information System: Amendments in the ECRIS proposal on the basis of the consolidated text following the COPEN (ECRIS) meetings of 1 and 22 February and 1 - 2 March, 2016 (LIMITE doc no 7298-16, pdf):
CONSOLIDATED TEXT OF FRAMEWORK DECISION 2009/315/JHA AS IT WOULD BE AMENDED BY THE DRAFT ECRIS DIRECTIVE"
- Draft Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on a European travel document for the return of illegally staying third-country nationals (LIMITE doc no: 7172-16, pdf):
The EU hopes third countries will accept this, many have not in the past: It is defined as:
"The document shall be valid for a single journey to the third country of return."
- Draft Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on the Union Code on Visas (Visa Code) (recast) (LIMITE doc no: 6906-16, 18.3.16, pdf): "The text of the draft Regulation as amended and agreed by the Working Party appears in bold (new text or ( ) when text has been deleted). The changes suggested by the Presidency, which have not yet been approved, are underlined." and LIMITE doc no: 7336-16 (29.3.16, 87 pages, pdf): "In addition, the recent suggestions introduced following the meeting of the JHA Counsellors on 21 March 2016 are highlighted."
EU calls for the fingerprinting of 6-year-old children
On Wednesday the European Commission set out its plans to expand EU and national databases "to allow effective management of migration and to contribute to internal security." One of the myriad ways this could be done is by "collecting fingerprints of children between the age of 6 and 12 years old" who enter the EU on short-stay visas.
See: page 9 of European Commission, Stronger and Smarter Information Systems for Borders and Security, COM(2016) 205 final, 6 April 2016
EU plans drone fleet to track migrants - Countries are divided over who would control the remotely piloted aircraft.(politico, link):
"Drones controlled by the EU will soon be flying across the continent under a European Commission plan to keep track of migrants arriving on Mediterranean shores.
The Commission says it needs its own fleet of remotely piloted aircraft systems to spot small refugee boats, as well as to enforce emissions standards and monitor ship safety elsewhere in Europe".
UK: Interpreting services within immigration removal centres (IRR News, link): "The lack of trained interpreters inside of immigration detention exacerbates fear, mistrust and depression and has contributed to a number of deaths."
Fair Trials welcomes CJEU judgement on European Arrest Warrant and detention conditions (link):
"On 5 April, in its decision in the Aranyosi and Caldararu cases (C-404/15 and C-659/15 PPU), the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has confirmed that Member States are obliged to respect the fundamental rights of requested people when considering European Arrest Warrants ."
EU: Council of the European Union: Standard Operating Procedures implementing the mechanism for resettlement from Turkey to the EU as set out in the EU-Turkey Statement of 18 March 2016 (LIMITE doc no: 7462-16, pdf). All sorts of additions and deletions.
EU: Europol and FBI (link):
"The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and Europol, the European law enforcement agency, have signed in Washington a mutual agreement that will considerably intensify the common fight against foreign terrorist fighters. The agreement, signed by FBI Deputy Director Andrew McCabe and Europols Deputy Director of Operations Wil van Gemert, enables the FBI to join Europols Focal Point Travellers".
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (6.4.16)
Wisdom and goodness to the vile seem vile: Towards a third phase of the Common European Asylum System? (link) by Steve Peers, Professor of Law. University of Essex:
" Overall, this is a very disappointing paper from the Commission. There are certainly abuses of the asylum system, but EU legislation already has many possibilities to address them, as regards fast-tracking decisions and appeals, reduced benefits and detention. Theres little evidence here of a balanced, rational and coherent response to the crisis. In fact, this looks rather more like panic.
Of course EU asylum law does not develop in a political vacuum. Member States had a key role agreeing these laws, and the main role implementing them and driving the reaction to the crisis. No criticism of the EU response to the crisis should ignore what is ultimately driving that response: the neo-nationalist political parties which are in government in several Member States and form the main opposition in several more. But is endless concessions to these parties really the right strategy? They will always be able to outflank the political mainstream when it comes to anger, fear and ignorance. Its always better to stand and fight for what you really believe in than to pretend to agree with your opponents fundamentally different views."
European Commission: Press releases: 6 April 2016:
- Stronger and Smarter Borders in the EU: Commission proposes to establish an Entry-Exit System (pdf)
- Smart Borders Package: Questions & Answers (pdf)
- Commission presents options for reforming the Common European Asylum System and developing safe and legal pathways to Europe (pdf)
- Commission launches discussion on future framework for stronger and smarter information systems for border management and internal security (pdf)
European Commission proposals for changing asylum system: Towards a reform of the Common European Asylum System and enhancing legal avenues to Europe (Full-text, pdf)
- Security: EU strengthens response to hybrid threats (pdf): "The European Commission and the High Representative adopted today a Joint Framework to counter hybrid threats and foster the resilience of the EU, its Member States and partner countries while increasing cooperation with NATO on countering these threats. In recent years, the EU and its Member States have been increasingly exposed to hybrid threats that comprise hostile actions designed to destabilise a region or a state." and see: Joint Framework on countering hybrid threats a European Union response (Commission and EEAS, pdf)::
"While definitions of hybrid threats vary and need to remain flexible to respond to their evolving nature, the concept aims to capture the mixture of coercive and subversive activity, conventional and unconventional methods (i.e. diplomatic, military, economic, technological), which can be used in a coordinated manner by state or non-state actors to achieve specific objectives while remaining below the threshold of formally declared warfare.... Massive disinformation campaigns, using social media to control the political narrative or to radicalise, recruit and direct proxy actors can be vehicles for hybrid threats."
EU: Council of the European Union: Blue Amber Ops, LEA Information Exchange Manual and Legal Aid
- Comments on the Blue Amber joint action days (LIMITE doc no: 15566-16, pdf):
"JADs are included in virtually every operational action plan in 2016. They still remain a controversial concept, mainly because of the lack of a clear definition and a corresponding approach (differentiating them from high-impact operations (HIOs), joint police operations (JPOs), operations launched as part of a joint investigation team (JIT), etc.). Furthermore, it is noted that many operations are falsely called JADs (e.g. operation LUXCAR, which was more akin to a joint police operation, i.e. a type of police operation that has been organised by each EU presidency for a number of years). This lack of a definition causes confusion and limits the value of the operations. We therefore suggest that a clear definition of joint action days be established."
- Manual on Law Enforcement Information Exchange (LIMITE doc no: 6704-16, pdf): 391 pages.
- Legal Aid: Proposal for a Directive on provisional legal aid for suspects or accused persons deprived of liberty and legal aid in European arrest warrant proceedings = Follow-up of the fifth and sixth trilogues (18 February and 3 March 2016) (LIMITE doc no: 6904-16, pdf) and see:
- As above: Discussion on selected issues (LIMITE doc no: 7378-16, pdf):
"As Member States will remember, the European Parliament would like to enlarge the scope of the Directive by providing that legal aid should be granted in certain specific cases where investigative or other evidence-gathering measures are carried out under Directive 2014/14/EU on the European Investigation Order (see doc. 6904/16).
At the meeting on 16 March, a lot of Member States voiced concerns concerning these proposals of the European Parliament. The Presidency communicated these concerns to the rapporteur of the European Parliament. He indicated that the European Parliament wants to await the position of the Commission before possibly revising its own position in this matter."
European Commission proposals for changing asylum system: Towards a reform of the Common European Asylum System and enhancing legal avenues to Europe (pdf) To be announced today
Helping Refugees Together by Peter Sutherland (project-syndicate.org, link):
"This year is likely to be the most momentous for refugee protection and migration since the signing of the Geneva Convention in 1951. Depending on the choices we make, we will either help create more open societies, based on greater international cooperation, or we will abet authoritarian governments and their nationalist agendas. So we must treat this issue with exceptional urgency and seriousness of purpose. "
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (5.4.16)
Greece postpones return of next group of migrants until Friday, Turkish official says (ekathimerini.com, link): "Greece has postponed the return of the next group of migrants to Turkey under a deal with the European Union until Friday, a Turkish government official said on Tuesday, with no other deportees expected before then."
Greeces New Asylum Legislation: What Will Change? (News That Moves, link):
"Appeals against a negative decision will be examined and processed with a final decision within 7 days by newly established Appeal Committees (see art. 60, page 44)
The appeals process is made on the basis of file examination without the presence of the applicant, and Appeals Committee decides whether the applicant will be interviewed or not. The seeker can still request to be interviewed two days before the appeal process starts (see art. 62, page 45)".
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (2-4.4.16)
First "easy cases" arrive in Turkey after deportation from Greek islands begins
On the day the EU-Turkey deal comes into force, over 130 people have been deported from Greece. They arrived in the port of Dikili this morning after being deported from the islands of Lesvos and Chios on boats staffed by Frontex officers, Turkish officials and Greek riot police. Those on board were "mostly Pakistanis, Bangladeshis and Moroccans who were already being deported to Turkey before the deal's creation," according to a report in The Guardian, but there were also apparently two Syrians on board, "including a woman who had volunteered to return." The BBC reports that Sri Lankan nationals were also deported.
Roundup of news stories from across the EU (4.4.16)
UK: British mobile phone users movements 'could be sold for profit (The Guardian, link): "British mobile phone users are one data breach away from having the routines of their daily lives revealed to criminals, privacy campaigners have said.
Mobile phone networks and wireless hotspot operators are collecting detailed information on customers movements that reveal intimate details of their lives, two separate investigations into mobile data retention have found.
Many people unwittingly sign up to be location-tracked 24/7, unaware that the highly sensitive data this generates is being used and sold on for profit. Campaigners say that if this information were stolen by hackers, criminals could use it to target children as they leave school or homes after occupants have gone out."
See: Cashing in on your mobile (Open Rights Group, link) and: Opt Me Out Of Location (link): "www.optmeoutoflocation.com has been set up to encourage the British public to call for their mobile and Wi-Fi service providers to make it explicit what they are asking their customers to opt into, thereby providing a clear choice to opt out."
Facebook: Electra (link): "Greece has not ratified the ECHR Protocol forbidding collective explulsions. Most countries participating in Frontex, though, HAVE. Our governments must be held accountable for this crime."
Comment: Steve Peers: "Every other EU country except the UK has ratified the Fourth Protocol. And surely Greece is covered by the ban on collective expulsion where there is a link to EU law (as there is in asylum cases), due to the EU Charter."
BORDER GUARD: European Parliament Study: The proposal for a European Border and Coast Guard: evolution or revolution in external border management? (pdf):
"The proposal significantly reinforces Frontexs regulatory and operational tasks and provides the Agency with an additional supervisory role. The proposal does not amend the fundamental premise of operational cooperation at the external borders, reserving executive enforcement powers to the Member States. Nonetheless, the concept of shared responsibility in the absence of shared accountability increases existing fundamental rights concerns."
And see: Regulation on a European Border and Coast Guard Agency (Statewatch European Documentation Centre (SEMDOC) Full documentation of Commission, Council and EP documents.
Greece begins refugee deportations under EU plan (ekathimerini.com, link): "Under heavy security, authorities on the Greek islands of Lesvos and Chios deported 202 migrants and refugees on boats bound for Turkey the first to be sent back as part of a controversial European Union plan to limit the amount of migration to Europe.
The operation that started at dawn, as migrants were escorted onto small ferries by officers from the EU border protection agency, Frontex, to nearby ports on the Turkish coast, under the program which has been strongly criticized by human rights groups.
"All of the migrants returned are from Pakistan except for two migrants from Syria who returned voluntarily," Giorgos Kyritsis, a spokesman for a government refugee crisis committee, told state TV....
""This is the first day of a very difficult time for refugee rights. Despite the serious legal gaps and lack of adequate protection in Turkey, the EU is forging ahead with a dangerous deal," Giorgos Kosmopoulos, head of Amnesty International in Greece, told the Associated Press from Lesvos.
"Turkey is not a safe third country for refugees. The EU and Greek authorities know this and have no excuse.""
EU should stop forced evictions of Roma in Italy (euobserver, link):
"Italian authorities have marooned men, women and children in a Roma-only camp next to Ciampino airport runway in Rome, and havent provided suitable alternative accommodation for these people even after the Rome Civil Court ruled the relocation discriminatory.
Forced evictions of hundreds of residents from the camps of Lungo Stura Lazio in Turin and Via Idro in Milan in the last year again without providing adequate alternative housing further underlines the prejudicial horror show that accommodation for Roma in Italy has become."
POLAND: RENDITION: Polish CIA prisons probe to be prolonged again? (Radio Poland, link): "A Polish prosecutor's office has lodged a request with the Attorney General to extend a long-running investigation into whether a CIA prison was hosted on Polish soil from 2002 to 2003.
The deadline for the completion of the probe already extended several times is 11 April.
The investigation was launched in 2008 and Poland has been repeatedly criticised for dragging its heels on the matter.
A "black site" for suspected terrorists was allegedly created at a military facility in Stare Kiejkuty, northern Poland, following the launch of the so-called "War on Terror".
Besides the matter of whether Poland hosted such a site, the Regional Prosecutor's Office in Kraków is also investigating whether Polish authorities consented to torture being applied."
See also: CIA photographed detainees naked before sending them to be tortured (The Guardian, link): "The CIA took naked photographs of people it sent to its foreign partners for torture, the Guardian can reveal.
A former US official who had seen some of the photographs described them as very gruesome.
The naked imagery of CIA captives raises new questions about the seeming willingness of the US to use what one medical and human rights expert called sexual humiliation in its post-9/11 captivity of terrorism suspects. Some human rights campaigners described the act of naked photography on unwilling detainees as a potential war crime." And: Inside CIA's secret prisons: Haunting images show 'blacksites', where prisoners have been held and tortured around the globe on American orders (Daily Mail, link)
UK: The human cost of Theresa May's student deportation programme (politics.co.uk, link): " It's been just over a week since the damning legal ruling on the Home Office's student deportation programme and the full details of the department's behaviour are starting to become clear.
The picture painted by those affected is one of a department out of control. It tried to remove parents from their children. It deported families. It sent multiple vans full of immigration officers to people's homes in dawn raids, before separating the husbands from the wives and sending them to detention centres. It sent immigration squads to higher education colleges to threaten students and pore over the most minute details, including individual attendance rates. It tarnished the reputation of a civil servant in her workplace. And it did all this with no evidence at all, except the hearsay testimony of one of its own officials.
(...) the case raises serious questions about the behaviour of Theresa May and the department she runs. This is a scandal on an extraordinary scale, with the Home Office using hearsay evidence to destroy the lives and reputations of tens of thousands of innocent people. Even with the legal ruling last week, many of them are still trying to put back the pieces."
And see: UK: Disaster for Theresa May as legal ruling brings student deportations to a halt (politics.co.uk, link) and: AWS Solicitors: press release: The judgment of Honourable Mr Justice McCloskey, President, in lead appeal on TOEIC/ETS scam (pdf): "There must be a Public/Parliamentary inquiry into the way the Home Secretary has dealt with this issue. Lessons must be learned from this disgraceful episode."
Turkey steps up preparations for receiving migrants returned from Greece
A camp for 5,000 people is reportedly being built in western Turkey as the country apparently prepares to receive 72,000 migrants to be returned from Greece on Monday 4 April as part of the EU-Turkey deal.
UK: Support the Stop35k campaign and stand up to a grossly unfair, illogical policy (Right to Remain, link): "From April 6th, any Tier 2 skilled worker who applies for ILR (indefinite leave to remain) must earn over £35,000. If they dont, they will be forced to leave the UK either voluntarily, or by being deported. A Tier 2 skilled worker is a non-EU person who must be qualified to university degree level. As things stand now, a Tier 2 skilled worker already has to satisfy a lot of conditions before entering the country. Their job had to be advertised to UK residents for a month, in order to establish that no UK worker is suitable, before the Tier 2 skilled worker can be considered for the role. This is called the Resident Labour Market Test, or RLMT. The job must pay over £20,800. If they lose their job they have 30 days to find another one or they must leave. They are forbidden from claiming housing benefits, JSA, family benefits, and many others. They must pay an NHS surcharge as well as the thousands of pounds for immigration fees. The company they work for must already pay thousands of pounds in order to hire the Tier 2 skilled worker, and this amount is set to increase. Only around 20,000 people per year are allowed to enter the UK using the Tier 2 General route, while Tier 2 ICT (intra-company transfers) and other routes are uncapped."
UK: Government to create even more armed policing units
Following the terrorist attacks in Brussels last month, the UK government has announced that it will create a number of new armed policing units in cities across the UK. This follows on from January announcements to recruit 600 new armed police to be deployed in London. The plans foresee a total of 1,000 new armed police being in place by spring 2018.
EU border guard: Council documents including "guidance for further work", new European Parliament study
Negotiations within the Council on the proposed European Border and Coast Guard, which would replace the Frontex agency, are progressing fast. Under current plans a draft text of the entire Regulation will be submitted to the Council's Permanent Representatives Committee on 6 April, "with a view to obtaining a mandate flexibe enough to open interinstitutional negotiations with the European Parliament." Other documents provided here show how the Council's position has taken shape.
Meanwhile a new European Parliament study "highlights some of the central challenges in the new EBCG [European Border and Coast Guard] framework and provides some recommendations on how these might be addressed."
Short Cuts (London Review of Books, link) by Frances Webber: "In October 2015, the government amended the ministerial code, removing all references to the obligation on ministers to comply with international law when carrying out their duties. This quiet change, which the government insists will make no difference in practice, echoes the Ministry of Justices 2014 proposal to make the European Convention on Human Rights advisory only. It seems that the government believes that compliance with international human rights agreements signed by the UK is optional. So we should not be surprised at the announcement on 7 March that UK troops are to join the Nato forces in the Aegean that are turning back refugees trying to reach Europe from Turkey, even though such actions were denounced by the European Commission and the European Court of Human Rights as amounting to collective expulsions and thus violations of EU and international human rights law. A week earlier, the Home Office had confirmed that the number of refugees accepted outside official resettlement programmes would be restricted and that overstaying students and foreign national offenders might not be allowed to make asylum claims measures which would breach the 1951 Refugee Convention. It seems that the government, having decided that repealing human rights laws is fraught with political and legal difficulties, is instead simply ignoring them when they interfere with policy objectives."
And: an article which covers some similar topics: A duty to inform? The outsourcing of state surveillance responsibilities to the British public by Max Rowlands, Statewatch Journal, vol 23 no 2, August 2013
European Parliament study on military research: EU should get ready for war
A report commissioned by the European Parliament calls for the EU to make significant investment in new weapons and military systems in order to reverse decreases in military investment at national level and ensure that the EU has "strategic autonomy" in order to act as a "security provider".
The report: European Parliament Directorate-General for External Policies, The future of EU defence research, March 2016 (pdf)
Returns under "one-for-one" plan to start on 4 April as evidence emerges of forced returns from Turkey to Syria
The European Commission foresees returns from Greece to Turkey under the controversial "one-for-one" plan starting on Monday 4 April, if changes to Greek and Turkish legislation can be rushed through by then. The credibility of claims that Turkey is a safe third country has been challenged yet again, this time with evidence gathered by Amnesty International that refugees have been forcibly returned from Turkey to Syria. Yesterday, press reports claimed that the Turkish military were shooting dead people attempting to enter Turkey from Syria.
Council of Europe anti-torture Committee publishes report on Belgium (Council of Europe, link): "The Council of Europe's European Committee for the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (CPT) published today the report on its September/October 2013 visit to Belgium, together with the response of the Belgian authorities.
One of the objectives of the visit was to examine the situation of inmates in various Belgian prisons, including in psychiatric annexes. In this context, the Antwerp, Forest, Merksplas and Tournai Prisons were visited.
Despite the "Masterplan" for renovating and constructing new prisons, overcrowding was still a major problem at the time of the visit. In the establishments visited, many prisoners held in multiple-occupancy cells had only 3 m² of living space per person, or even less, with some having to sleep on mattresses on the floor.
Other shortcomings in terms of material conditions were also observed. Prisoners at Forest and Tournai Prisons did not have toilets in their cells and had to use a bucket at night. Further, most of the prisoners spent 21 hours a day in their cell because there were too few activities on offer in the prisons visited. The CPT recommends that the Belgian authorities provide at least 4 m² of living space for each prisoner, improve detention conditions, particularly at Forest and Tournai Prisons, and increase the number of activities and work opportunities available to prisoners."
Full report (French only): Rapport au Gouvernement de la Belgique relatif à la visite effectuée en Belgique par le Comité européen pour la prévention de la torture et des peines ou traitements inhumains ou dégradants (CPT) du 24 septembre au 4 octobre 2013 (pdf) and: Government response (pdf, also in French).
Turkey shoots dead Syrian refugees crossing the border as they flee civil war (Mirror, link): "Border forces in Turkey are shooting refugees dead as they cross over into the country fleeing civil war in Syria, it has been reported.
Guards have killed sixteen refugees including three children as they crossed into Turkey, the Times reports.
