• Home /
• SEMDOC /
• Legislative observatory /
• Migration, asylum, borders and visas (Title IV EC) /
• Case Law /
• Infringement actions

Infringement actions

[Infringement actions - Migration, asylum, borders & visas (Title IV EC)]

[cases brought against: 6 original MS, plus plus UK, Greece, Spain, Portugal, Austria, Hungary, Malta]

Decided cases

C-454/04 Commission v Luxembourg
- concerns: Directive 2001/55 (OJ 2004 C 314)
- judgment against Luxembourg 2 June 2005

C-449/04 Commission v Luxembourg 
- concerns: Directive 2001/51 (OJ 2004 C 314)
- judgment against Luxembourg 21 July 2005

C-462/04 Commission v Italy
- concerns: Directive 2001/40 (OJ 2005 C 6/30)
- judgment largely supporting Commission 8 Sept. 2005

C-448/04 Commission v Luxembourg:
- concerns: Directive 2001/40 (OJ 2005 C 6/30)
- judgment largely supporting Commission 8 Sept. 2005

C-476/04 Commission v Greece
- concerns: Directive 2001/55 (OJ 2004 C 314)
- judgment against Greece 17 Nov. 2005

C-455/04 Commission v UK
- concerns: Directive 2001/55 (OJ 2004 C 314)
- judgment against UK 23 Feb. 2006

C-102/06 Commission v Austria
- concerns: Directive 2003/9
- judgment against Austria 26 Oct. 2006

C-48/06 Commission v Luxembourg
- concerns: Directive 2002/90
- judgment against Luxembourg, 7 Dec. 2006

C-72/06 Commission v Greece
- concerns: Directive 2003/9
-judgment against Greece, 19 April 2007

C-4/07 Commission v Portugal
- concerns: Directive 2003/110
- judgment against Portugal, 27 Sep. 2007

C-5/07 Commission v Portugal
- concerns: Directive 2003/109
- judgment against Portugal, 27 Sep. 2007

C-3/07 Commission v Belgium
- concerns: Directive 2003/110
- judgment largely against Belgium, 8 Nov. 2007

C-59/07 Commission v Spain
- concerns: Directive 2003/109
- judgment against Spain, 15 Nov. 2007

C-34/07 Commission v Luxembourg
- concerns: Directive 2003/109
- judgment against Luxembourg 29 Nov. 2007

C-57/07 Commission v Luxembourg
- concerns: Directive 2003/86
- judgment against Luxembourg, 6 Dec. 2007

C-58/07 Commission v Spain
- concerns: Directive 2003/110
- judgment against Spain, 14 Feb. 2008

C-293/08 Commission v Finland
- concerns: non-transposition of Directive 2004/83
- judgment against Finland, 5 Feb. 2009

C-256/08 Commission v UK
- concerns: non-transposition of Directive 2004/83
- judgment against UK, 30 April 2009

C-266/08 Commission v Spain
- concerns: non-transposition of Directive 2004/81
- judgment against Spain, 14 May 2009

C-322/08 Commission v Sweden
- concerns: non-transposition of Directive 2004/83
- judgment against Sweden, 14 May 2009

C-272/08 Commission v Spain
- concerns: non-transposition of Directive 2004/83
- judgment 9 July 2009

C-523/08 Commission v Spain
- non-transposition of Directive 2005/71; judgment 11 Feb. 2010

C-431/10 Commission v Ireland
- non-transposition of Directive 2005/85; judgment 7 April 2011

Withdrawn

C-460/04 Commission v Netherlands
- concerns: Directive 2001/51 (OJ 2004 C 314)
- withdrawn 23 Feb. 2005

C-474/04 Commission v Greece
- concerns: Directive 2001/40 (OJ 2004 C 314)
- withdrawn 9 March 2005

C-515/04 Commission v Belgium
- concerns: Directive 2001/55 (OJ 2005 C 31)
- withdrawn 11 July 2005

C-516/04 Commission v Belgium
- concerns: Directive 2001/55 (OJ 2005 C 31)
 - withdrawn 8 April 2005

C-450/04 Commission v France
- concerns: Directive 2001/40 (OJ 2004 C 314)
- withdrawn 29 Sept. 2005

C-461/04 Commission v Netherlands
- concerns: Directive 2001/55 (OJ 2005 C 314)
- withdrawn 16 Nov. 2005

C-451/04 Commission v France
- concerns: Directive 2001/55 (OJ 2005 C 314)
- withdrawn 30 Jan. 2006

C-47/06 Commission v Luxembourg
- concerns: Directive 2003/9

C-75/06 Commission v Portugal
- concerns: Directive 2003/9

C-51/07 Commission v Luxembourg
- concerns: Directive 2003/110

C-91/07 Commission v Italy
- concerns: Directive 2003/86

C-104/07 Commission v Italy
- concerns: Directive 2003/109

C-29/07 Commission v Greece
- concerns: Directive 2003/110

C-79/07 Commission v Malta
- concerns: Directive 2003/110

C-86/07 Commission v Italy
- concerns: Directive 2003/110

C-87/07 Commission v Malta
- concerns: Directive 2003/86

C-389/06 Commission v Belgium
- concerns: Directive 2003/9
- withdrawn 11 Sep. 2007

C-37/07 Commission v France
- concerns: Directive 2003/109
- withdrawn 12 Sep. 2007

C-30/07 Commission v Hungary
- concerns: Directive 2003/109

C-496/06 Commission v Germany
- concerns: Directive 2003/9
- withdrawn 21 Jan. 2008

C-192/07 Commission v Germany
- concerns: Directive 2003/86
- withdrawn 24 Jan. 2008
 
C-485/06 Commission v Germany
- concerns: Directive 2002/90
- withdrawn 13 Feb. 2008

C-216/07 Commission v Germany
- concerns: Directive 2003/110- withdrawn 13 Feb. 2008

C-130/08 Commission v Greece
- concerns correct interpretation of Dublin II Regulation
- withdrawn 22 Oct. 2008

C-191/08 Commission v Portugal
- non-transposition of Directive 2004/83
- withdrawn Nov. 2008

C-190/08 Commission v Netherlands
- non-transposition of Directive 2004/83
- withdrawn 25 Nov. 2008

C-220/08 Commission v Greece
- non-transposition of Directive 2004/83
- withdrawn 26 Nov. 2008 

C-209/08 Commission v Luxembourg
- non-transposition of Directive 2004/81
- withdrawn 23 Dec. 2008

C-269/08 Commission v Malta
- non-transposition of Directive 2004/83
- withdrawn 5 Feb. 2009

C-496/09 Commission v Italy
- non-transposition of Regulation 1030/2002
- withdrawn 17 Nov. 2010

C-304/10 Commission v Poland
- non-transposition of Directive 2004/82
- withdrawn 18 Jan. 2011

C-568/10 Commission v Austria
- incorrect application of Directive 2004/114
- withdrawn 22 Nov. 2011