Monitoring organisation the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights claims border forces have shot dead the sixteen refugees over the past four months.
An officer in the British-backed Free Syrian Police and a Syrian smuggler, living in Turkey, claimed that the true number was higher.
The newspaper reports on February 6 a man and his child were killed in Ras alAin on the eastern stretch of the Syrian-Turkish border.
Two refugees were shot dead at Guvveci on March 5 on the western border.
The Syrian smuggler told the newspaper that refugees still cross the border but will 'either be killed or captured'."
And see: Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (31.3.16)
News Digest: round-up of news stories from across Europe (31.3.16)
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (31.3.16)
Even humane Sweden is getting tough on refugees (IRIN, link): "Back in November, it was like the end of innocence. Deputy Prime Minister Åsa Romson famously broke down in tears as Sweden, the European country that has accepted the most asylum seekers per capita in recent years, announced it was ending its open-door policy.
After being overwhelmed by the daily arrival of up to 10,000 asylum seekers, this was the first indication that the political sands had shifted. Shortly afterwards, temporary border checks were introduced on the Øresund Bridge, linking Copenhagen and Swedens third city, Malmo. The border controls extended into Denmark and the police later significantly reinforced border guard deployments in the south of the country.
The measures have significantly dented the number of new arrivals but the government is still preparing to pass a series of major amendments to Swedens Aliens Act that will reduce prospective asylum seekers access to full refugee status, permanent residency and family reunification.
While all these measures are being called temporary, they are Europes new normal and Swedens reputation as one of the few welcoming nations to refugees has taken a hit."
And see: profile: Sweden Immigration Detention (Global Detention Project, link)
EU: Refugee crisis: Arrivals rocket in Italy amid warnings Turkey deal could force migrants on more dangerous routes (The Independent, link): "The number of refugees arriving in Italy is rising sharply amid fears that a controversial deal struck with Turkey could force asylum seekers to take longer and more dangerous routes to Europe.
The Italian interior ministry has documented 16,075 migrants crossing to its shores so far this year, compared to just over 10,000 during the same period in 2015.
Most were rescued from smugglers boats off the Libyan coast and brought ashore in Sicily by the coast guard."
EU: European Parliament civil liberties committee report on migration and the situation in the Mediterranean
The report makes recommendations under a vast number of headings headings, including: solidarity, search and rescue, tackling human trafficking and crimina smuggling, relocation and resettlement, humanitarian admission and humanitarian visas, the Common European Asylm System (CEAS), the revision of the Dublin III Regulation, the Temporary Protection Directive, family unity and children, returns, a common EU list of "safe countries of origin", the European Asylum Support Office (EASO), Frontex and its proposed replacement - the European Border and Coast Guard Agency, Schengen and external borders, hotspots, criminal law and migration, cooperation with third countries, funding to third countries, the involvement of civil society, demographic trends, legal labour migration and the Blue Card Directive.
See: REPORT on the situation in the Mediterranean and the need for a holistic EU approach to migration (23.3.16, pdf). A plenary vote on the report is due to take place on 13 April.
Under the heading of civil society, the report "affirms that volunteer and civil-society initiatives dedicated to providing assistance to migrants should be promoted and, where appropriate, funded by the Commission and the Member States." However it makes no mention of recent moves in Greece to place NGOs and volunteer organisations under more stringent supervision. See: Registering of NGOs, details of their workers/volunteers and independent volunteers begins (Statewatch News Online, 2.3.16)
EU: Europol-Brazil cooperation agreement on the way
The European Parliament's civil liberties committee has given the green light for the Council to approve a "strategic cooperation agreement" between Europol and Brazil, which would allow for the exchange of non-personal data between the EU's policing agency and the law enforcement authorities of the Latin American state. The Parliament only has a "consultation" role with regard to such agreeents - its opinion is non-binding.
See: LIBE committee: Report on the draft Council implementing decision approving the conclusion by the European Police Office (Europol) of the Agreement on Strategic Cooperation between the Federative Republic of Brazil and Europol (pdf), due to go to a vote before all MEPs on 12 April.
And: the draft COUNCIL IMPLEMENTING DECISION approving the conclusion by the European Police Office (Europol) of the Agreement on Strategic Cooperation between the Federative Republic of Brazil and Europol (13980/15, pdf)
Europol was previously seeking an operational cooperation agreemnet, which would permit the exchange of personal and classified data. See: The spider's web: Europol goes global in the hunt for intelligence and analysis (Statewatch News Online, March 2013)
EU: Black people in Europe report widespread racism in anti-immigration context (ENAR, link): "Racist political discourse is predominantly framed in the context of anti-immigration and targets migrants that are both Black and Muslims. As a result Black migrants, refugees, asylum seekers and Black Europeans are reportedly suffering an increase in violent hatred and discrimination across all areas of life.
Discrimination in employment is prevalent and barriers are erected at every stage to prevent black people from gaining employment that matches their skills and experience. In the United Kingdom, applicants with an African sounding surname need to send twice as many job applications as those with a White British sounding name to get an interview. Statistics across EU Member States show that people with an African origin have systematically higher unemployment rates than the national average, which is due in part to racial discrimination. In Finland, unemployment rates are more than three times higher for people of African origin (41.2%) compared to the national average (8.7%).
Black people are particularly exposed to police violence as well as racist violence and abuse from other members of the public. In Sweden, 17% of hate crimes targeted Black people in 2014 (1,075 in total). There is a lack of trust between Black communities and the police which arises from various methods used by the police such as racial profiling and lack of full investigation of racially motivated crimes. Some law enforcement personnel display clearly racist behaviours and the police forces in some Member States are described as institutionally racist."
See: Key findings (pdf) and the full report: Afrophobia in Europe: ENAR Shadow Report 2014-2015 (pdf)
UK: Prison overcrowding: HMP Oakwood to convert single cells into doubles to make room for 500 extra inmates (The Independent, link): "Inmates at the UKs largest privately-run jail are to start sharing cells from this summer after the Government ordered it to make room for another 500 prisoners, in a move described by campaigners as a recipe for overcrowding and violence.
HMP Oakwood near Wolverhampton, which is operated by the private company G4S, is to see its official operating capacity rise by almost a third from July. The increase will bring the number of prisoners held at the jail from 1,600 to 2,106."
And see: Prison capital: UK locks up more people than any other EU member state
News Digest: Round-up of news stories from across Europe (30.3.16)
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (30.3.16)
European policy is driving refugees to more dangerous routes across the Med (The Conversation, link): "It is estimated that in 2015, more than a million people crossed the Mediterranean to Europe in search of safety and a better life. 3,770 are known to have died trying to make this journey during the same period. This so-called migration crisis is the largest humanitarian disaster to face Europe since the end of World War II.
Thats why weve been working to examine the conditions underpinning this recent migration across, and loss of life in, the Mediterranean.
Our first research brief, based on interviews with 600 people, including 500 refugees, shines a light on the reasons why so many risk everything on the dangerous sea crossing. It also offers an insight into why the EU response has been so ineffective."
This article is based on research undertaken as part of project Unravelling the Mediterranean Migration Crisis (MEDMIG) (link). More extensive findings are documented in the project's first report: Research Brief No. 1 March 2016 (pdf)
EU: Leaked: "non-papers" on migration, mobility and readmission with Ethiopia, Somalia and Sudan
These documents give an indication of the EU's plans as regards migration from three key East African countries, all suffering conflict and poverty. Another document exists concerning Eritrea, where the UN has documented very serious human rights abuses. However, it is not yet available publically.
The reports: Commission-EEAS non-papers on enhancing migration, mobility and readmission with Ethiopia, Somalia and Sudan (pdfs)
EU: Putting the PNR pieces in place: more EU funding for mass surveillance
The EU Passenger Name Record (PNR) Directive is still yet to be formally approved by the European Parliament, but that has not prevented the European Commission and Member States from setting up the infrastructure required for the mass surveillance of air travel. The latest contribution to this effort is a project led by the Hungarian interior ministry that will investigate ways to make sure that different national systems "are able to communicate with each other," thus facilitating the cross-border exchange of the personal data given by travellers to airlines.
EU: Frontex: report on the functioning of the European Border Surveillance System (Eurosur)
A December 2015 report by Frontex on the functioning of the European Border Surveillance System (Eurosur) provides an overview of how the system functioned from 2011, when the system launched, until November 2015. Thousands of "events" have been recorded in the system over this period and the report highlights four "operational success stories", incuding two incidents in which the system contributed to saving lives at sea.
Greece: Number of migrants reaching Greece surges again (ekathimerini.com, link): "Hundreds of migrants and refugees have arrived on Greek islands after days of low numbers, despite a European Union-Turkey agreement under which new arrivals will be sent back to Turkey.
Figures released by the Greek government Wednesday showed 766 people reached the islands of Lesbos, Samos, Chios and Kos in the 24 hours until Wednesday morning. The number is a roughly a three-fold jump compared with arrivals in previous days, when weather conditions had been poorer."
The increase in numbers comes less than a day after the authorities were apparently "encouraged" by the reduced numbers of arrivals: Authorities encouraged by decreased refugee flow (ekatherimini, link).
And see: Flows from Turkey to Greece on sharp decline, while logistic assistance from member states continues (New Europe, link): "Just 11 days after the EU Turkey agreement, progress on returns of irregular migrants to Turkey has been made, as Turkey sent back 76 irregular migrants on Thursday and 71 on Friday, 25-26 March 2016 in respect, as the European Commission spokesperson for Migration, Home Affairs and Citizenship Natasha Bertaud announced in Brussels. In terms of arrivals, the numbers are encouraging, as less than 1,000 people arrived last week. In detail, numbers of the arrivals are: 20 March: 1,667, 21 March: 600, 22 March: 260, 23 March: 0, 24 March: 161, 25 March: 78, 26 March: 73, 27 March: 232 and 28 March: 192."
UK: JEAN CHARLES DE MENEZES: European Court of Human Rights judgment
"In todays Grand Chamber judgment1 in the case of Armani Da Silva v. the United Kingdom (application no. 5878/08) the European Court of Human Rights held, by 13 votes to four, that there had been: no violation of Article 2 (right to life investigation) of the European Convention on Human Rights.
The case concerned the fatal shooting of Jean Charles de Menezes, a Brazilian national mistakenly identified by the police as a suicide bomber. Ms Armani Da Silva, who is Mr de Menezes cousin, complained that the State had not fulfilled its duty to ensure the accountability of its agents for his death because the ensuing investigation had not led to the prosecution of any individual police officer."
See the press release (pdf) and the judgment: CASE OF ARMANI DA SILVA v. THE UNITED KINGDOM (Application no. 5878/08) in English (pdf) and French (pdf)
An overview of the judgment: Grand Chamber judgment in Jean Charles de Menezes case (Dought Street Chambers, link)
Background: UK-ECHR: INQUEST: European Court of Human Rights family to challenge UK government failure to prosecute police officers: background briefing on the broader context of the shooting of Jean Charles de Menezes
Also: Jean Charles de Menezes ruling due in European court of human rights (Guardian, link): "A ruling on whether British police officers should have been charged for the fatal shooting of Brazilian Jean Charles de Menezes at a London tube station in 2005 is to be delivered by the European court of human rights on Wednesday De Menezes was shot dead at Stockwell underground station on 22 July 2005, when he was mistakenly identified as a suicide bomber just two weeks after the 7 July London bombings in which 52 people died, and the day after the attempted attacks on 21 July, during a turbulent summer in the British capital."
Statewatch Analysis: Policing the internet: from terrorism and extremism to content used by traffickers to attract migrants and refugees" (pdf) by Chris Jones:
The EUs deal with Turkey on refugees and migrants has been presented by its proponents as a quick and effective way to deal with the ongoing arrival of people in Europe. Its opponents maintain it is morally bankrupt and contrary to international law. Yet the EUs approach to migrants and refugees is not solely concerned with such high-profile actions, and a whole host of new projects have been launched or given a new lease of life in recent months.
One of these projects is a new unit set up within Europol, the Internet Referral Unit (IRU). Originally set up to remove terrorist and violent extremist material from the internet, it will now also deal with content used by traffickers to attract migrants and refugees. The legal basis for the unit was established in secret trilogue meetings with the Parliament and the Commission, during negotiations on the new Europol Regulation
Greece-Macedonia border: Macedonia extends Border Emergency until end of year (MINA, link):
"The Macedonian Parliament on Monday voted to extend the state of emergency enforced in the areas on the southern and northern borders until 31 December 2016 as a result of the migrant crisis.
Speaking in Parliament, Defense Minister Zoran Jolevski said the motion on amending the decision approving an extension of the state of emergency came as a result of the growing number of migrants entering and passing through Macedonia.
The objective is to secure continuity of the execution of tasks by the army and security forces of the Interior Ministry in an attempt to guard and protect the state border."
5 deadlines to watch on the EU-Turkey migration deal - New threats emerge to the agreement to control migrant flows (Politico, link):
"Making the controversial EU-Turkey migration deal work was always going to be a huge logistical challenge. Now that the terror attacks in Brussels have stirred up fresh opposition, its a political one too....
If Greece does not change its laws and Turkey is still foot-dragging on granting full protection for non-Syrians, experts say, it will be another sign the deal is in trouble. EU officials say they hope that the message that migrants will be jailed and returned would be enough to significantly discourage new arrivals by the end of April." [emphasis added]
Are you Syrious reports that on Monday:
"One boat with 35 people landed in the north coast of Lesvos... . Chios volunteers report that one boat with 49 refugees arrived...
Official Greek Government figures show that there is a total number of 50.146 refugees in Greece today. 4.289 on the islands, 14.430 in Attica, 2.879 in central Greece and 28.548 in the northern Greece. Number of arrivals in 24h period until 07:30AM was: 90 on Lesvos, 64 on Samos and 78 on Chios."
And: "WEATHER REPORT Monday night +24h: WARNING: Waves up to 1.5 meters high expected of the coast of Kastelorizo and Leros, 1 meter high for south east Samos and even 2 meters in north east Kos. ATTENTION:: 0.5 meters high waves of the coast of Lesvos and Chios."
Italy reports upsurge in migrants crossing from Libya (euobserver, link):
"The Italian coastguard reported on Monday (28 March) it had rescued 1,482 migrants off the Libyan coast in two days, a new indication that the number of migrants attempting to cross the Mediterranean to Italy is on the rise.
Some analysts had feared that the EU's focus on shutting down the so-called Balkan route would force migrants to aim for other ways of getting into Europe.
Last week, the United Nations refugee agency said in 2016 almost 14,500 people had arrived in Italy via Libya, which was 42.5 percent more than in the same period last year."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (26-8.3.16): reactions to and consequences of the EU-Turkey deal
Lesvos, Greece: Eric Kempson: Faith in humanity restored!!!!! (YouTube, link)
"You have to watch this video of these amazing people who came to the aid of the refugee's facing a death march to Mytilene.
These are local people and tourists many of whom rented cars so that they could help.
Without this help the refugee's faced a death march with days of walking to Mytilene in the hot sun with children and infants
Brought tears to my eyes...Amazing!!!!"
EU judges could limit UK surveillance powers before referendum (Guardian, link):
"ECJ [European Court of Justice] to hold emergency hearing on snoopers charter as its impact on UK law is likely to become part of in/out campaign.. An emergency hearing on the bulk interception of communications data has been scheduled for 12 April at the European court of justice (ECJ), whose rulings are binding on UK courts. Its final decision could have a decisive impact on the powers of GCHQ, the Cheltenham-based monitoring agency, and could come shortly before Britons decide whether to remain in or leave the EU on 23 June.
At issue is the effect of an influential earlier ECJ ruling, Digital Rights Ireland, which has already been used to overturn the governments Data Retention and Investigatory Powers Act 2014 (Dripa) on the grounds that it is inconsistent with European Union law.
The challenge has been brought by two MPs, the Conservative David Davis and Labours deputy leader, Tom Watson. Davis is expected to attend the Luxembourg hearing."
UNHCR (29.3.16): 164,338 arrivals in 2016 in EU: 149.208 to Greece, 14,492 to Italy. 528 dead/missing in 2016.
Arrivals in Lesvos (UNHCR):
Wednesday, 23 March: 269
Thursday, 24 March: 83
Friday, 25 March: 177
Saturday, 26 March: 5
Sunday, 27 March 144
Monday, 28 March 161
It is reported that there was bad weather on these days - it is expected to improve early next week.
Austria: Report by Are You Syrious (link)
"Administrative Court of Austria has currently dealing with a lawsuit refugees filed against the state for their pushbacks. Right before the Balkan route was closed, hundreds of Syrian, Afghan and Iraqi refugees were pushed back from Austria to Slovenia. These refugees who were pushed back claim in their lawsuit that they were held at the border zone without toilets or any supplies in horrendous conditions, as well as that there were no reasons given to them in regards to why they were pushed back to Slovenia. According to Leschanz, the refugees prime point in the lawsuit asks why they were treated differently than other refugees that passed through, even if they fled the same reasons as the other refugees who were allowed to cross on the 6th March. Indeed, when the West Balkan route's closure was announced, thousands could pass, some hundreds were pushed back by a seemingly random choice." [emphasis added]
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (25.3.16): reactions to and consequences of the EU-Turkey deal
Greece: ECHR complaint on Afghan minors in Greece communicated to Greek government: See: Electra (link)
"I have just been informed that the European Court Of Human Rights (ECHR) decided to communicate the Afghan unaccompanied minors' application to the Greek Government and to officially grant them anonymity throughout the procedure.
As for the interim measures' request, the Court decided to count on the assurances of the Greek Government that once these applicants approach the national Asylum Service, they will IMMEDIATELY receive the apropriate protection, including guardianship and representation, access to the asylum procedure and care on reunification with family members abroad, the satisfaction of the children's needs concerning "accomodation with adult relatives. a foster family, accomodations with special infrastructures suitable for minors, protection against the danger of trafficking or abuse. The greek authorities also committed to the Court that "they will try to locate, as soon as possible, the members of the minors family, taking other protective measures (long list) and generally complying with the obligatins towards them, "according to the best inerest of the child".
The Court underlined that "if the assurances given are not complied with, besides the cooperation of the applicant minors, they can ask the Court for interim protection".
The communication of an application usually takes years. This one was communicated about 10 days after it was lodged.
It is now open for third party interventions. Those NGOs wishing to intervene and provide amicus curiae, are invited to do so. There already has been expressed an interest for intervention by the French Union of Immigration Lawyers."
Refugee crisis: European Commission "State of Play" reports since September 2015 now here and updated to 21-22 March 2016. A summary of institutional failure.
UK-LIBYA: SAS deployed in Libya since start of year, says leaked memo - King Abdullah of Jordan indicates US was briefed about plans for Jordanian special forces to operate alongside British (Guardian, link):
"SAS forces have been deployed in Libya since the beginning of the year, according to a confidential briefing given to US congressional leaders by the king of Jordan.
A leaked memo indicates the US lawmakers were personally briefed by King Abdullah in January about plans for Jordans special forces to operate in the country alongside the British. According to the notes of the meeting in the week of 11 January, seen by the Guardian, King Abdullah confirmed his countrys own special forces will be imbedded [sic] with British SAS in Libya....
Intelligence agencies want to keep terrorist websites open so they can use them to track extremists and Google had told the Jordanian monarch they have 500 people working on this."
Lesvos, Greece: The Hope Centre, Elpis (link)
...as you will all be aware/have read or heard via the many Facebook posts and the news in general, the whole situation has changed dramatically on Lesvos over the past week and is increasingly becoming worse all over, especially on the Greek mainland and on the borders. The situation is just heartbreaking and horrendous with so many people having to endure the most horrific conditions, as well as complete violation of their human rights, and with no one really knowing what is going to happen next.
What we do know is that people are still needing much support, and will be needing a lot more support, especially in the way of safe accommodation. And what we also believe is that this barbaric EU/Turkey agreement is not going to stop people attempting to reach Lesvos/Europe, but will just increase the danger risk to them. So as far as The Hope Centre goes, we are very much continuing to work hard and going ahead with developing the centre into an open hearted, safe and warm welcoming space to support those who will maybe be seeking asylum in Greece, or those who continue to arrive and are in need of support, in any way we are able to provide it. We are still very much needing more volunteers to work at The Hope Centre and the tasks are many and varied. The work is mainly repairs/renovation work, skilled and unskilled (though we prefer to call that 'creative') such as painting, plastering, building, carpentry, electrical, fencing, welding, and much garden landscape work/permaculture. If you are able to help in any way or know others who would be interested, that would be just wonderful....just turn up and you will be warmly welcomed with much gratitude
Thank you again so much for all your love and support
Much love and many Hugs to all, Cookie xxx - on behalf of The Hope Centre Elpis"
The Paradox of the EU-Turkey Refugee Deal (MPI, link):
"UNHCR, the International Rescue Committee (IRC), and Save the Children, among others, have all withdrawn services out of concern for the conditions and rights violations that will ensue. Without their support, the process loses both legitimacy and resources.
This, in turn, raises a more significant question about the evident ad hoc implementation of the EU-Turkey deal. Much of the process is being worked out on the ground by officials who are still unclear about the legal ramifications of their decisions. This may be deliberate: to increase the numbers returned, policymakers may have to feign a reality that does not currently exist, not just with regard to conditions in Turkey, but also with respect to offering arrivals a real and informed opportunity to make an asylum claim.
In doing so EU leaders would be making a calculated risk. It will take time for a case to reach either the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) or the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) to find the processes unlawful. The scheme has already been declared "extraordinary" and "temporary," and individuals summarily returned are unlikely to have legal recourse." [emphasis added]
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (24.3.16): reactions to and consequences of the EU-Turkey deal
EU: Justice and Home Affairs Council: Joint statement of EU Ministers for Justice and Home Affairs and representatives of EU institutions on the terrorist attacks in Brussels on 22 March 2016 (Press release, 24.3.16):
"increase as a matter of urgency the systematic feeding, consistent use and interoperability of European and international databases in the fields of security, travel and migration by making full use of technological developments and including privacy safeguards from the outset. This is particularly relevant for reliable identity verification. The Commission will present in the coming weeks a communication on smart borders and interoperability.." [emphasis added]
Germany: neo-Nazis and the market in asylum reception (IRR, link): "The German governments use of the largely unregulated private security sector in the reception and care of asylum seekers has led to neo-Nazis having unrestricted access to the very people they want to harm."
UN rights chief fears "collective expulsions" under EU-Turkey deal (TRF, link):
"The top United Nations human rights official voiced concern on Thursday that a deal to manage migrant flows struck by the European Union and Turkey could lead to "collective expulsions" of refugees in violation of international law" [emphasis added]
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (23.3.16): Reactions to and consequences of the EU-Turkey deal
Turkey safe country sham revealed as dozens of Afghans forcibly returned hours after EU refugee deal (AI, link):
"Turkeys forcible return of around 30 Afghan asylum seekers just hours after the European Union (EU)-Turkey refugee deal came into force shows that implementing the deal would risk refugees lives from the word go, Amnesty International said.
The organization has received credible information indicating that Turkey violated European and international law by forcibly returning the asylum-seekers, who fear attacks by the Taliban, to Kabul without granting them access to an asylum procedure.
H.R. said that he had been part of a group trying to reach Greece by boat. They were apprehended by the Turkish coastguard and then detained in the western coastal city of Izmir.
After five days in detention, he said he was physically forced to put his thumbprint on a document agreeing to a voluntary return to Afghanistan. He was not given a copy of the document. H.R. told Amnesty International by phone:
We dont want to go back because we are in danger in Afghanistan. If we go back, we will be killed by the Taliban."
Your Human Rights Being Destroyed! (Eric Kempson, Lesvos, video link): All corncerned about human rights and the rights of refugees should watch.
UK: Disaster for Theresa May as legal ruling brings student deportations to a halt (Politics.co.uk, link)
"The ruling could hardly be more damning. It found Theresa May deported thousands of students from Britain on the basis of unscientific hearsay evidence. The Home Office behaved like a tin-pot dictatorship: detaining innocent people, accusing them of made-up charges without providing anything to back it up, denying them their day in court and then deporting them.
Today's ruling could open the doors to the return of thousands of students to the UK, if of course - they wish to come back to a country which has treated them so appallingly. And it brings to a shuddering halt Theresa May's mass deportation programme of students. It also raises serious questions about the legal and operational functions as well as the basic morality of the Home Office."
And see: AWS Solicitors: press release: The judgment of Honourable Mr Justice McCloskey, President, in lead appeal on TOEIC/ETS scam (pdf): "There must be a Public/Parliamentary inquiry into the way the Home Secretary has dealt with this issue. Lessons must be learned from this disgraceful episode."
Greece: PRESS RELEASE: LESVOS SOLIDARITY: PIPKA
"PIKPA is an open, self-organised refugee camp in Mytilene, Lesvos. We distribute food & clothes to the port, Kara Tepe, Moria & to other refugee groups"
A few hours after the EU agreed on the barbaric measures of the EU/Turkey deal, a massive movement of refugees from the island of Lesvos towards the mainland started. The refugees received no clear information about where they were heading or about their rights. It was apparent that the government did not and does not have a plan on how shelter and health care services can be provided in the new destinations.
At the same time, the mayor of Mytilene announced to a group of representatives of Lesvos Solidarity that the space of PIKPA has to be evacuated. This means that the vulnerable cases that the camp is giving shelter to (people with long term health conditions, disabilities, single parent families, elderly etc) will have to leave immediately so that the mayor can transform the space into a children's camp and a sports center. After the new measures he said, there will be no need for
solidarity shelter camps....
Pikpa Solidarity camp, which has been accused by the municipality for illegal and irregular actions, has been for three and a half years been a strong solidarity hub, known all around the world. We will not allow our solidarity struggle to get destroyed due to the horrific and inhumane measures that the EU has decided to apply."
And: PIPKA: "We have created information sheets in Arabic and Farsi: It states that if you are in need of international protection and would be at risk on return in your home country, that you should apply for asylum. It also says family reunification (all) and relocation (Arabic only) are options. It stresses the right to claim asylum and that we advise people to do so. Please share. Thanks"
Link to: Information Sheets
CoE: Commissioner for Human Rights: Commissioner publishes Memorandum on asylum and immigration in the UK (link):
"Yesterday the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights published a Memorandum addressed to the UK Immigration Minister, James Brokenshire, in which he commends the UKs efforts in providing resettlement to Syrian refugees. He also expresses a number of concerns regarding a trend of restrictive immigration policy and law which adversely affects the human rights of refugees and immigrants.
The Memorandum also highlights the plight of the 67 refugees and asylum seekers who have been in the UK Sovereign Base Areas on Cyprus since 1998. The government is urged to resettle them to the UK thus putting an end to their extremely precarious legal and social situation." and Government reply (pdf)
Why the EU-Turkey Migrant Deal Is a Moral Disaster (link): by Bridget Anderson:
"It proposes a collective expulsion that debases the value of respect for human rights that Western Europe has prided itself on since the end of World War II, and that the narrative of the EU has been constructed around. This is compounded by swapping desperate human beings one for one, treating people as if they are commensurable and tradable, which is morally bankrupt. Each of those people on boats has their own history. It is desperationnot ignorance or foolhardinessthat pushes them to risk their lives. People who have no hope of getting resettled because they are the wrong nationality will continue to risk their lives because they have no alternatives....
Legally, Turkey cannot be considered a safe haven in the same way that European states are. Turkey has ratified the U.N. Convention on the Status of Refugees, which recognizes and defines the status of refugee and also sets out the responsibilities of states when people make such claims. However, Turkey stipulated a geographical limitation, claiming only those fleeing events in Europe can get full refugee status....
this new agreement between Turkey and the EU goes further than just undermining law. It undermines the very idea of safe haven that goes back centuries. This agreement involves rejecting people without listening to their asylum claims, including people coming from states that we know are riven with poverty and conflict, such as Iraq and Afghanistan. Europe is deeply implicated in the violence that has produced the conditions people are now fleeing.".
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (22.3.16): reactions to and consequences of the EU-Turkey deal
UNHCR: Daily report (21.3.16)
"UNHCR is concerned that the EU-Turkey deal is being prematurely implemented without required safeguards in place in Greece. At present, Greece does not have the systems on any of the islands for assessing asylum claims. Greece also does not have yet the proper conditions in place for people to decently and safely accommodate people pending their decision....
UNHCR will not participate in any way in procedures or processes of returning persons in need of international protection to Turkey
As a result of the 18 March agreement between the EU Council and Turkey, the Greek authorities began implementing new procedures. Over the weekend, for people registered prior to 20 March, Greek authorities provided additional ferry transport from the islands of Lesvos and Chios to the mainland. Refugees and migrants arriving to the Greek islands and registered as of 20 March are brought from the shores to the hotspots (on the islands where hotspots are established). Authorities in Athens confirmed hotspots are being converted into closed facilities and will be managed by the Hellenic Police.."
UNHCR redefines role in Greece as EU-Turkey deal comes into effect (UNHCR, pdf):
"UNHCR has till now been supporting the authorities in the so-called "hotspots" on the Greek islands, where refugees and migrants were received, assisted, and registered. Under the new provisions, these sites have now become detention facilities. Accordingly, and in line with our policy on opposing mandatory detention, we have suspended some of our activities at all closed centres on the islands. This includes provision of transport to and from these sites."
UN slams migrant 'detention facilities' in Greece (ekathimerini.com, link): "The UN refugee agency on Tuesday harshly criticized an EU-Turkey deal on curbing the influx of migrants to Greece, saying reception centers had become detention facilities, and suspended some activities in the country."
Secret EU plan to deport 80,000 Afghans: Revealed: Confidential EU discussion document proposes using aid summit as 'leverage' for removal of migrants to Afghanistan, as Brussels relies on chequebook diplomacy to curtail the crisis (Daily Telegraph, link):
"More than 80,000 Afghans will need to be deported from Europe in the near future under a secret EU plan, amid warnings of a new influx as parts of the country fall back under Taliban control.
The European Commission should threaten to reduce aid that provides 40 per cent of Afghanistan's GDP unless the "difficult" Kabul government agrees to the mass removal of tens of thousands of failed asylum migrants, a leaked document suggests. It admits the threat, if carried through, could result in the collapse of the fragile state....The EU has publicly embraced a strategy of chequebook diplomacy as it struggles to contain the biggest migrant crisis since 1945. "
See also: Afghanistan: EU shuts the door despite asylum recognition rates rising from 43% to 60%
And: Joint Commission-EEAS non-paper on enhancing cooperation on migration, mobility and readmission with Afghanistan - Country Fiche proposing possible leverages across Commission-EEAS policy areas to enhance returns and effectively implement readmission commitments (Doc no: 6738-16, 3 March 2016, pdf)
EU-USA: EPIC Intervenes in Privacy Case before European Court of Human Rights (link)
Today EPIC filed a brief in a case before the European Court of Human Rights. The case involves a challenge brought by 10 human rights organizations arguing that surveillance by British and U.S. intelligence organizations violated their fundamental rights. In its brief, EPIC explained that the NSA's "technological capacities" enable "wide scale surveillance" and that U.S. statutes do not restrict surveillance of non-U.S. persons abroad. "The NSA collects personal data from around the world and transfer that data without adequate legal protections." EPIC routinely files amicus briefs in federal and state cases that raise novel privacy issues. This is EPIC's first brief for the Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg. [emphasis added]
EU-Greece: Refugee deal between Turkey and EU sparks chaos on Greek islands - 'We are quite frankly alarmed at the speed at which this deal has been put into effect' (Independent, link):
"Confusion reigned on the Greek islands on 20 March as a controversial deal between the European Union and Turkey to deport refugees came into effect.
Aid organisations and volunteers on the islands on the frontline of the crisis said that there was no sign of the hundreds of extra police, migration officers and translators needed to enforce the arrangement. They warned that they had received no information from the Greek authorities and remained deeply concerned about the protections that would be granted under the new arrangement to those fleeing persecution and war." and
EU to start sending refugees back to Turkey within days after controversial deal 'approved' in Brussels Humanitarian organisations day the proposals violate international law (Independent, link):
"Human Rights Watch condemned the situation as a new low and said the proposed conditions put the very principle of international protection for those fleeing war and persecution at stake.
The plan has also been heavily criticised for singling out Syrian refugees, who make up roughly 40 per cent of arrivals in Europe, over Iraqis, Afghans and other groups needing protection."
Report from Are You Syrious (20.3.16)
"Refugees are rejecting the possibility of being sent back to Turkey, or to their countries of origin. Worrying information is coming from different camps about volunteers and small NGOs being asked to leave.... olunteers warn that military camps are not the solution."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (21.3.16): reactions to and consequences of the EU-Turkey deal
Relocation out, "one-for-one" in; Frontex calls for 1,500 more police officers in Greece
EC press release: Commission makes immediate proposal to implement EU-Turkey agreement: 54,000 places allocated for resettlement of Syrians from Turkey (pdf)
The title of the Commission's press release should say 54,000 places reallocated, as: "54,000 places which were foreseen for relocations will now be available for the purpose of resettling Syrians from Turkey to the EU," under the "one-for-one" scheme.
In September 2015 Member States agreed to relocate 160,000 people in need of international protection from Greece and Italy to other Member States, based on two Council Decisions, one for 40,000 people and one for 120,000 people.
Under that scheme as of 18 March, 97,725 "places" had been formally made available out of the 16,000. 937 people had been relocated (368 from Italy and 569 from Greece).
Under a Commission proposal published today, 54,000 of the "places" that were promised and never materialised will now be transferred to the "one-for-one" scheme.
Full story and more news: Refugee crisis daily update (21.3.16): criminal complaint against Spanish government; UNHCR opposes transformation of open site into detention facility in Greece; Austria to cut state aid to refugee charities.
News Digest: Round-up of news stories from across the EU (21.3.16)
GREECE: UNHCR halts transportation of people to Moria hotspot, now being transformed into a "closed facility"
From the UNHCR in Greece: "Dear colleagues, please be informed that as of 20 March, UNHCR has discontinued its transport of refugees and migrants from the shores and ports to the Moria detention facility. The government's decision to transform the Moria hotspot that allowed for freedom of movement into a closed facility has led UNHCR to take this principled decision. The authorities are aware of UNHCR's decision and are responsible for the transport of people arriving on their territory. UNHCR will, however, together with partners and volunteers (& the ambulance service) transport individuals in need of urgent medical attention to the hospital. We will also continue to work alongside NGOs and volunteers on providing life-saving assistance on the shores and in the ports. Thank you for your continued support and cooperation in this difficult and rapidly-changing situation."
More: Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (21.3.16): Greece struggles to meet EU-Turkey plan requirements; analysis of EU plans to "halt citizen-led response to the migration crisis"; further news and updates.
UK: UNDERCOVER POLICING: As inquiry hearings on secrecy approach, campainers release new briefings
Police Spies Out of Lives have produced two new briefings on issues related to secrecy and openness a the Pitchford Inquiry, which is due to examien the undercover police work in England and Wales since 1968:
- Secrets beyond lies: the police and state's requests for secrecy (pdf). An overview of the secrecy requests made by the police and state bodies to the Public Inquiry into Undercover Policing.
- Open Inquiry, Open Justice (pdf). A guide to the submission by non-police non-state Core Participants [those affected directly by undercover police officers, campaign groups, and so on] to the Public Inquiry into Undercover Policing, in response to police and state requests for secrecy.
See also: some background on the time when the Met Police were happy to help spread public information about the work of spying on "subversives": BBC True Spies series: police happy to disclose information when it suits them (Special Branch Files Project, link)
UK Justice Policy Review: Volume 5 (Centre for Crime and Justice Studies, link): "The fifth in an annual series by the Centre for Crime and Justice Studies, supported by The Hadley Trust, assessing year-on-year developments in criminal justice and social welfare across the UK.
Combining analysis of the main developments with key data on issues such as spending, staffing and the numbers going through the criminal justice system, UK Justice Policy Review offers an accessible overview of UK-wide developments.
This edition of UKJPR covers the final year of coalition government and the transition to the new Conservative administration.
It paints a picture of growing pressure on criminal justice agencies across England, Wales and Northern Ireland, as they struggled to cope with five years of austerity-driven cuts. Scotland is a partial exception, where increased expenditure funded stable or rising staff numbers in the police, prison and probation services.
Looking ahead, it points to the risk for a perfect storm of growing demand and shrinking budgets engulfing the UK's criminal justice institutions by the time of the next General Election.
A rising prison population set to top 100,000 by 2020 and inadequate legal aid funding are just two of the threats facing the delivery of justice across the UK."
Report: UK Justice Policy Review: Volume 5 (pdf)
Greece struggling to implement EU-Turkey deal
Greece Under Strain As Migrant Deal Takes Effect (Yahoo! News, link): "Authorities in Greece are struggling to put in place infrastructure to implement the deal signed by EU leaders and Turkey in Brussels to stem the flow of migrants.
(...) Speaking to Sky News, an official from the Greek government's crisis management office said the challenges were huge.
"If we had to do it today, we wouldn't be able to do it. There are things that have to be done before we are ready to implement a deal like this," Giorgos Kyritsis said.
"We are talking days in terms of the legal procedures. We have to make many legislation arrangements and then we have to make the infrastructure and that is a matter of weeks, not months.""
More: Greece struggles to launch EU-Turkey plan (EUobserver, link): "Would-be asylum seekers have continued to arrive on the Greek islands from Turkey as the EU promises to support Greece in its efforts to send them back.
About 875 of mostly Syrians and Iraqis arrived on four Greek Aegean islands over the weekend with Turkey stopping another 3,000." And see: EU-Turkey deal fails to stem refugee flight to Greece (Reuters, link) and Greece Struggles to Enforce Migrant Accord on First Day (The New York Times, link)
Further detail on the situation in Greece as it was in December 2015 can be found in a recent European Economic and Social Committee (EESC) report on Greece (link). The EESC undertook fact-finding missions to see how civil society and other organisations were responding to the situation of refugees and migrants in various locations in Greece, reaching a number of conclusions under the following headings:
- Lack of efficient coordination in locations that need it most;
- The relocation scheme is still not very popular;
- Lack of humanitarian services to respond to the refugee crisis;
- Discrimination towards refugees on the grounds of nationality;
- The Frontex presence is limited;
- No clear and strategic plan regarding those not entitled to protection;
- Children's rights at stake;
- No registration and follow-up of persons who cross the borders to the west;
- Refugees face abuse and exploitation;
- The refugee flows will continue.
The deal with Turkey (pdf), of course, is supposed to significantly diminish the number of people arriving in Greece. But apart from reducing the numbers of people arriving - thus reducing the level of need - it is not clear how, if at all, the actions outlined in the EU-Turkey plan will contribute to alleviating the problems outlined in the EESC report.
More: Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (21.3.16): UNHCR ceasing transportation to Moria camp, converted into a closed detention centre; analysis of EU plans to "halt citizen-led response to the migration crisis"; further news and updates.
New Developments in Complicity of Torture Case against French IT Company (Rights as Usual, link): "On Tuesday 15 March, French newspaper Libération and radio station France Inter revealed the results of a large-scale inquiry they conducted on the activities of French IT company Amesys, a subsidiary of Bull. The company is being investigated for its activities in Libya, specifically for having sold a surveillance system called Système Eagle to the Libyan regime under Gaddafi. The surveillance equipment was used to track Libyan opponents who were subsequently arrested and tortured. It is allegedly still in use in Libya.
Journalists gained access to dozens of documents showing the scale of the operation, and these documents are now part of the investigative judges file against the company. The system worked by identifying key words in individuals emails. Words such as corruption, or anything vaguely critical of the regime written in an email could trigger a persons increased surveillance and his or her arrest.
This is a significant development in an investigation which has been dragging on for years. To this day, the company is still not formally charged with anything and strongly denied the allegations in a press release published on its website."
Some background: French firm Amesys, criticised for selling to Gaddafi's Libya, offers customers "lawful or massive interception" of telecommunications (Statewatch News Online, December 2011) and Opening of a judicial inquiry targeting Amesys for complicity in acts of torture in Libya (FIDH, May 2012, link)
Reactions and consequences of EU-Turkey deal: Refugee crisis: latest news and documents (19-20.3.16)
- Italy: Mass discrimination based on nationality and human rights violations Nigerian refugees and trafficking victims deported from Rome (pdf) by Yasha Maccanico:
Europes answer to the refugee crisis has so far been to intensify existing policies and practices, conveniently overlooking their role in the genesis of the problem and in demeaning the rule of law in its member states.
- EU/Italy Commission requires large scale abuse of migrants for relocation to proceed (pdf) by Yasha Maccanico:
On 15 December 2015, the Commissions Progress report on the implementation of hotspots in Italy was sent to the European Parliament and the Council, calling for further progress to be made in the fields of hotspots, relocation, returns, border management and reception capacity. Lamenting the slow progress in implementing European Union Law to build a Common European Asylum System in mid-October, the Commission called on Italy to operationalise all hotspots, make full use of the existing detention capacity while reforming norms on detention and ensuring swift transfers to either second-line reception facilities or detention centres.
- Reinforcing the Fortress Commissions priority actions for the refugee situation (pdf) by Zak Suffee:
The EUs response to the refugee situation has included the deployment of warships, plans for mass refoulement and the possible introduction of one-for-one schemes, none of which were mentioned in the priority actions proposed by the European Commission in February 2016.
The priority actions, entitled the State of Play of Implementation of the Priority Actions under the European Agenda on Migration  aims to address the refugee situation by way of a number of priority actions which can be summarised under the following headings: 1) the future of Greece; 2) securing the EU; 3) hotspot management; 4) returns and readmissions; and 5) Management of financial resources in and outside the European Union.
- The final EU/Turkey refugee deal: a legal assessment (pdf) by Professor Steve Peers (University of Essex):
The EU and Turkey have now reached an agreement on refugee issues, which has aroused considerable legal and political controversy. To examine the arguments about the deal, I present here the main text with my legal assessment of each point annotated. This builds upon my comments (together with Emanuela Roman) first of all in general on the relevant points last month, and then secondly on the leaked draft text of the final deal earlier this week (I have reused here some of the latter analysis where relevant). The agreement should be read alongside the EU summit conclusions, as well as the Commission communication on the deal. It incorporates the March 7 EU/Turkey statement which addressed the same issues in less detail.
EU-Turkey deal fails to stem refugee flight to Greece (ekathimerini.com, link):
"They waved, cheered and smiled, elated to have made it to Europe at dawn on Sunday in a packed blue rubber motor boat.... Twelve boats had arrived on the shoreline near the airport by 6 a.m. (0400 GMT), a police official said....
The returns to Turkey are due to begin on April 4, as would resettlement of Syrian refugees in Europe. Doubts remain about whether the deal is legal or workable. It was not clear what would happen to the tens of thousands of migrants and refugees already in Greece.
Authorities in Lesbos began removing refugees and migrants from the island on Saturday to make space for new arrivals. The island has a capacity to host 3,500 people at a place set up to register arrivals."
and: Refugee crisis: Boats arrive in Greece despite EU deal (aljazeera.com, link): "Five boats carrying Syrians arrive from Turkey hours after deal aiming to cut off refugee route to EU comes into force." and
Thousands protest against refugee policies in Vienna (The Local.at, link): "Vienna's inner city ring was blocked for hours as thousands of demonstrators came out to protest against Austria's new asylum seekers policy on Saturday."
also: Swedish lawyers condemn EU-Turkey migrants deal (The Local.se, link); "Swedish group Lawyers Without Borders has expressed concern over the legailty of the deal reached between the EU and Turkey designed to curb migration to the 28-member bloc... Louise Gunvén, lawyer and board member of Lawyers Without Borders told Swedish news agency, TT. Asylum law prohibits return to a country that is unsafe, where people risk being subjected to inhumane or degrading treatment or torture. "Our extensive experience of Turkey is that people risk being exposed to such treatment. Considerable failings exist in the Turkish legal system, as well as the risk of not getting a fair trial," Gunvén said.""
EU: Council of the European Union: Draft Council conclusions on convergence in asylum decision practices - Adoption (LIMITE doc no: 7255-16, pdf)
It is obvious that the EU is moving toward standard 'country of origin' reports that will be used in more Member States in order to ensure consistent decision-making. The important point is that the information should be transparent and accurate. It is worrying that there is no specific mention of making reports public, or of taking into account evidence supplied by human rights NGOs when drawing up the reports.
EUROPEAN COMMISSION TAKES CHARGE OF THE REFUGEE OPERATION IN GREECE: President Juncker appoints EU Coordinator to organise operational implementation in Greece (Press release, pdf):
"President Juncker has today appointed Maarten Verwey to act as the EU Coordinator to implement the EU-Turkey statement....
European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker said: "We agreed today that the Commission will appoint an EU Coordinator on the ground to make the plan operational. I have decided that this will be Maarten Verwey, the Director General of the Structural Reforms Support Service who already is in Greece helping on a daily basis with the management of the refugee crisis. He will organise the work and coordinate the dispatching of the 4,000 staff that will be needed from Greece, Member States, the European Asylum Support Office (EASO) and FRONTEX. We need case workers, interpreters, judges, return officers and security officers.""
Comment: Like in the euro crisis the EU takes over control of the Greece-Turkey operation.
Everyone who cares should watch this video: Another tragic day in Eftalou, Greece (Eric Kempson):
"This is an emotional account of what happens here on our beach almost every day, please share and let the world know the humanitarian crisis that is unfolding at the gates of Europe, these people need help and support. Just imagine if you faced this every day in your back yard!! We help where we can but it feels inadequate, more needs to be done for these people, there is only so much local volunteers can help. These people need shelter and help."
Report from Lesvos, Greece (Saturday):
"The new EU agreement is taking effect in a major way currently on Lesvos. At this moment and for the past hours all camps have started to be emptied by the bus loads. Evacuations will continue all night. Refugees are being made to buy a ticket and have been on this boat since 11 am. Cash is needed at the port to buy tickets for families now standing outside since this morning. No agencies handling this and they cannot enter the "mandatory boat " without paying. Go figure that. Some with no money for food once on the boat. It seems the plan is to have all camps emptied by tomorrow.
All Greek island camps are being evicted. Volunteers are bearing witness in the port, distributing quick lunch packs and warm clothes before the refugees board and keeping an eye on the situation. We are all in a state of deep shock at the immediacy and severity of the implementation. All we can do is stand by and watch. Keep them in your thoughts tonight, there is a hopelessness and fear settling in that I have not seen here before."
and from Pikpa centre, Lesvos (link)
"As a result of the EU-Turkey agreement, the evacuation of the two camps on Lesvos at Moria and Kara Tepe began today. Refugees are being transported to the port and removed from the island on a special ferry service to Kavala. The current situation is that as of tomorrow night (20/3); the entire population of refugees on the island will be expelled to mainland Greece. There is currently a lack of organisation and no clear information about their destination, future accommodation and the procedures to be followed in relation to applications for asylum, family reunification and relocation.
We are greatly concerned that all individuals will not have access to the right to claim asylum and that those who will claim asylum, as a result of the severe lack of legal advice and the speed with which claims will be decided, will not have their claims properly assessed. Decisions will be taken en masse, resulting in mass expulsions. The sudden movement of people means the organisational structures are not set up for such an influx of refugees, the inevitability of which can only be subhuman living conditions, as we have seen in Idomeni.
The aim is to convert Moria into a closed detention centre run by the army; where we have grave concerns about the conditions refugees will be held in. As a result the structures of solidarity are going to be excluded from helping refugees, monitoring abuses and advising people of their rights.
EU-Turkey deal: Greece empties islands from refugees & migrants, hot spots turn into detention centers (Keep talking Greece, link):
"Thousands of refugees and migrants are to be transported from the Greek islands ot mainland in new camps as the EU-Turkey deal goes in effect on midnight tomorrow, Sunday, March 20th 2016. The hot spots on the islands Lesvos, Chios, Samors, Leros and Kos in the eastern Aegean Sea will have to be empty so that they can be turned into detention centers for the new arrivals of refugees and migrants as of 21. March 2016, at oo:o1 o clock. the new arrivals will be not allowed to travel to the mainland, but stay in the camps until they will be returned to Turkey or not....
According to media, travel agencies on these islands have been informed to issue no more ship tickets for refugees with Piraeus as destination. The hot spot in Moria, Lesvos, will operate as detention center and not more as center were refugees can stay"
See Statewatch coverage this week: Next operational steps in EU-Turkey cooperation in the field of migration (COM 166-16, pdf): "The return of all new irregular migrants and asylum seekers from Greece to Turkey"
HOTSPOTS TO BE "ADAPTED" to "implement returns to Turkey" and to exclude "relocation" to EU states of those in need of international proteaction: Hotspots to be turned from registration and refferal for trhose in need of international protection and: "adapted with the current focus on registration and screening before swift transfer to the mainland replaced by the objective of implementing returns to Turkey. For instance, the infrastructure in the hotspots would need to be reconfigured to accommodate the readmission and asylum offices."
And: the building of secure detention centres on the Greek islands: "Another important element would be a substantial increase in reception capacity in the islands. This could include separate facilities for irregular migrants and those undergoing the longer procedure of an asylum request, and would require sufficient detention capacity to be put in place for individuals who present a risk of absconding."
Is this what the EU-Turkey deal means: Friday 18 March 2016, the same day that the "deal" by the EU was done with Turkey, Channel Four carried this shocking video of a Turkish coastguard boat - openly - trying to sink a refugee motorised ribber dinghy: Shocking video appears to show the Turkish coastguard striking an inflatable dinghy carrying refugees and migrants in deep and dangerous waters (Facebook lvideo link) Shocking video appears to show the Turkish coastguard striking an inflatable dinghy carrying refugees and migrants in deep and dangerous waters. The officers are under instructions to get the boats to turn back.
"Migrant Report states that a Turkish coastguard crew has been caught on camera attacking a rubber boat with about 40 asylum seekers on board, including five women and 15 children. The incident happened at about 8 AM off the Greek island of Agathonisi. A Turkish Coast Guard Cutter started chasing the dinghy, which at this point was moving fast out of Turkish waters. Eventually the coast guard deployed their own RHIB with three men on board. The raft started zigzagging to avoid being intercepted. At this point, the coast guard officials started hitting the migrant boat apparently aiming to disable the engine. While this was taking place, the larger coastguard vessel started making a circle around the migrants boat creating a dangerous wave that is intended to flood the engine but could have also capsized the vessel. The chase, which lasted about 40 minutes, continued well into Greek waters with the Turkish coastguard pulling back when they were about half a nautical mile away from the shore of Agathonisi."
European Commission: President Juncker appoints EU Coordinator to organise operational implementation in Greece (Press release, pdf):
"European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker said: "We agreed today that the Commission will appoint an EU Coordinator on the ground to make the plan operational. I have decided that this will be Maarten Verwey, the Director General of the Structural Reforms Support Service who already is in Greece helping on a daily basis with the management of the refugee crisis. He will organise the work and coordinate the dispatching of the 4,000 staff that will be needed from Greece, Member States, the European Asylum Support Office (EASO) and FRONTEX. We need case workers, interpreters, judges, return officers and security officers." [emphasis added]
Tony Bunyan, Statewatch Director, comments:
"The hypocrisy of the EU knows no limits. This is the first official mention of the need for "judges" to ensure that asylum application appeals can be heard. It is not mentioned in any of the Commsion Communications or its reports on Greece and Italy over the past six months - it is not on any list of "needs". It is only officially recognised now - more than a year into the refugee crisis - alongside creting "returns officers" as well.
And there is still no mention of the crying need for the provision of lawyers and legal advice for refugees in Greece and Italy."
Greece: PLEIADES' PRESS RELEASE ON MILITARIZATION OF HUMANITARIAN RESPONSE TO REFUGEES (link):
"We strongly decry the militarization of the humanitarian response to incoming refugees and express our outmost concern on the detrimental semantics of democracy, of the threat that is implied by THE ARMY taking over on such a delicate humanitarian issue such as the reception of displaced populations fleeing war or internal conflict in the countries of origin, exclusively managing, from now on, according to the newly voted legislation, their housing, nutrition, transportation and medical support, as well as the activity of those volunteering in support of them."
Migration: Why the EUs deal with Turkey is no solution to the crisis affecting Europe - Interview with Aurélie Ponthieu, MSF Humanitarian Adviser on Displacement, Brussels (MSF, link):
"The proposed deal with Turkey shows once again how European leaders have completely lost track of reality. If this cynical agreement is implemented, for each Syrian that risks his life at sea another Syrian will have the chance to reach Europe from Turkey. This crude calculation reduces people to mere numbers, denying them humane treatment and discarding their right to seek protection in Europe. These people are not numbers, but men, women, children and families. Around 88% of those using this route are coming from refugee producing countries, and more than half of them are women and children. They should be treated humanely and in full respect of their rights and dignity....
The EU-Turkey deal and the deployment of EU humanitarian aid to Greece will be no quick fix to the need people have to find safety and protection in Europe. It is time European governments start facing reality and provide a responsible, common, humane and dignified response to peoples unstoppable search for protection and a better life for themselves and for their children, by providing a safe passage for those in need in dignity"
UNHCR on EU-Turkey deal: Asylum safeguards must prevail in implementation (link):
"Today's agreement clarifies a number of elements. Importantly, it is explicit that any modalities of implementation of the agreement will respect international and European law. In UNHCR's understanding, in light of relevant jurisprudence, this means that people seeking international protection will have an individual interview on whether their claim can be assessed in Greece, and the right to appeal before any readmission to Turkey. This would also entail that once returned, people in need of international protection will be given the chance to seek and effectively access protection in Turkey. We now need to see how this will be worked out in practice, in keeping with the safeguards set out in the agreement many of which at present are not in place.
How this plan is to be implemented is thus going to be crucial. Ultimately, the response must be about addressing the compelling needs of individuals fleeing war and persecution. Refugees need protection, not rejection....
people being returned to Turkey and needing international protection must have a fair and proper determination of their claims, and within a reasonable time. Assurances against refoulement, or forced return, must be in place. Reception and other arrangements need to be readied in Turkey before anyone is returned from Greece. People determined to be needing international protection need to be able to enjoy asylum, without discrimination, in accordance with accepted international standards, including effective access to work, health care, education for children, and, as necessary, social assistance." [emphasis aded]
EU-Turkey Summit: EU-Turkey statement, 18 March 2016 (pdf):
As from tomorrow, 20 March 2016 all refugees and migrant not lodging an asylum application successfuly will be returned to Turkey - but how will the EU ensure that Turkey does not carry out collective expulsion (refoulement) and how can it operate before Grece has agreed that Turkey is a safe country (which it is not) to return people to? There are special provisions for Syrians but refugees from other states will returned to the very countires they fled from.
"All new irregular migrants crossing from Turkey into Greek islands as from 20 March 2016 will be returned to Turkey. This will take place in full accordance with EU and international law, thus excluding any kind of collective expulsion. All migrants will be protected in accordance with the relevant international standards and in respect of the principle of non-refoulement. It will be a temporary and extraordinary measure which is necessary to end the human suffering and restore public order. Migrants arriving in the Greek islands will be duly registered and any application for asylum will be processed individually by the Greek authorities in accordance with the Asylum Procedures Directive, in cooperation with UNHCR. Migrants not applying for asylum or whose application has been found unfounded or inadmissible in accordance with the said directive will be returned to Turkey."
See: "Critics brand EU deal with Turkey on migrants 'a dark day for humanity (AOL News, link): "But the deal was described as "a dark day for humanity" by human rights group Amnesty International, whose UK director Kate Allen said: "It's absolutely shameful to see leaders seeking to abandon their legal obligations. Forcing refugees back into the hands of the very smugglers they just came from so they can have another go at exploiting them is obviously a madness. There's no way anyone should herald this as a solution."
The final EU/Turkey refugee deal: a legal assessment (EU Law Analysis, link) by Steve Peers, Professor of Law:
"It is unfortunate, to say the least, that the EU did not try to ensure beyond doubt that the deal was legal, by putting in place some sort of effective monitoring of Turkish commitments as regards the treatment of refugees and migrants, in particular asking Turkey to fully apply the Geneva Convention to all refugees as a condition of the deal. After all, the EU will now be meeting a significant proportion of the costs of housing refugees in that country. It is even more disturbing that some Member States want to arrange for expedited returns to Libya. Surely before too long, the CJEU will asked to interpret the definition of 'safe third country' in EU asylum law. That finding will be crucial in determining whether it really is legal to return people to Serbia, Turkey, Libya and possibly other countries besides. " [emphasis added]
and the following has been deleted from a leaked draft: ". Migrants having been returned to Turkey will be protected in accordance with the international standards concerning the treatment of refugees and respecting the principle of non-refoulement."
The EU's"day of shame": Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (18.3.16)
European Council 17-18 March 2016: Conclusions (pdf): This is not the text of the EU-Turkey deal, which is supposed to take the form of a "statement". However, much of the text concerns the issue of migration and cooperation with Turkey, and also hints at the possibility of military or other action within Libyan territory:
"In this context, the fight against smugglers everywhere and by all appropriate means remains key. The EU stands ready to support the Government of National Accord, as the sole legitimate government of Libya, including, at its request, to restore stability, fight terrorism and manage migration in the central Mediterranean."
EU: European Data Protection Supervisor on the proposed European Border and Coast Guard Agency
Press release: Securing Europes Rights and Borders (pdf): "Migration and security are two complex matters for the EU and the proposal reflects this complexity. The EDPS regrets that, despite the pressing political agenda of the European Commission, he was not consulted at an earlier stage of the legislative process since this proposal has clear data protection implications. His recommendations address his main data protection concerns and can help make the proposal more robust to withstand legal scrutiny.
The EDPS recommends that the proposals two aims need to be approached separately since different areas of data protection law apply; a distinct assessment of the necessity and proportionality of proposed actions is essential. Clear compliance with data protection principles will make the proposed Regulation more robust and efficient.
The scale and scope of personal data collection must be clarified since the current proposal implies that the new European Border and Coast Guard Agency will turn into a personal data hub where massive amounts of personal information is to be processed for border management."
And full opinion: EDPS' recommendations on the proposed European Border and Coast Guard Regulation (pdf). For background and documentation see: SEMDOC: Regulation on a European Border and Coast Guard Agency
EU, Turkey reach deal to return asylum seekers: Sources (Middle East Eye, link): "EU and Turkish officials have agreed a deal that will see hundreds of thousands of asylum seekers returned to Turkey in exchange for accelerated accession to the EU after hours of crunch talks in Brussels on Friday.
Asylum seekers will begin being forcibly returned from Europe to Turkey from 20 March if EU member states agree to the terms of the deal, a spokesperson for European Council chief Donald Tusk told Sky News.
The deal has so far only been agreed by Tusk and Turkish Prime Minister Ahmet Davutoglu, an EU source told Danish journalist Per Thiemann, and must now be put to the union's 28 member states.
The precise terms of the deal have not yet been made public."
And: EU strikes deal with Turkey to send back refugees (The Guardian, link): "The EU has struck a deal with Turkey that would mean all refugees and migrants arriving in Europe from Sunday being sent back across the Aegean Sea.
The European council president, Donald Tusk, cleared key sticking points with the Turkish prime minister, Ahmet Davutoglu, during talks on Friday morning. The Turkey agreement has been approved, Finlands prime minister, Juha Sipila, said on Twitter."
Background and more on the situation fo refugees in Europe: Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (18.3.16)
FRANCE: La Cimade press release: With closed counters: foreigners kept at a distance by prefectures (pdf): "Foreigners are increasingly finding the doors shut when they try to apply for or renew their residence permits in the prefecture [office of the government envoy in charge of security, among other competences] offices: this is what La Cimade criticises in the report À guichets fermés [With closed counters], which was published today. Contravening the principle of equality before public services, access to the prefecture office results from successfully negotiating a course which is laden with obstacles. For foreigners, the difficulties which they encounter to undergo the necessary administrative procedures are as serious as the important restrictions which exist in the criteria for granting residence permits. An important concern involves the cuts in resources which simultaneously deteriorate working conditions for civil service employees and access to rights for its users, particularly those who are most vulnerable."
Full report: À guichets fermés (La Cimade, link)
EU-TURKEY DEAL: "On the edge of international law" - or against it?
As the EU and Turkey come closer to an agreement that aims to keep refugees and migrants out of Europe, Lithuanian president Dalia Grybauskaite has said that a proposed deal, on which EU heads of state and government agreed yesterday (Thursday 17 March), "is on the edge of international law. Civil society organisations, meanwhile, say that the proposals under discussions, if agreed, would be illegal.
UNDERCOVER POLICING: Spycops inquiry: If its in secret, its dead in the water (The Justice Gap, link): "As this is a public inquiry, it follows that the starting point must be open proceedings, with minimal restrictions, fully justified on a case by case basis. Those who were spied upon deserve answers. The Inquiry was ordered to help address the loss of public confidence in the police resulting from serious misconduct in undercover operations. If it appears to be a cover-up, the Inquiry will only increase the concerns it was called to address."
The article makes clear the need for openness and transparency a the forthcoming Pitchford Inquiry, at which the police are hoping to be allowed to maintain their practice of "neither confirming nor denying" the existence of particular information, and for secret hearings to take place. The Police Spies Out of Lives group are asking people to support calls for transparency: Public asking Police to come clean ahead of hearing next week (Police Spies Out of Lives, link): "People are showing their solidarity to those fighting to keep the public inquiry PUBLIC, and asking the police to COME CLEAN over abuses. To do this, they are sharing photos of themselves on social media.
This is response to the call out by Cardiff against Police Spies and is in the lead up to the Inquiry Preliminary hearing and demo next week."
And: a long piece from Australia: Helen Steel and John Dines: The spy who loved me (The Sydney Morning Herald, link)
USA: RENDITION AND TORTURE: The U.S. Government Is Still Fighting to Bury the Senate Torture Report (The Intercept, link): "Government lawyers on Thursday continued their fight to bury the Senate Torture Report, arguing before the D.C. District Court of Appeals that the 6,700-page text could not be released on procedural grounds.
When the 500-page executive summary of the report was released more than a year ago, it prompted international outcry and renewed calls for prosecution. The summary describes not only the CIAs rape and torture of detainees, but also how the agency consistently misrepresented the brutality and effectiveness of the torture program."
And: Judges Consider Release of Full CIA Torture Report (US News, link). The report, in its censored form: Senate Select Committee on Intelligence Committee Study of the Central Intelligence Agency's Detention and Interrogation Program (10MB, pdf)
EU-US: "Privacy Shield" under fire
"The next US administration can, if it so chooses, weaken an already patchy data sharing pact with the EU known as Privacy Shield.
The provisional agreement spells out how US companies can use the transferred data of EU nationals while respecting tough EU privacy laws.
But fears are mounting a US administration headed by firebrand Donald Trump may attempt to punch holes in an agreement whose legal basis is largely based on promises and letters signed by top US officials." See: Cracks emerge in EU US data 'shield' (EUobserver, link)
See also: Sending data to the US: how to safeguard your privacy (European Parliament, link); Privacy Shield negotiators on defensive ahead of member states review (EurActiv, link); European Data Protection Supervisor: speech at LIBE committee hearing: Towards an Opinion on the EU-US Privacy Shield (pdf): "a lasting solution must be capable of providing legal certainty. It must be capable of being credibly defended - and upheld! - in case of future scrutiny before the Court."
And: Privacy Shield deal must be sent back to negotiators, say digital rights groups (Ars Tecnica, link): "A group of leading digital rights organisations on both sides of the Atlantic has called for the Privacy Shield arrangement between the EU and US to be sent back to the negotiators. In a letter to senior EU officials, the group says that without "substantial reforms" to ensure protection for fundamental rights of individuals, the Privacy Shield will "put users at risk, undermine trust in the digital economy, and perpetuate the human rights violations that are already occurring as a result of surveillance programs and other activities.""
SLOVAKIA: Fico says 4-party government may be in place next week (EurActiv, link): "Slovakias ruling centre-left party Smer, and three small centrist and nationalist parties, have drafted a coalition agreement, and a new government could be installed by the middle of next week, Prime Minister Robert Fico said on Thursday (17 March).
Ficos party won the most votes in the 5 March election, but lost its overall majority, threatening instability before Bratislava takes over the rotating presidency of the crisis-ridden European Union in the second half of this year."
Background: Slovak far-right makes spectacular gains on fear of migrants (The Times of Israel, link): "A Slovak extreme right nationalist party made spectacular gains in weekend elections thanks to anti-migrant sentiment in the EU member state and Prime Minister Robert Ficos decision to tap into it on the campaign trail, analysts say. "
UK: Mass stop and search by police doesn't reduce crime, says study (The Guardian, link): "The use of large surge stop-and-search operations by the police has no discernible effect in reducing crime, according to newly released Home Office research.
The study looks at the mass use of stop and search by Londons Metropolitan police to tackle knife crime in 2008/09, at a time when officers were carrying out one search every 20 seconds on average nationwide.
(...) The use of large-scale mass stop and search operations has been highly controversial not least because black people are still four times more likely to be stopped and searched on the streets by the police than white people."
Full report: Home Office: Do initiatives involving substantial increases in stop and search reduce crime? Assessing the impact of Operation BLUNT 2 (pdf)
EU: Council of the European Union: Coherence and consistency between internal and external EU human rights policy - Presidency discussion paper (6256-16, pdf): "It has been concluded several times that the work to increase consistency and coherence deserves further attention. To follow-up on these discussions, it would be useful to explore more in depth the shared understanding of the issues at play and discuss whether these is a common and shared understanding of what is required to be able to consider the internal and external aspects to be coherent and consistent. The importance of having a clear view on this, is that it enables identification of examples of incoherence and inconsistency and thereby the finding of effective solutions and approaches which take into account the interests of both internal and external realities."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (17.3.16)
EU-TURKEY: Draft Summit Statement: EU-Turkey Statement 18/3/2016: Draft 16/03/16 (pdf)
"Turkey furthermore agreed to accept the rapid return of all migrants not in need of international protection crossing from Turkey into Greece and to take back
all irregular migrants intercepted in Turkish waters... All new irregular migrants crossing from Turkey into Greek islands will be returned to Turkey...
Comment: The EU to end so-called "irregular migration" (by refugees and migrants) and deny sanctuary to those fleeing from war, persecution and poverty.
Migrants arriving in the Greek islands will be duly registered and any application for asylum will be processed by the Greek authorities in accordance with the Asylum
Procedures Directive. Migrants not applying for asylum or whose application has been found unfounded or inadmissible in accordance with the said directive will be returned to Turkey.... The costs will be covered by the EU....
The Members of the European Council welcome the Commission's intention to propose an amendment to the relocation decision of 22 September 2015 to allow for any resettlement commitment undertaken in the framework of this arrangement to be offset from non-allocated places under the decision. Should the number of returned exceed the numbers provided for by these arrangements, this mechanism will be subject to review."
Comment: The scheme for "relocation" in the EU has abjectly failed - to the shame of nearly all EU Member States..
The Members of the European Council welcome Turkey's commitment that migrants returned to Turkey will be protected in accordance with the international Standards concerning the treatment of refugees and respecting the principle of non-refoulement." [emphasis added]
Comment: How is this going to be monitored and enforced?
European Parliament: MEPs propose a centralised EU system for asylum claims with national quotas (Press release, pdf):
"The failure to date of the EU asylum system to cope with ever-rising numbers of migrant arrivals calls for a radical overhaul of the so-called Dublin rules, said Civil Liberties Committee MEPs on Wednesday. They propose establishing a central system for collecting and allocating asylum applications. The scheme, which could include a quota for each EU member state, would work on the basis of hotspots from which refugees would be distributed."
Draft report: On the situation in the Mediterranean and the need for a holistic EU approach to migration (pdf)
Statewatch comment: Before adopting the "hotspots" approach the EP might be wise find out how they work, are refugees rights respected (ie: do they have the autimatic right to legal advice?), what is the effect of "natilonality screenng" and "profiling" for a start?
New Institute of Race Relations (IRR): report: Entitlement and belonging: social restructuring and multicultural Britain (pdf): "The government considers the Housing and Planning Bill 2015 and the Immigration Bill 2015, currently going through parliament, as flagship pieces of legislation. This paper examines the likely impact of the legislation on the inner-city communities of multicultural Britain, the implications of its enforcement and the wider questions thrown up about the future of the welfare state."
Round-up of news stories from across the EU (17.3.16)
ECJ: The Dublin III Regulation allows Member States to send an applicant for international protection to a safe third country, irrespective of whether it is the Member State responsible for processing the application or another Member State (ECJ press release, pdf)
EU: Capitalism and surveillance: European Data Protection Supervisor: Opening statement at the roundtable on data and competition hosted by l'Autorite de la Concurrence, Paris, 8 March 2016: "Our question is therefore this: with todays internet based on surveillance, how can the EU enable alternative, non-privacy invasive business models to penetrate the market? How can the EU stop lagging behind in a sector where none of the top ten companies is European?"
EU: Data retention: Commission still refusing demands for new mass surveillance measures
Calls for a new EU data retention law have grown over the last few months, but the European Commission is still refusing the possibility of introducing new EU-wide telecoms surveillance measures and is standing by its September 2015 statement that "the decision of whether or not to introduce national data retention laws is a national decision".
After the European Court of Justice (ECJ) annulled the EU's Data Retention Directive in April 2014, some Member States annulled their national laws implementing the Directive; some kept theirs in place; and some passed new legislation (for example the UK, with its Data Retention and Investigatory Powers Act).
EU: Meijers Committee: Note on a Proposal for a Directive on combating terrorism (pdf):
"The Meijers Committee would like to comment on the European Commission's proposal for a Directive on combating terrorism,1 partly in light of the proposals made in the Council's General Approach of 3rd of March 2016 and the European Parliament's LIBE Committee's draft report of 10th of March 2016. The Meijers Committee holds that the proposal is insufficiently substantiated, that it extends the scope of criminal law too far and compromises fundamental rights."
And see: Background: Directive on combating terrorism (SEMDOC, link)
EU: Council President Tusk: Tripartite Social Summit - Wednesday 16 March 2016 (Press release, pdf)
"In his opening statement, the President of the European Council, Donald Tusk, stressed the need to agree on well-adjusted measures and emphasised that : "I have no doubt that the successful integration of refugees into our labour markets is in our best interest. It is the only way to enable the newcomers to stand on their own feet. And it is the only way to turn the current wave of migration into an economic opportunity. But the integration of refugees must not be done on the back of the most vulnerable individuals of our own societies: the poor, the unemployed, the disadvantaged. Questions like "why do refugees get so much support from the government, while it seems to have given up on me?" are legitimate. We must not provide any breeding ground for such questions to arise. And this is where I very much count on the social partners. Their role in maintaining social cohesion in Europe is key".
Auditors slam EU migration response as incoherent (euractiv, link): "The European Court of Auditors has published a damning report on the EUs migration policy, condemning it as incoherent and lacking in strategy, just as Union leaders prepare to agree on a controversial deal with Turkey on Friday"
See: Special Report No 9/2016 (pdf): "We conclude our report by recommending that the Commission develop clear and measurable objectives to be implemented by a coherent set of EU funding instruments supported by effective monitoring and evaluation, and by an appropriate information system. Governance arrangements must be simpler and better coordinated."
Returning migrants to Turkey poses huge administrative test (FT Blog, link):
"Europes return plan violates Greek law. To address this, Greece must overhaul its asylum laws in a matter of days to enshrine Turkey as a safe third country to receive asylum seekers.
The next step is harder: clearing the backlog. There are around 8,000 migrants on Greek islands, such as Lesbos and Chios. Officials say they ideally need to be moved before the so-called X Day as early as Friday when the returns policy officially begins.
Yet Greek facilities are strained. Shelter is lacking on the mainland, where almost 40,000 migrants are already stranded. Mixing the groups those who are trapped in Greece, awaiting relocation to Europe, and those who will be sent straight back to Turkey could get ugly. "
See also: The final EU/Turkey refugee deal: a legal assessment (EU Law Analysis, link) and: Why Turkey is Not a Safe Country (pdf)
Report from Lesvos: 2 April 2016: Electra (FB, link)
"The new law has passed last night. Mass deportation of 750 by tomorrow. 148 detained Pakistanees in Moria (although they are PRE-21 May arrivals).
They thought they were waiting in detention to be transfered to Germany. When some realized they were going to be returned to Turkey, they tried to ask for asylum but were anounced "it is forbidden". Local lawyer had to threaten with reporters to achieve some "expressions for wish to request asylum" registered. The local Asylum Office (reportedly functioning with 2 officers for registrations of asylum claims) is already "booked until the end of May".
People in wheelchair, children and adults, many sleeping on blankets they put on the floor, are all within the population to be deported. The authorities don't announce WHO of these persons will be among the first 750. Noone has been specifically notified that they are "leaving tomorrow".
Lesvos is currently an island. Not only in geophysical terms. It is a space where the rule of law, where respect for fundamental rights does not apply. We call Europe to stop this crime before it is too late." [emphasis added]
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (16.3.16)
Refugee crisis: Next operational steps in EU-Turkey cooperation in the field of migration (COM 166-16, pdf): "The return of all new irregular migrants and asylum seekers from Greece to Turkey"
HOTSPOTS TO BE "ADAPTED" to "implement returns to Turkey" and to exclude "relocation" to EU states of those in need of international proteaction: Hotspots to be turned from registration and refferal for trhose in need of international protection and: "adapted with the current focus on registration and screening before swift transfer to the mainland replaced by the objective of implementing returns to Turkey. For instance, the infrastructure in the hotspots would need to be reconfigured to accommodate the readmission and asylum offices."
And: the building of secure detention centres on the Greek islands: "Another important element would be a substantial increase in reception capacity in the islands. This could include separate facilities for irregular migrants and those undergoing the longer procedure of an asylum request, and would require sufficient detention capacity to be put in place for individuals who present a risk of absconding."
Finally the legality of the mass return of refugees and migrants from Greece to Turkey (p3-4) is uttelry dependent on the Commission's assertoin that legality is ensured: "Provided these safeguards are respected by Greece and Turkey, this scheme will be in accordance with European and international law" (see for example: Why Turkey is Not a Safe Country (pdf)
European Commission: New reports 16 March 2016 prior to the EU-Turkey Summit on 18-19 March:
Health warning the titles of the reports are quite misleading: eg: Annex 3: "First report on relocation and resettlement" is in fact a State of Play report on Greece. Helpful titles given below:
- Six Principles for further developing EU-Turkey Cooperation in tackling the Migration Crisis - Brussels, 16 March 2016 (Press release, pdf)
- First report on relocation and resettlement (COM 165-16, pdf)
- Next operational steps in EU-Turkey cooperation in the field of migration (COM 166-16, pdf): "The return of all new irregular migrants and asylum seekers from Greece to Turkey"
- Annex 1: Relocations from Greece (pdf)
- Annex 2: Relocations from Italy (pdf)
- Annex 3: Greece State of Play Report (pdf) includes:p3; Tranportation directly to: "detention facilities needs to be established", p9: Forced return programme to be implemented by the Hellenic police and p11 "timely pre-removal detention".Still no mention of the need to provide access to legal advice.
- Annex 4: Italy State of Play (pdf)
- Annex 5: Chart on relocation process (pdf)
- Annex 6: Resettlement State of Play (pdf)
- Annex 7: Plans for Resettlement after 15 March 2016 (pdf)
- Relocations from Greece and Italy (pdf)
NB: "Relocation" means within EU of refugees in need of international protection
"Resettlement" means of refugees from Syria, Lebanon, Turkey and other states to EU Member States.
REFUGEES: PETITION: Sign up: STOP EU-TURKEY DEAL - SAFE PASSAGE NOW (European march for Refugee Rights, link): 52,444 already signed:
"Heads of EU Member States
Donald Tusk, President of the European Council
Jean-Claude Juncker, President of the European Commission
On 27 February 2016, citizens in 32 countries and over 120 cities from Europe and the rest of the world raised their voices for refugee rights under the slogan #safepassage. We demanded legal and safe routes and high standards of reception and asylum. On 7 March 2016, EU leaders met with Turkey and designed a plan that should be agreed upon at the next European council meeting on 17-18 March. We call on European leaders ahead of this summit to live up to the European values of human dignity and human rights, to respect international law and above all, to bring us humane policies for a humane Europe."
GREECE: Rule of law in Greece buckles under institutionalised ill-treatment by law enforcement agents (verfassungsblog.de, link):
"The latest report on Greece by the Council of Europe anti-torture Committee (CPT), issued on 1 March, rang, once again, the alarm concerning decades-old, institutionalised, unlawful violence by law enforcement agents. In its press release CPT highlighted the need for Greece to fully acknowledge the phenomenon of police ill-treatment and to adopt a comprehensive strategy and determined action to address it.
The issue is compounded by the fact that this deeply ingrained violence is combined with institutionalised racism inside parts of the Greek law enforcement forces, thus targeting in particular migrants. In its 2015 report the Greek Racist Violence Recording Network noted that in 21 out of the 81 racist incidents that were recorded in 2014 the perpetrators were either only law enforcement officials or law enforcement officials along with other perpetrators. Out of these, 13 took place in public places, six in police stations or detention centres, and two in an abandoned private place."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (15.3.16)
Stop Your Backsliding, Europe (INYT, link) by Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights Refugees: Nils Muinieks:
"Some union officials are portraying this deal as a good solution to the crisis. In reality, the automatic forced return that the deal allows is illegal and will be ineffective.
It is illegal because forced returns run contrary to the European Convention on Human Rights, which prohibits the collective expulsions of aliens. They also violate the right to seek asylum that was established in 1948 by the Universal Declaration on Human Rights, and contravene guarantees established by the 1951 United Nations Refugee Convention, which recognizes that seeking asylum can require refugees to breach immigration rules..."
German NGO slams Turkeys illegal refugee proposal (euractiv, link):
"As EU leaders struggle to agree on a final action plan with Turkey, Germanys largest immigration NGO has published a legal opinion today (15 March) questioning the legality of the proposals...
PRO ASYL, a German organisation that champions the rights of immigrants, has published a legal opinion that claims the plan is illegal, as it is based on the claim that Turkey is a safe third country. The NGOs chief, Günter Burkhardt, is in no doubt that, Turkey is not a safe third country within the definitions of EU and international refugee law. ...
If the EU makes this deal, then it will be violating its own laws and international laws, Karl Kopp, speaker from Pro Asyl on European issues and on the board of the European Refugee Council (ECRE), told EurActiv.de. That would be a disastrous signal to send."
UNHCR: Reports that this year there have been 153,158 arrivals in the EU: 143,205 in Greece and 9,495 in Italy. 448 dead/missing
And: "The Greek Ministry of Migration Policy announced on 13 March that 44,035 refugees were in Greece with 8,904 located on the islands and 35,131 people on the mainland. Of those, an approximate 12,000 people were located at Eidomeni, near the border crossing between Greece and the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia." (Daily Report, 15.3.16)
E-BORDERS: UK: House of Commons: Public Accounts Committee: e-Borders and successor programmes (pdf) and Committee page (links to evidence)
"On current projections the Home Offices (the Departments) e-Borders programme and its successors will cost over a billion pounds, be delivered 8 years late and not provide the benefits expected for transport carriers and passengers.... The Department was emphatic that our borders are secure. However, the Department needs to accept that its assertion that it checks 100% of passports is both imprecise and unrealistic due to the complexity of our border.."
See: E-borders will be eight years late and cost more than £1bn (The Register, link): !MPs have slammed officials' misplaced confidence in the Home Offices "vital to national security e-Borders project, which will eventually cost the taxpayer more than £1bn and arrive at least eight years late.
Greece: Macedonia-Greece: March of Hope - the aftermath
"Last night, a pregnant 27-year-old Afghan woman, her 17-year-old sister and their cousin drowned while attempting to cross the river between Greece and Macedonia near Idomen camp, where up to 12,000 refugees are staying in inhumane conditions, sleeping in flooded tents, hoping the border would miraculously reopen. Today, a big group of around 3,000 refugees from the camp attempted to make a collective crossing on the same spot where drownings took place. They have started marching from Idomeni camp to Suha Reka river in the morning, with many volunteers and journalists following them on what they called The March of Hope."
UK: Investigatory powers bill not up to the task (Letter to Guardian, link):
"The UKs investigatory powers bill receives its second reading on Tuesday. At present the draft law fails to meet international standards for surveillance powers. It requires significant revisions to do so.
First, a law that gives public authorities generalised access to electronic communications contents compromises the essence of the fundamental right to privacy and may be illegal. The investigatory powers bill does this with its bulk interception warrants and bulk equipment interference warrants.
Second, international standards require that interception authorisations identify a specific target a person or premises for surveillance. The investigatory powers bill also fails this standard because it allows targeted interception warrants to apply to groups or persons, organisations, or premises.
Third, those who authorise interceptions should be able to verify a reasonable suspicion on the basis of a factual case. The investigatory powers bill does not mention reasonable suspicion or even suspects and there is no need to demonstrate criminal involvement or a threat to national security.
These are international standards found in judgments of the European court of justice and the European court of human rights, and in the recent opinion of the UN special rapporteur for the right to privacy. At present the bill fails to meet these standards the law is unfit for purpose.
If the law is not fit for purpose, unnecessary and expensive litigation will follow, and further reform will be required. We urge members of the Commons and the Lords to ensure that the future investigatory powers legislation meets these international standards. Such a law could lead the world."
Germany: Frag den Staat (link): Ask Parliament! - How to free scientific reports in large numbers:
"On February 18th 2016 German Parliament (Bundestag) announced the release of thousands of previously non-public reports conducted by the Research Section of Parliament in reaction to our campaign FragDenBundestag! (Ask Parliament!)."
Greece: Refugees on Lesbos offered sanctuary thanks to Brit couple (Mirror, link):
"Rather than welcoming British tourists, Eric and Philippa Kempson have opened a hotel of hope to the hundreds of fleeing refugees... ...
Now, as Turkey and the EU agree their one in, one out policy in response to the migrant crisis, Philippa says: Im absolutely speechless about these latest measures theyre farcical. Labels like irregular migration are meaningless. "We need to remember these are human beings fleeing horrific circumstances.
Hotel Elpis, on tranquil Eftalou Beach, gives desperate refugees shelter, somewhere to wash and a meal when they land on Lesbos. The 20-room hotel welcomed its first 110 residents two weeks ago."
EU-TURKEY SUMMIT: European Council (17-18 March 2016) - Draft conclusions (LIMITE doc no: 5862-16, pdf)
"Following the decisions of the Heads of State or Government of 7 March, and in the context of the Joint Action Plan with Turkey and its possible expansion...
the use of all means to support the capacity of Greece for the return of irregular migrants to Turkey...
speeding up relocation from Greece, which includes conducting the necessary security checks; the number of applications now being larger than the number of offers, [as shown in the Commission report of 16 March], Member States should swiftly offer more places..."
GREECE-MACEDONIA: Hundreds of refugees hunt for new route into Europe as three drown on Greece-Macedonia border (The Independent, link): "Three refugees have drowned while attempting to cross a river from Greece into Macedonia, according to police, as refugees attempt to find a new route to cross into the country.
Macedonian police said the bodies of two men and a woman had been found in the Suva Reka river near the border town of Gevgelija on Monday morning, which had swelled due to heavy rain.
More than 1,000 refugees are reported to have left the Ideomeni camp in the north of Greece on Monday morning, walking for hours with their belongings in heavy rain before finally attempting to cross the fast-flowing water."
More on the same issue and other stories and documentation: Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (14.3.16)
EU: Explainer: The European Law Protecting Over A Million Children In Court (RightsInfo, link): "On Wednesday, 9th March 2016, the EU Parliament in Strasbourg voted, in an overwhelming majority of 613 votes to 30 (with 56 abstentions), to pass a Directive on special safeguards for child suspects...."
The article highlights five key points relating to the Directive (which will not apply in the UK, Ireland or Denmark): 1. Providing children with a lawyer is now compulsory; 2. Questioning must be appropriate to the childs age and mental capacity; 3. Parents must be allowed to assist their arrested children; 4. Cases involving children must be treated as a matter of urgency; 5. Children cannot be tried in their absence.
UK: Cops hacked the Police National Computer to unlawfully retain suspects' biometric data (The Register, link): "Police employees have been hacking the Police National Computer to unlawfully retain suspects' biometric data, it has emerged.
The manipulation of the national IT system has come in response to public demands to restrict the length of pre-charge bail, the Biometrics Commissioner has suggested.
In his 122-page annual report (PDF), the commissioner noted that it had become not uncommon for the police to release suspects in ongoing investigations without officially placing them on bail, as the forces clearly feel under pressure to meet the Home Office's guidance to bring charges within 28 days of an initial arrest."
See also: Britains biometrics commissioner in DNA warning (Planet Biometrics, link): "A report by Britains biometrics commissioner has revealed that the fingerprints and DNA of at least 45 terror suspects had to be destroyed after police errors.
The report by Alastair MacGregor QC, the Commissioner for the Retention and Use of Biometric Material , also revealed that the police now have DNA profiles of 7,800 terrorism suspects.
MacGregor has found that the number of individuals whose DNA profiles and fingerprints are being logged on the little-known database as a result of counter-terrorism investigations is growing quickly, having risen from 6,500 identified individuals in October 2013 to 7,800 last year."
Full report: Annual Report 2015: Commissioner for the Retention and Use of Biometric Material, Alastair Macgregor QC, December 2015 (pdf)
FRANCE:La Cimade press release: Fires in detention: the violence of detention must cease
Four voluntary fires were started in the last few days in the Mesnil-Amelot administrative detention centre (CRA, Centre de rétention administrative). Of the three which occurred in the no. 2 CRA, the most violent one spread out on Saturday afternoon, leading to injuries to at least four people; two fire engines and a helicopter were used to put it out. The two other fires occurred in the night between Sunday and Monday. In the no. 3 CRA, the fire started on Sunday evening.
The Mesnil-Amelot CRA is an administrative invention through which two centres are grouped within the same enclosure, with a delocalised court in an adjoining building. It is the largest CRA in France, which is strategically placed at the end of the runways of Roissy airport. All the violence of the detention and expulsion policy enacted by the State towards foreigners crystallises there.
EU: EUROPEAN ARREST WARRANT: Warning over ECJ opinions that propose prioritising "mutual recognition" over human rights
Fair Trials joins with criminal justice experts on European Arrest Warrant (Fair Trials, link): "Experts in criminal justice from across the European Union have united in expressing their concerns regarding the protection of human rights in the fast-track extradition system; the European Arrest Warrant, as well as the poor and inhumane prison conditions in EU member states.
...if the court were to follow the opinion it would mean the human rights-based grounds for refusing European Arrest Warrants applied in national implementing laws, are incompatible with the EAW Framework Decision."
The letter: AG Bot's Opinion in Aranyosi and Caldararu - a Threat to Justice in Europe (pdf): "We believe that the Opinion of AG Bot should prompt a fundamental review of the Commission's approach. In outline, his conclusion is that "Article 1(3) ... must be interpreted in a way that it does not create a ground for non-execution of an Arrest Warrant ... on the basis of a risk of a violation in the requesting state of the human rights of the requested person". We recognise, of course, that this is not a legally-binding decision and that the Court will ultimately issue an opinion. However, we are writing now given the grave importance of the Court's ultimate response to the questions referred to it and the Advocate General's unexpected and deeply troubling advice to the Court.
The implications of this approach - according the principle of mutual recognition a higher legal status than protection for fundamental human rights - cannot be under-stated. If adopted by the Court, it would place the EU legal order out of line with overwhelming global consensus that there is an absolute and non-derogable right for a person not to be extradited to countries in which there is a real risk that they would be subject to torture or inhuman or degrading treatment. Despite AG Bat's arguments, international human rights standards allow for no " balancing" of this right against the interests of law-enforcement or judicial efficiency."
The opinions of Advocate-General Bot in the two cases in question are available on the CJEU website in various languages including French, German and Spanish. They are currently unavailable in English. See: Aranyosi and Caldararu (links).
1000s protest as Poland government battles court (News 24, link): "Tens of thousands of people took to the streets of Warsaw on Saturday in the latest round of a constitutional row that has put the government on a collision course with the country's top court.
Warsaw city hall estimated that around 50 000 anti-government protesters rallied outside the constitutional court which is in dispute with the government over reforms which critics say undermine judicial independence.
The demonstration came as the government refused to publish a ruling by the constitutional court abolishing the new laws."
See: Polish government rejects watchdog's call to publish court ruling (Radio Poland, link): " A spokesman for Poland's Law and Justice government said on Saturday that the prime minister will not publish a key ruling by the Constitutional Tribunal, despite being urged to do so by European Council watchdog the Venice Commission."
The Venice Commission report: European Commission for Democracy through Law (Venice Commission): Opinion on amendments to the act of 25 June 2016 on the constitutiona tribunal of Poland (pdf). Adopted at: 106th Plenary Session of the Venice Commission of the Council of Europe (Council of Europe, link)
FRANCE-UK: CALAIS: People protest, move on as situation worsens
Refugees target Cherbourg port as security tightens at Calais (The Telegraph, link): "Since the start of the year, there have been more than 400 attempts by migrants to sneak on to ships in Cherbourg bound for England or Ireland.
That is twice the number of attempts for the whole of 2015, according to the most senior state official in the region.
Many more may head there from Calais in the coming weeks as French authorities continue the demolition of half of the squalid Jungle, which is home to up to 7,000 migrants."
Refugees sew mouths shut in protest at Calais camp (NRT, link): "A number of refugees have sewn their lips shut in protest over the Calais Jungle camps closure, which began over a week ago in northern France.
NRT correspondent Halgurd Samad said French authorities are destroying the southern part of the camp where more than 1,500 refugees had settled.
The refugees taking part in a literal silent protest want to be resettled across the channel in England. They say they represent all of the refugees who were or are still living in the camp, and that they are waiting for a response from the British government."
Far-right activists 'impersonated police to attack refugees for money and mobile phones' in Calais (The Independent, link): "A group of far-right activists have reportedly admitted impersonating as police officers to attack and rob refugees in a series of attacks in Calais.
The five local men, aged between 19 and 14, were arrested on Wednesday and include the founder of an anti-immigration movement and protest organisers."
UK 'to give France 20 million extra' to stop migrants and refugees reaching England from Calais (The Independent, link): "David Cameron is to agree to give an extra 20 million (£15.4 million) to France for policing and dispersing migrants attempting to reach the UK from Calais, a minister has said.
In a radio interview before a Franco-British summit at Amiens in the Somme, the French Europe minister, Harlem Desir, said the extra funding came on top of previous British spending of 60 million (£47 million)."
More news and documentation:Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (14.3.16): Photos from Greece; evaluation of the European Asylum Support Office (EASO)
The Investigatory Powers Bill Is Unfit for Parliament (The Huffington Post, link): "here's a long history to state surveillance, going all the way back to Thomas Cromwell, of Wolf Hall fame. However, the levels of intrusion used to be extremely limited, simply because so much effort is needed to intercept and steam open letters, that it could only be done on people who were genuinely under suspicion. These days, with more of our lives being lived online, not only can we collect more information on more people than ever before, but it is far more intrusive. The contents of your phone probably reveal far more about you than any letters you write.
And so we should all be very concerned when the Home Office demands access to much more of our information. The problem isn't about people who are under suspicion of a crime; we can all agree that it is right to monitor such people, with appropriate safeguards. But it's different when it comes to keeping track of every website that we visit regardless of suspicion as proposed in the new Investigatory Powers Bill to be debated in Parliament this week."
For a detailed overview, see: House of Commons Library briefing paper: Investigatory Powers Bill (pdf). Background documentation: Draft Investigatory Powers Bill: official documents (Statewatch Database)
And: "equipment interference" proposals bad for business: F-Secure warns British Government over its hacking intentions (F-Secure, link)
Belgium says Europeans not welcome if they dont take on work (euronews, link): "In the heart of Europe, Belgium is home to more than a million immigrants out of a total population of 11 million.
Around 70% are from other EU member states, with large Italian, Dutch and French communities.
In recent years Belgian immigration policy towards Europeans has tightened, and more and more people are having their residency permits withdrawn, from eight in 2008 to more than 2000 in 2014. Between 2008 and last year more than 10,000 people were ordered to leave Belgium."
Background: March 2014: Even Barroso could soon be expelled from Brussels? (Sancho Panza, link)
And in the UK, similar developments: July 2014: Tougher benefits rules for EU migrants: New arrivals will lose payments after just three months under new Tory plans (The Independent, link) and Cameron cuts EU migrants unemployment and child benefits (EurActiv, link)
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (12-13.3.16)
Statewatch Analysis: The EU Border Guard takes shape (52 pages, pdf) by Professor Steve Peers, University of Essex:
"Back in December 2015, the Commission proposed the text of a Regulation creating a new EU Border Guard, which would replace the current Frontex agency. EU leaders have already asked for this law to be agreed by June. Most of the text of this proposal has already been agreed by the Council, although after that it will still have to be agreed with the European Parliament.
To aid those who are concerned about or interested in the development of this Agency, I have consolidated all of the parts agreed to date by the Council on the basis of Council documents 6359/1/16, 6884/16 and 6652/16. The state of play is set out in doc 6744/16."
Greece: Under Greece-Turkey protocol "migrants" to be returned "within 48 hours"
- 15 days mnimum providing applicant has the means to prepare appeal and the process is subject to judicial review
Minister confirms Turkish observers will be assigned to Greek refugee centers (ekathimerini.com, lnk):
"Alternate Minister for Citizens Protection Nikos Toskas on Saturday confirmed that Turkish officials will be posted to the Greek islands of the eastern Aegean to act as observers and oversee the relocation of migrants who are not eligible for protection from Greece back to Turkey.
Speaking on Skai TV amid media reports that Turkish officials would be allowed into refugee documentation centers, Toskas said that this is part of a protocol he signed with his Turkish counterpart during a Greek government mission to Izmir earlier in the week in order to speed up relocations.
In this framework, it will be possible for Turkish observers to be admitted at Greek islands to speed up procedures so that migrants who are not eligible for protection are returned [to Turkey] within 48 hours, Toskas said.
For the time being, he said, one Turkish observer will be assigned to the Moria camp on the island of Lesvos." [emphasis added]
Tony Bunyan, Statewatch Director, comments:
"This appears to confirm that within the new EU-NATO regime refugees will be brought ashore to "hotspot" centres in Greece. There they will subject to: "Identification, Registration, Profiling, and Referral" (pdf). "Referral" would mean "channeling" into those refugees who judged to be entitled to apply for "relocation" within the EU and those said not to be entitled to international protection. The process described does not seems to recognise that all refugees have the right to apply for asylum and that those judged not to be entitled to international protection have the right to legal representation and appeal against such a decision.
It is extremely difficult to see how peoples' rights can be respected in 48 hours. If refugees are to be "processed" in Greece then the full weight of EU law and rights apply. See CJEU judgment (pdf) which found that:
!As regards the fact that the time-limit for bringing an action is 15 days in the case of an accelerated procedure, whilst it is 1 month in the case of a decision adopted under the ordinary procedure, the important point, as the Advocate General has stated in point 63 of his Opinion, is that the period prescribed must be sufficient in practical terms to enable the applicant to prepare and bring an effective action....
"the reasons which led that authority to examine the merits of the application under such a procedure can in fact be subject to judicial review in the action which may be brought against the final decision rejecting the application a matter which falls to be determined by the referring court.""
Majority of Spanish Congress against EU refugee deal signed by acting PM - This is the first time that the lower house has opposed a European agreement (El Pais, link):
"Acting Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy will go to the European Council on March 17 to defend a position that most of Spanish Congress radically rejects.
Except for his own Popular Party (PP), all other congressional groups 227 deputies out of a total of 350 feel that the European Unions deal with Turkey to expel refugees is illegal....
This is the first time that a vast majority of Congress has rejected a deal subscribed to by the EU government. Socialist leader Pedro Sánchez said the European deal with Turkey was immoral and possibly even illegal.
We have a week to change this agreement. The European Council of March 17 and 18 cannot approve this pact of shame, he said."
UNHCR Daily Report, 11.3.16:
"Turkish Minister of EU Affairs, Volkan Bozkir, stated that the agreement, under which Turkish authorities are to readmit refugees and migrants from Greece does not apply to people who have already reached the Greek islands but to those who will arrive once the agreement begins to be implemented." [emphasis added]
Danish childrens rights activist fined for people trafficking (Guardian, link):
"Lisbeth Zornig says her fine for giving a lift to family of Syrians is criminalising decency amid asylum clampdown in Denmark
A high-profile Danish campaigner for childrens rights was prosecuted on Friday under people trafficking laws, shining a spotlight once more on the countrys crackdown on asylum, as Scandinavian countries compete to make themselves unattractive destinations for refugees.
Lisbeth Zornig, the countrys former childrens ombudsman and a well-known author, was fined DKr22,500 (£2,328) the maximum demanded by the prosecutor by a court in Nykøbing Falster, southern Denmark, for allowing a family of Syrians to hitch a ride with her to Copenhagen.
Her husband was fined the same amount for taking the family into his home for coffee and biscuits, and then driving them to the railway station, where he bought them tickets to Sweden. This was a political trail, using me and my husband to send a strong message: dont try to help refugees, Zornig said after the verdict. I am very angry because the only thing we did was the decent thing, the same that hundreds of others did. They are criminalising decency. Zornig has decided to appeal against the verdict."
EU: ECRE Memorandum to the European Council Meeting 17 18 March 2016: Time to Save the Right to Asylum (pdf):
"Ahead of the European Council Summit meeting of 17 and 18 March 2016, ECRE urges Heads of State or Government to assume political leadership and pave the way for a concerted EU response to what primarily continues to be a refugee crisis and not only a migratory phenomenon. Such a response must be based on the principle of solidarity and fair sharing of responsibility and respect for human rights. Current fragmented national approaches have added to the suffering of refugees and migrants."
And see: Letter sent to President of the European Council Donald Tusk, President of the European Commission Jean Claude Juncker and EU Heads of State or Government (link):
EU: Justice and Home Affairs Council: 10-11 March 2015: Final Press release, 10-11-3-16 (pdf)
Ex-MI5 boss: Private firms spy like us (Evening Standard, link): "Private firms are compiling detailed personal profiles of ordinary citizens using methods that are just as intrusive as those deployed by Britains intelligence agencies, the former head of MI5 has warned.
Baron Evans of Weardale said the companies were using open source material to learn an awful lot about what you do on a daily basis and who you associate with to an extent that would be very surprising to most of the public.
Lord Evans, who served as director general of the Security Service until 2013, added that the firms had really effective and powerful investigative capabilities but faced only limited legal controls that were much weaker than those applied to the intelligence agencies."
And see: Spying on a see through world: the "Open Source" intelligence industry, by Ben Hayes (Statewatch Journal, January-March 2010)
Prison capital: UK locks up more people than any other EU member state
The latest Council of Europe (CoE) prison statistics show that the UK imprisons more people than any other member of the European Union, with over 95,000 behind bars. Of the 47 member states of the Council of Europe, only Russia (671,027 people) and Turkey (151,451) have more people in prison. Within the UK, Scotland has the highest rate of incarceration, and between 2005 and 2014 the country's prison population rate rose by over twice as much as in England and Wales.
Across the 47 member states of the Council of Europe, there has been a decline in overcrowding but it remains a serious problem. Europe's prisons "remain close to the top of their capacity, holding 1,600,324 people." The countries with the most overcrowded penal institutons in 2014 were Hungary, Belgium, the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, Greece, Albania, Spain, France, Slovenia, Portugal, Serbia and Italy. The most common crimes for which people are imprisoned are drug offences (17% of the total prison population) and theft (14%).
UN human rights chief to discuss "very serious concerns" over proposed EU-Turkey deal during Brussels trip
"The EU's draft arrangement with Turkey earlier this week raises a number of very serious concerns. We do not yet have full details of this draft, and I plan to discuss my concerns in full during my visit to Brussels early next week, before the two-day EU Summit which begins on 17 March. Among my concerns is the potential for collective and arbitrary expulsions, which are illegal. Border restrictions which do not permit determination of the circumstances of each individual violate international and European law.
I must also reiterate my profound concern about restrictive measures such as erecting fences; denying people access to individualised procedures; and arbitrarily denying entry to people of specific nationalities. I am in addition concerned about measures to seize belongings from people who may have already suffered greatly, and to restrict them from bringing in family members."
Full statement: Statement by Zeid Ra'ad Al Hussein, United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, to the Human Rights Council's 31st session (10 March 2016, pdf) and see: UN rights chief calls on EU to adopt more humane measures on migration (UN Human Rights, link)
More: Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (11.3.16): joint NGO statement against border closures; non-assistance to migrants in distress; interview with International Organisation for Migration director.
EU wants to give police greater digital access (EUobserver, link): "The European Commission is set to propose expanding police access to sensitive digital data, including details of financial transactions made inside the EU and biometric data of asylum seekers.
The idea is laid out in an internal document, seen by this website, from EU counter-terrorism coordinator Gilles de Kerchove.
The paper, dated 4 March 2016, says the commission is mulling proposals to broaden the Terrorist Financing Tracking Program (TFTP), also known as the Swift agreement."
See: European Counter-Terrorism Coordiator: State of play on implementation of the statement of the Members of the European Council of 12 February 2015, the JHA Council Conclusions of 20 November 2015, and the Conclusions of the European Council of 18 December 2015 (LIMITE doc no: 6785-16, pdf)
EU: DATA PROTECTION REGULATION: The lobby-tomy 2: What was the lobbying about? (EDRi, link): "What do companies really think about privacy protection? Publicly everybody thinks privacy is important, but do they think the same thing behind closed doors? What were the hot issues during the lobby and did everybody treat privacy protection well?
Of all the (over 150 ) lobbying documents, unfortunately only three are clearly in favour of more data protection. Two of those are ours. The other one was sent by the European consumers association. That is a very low number.
We have qualified one third of the documents as unmistakably bad for data protection. This means that organisations in those cases want fewer obligations, and want to make more data processing possible and/or easier.
Of course, judging almost two hundred lobby documents on their substance is no exact science. It doesnt get any more precise than more or less data protection. Still, a troubling image appears."
See also: Lobby-tomie (link) - the blog series in Dutch (Bits of Freedom, link)
FRANCE: A look at the latest French laws on intelligence collection (Electrospaces.net, link): "Over the last year, The French parliament passed new laws granting additional powers to intelligence services regarding interception of communications and data requests. This is part of a broader reform aimed at creating a legal framework for intelligence practices which were not formally authorized by law before 2015. In the press, it was said that these laws allowed sweeping new surveillance powers, legalizing highly intrusive methods without guarantees for individual freedom and privacy.
This article will focus on the provisions related to communications intelligence (COMINT), including targeted telephone tapping (lawful interception or LI), metadata collection and data requests to internet service providers (ISPs). Targeted interception of the content of internet communications is not regulated by these new laws, but only by older decrees which are still a bit unclear. The new laws are only about collection the metadata of internet communications."
EU: FRONTEX: Report on implementing the 2014 rules on surveillance of external sea borders
"The report comprises three parts.
The first, describing the amendments introduced to the governing procedural documents related to the Joint Operations, the Operational Plans.
The second part, a description of the procedures set forth by Frontex to implement the Regulation during sea operations and information on its application, including detailed information on compliance with Fundamental Rights, and any incidents which may have taken place.
In this second part, the report analyses the implementation of the Regulation by joint operations starting with the issue of disembarkation in third countries, followed by the procedures put in place to address the special needs of certain categories of persons and of persons in need of international protection. The report then assesses communication and cooperation channels.
The third part contains the assessment of the implementation of the Regulation during the first year and evaluates the need for further developing the measures adopted so far."
Operations covered by the report: EPN (European Patrols Network) Hermes 2014, EPN Triton 2014 (the successor to the Italian navy's Mare Nostrum operation), Poseidon Sea 2014, JO (Joint Operation) EPN Indalo 2014, JO EPN Hera 2014.
See: Annual Report on the implementation of EU Regulation 656/2014 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 15 May 2014 establishing rules for the surveillance of the external sea borders (pdf). See: the text of the Regulation (pdf) and an analysis of the new rules at the time they were agreed: Steve Peers, New EU rules on maritime surveillance: will they stop the deaths and push-backs in the Mediterranean?, February 2014 (pdf)
UK: Parliamentary Office of Science and Technology: new briefing paper on digital forensics and crime
"Digital forensic science is the process of obtaining, analysing and using digital evidence in investigations or criminal proceedings. Digital evidence ranges from images of child sexual exploitation to the location of a mobile phone. This note looks at how evidence is obtained, legislation and regulation, and efforts to address challenges faced by practitioners."
See: POSTNOTE: Digital Forensics and Crime (pdf)
EU Internet Forum against terrorist content and hate speech online: Document pool (EDRi, link): "Since last year, we have been reporting on the EU Internet Forum set up by the European Commission to fight terrorism and hate speech online. In reality, the IT-Forum gathers two initiatives: one run by the Home Affairs Directorate General of the European Commission, on terrorism; and one run by the Justice and Consumers Directorate General, on hate speech (sometimes illegal hate speech, sometimes non-specific hate speech).
Since the initial meetings of both initiatives took place behind closed doors and the meetings of the terrorism part still do, we have also been busy trying to get information on the nature of the discussions and participants involved. This document pool gives you an overview of the activities of the EU Internet Forum and a list of documents we received upon request from the European Commission."
Inspectors: Refugees held in wholly unacceptable conditions in freight shed (Free Movement, link): "An unannounced inspection of short term detention facilities for refugees and migrants crossing the Channel into the UK has revealed that hundreds, including many children, have been held in wholly unacceptable and insanitary conditions. Many were held in a disused freight shed and forced to sleep on concrete floors, with no food, drink or clothing provided.
The increase in numbers making the crossing to the UK in the summer of 2015 was found to have overwhelmed the Home Office and contractors but the emergency arrangements were still in place several months later, when the inspection took place. The increase in arrivals over the summer was predictable and the report questions why no adequate plans were put in place."
See the report: HM Chief Inspector of Prisons: Longport freight shed, Dover Seaport and Frontier House (pdf)
News Digest: round-up of news stories from across the EU (11.3.16)
Refugee crisis: latest news and documents (10.3.16)
Justice and Home Affairs Council adopts Conclusions on "migrant smuggling" and facilitating "illegal entry & transit"
- the "humanitarian exception" of helping refugees is seen as an "obstacle" to prosecutions - the term "refugee" is not mentioned once
Tony Bunyan, Statewatch Director, comments:
"Has the threat to criminalise NGOs, volunteers and local people disappeared? On the contrary, it has moved formally onto the agenda for Eurojust to conclude that the "humanitarian exception" of helping refugees in need is an "obstacle" to the investigation and prosecution of "migrant smugglers".
At the same time, here and now, in Greece NGOs and volunteers are being required to register with the state-police and account to them for all their actions."
See: NGOs and volunteers helping refugees in Greece to be placed under state control
EU: Justice and Home Affairs Council: 10-11 March 2015: Press release, 10-3-16 (pdf)
"B" Points Agenda (for discussion, pdf) and "A" Points Agenda (adopted without discussion, pdf) and Background Note (pdf)
Border Guard Agency:
See: Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on the European Border and Coast Guard and repealing Regulation (EC) No 2007/2004, Regulation (EC) No 863/2007 and Council Decision 2005/267/EC - Provisions on return (LIMITE doc no:6884-16, pdf) and
Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on the European Border and Coast Guard and repealing Regulation (EC) No 2007/2004, Regulation (EC) No 863/2007 and Council Decision 2005/267/EC (LIMITE doc no: 6652, pdf)
- Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on the European Border and Coast Guard and repealing Regulation (EC) No 2007/2004, Regulation (EC) No 863/2007 and Council Decision 2005/267/EC - State of play (LIMITE doc no: 6744-16, pdf)
- State of play on implementation of the statement of the Members of the European Council of 12 February 2015, the JHA Council Conclusions of 20 November 2015, and the Conclusions of the European Council of 18 December 2015 (LIMITE doc no: 6785-16, pdf)
- Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on combating terrorism and replacing Council Framework Decision 2002/475/JHA on combating terrorism [First reading] - General approach (LIMITE doc no: 6655-16, pdf)
EU: New "Group of Personalities" (GoP) advance need for "military research" in EU following the "security research" initiative:
Report of the Group of Personalities on the Preparatory Action for CSDP-related research: EUROPEAN DEFENCE RESEARCH: The case for an EU-funded defence R&T programme (5 MB, pdf)
"Europes capacity to provide for its own security depends on our ability to continuously innovate to ensure technological leadership and be a credible partner to our allies. The recent dramatic falls in investment in R&T risk undermining our efforts to support the sector and our broader defence and security goals....
This work on research in defence is part of a broader policy goal to strengthen European defence cooperation. To that effect, the Commission will present an Action Plan on defence this year."
Members of the GoP: High-level group of personalities on defence research (pdf) Not an NGO/civil society in sight.
See: EU DEFENCE UNION: Yet another elite "Group of Personalities" set up: Bienkowska launches high-level defence research group (Statewatch database) and EU: Commission proposes military research programme (Statewatch database)
See: Statewatch publications: Security research initiative: Neoconopticon: the EU security-industrial complex (pdf) by Ben Hayes and Arming Big Brother: the EU's Security Research Programme by Ben Hayes
German Bundeswehr to gain combat drones (link):
"For the interim period, an Israeli model is to be leased; over the next ten years, European arms companies are to develop a competitive Euro-drone
The German Bundeswehr has now selected a model of combat drone for future use. It plans to lease three to five of the latest TP version (Block 2) of the Heron family of drones, developed by Israel Aerospace Industries. The prime contractor for the leasing arrangement is the Airbus Group, which entered into a teaming agreement with the Israeli manufacturer on marketing in Europe."
EU-Funded migration management project launched in Belgrade (Frontex, link): " This regional support programme for the countries of the Western Balkans and Turkey aims to establish a harmonized, effective and protection-sensitive migration management in line with EU standards"
Greece: Tsipras reacts to Tusk statement on closure of Balkan route for migrants (ekathimerini.com, link): "The Western Balkans route has come to an end due to unilateral actions by certain countries. EU has no future if it goes on like that, Tsipras tweeted. We expect D. Tusk, president of EU28 to focus efforts on implementing our common decisions and not encourage those who ignore them, the Greek premier added.
Earlier, Tusk wrote on Twitter that Irregular flows of migrants along Western Balkans route have come to an end. Not a question of unilateral actions but common EU28 decision... I thank Western Balkan ountries for implementing part of EUs comprehensive strategy to deal with migration crisis, Tusk added."
and: Tusk Tsipras Merkel: War of Words about the Closure of Balkan Route (Keep Talking Greece, link)
Comment: The EU Council President D Tusk seems to have forgotten that the draft Summit statement referred to closing the Balkan route but the final press statement did not. This is why it is right to speak of continuous unilateral action by European states.
And see: Austria wants Balkan route to stay closed (link): "Austrias interior minister says the Balkan migrant route should remain closed permanently and that the clock will not be turned back."
UK: IP BILL: Why are the intelligence agencies revealing their spying techniques? (Guardian, link) "Now that the security services are allowed to record us through our phones, privacy has become impossible unless we renounce modern telecoms....And is it a good idea to take a chainsaw to your computer or incinerate your iPhone? Certainly, if you have something illegal to hide although doing so will inevitably limit your ability to commit more crimes. For the rest of us, it all depends on whether we value our personal privacy more highly than the convenience of using modern communications and whether we think the agencies are on our side." and Snooper's charter: wider police powers to hack phones and access web history (Guardian, link): "Latest version of investigatory powers bill will allow police to hack peoples computers and view browsing history."
See: Equipment Interference: DRAFT Code of Practice [Spring] 2016 (pdf)
And Statewatch: Remote access to computers: Is it time to go back to the typewriter, carbon paper and Tippex? (March 2015) by Tony Bunyan and EU agrees rules for remote computer access by police forces (September 2009) by Tony Bunyan
European Parliament: MEPs demand details of the EU-Turkey deal and compliance with international law (Press release, pdf):
"MEPs demanded details on Wednesday of the deal struck by EU leaders with Turkey on the management of migrant and refugee flows, underlining that the international asylum rules must be respected. In a plenary debate with the Council and the Commission, most political group leaders insisted that EU accession negotiations with Turkey and talks on visa liberalisation for Turkish nationals travelling to the EU should not be linked to the refugee issue....
Note to editors: Visa exemption rule changes entail switching the country concerned from one annex to Regulation 539/01 to another (such changes are subject to co-decision by Parliament and the Council)."
Better lawmaking? Only if it is in the peoples interest (euractiv, link): "It is in the public interest to have a well-functioning legislative and regulatory body that is appropriate for the context. However, it raises many questions about the objectives being pursued, writes Reine-Claude Mader. Reine-Claude Mader is a member of the European Economic and Social Committee (EESC).
Businesses complain about the so-called gold-plating, which they define as overregulation and excessive standards due to the transposition of legislation into national law by the member states. They believe that it raises their costs, whilst the European Commission believes that these additions interfere with European policy.
The concerns are such that 50 civil society organisations, including trade unions, environmental groups and the BEUC, have launched a monitoring network to ensure that private interests do not take precedence over the public interest. They point to the possible risks for the future of social, environmental and wage standards, consumer protection, financial regulation and public health."
Detention of asylum-seekers: the first CJEU judgment (EU Law Analysis, link):
One of the most controversial aspects of immigration and asylum law is the detention of migrants: people who have broken no criminal law (other than, possibly a criminal law about migration control) but who are detained during their asylum application, or pending their removal from the country. The EU has had rules on detention of irregular migrants for some time, in the Returns Directive (on the CJEUs interpretation of those rules, see my journal article here). But it has only recently had rules on the detention of asylum-seekers, in the second-phase Directive on the reception conditions for asylum-seekers. (The UK and Ireland have opted out of both Directives).
Recently, in the JN judgment, the CJEU ruled for the first time on the interpretation of these new rules...
the EUs refugee policies are obviously in a state of deep crisis. Rather than leave the issue entirely to populists at the EU or national level, it would be better for the EU ask a panel of respected international experts to recommend (quickly) how the EU, in the wider international context, should deal with the crisis. I would nominate (say) Mary Robinson, David Miliband, Madeline Albright and Carl Bildt for this task. In any event, we cannot go on as we are: the EU needs an asylum policy that is simultaneously fair, humane, realistic and coherent; but it is falling far short of that at the moment. "
UN: Joint report of the Special Rapporteur on the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association and the Special Rapporteur on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions on the proper management of assemblies (pdf)
See: UN experts provide a roadmap to avoid human rights violations during protests (link): "GENEVA Two United Nations human rights experts presented today a new report to the UN Human Rights Council offering extensive recommendations to States and police forces around the world on how best to manage public gatherings." And: Factsheet: Recommendations on managing assemblies (pdf)
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (9.3.16)
UNHCR Daily Report (9.3.16):
"In Izmir, Turkey, Greek Prime Minister, Alexis Tsipras chaired the fourth Greek-Turkish High-Level Cooperation Council with his Turkish counterpart Ahmet Davutoðlu. Transport, trade, tourism and the refugee issue were exceptionally added to the agenda. Tsipras and Davutoðlu signed the previously announced readmission agreement, according to which people who do not qualify for international protection in Greece will be returned to Turkey."
Comment: This would appear to mean that refugees will have to be brought ashore in Greece and due process undertaken to determine whether or not a person qualifies for international protection.
UNDERCOVER POLICING: Battle over secrecy at Pitchford Inquiry; campaigner confronts police spy who deceived her
As the Pitchford Inquiry into the practice of undercover police in England and Wales approaches, the police are hoping to have the possibility to submit secret evidence, and to continue to use the "neither confirm nor deny" response to crucial questions on their practices and activities.
On the other side of the globe, a campaigner has tracked down a former undercover officer, John Dines, who deceived her into a two-year relationship. Dines is now teaching police in Sydney, on a course that involves the topics "human rights" and "gender sensitivity". A New South Wales politician has stated that: "It is offensive in the extreme that John Dines can be involved in teaching these matters to police in this State."
Whats the Pitchford Hearing About? (Campaign Opposing Police Surveillance, link): "How much of the public inquiry into undercover policing will be held in secret? How much of the polices information will be revealed?"
International Network of Civil Liberties Organizations (INCLO) Launch Report on Crowd Control Weapons (ICCL, link): "Over the past number of years, law enforcement and security forces have increasingly turned to the use of crowd-control weapons (CCWs) to respond to popular protests. Today, the International Network of Civil Liberties Organizations (INCLO) and Physicians for Human Rights (PHR) release "Lethal in Disguise: The Health Consequences of Crowd-Control Weapons", a report documenting the health effects of these weapons. The report focuses on the dangers of so-called less lethal weapons, particularly when used to control or manage assemblies. It is unique in its format of linking medical literature and data on weapons health effects with case studies highlighting their human toll.
The report was launched at the United Nations in Geneva on the occasion of the presentation of a joint report on the proper management of assemblies, prepared by the Special Rapporteur on the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association, Maina Kiai, and the Special Rapporteur on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions, Christof Heyns. The Special Rapporteurs report was presented to the 31st session of the Human Rights Council."
Full report: Lethal in Disguise: The Health Consequences of Crowd-Control Weapons (pdf)
News Digest: round-up of news stories from across the EU (9.3.16)
Greece and Turkey intensify joint work on migrants (euobserver link): "Greek prime minister Alexis Tsipras met his Turkish counterpart Ahmet Davutoglu in Izmir on Tuesday and signed several agreements to pave the way for the EU-Turkey deal to work.
Tsipras told a joint news conference that the EU deal sends a clear message to migrants coming from third countries, rather than countries at war ... that there is neither the political will nor the ability to cross to Europe. [emphasis added]
Comment: This appears to mean that refugees from countries where there are ongoing conflicts - Syria, Irag and Afghanistan - will not be returend under these agreements.
Also: Europe finds no delight in Turkish deal - Planned deal with Turkey attacked from all sides (politico, link):
"German and EU leaders have portrayed the proposed arrangement as a major breakthrough; Europes best, possibly last, hope to bring the refugee crisis under control. But a broad spectrum of critics, from national and European MPs, to the UNs refugee agency to Amnesty International, assailed the plan, arguing it would force the EU to abandon its core principles.
Clearly, Europe is willing to do anything, including compromising essential human rights and refugee law principles, to stem the flow of refugees and migrants to Europe, Aurelie Ponthieu, a top official at Doctors Without Borders, said in a statement." [emphasis added]
Opinion: Inching toward a Fortress Europe (DW, link): "Turkey is demanding an ever-higher price for its cooperation in fending off refugees. As long as they stop the influx, Europeans are prepared to accept any legal fig leaf held up by Ankara, says Barbara Wesel.
In Germany an asylum seeker has the right to an assessment of one's individual reasons for fleeing, and the EU is obliged to uphold the rules of the Geneva Convention. But none of that matters when the only goal is to bring the number of refugees down to zero. We are moving ever closer to the ideal of rightwing populists - a Fortress Europe.
Now that the EU has taken in a million refugees, it is willing to enter into an unsavory agreement with Turkey, putting its own future on the line, while raising the drawbridges at its borders. It is a pathetic spectacle in every respect."
EU: Enhancing and diluting the legal status of subsidiary protection beneficiaries under Union law the CJEU judgment in Alo and Osso (EU Law Analysis, link):
"Is it in accordance with the Qualification Directive (QD) to restrict the freedom of movement within the host country of beneficiaries of subsidiary protection (a form of protection parallel to refugee status) in receipt of social security benefits? This question was addressed by the CJEU in its ruling of 1 March 2015 in the Alo and Osso case. The Courts answer and its reasoning is equally interesting, groundbreaking and controversial as it, on the one hand, strengthens the impact of the Geneva Convention (the United Nations Convention on the Status of Refugees on the QD standards and the substantive content of subsidiary protection while it, on the other hand, creates uncertainty about the applicable non-discrimination standard in such cases."
EU: MEPs refuse to vote on PNR before Council strengthens data protection (euractiv, link): "A joint initiative of the conservative EPP and the ECR groups, the proposal to place the PNR on the agenda of the current plenary session was rejected by virtually all the other political families. They fear a vote on PNR may allow member states to abandon the personal data protection package they have promised as a counterweight to the new surveillance powers." and
MEPs at war over blocked PNR vote (Parliament Magazine, link): "Parliamentary groups accuse each other of playing 'dirty political games' after request to include PNR in plenary voting agenda denied."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (8.3.16)
EU-Turkey deal could see Syrian refugees back in war zones, says UN (Guardian, link):
"Refugees chief questions legality of agreement to send people back to Turkey without guarantees for their protection. A senior UN official says he is very concerned that a hasty EU deal with Turkey could leave Syrian refugees unprotected and at risk of being sent back to a war zone.
Filippo Grandi, the UN high commissioner for refugees , questioned the legality of an outline deal struck by the EU and Turkey. As a first reaction I am deeply concerned about any arrangement that would involve the blanket return of anyone from one country to another, without spelling out the refugee protection safeguards under international law, he said on Tuesday....
Speaking to the European parliament in Strasbourg, Grandi said asylum seekers should only be returned to other states if there was a guarantee that that they would not then be sent back to the place they had fled."
EU-USA: U.S.-EU Cooperation Against Terrorism (CRS, pdf):
"Congressional decisions related to data privacy, intelligence-gathering, border controls, visa policy, and transport security may affect how future U.S.-EU counterterrorism cooperation evolves. EU officials have welcomed passage of the Judicial Redress Act (P.L. 114-126) to provide EU citizens with a limited right of judicial redress for privacy violations in a law enforcement context, but they have expressed unease with some provisions in the Visa Waiver Program Improvement and Terrorist Travel Prevention Act of 2015 (passed as part of P.L. 114-113 in the wake of the Paris attacks and heightened U.S. concerns about European citizens fighting with terrorist groups abroad).
Given the European Parliaments growing influence in many of these policy areas, Members of Congress may be able to help shape the Parliaments views and responses through ongoing contacts and the existing Transatlantic Legislators Dialogue (TLD)."
UNHCR's reaction to Statement of the EU Heads of State and Government of Turkey, 7 March (lpdf):
"As for the statement released yesterday after the meeting between EU and Turkey, UNHCR is not a party to it nor privy to all the details and modalities of implementation.
On the face of what appears to have been agreed, we are, however, concerned about any arrangement that involves the blanket return of all individuals from one country to another without sufficiently spelt out refugee protection safeguards in keeping with international obligations.
An asylum-seeker should only be returned to a third state, if (a) responsibility for assessing the particular asylum application in substance is assumed by the third country; (b) the asylum-seeker will be protected from refoulement; (c) the individual will be able to seek and, if recognized, enjoy asylum in accordance with accepted international standards, and have full and effective access to education, work, health care and, as necessary, social assistance.
Legal safeguards would need to govern any mechanism under which responsibility would be transferred for assessing an asylum claim. Pre-departure screening would also need to be in place to identify heightened risk categories that may not be appropriate for return even if the above conditions are met.
Details of all these safeguards should be clarified before the next meeting of the EU Council on 17 March." [emphasis added]
EU-USA: While President Obama signs the Judicial Redress act, are the European Commission and the Parliament sharing the same Umbrella? (EASFJ, link):
"The European Commission is dealing with challenges on another EU-U.S. data sharing deal: the Parliament legal service and MEPs argued that the so-called Umbrella Agreement, which will be brought into being with the signature of the Judicial Redress Act, does not comply with EU law."
EU REFUGEE CRISIS: UNHCR: 7.3.16: 141,930 arrivals in the EU: 132,177 in Greece, 9.295 in Italy. 410 dead/missing. 48% from Sytria, 25% from Afghanistan and 15% from Iraq - 88% of arrivals.
EU-TURKEY: Is the EU-Turkey deal even legal? Probably not, but who cares anymore!: Berlin/Ankara migration pact wrecking ball or silver bullet? (FT blog, link):
"Big legal doubts hang over this scheme. Rules on asylum are quite clear: all applications have to be properly considered, and an asylum seeker cannot be returned to a country that does not offer proper protection.
Returns to a country that is not a full member of the Geneva Convention, such as Turkey, would likely be illegal argue refugee groups.
Only Syrians have the right to claim some form of international protection in Turkey and even that does not equate to full refugee status. But others even those fleeing desperate circumstances in Iraq, Afghanistan or Eritrea have no such luck.
The EU will try to get around this obstacle by declaring that Turkey is a safe third country, which given the state of its asylum system is highly debatable, and appears to contradict the blocs own rules. Despite its legal fragility, this proposal would only give the EU a legal basis to return Syrians to Turkey: it would not cover non-Syrian asylum seekers." [emphasis added]
EU-TURKEY SUMMIT: Statement of the EU Heads of State or Government: 07/03/2016 (pdf):
"Turkey confirmed its commitment in implementing the bilateral Greek-Turkish readmission agreement to accept the rapid return of all migrants not in need of international protection crossing from Turkey into Greece and to take back all irregular migrants apprehended on Turkish waters."
assistance to Greece in managing the external borders, including those with the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia and Albania, and ensuring the proper functioning of hotspots, with 100% identification, registration and security checks, and the provision of sufficient reception capacities..
assist Greece in ensuring comprehensive, large scale and fast-track returns to Turkey of all irregular migrants not in need of international protection, building on the Greece-Turkey readmission agreement and, from 1 June, the EU-Turkey readmission agreement;" [emphasis added]
Comment: The last two statements appear to mean that refugees will be brought ashore into Greece and not immediately returned without due process as some statements to the media have suggesred.
CoE: Commissioner for Human Rights: Human rights of refugee and migrant women and girls need to be better protected (link):
"For the first time since the beginning of the refugee and migrant crisis in Europe, women and children on the move outnumber adult men. While in 2015 about 70 % of the population on the move were men, women and children now make up nearly 60% of refugees and other migrants crossing into Europe. This also means that more women and children risk and lose their lives in the Mediterranean Sea and on the land routes to Europe. Of more than 360 persons who died in the Mediterranean in January 2016, one third were women and children."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (7.3.16)
Guardian as it happens reporting on theEU-Turkey: Summit (link)
"As if by magic, Tusk and his allies seek to end the European refugee crisis in two clean movements.
First: by rubber-stamping the closure of the Macedonian-Greek border, where hundreds of thousands of refugees have crossed in the past year in their march northwards towards northern Europe. Second: by strong-arming Turkey into readmitting most if not all of the asylum-seekers who continue to land on the Greek islands in their thousands every day.
Tusks logic is straightforward. If the Macedonian border can be shut, then the crisis can be contained in Greece. And if refugees can be returned to Turkey, then the damage wrought on cash-strapped Greece will in turn become manageable. Even if Tusks plan has obvious moral implications it risks undermining the 1951 refugee convention, which was one of the seminal human achievements of the post-Holocaust era one can understand its practical appeal for European politicians.
But as has become familiar throughout this migration crisis, the logic of Europes leadership does not acknowledge the reality on the ground.
and: "Germany is the other key wrinkle in the summit agreement.
German chancellor Angela Merkel is resisting a push to declare the refugee route across the Balkans closed, endorsing the policy of border closures by Austria and Greeces Balkan neighbours.
For all countries, including Greece, closing anything is not an option, Merkel said as she arrived at the summit.
Summit chairman Donald Tusk had proposed an EU endorsement of border closures on the route north from Greece, with a draft EU statement saying: Irregular flows of migrants along the Western Balkans route are coming to an end; this route is now closed.
Also: Merkel unhappy with draft statement on 'closed' Balkan route, reports say (ekathimerini.com, link): "
EU-TURKEY: Meeting of the EU Heads of State or Government (Brussels, 7 March 2016) - Draft statement (6 March 2016, SN26/16, pdf):
"Action is required along the following lines:
a) provide an immediate and effective response to the very difficult humanitarian situation which is rapidly developing on the ground...
b) provide further assistance to Greece in managing the external borders, including those with fYROM and Albania, and ensuring the proper functioning of hotspots, with 100% identification, registration and security checks, and the provision of sufficient reception capacities...
c) assist Greece in ensuring comprehensive, large scale and fast-track returns to Turkey of all irregular migrants not in need of international protection, building on the Greece-Turkey readmission agreement and, from 1 June, the EU-Turkey readmission agreement;
d) accelerate the implementation of relocation to alleviate the heavy burden that presently weighs
e) continue to cooperate closely with the non-EU countries of the Western Balkans and provide any necessary assistance...
f) implement the existing resettlement commitments and continue work on a credible voluntary humanitarian admission programme with Turkey...
g) take any necessary measures immediately in respect of any new routes opening up, and step up the fight against smugglers;
h) take forward, as a matter of priority, all the elements of the Commission roadmap on getting "back to Schengen", so as to end temporary internal border controls and re-establish the normal functioning of the Schengen area before the end of the year."
Afghanistan: EU shuts the door despite asylum recognition rates rising from 43% to 60%
EU policy on which refugees should be given international protection and relocation within the EU has changed numerous times since last year. In autumn 2015, the agreed policy was to recognise people coming from Syria, Iraq and Eritrea - based, then, on a 75% recognition rate in Eurostat statistics. This changed in practice in January to offering relocation to refugees from Syrai, Iraq and Afghanistan - countries where there are ongoing conflicts. Then in February, under pressure from Germany and Austria, Macedonia and Serbia only accepted refugees from Syria and Iraq - turning back those from Afghanistan. Yet EU institutions and Member States "are aware of the worsening security situation and threats to which people are exposed," as a leaked document from the European Commission and European External Action Service (EEAS) reveals.
See: Joint Commission-EEAS non-paper on enhancing cooperation on migration, mobility and readmission with Afghanistan - Country Fiche proposing possible leverages across Commission-EEAS policy areas to enhance returns and effectively implement readmission commitments (Doc no: 6738-16, 3 March 2016, pdf)
EU: Refugee crisis: NATO Secretary General welcomes expansion of NATO deployment in the Aegean Sea (NATO, link): " NATO took swift decisions to deploy ships to the Aegean Sea to support our Allies Greece and Turkey, as well as the EU's border agency FRONTEX, in their efforts to tackle the migrant and refugee crisis. NATO ships are already collecting information and conducting monitoring in the Aegean Sea. Their activity will now be expanded to take place also in territorial waters."
Some critical comments: NATO Expands Aegean Sea Migrant Patrols Into Turkish and Greek Territorial Waters Rescued Migrants to Be Automatically Returned to Turkey (Migrants at Sea, link)
And see: Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (7.3.16)
EU: Proposed new counter-terrorism law: Joint NGO critique (pdf): "In this submission, Amnesty International, the International Commission of Jurists (ICJ), and the Open Society Justice Initiative (OSJI) and the Open Society European Policy Institute (OSEPI) analyse and offer recommendations on the European Commissions December 2015 proposal for a Directive on Combating Terrorism and Replacing Council Framework Decision 2002/475/JHA on Combating Terrorism (the proposed Directive) in light of Member States obligations under international law, in particular international human rights law...
This submission seeks to specifically address:
- The failure to provide sufficient guarantees of human rights protection in the implementation of the Directive by Member States;
- The overbroad scope and vague delineation of many of the offences to be established under the Directive, with consequences for the principle of legality and the prohibitions on arbitrary, disproportionate and discriminatory interference with human rights;
- The designation of ancillary and inchoate offences with a low degree of proximity to the principal offence of commission of a terrorism-related act;
- The imprecise definition of the specific intent required to incur responsibility for a number of offences and lack of requirements for wilful or voluntary conduct;
- The potential of the Directive to undermine states obligations under international humanitarian law and international criminal law, where those regimes are applicable."
EU: Council questioned over CIA rendition programme
The European Parliament's civil liberties committee (LIBE) has submitted a number of questions to the Council of the EU over its work in relation to the CIA rendition programme. The committee is seeking answers on, amongst other things:
- whether the Council has apologised for providing incomplete information to the Parliament on meetings with US officials;
- whether the Council has formally acknowledged Member States' involvement in the rendition programme; and
- whether the Council has cooperated fully with "the truth-finding and accountability processes in the Member States".
The questions were tabled on 2 March. The Council is yet to respond.
See: Question for oral answer to the Council submitted by Claude Moraes, on behalf of the committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs: Follow-up to the resolution of Parliament of 11 February 2015 on the US Senate report on the use of torture by the CIA (2014/2997(RSP)) (pdf) and on the European Parliament website (link).
UK: Shortage of asylum seeker accommodation and "appalling" prejudice, says report (parliament.uk): "The Commons Home Affairs Committee says the red doors and wrist bands scandals leave major questions to be answered about the running of the COMPASS contract providing asylum support services. It says delivery of the contract has been mostly unsatisfactory to date, with these episodes highlighting flaws in accountability and oversight of the contracts, and a failure to ensure that the way asylum seekers are treated and housed meets basic standards.
The Committee also warns of an impending shortage of asylum seeker accommodation and a lack of fair and equal dispersal throughout the country."
The report: House of Commons Home Affairs Committee: The work of the Immigration Directorates (Q3 2015) (pdf)
UK: Government report: The process for withdrawing from the European Union (pdf): "This document sets out the process that would follow a vote to leave the European Union, and the prospects for negotiations. Alternative models for the UKs relationship with the EU after exit will be examined in a second document."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (News and lots of key documents: 3-4.3.16)
Council of the European Union: C-T Directive, Checks at borders, Border Guards and Vienna Declaration
- Counter Terrorism Directive: Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on combating terrorism and replacing Council Framework Decision 2002/475/JHA on combating terrorism [First reading] - General approach (6655-16, pdf):
"The Council is invited to reach a general approach on the text, as set out in the Annex, which will constitute the basis for future negotiations with the European Parliament in the context of the ordinary legislative procedure. Changes compared to the Commission proposal are marked in bold."
- EU Counter-Terrorism Coordinator: State of play on implementation of the statement of the Members of the European Council of 12 February 2015, the JHA Council Conclusions of 20 November 2015, and the Conclusions of the European Council of 18 December 2015 (LIMITE doc no: 6450-16, pdf):
"information sharing still does not reflect the threat: while there are now five times more person entities in Europol's Focal Point Travellers database compared with last year, the analysis file still contains only 2,786 verified foreign terrorist fighters (FTF) entered by EU Member States.
The European Information System (EIS) contains only 1,473 FTF entered by Member States. This despite well-founded estimates that around 5,000 EU citizens have travelled to Syria and Iraq to join DAESH and other extremist groups. It should also be noted that more than 90% of the contributions by Member States regarding verified FTFs in FP Travellers in 2015 originate from just 5 Member States."
- Checks at external borders: Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council amending Regulation (EC) No 562/2006 as regards the reinforcement of checks against relevant databases at external borders - General approach (6673-16, pdf):
"The changes vis-à-vis the Commission proposal are highlighted in underline."
- EU Border Guards: Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on the European Border and Coast Guard and repealing Regulation (EC) No 2007/2004, Regulation (EC) No 863/2007 and Council Decision 2005/267/EC (LIMITE doc no: 6746-16, dated 3 March 2016, pdf): "It is noted that the new (vis-à-vis doc. 6483/16) proposed changes are highlighted in bold, underline and strikethrough."
- EU Border Guards: As above 6483-16 (LIMITE doc, pdf):
"The most recent compromise suggestions reflecting the discussions so far on these provisions and the relevant contributions by delegations are highlighted in bold/underline/strikethrough; the compromise suggestions which had been submitted by the Presidency in previous discussions are marked with underline."
- EU Border Guards: As above: 6359-REV-1-16 (pdf):
"the Presidency believes that the compromise text included in the Annex and in 6283/16 and 6330/16 has a sufficient degree of support by delegations. It invites the Committee to confirm this with a view to preparing the upcoming negotiations with the European Parliament on this file."
- Declaration agreed by Croatia, Slovenia and Austria: Conference "Managing Migration Together", Vienna, 24 February 2016 (6481-16, pdf)
Are there no limits to irresponsble EU statements? Remarks by President Donald Tusk after his meeting in Ankara with Prime Minister Ahmet Davutoðlu (pdf):: EU Council President Donald Tusk:
"To many in Europe the most promising method seems to be a fast and large-scale mechanism to ship back irregular migrants arriving in Greece" [emphasis added]
EU: European Commission reports prior to 7 March EU-Turkey Summit:
- Progress report on the implementation of the hotspot approach in Greece (COM 141-16, pdf)
- EU-Turkey Joint Action Plan - Third implementation report (pdf)
- Back to Schengen - A Roadmap (pdf) and Annexes (pdf)
- Second Report on progress by Turkey in fulfilling the requirements of its visa liberalisation roadmap (pdf)
And see: Commission Timetable (pdf)
Also: RELOCATION (state of play as of 03 March 2016) (pdf)
Since September 2015 only 335 refugees from Italy have been relocated in the EU and only 322 from Greece. 160,000 relocation palces were asked for but only 17 Member States promised just 4,237 places to Greece and Italy.
It appears that the Commission is no longer presenting regular updates on its plans: see:State of Play: Measures to Address the Refugee Crisis (1.2.16, pdf).
EU closes on migrant deal with Turkey (FT,.link)
"The EU is close to a breakthrough deal with Ankara that would see all non-Syrian migrants reaching Greek islands returned to Turkey, marking a crucial step in the blocs hardening stance against the flow of people pouring into its territories.
After weeks of diplomatic pressure from Berlin and Brussels, Ahmet Davutoglu, the Turkish prime minister, privately signalled in negotiations on Thursday that Ankara will accept the systematic returns of non-Syrians and step up action against smugglers.....
Two diplomats familiar with the discussion on Thursday said Turkey also agreed to accept all migrants rescued in international waters by a Nato mission a sensitive issue that had held-up progress on the operation. "
Or: Dont expect big decisions from EU-Turkey summit, say diplomats (euractiv, link):
"EXCLUSIVE / No official decision is expected to be made during an EU-Turkey summit on Monday (7 March) dedicated to the refugee crisis, due to the upcoming German state elections, diplomats told...
Germany prefers that the EU-Turkey summit remains low-profile and that it doesnt impact on the vote, EurActiv was told. Consequently the summit of EU leaders with Turkish Premier Ahmet Davutoglu will be an informal meeting, where no official decision is expected to be made and no summit conclusions will be adopted."
Or: EU asking Turkey to take back migrants (euobserver, link): "In its effort to reduce the flow of migrants coming to Europe, the EU is now focusing on sending back economic migrants to Turkey.
"To many in Europe, the most promising method seems to be a fast and large-scale mechanism to ship back irregular migrants arriving in Greece," European Council president Donald Tusk said on Thursday (3 March) in Ankara. "It would effectively break the busines model of the smugglers," he said"
Or: EU mulls 'large-scale' migrant deportation scheme (ekathimerini.com, link): ""We agree that the refugee flows still remain far too high," Tusk said after meeting Turkish Prime Minister Ahmet Davutoglu.
"To many in Europe, the most promising method seems to be a fast and large-scale mechanism to ship back irregular migrants arriving in Greece. It would effectively break the business model of the smugglers."
Tusk was careful to single out illegal economic migrants for possible deportation, not asylum-seekers. And he wasn't clear who would actually carry out the expulsions: Greece itself, EU border agency Frontex or even other organizations like NATO."
UNHCR: 6 steps towards solving the refugee situation in Europe (link):
"Ahead of a meeting of heads of state or government of the European Union (EU) with Turkey on 7 March in Brussels, UNHCR, the UN Refugee Agency, has today issued recommendations aimed at helping States solve the refugee situation in Europe.
"We are running out of time, and strong leadership and vision are urgently needed from European leaders to deal with what is, in our view, a situation that can still be managed if properly addressed," said UN High Commissioner for Refugees Filippo Grandi. "This is as much a crisis of European solidarity as it is a refugee crisis. The collective failure to implement the measures agreed by EU Member States in the past has led to the current escalation in the crisis," he added.
And see: UNHCR: Stabilizing the situation of refugees and migrants in Europe: Proposals to the Meeting of EU Heads of State or Government and Turkey on 7 March 2016 (pdf)
EU-PNR: MEP vote on EU passenger record delayed (euobserver, link): "MEPs delayed a vote to adopt the EU passenger names record (PNR). The bill was set for adoption next week but left-wing parties opposed putting the the vote on the agenda. EU PNR will sweep up personal details of commercial airline passengers in an effort to fight terrorism and crime."
Greece: Electra Leda Koutra (Facebook, link) writes:
"The Ministry of Migration confirms and provides clarifications for the banning of reporters in hotspots anounced by the Ministry of Interior's Press Release, providing us also with the reasoning of such a decision - the employees have (allegedly) asked for that, because they have too much work
They go further expanding the banning, by informing us through the press that not only reporters, but also NGO representatives and researchers from universities will no longer be admitted.
This is a breach of art.10 ECHR, against groups of people able to document atrocities =usually falling within the ambit of the term "human rights defenders". Restriction in the exercise of rights should be prescribed by law and be proportionate to the aim pursued.
But these are wild times, so we are currently attempting to "regulate social behavior" through... press releases. Besides the fact that a ministry poses restrictions that another ministry subsequently clarifies, it is a 3rd ministry, that of National Defense, that has been declared by Law, for a week now, as responsible for the direction and coordination of hotspots.
The above is indicative of chaos reigning, but also of "military aesthetics" around the "management" of the humanitarian crisis in Greece. I wouldn't be surprised if the Min.of Defence, in exercise of its new duties, among which "the direction and coordination of other national authorities and NGOs dealing with the assistance of refugees in hotspots", imposed the ban."
See Statewatch: NGOs and volunteers helping refugees in Greece to be placed under state control
UK: Right To Remain's new Toolkit is on line: (link):
"The Right to Remain Toolkit is a unique guide to the UK immigration and asylum system, with actions you can take in support of your claim, or to help someone else.
The Toolkit is needed more than ever - the asylum and immigration system is increasingly complicated, and there are more legal and procedural barriers to establishing the legal right to remain and accessing justice than ever.
We have just launched the brand new edition of our Toolkit, made possible thanks to the amazing public support we received in our crowdfunding appeal: we raised more than £8000 in donations."
EU Council President: EU's Tusk defends use of barbed wire against refugees (worldbulletin.net, link):
"EU president Donald Tusk on Wednesday defended the use of barbed-wire fences against refugees, saying that securing the outer borders of Europe's passport-free Schengen area was a "pre-condition" to solving the refugee crisis.
"I'm convinced that... back to Schengen is a pre-condition for this European solution to the migration crisis," Tusk said in Slovenia as part of a multi-country tour ending in Turkey later this week.
Asked about barbed wire fences, Tusk said: "I'm afraid that sometimes you need tougher measures if you, we want really to apply Schengen. Sorry but this is the reality."
European Parliament: Report on the proposal for a directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on procedural safeguards for children suspected or accused in criminal proceedings: Committee on Civil Liberties, Justice and Home Affairs Rapporteur: Caterina Chinnici (pdf)
EU-USA: NSA can still spy under new Privacy Shield agreement with Europe (Yahoo News, link):
"The new Privacy Shield was published in full a few days ago, showing the principles that would govern the exchange of digital information between EU consumers and U.S. companies. However, the new agreement also has provisions that explain how and when the NSA can continue bulk data collection in the region."
Refugee crisis: latest news from across Europe (2.3.16)
Greece: Lesvos: Registering of NGOs, personal details of their workers/volunteers and independent volunteers begins
Tony Bunyan, Statewatch Director, comments: "We stand by our view that this practice has no place in a democracy worthy of the name"
See: NGOs and volunteers helping refugees in Greece to be placed under state control
Only in the Soviet Union and under the STASI in East Germany were NGOs expected to hand over lists and personal details of all their members/volunteers
- "In particular there should be no attempts by public authorities to make NGOs effectively agencies working under their control.." (Council of Europe)
Lesvos General Coordination meeting (25.2.16): "Mr. Yiannis Yiannelis, the Secretary General for the Aegean and Island Policy answered the questions of the audience on the registration process and on the forms that are now available in both Greek and English for individual volunteers and NGOs.
He thanked the NGOs and volunteers for their efforts in assisting in the humanitarian response, while stressing the necessity to complete the registration procedure, so work and staff of NGOs or volunteers are known to the authorities." [emphasis added]
See: Statement on the registering of NGOs and volunteers: Secretariat General for the Aegean and Island Policy Coordinating Committee (pdf)
"According to the Joint Decision of Minister of Interior Policy and Administrative Reconstruction and Minister of Marine and Island Policy (Government Gazette 114 / B/28-1-2016) a Coordination Committee has been established in order to register, coordinate and evaluate the Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs), Voluntary Groups and independent volunteers who are active on Lesvos island.
The Committee has the following activities:
Registration, identification and accreditation of all NGOs and independent volunteers who are active on Lesvos Island in order