• Home /
• Statewatch Database /
• Court cases decline

Court cases decline

01 January 1991

Court cases decline
artdoc May=1993

The `biggest decline for 30 years in the number of court cases',
according to the latest figures from the Attorney-General, is
alleged to have been engineered largely by cost-cutting.
Reductions in cases of up to 20% coincide with the release of a
paper of the Criminal Justice Consultation Committee circulated
to magistrates' courts, warning of the `substantial cost
implications for the CPS, the courts and the legal aid fund' of
magistrates' decisions to commit cases to the Crown court, and
quoting Home Office research claiming that 60% of cases committed
for jury trial could have been dealt with by magistrates.
While the decline in cases has been attributed to an increase in
police cautions and a fall in police morale, leading to a decline
in arrests, NAPO assistant general secretary Harry Fletcher
pointed to an increase in plea-bargaining and a 75% drop in the
number of cases sent to the Crown court, and said: `We are seeing
an increasingly cost-driven criminal justice system. The fear
must be that as cost and market forces become paramount, the
issue of justice becomes blurred, even lost.'
The vast majority of criminal cases are dealt with in the
magistrates' courts, and magistrates decide whether a particular
offence merits the grant of legal aid. There has been a dramatic
increase in legal aid refusals for cases such as minor assaults
and breach of the peace, leaving many thousands of defendants
unrepresented before magistrates, even though they could go to
prison. Guardian 1.4.93.

Statewatch vol 3 no 2 March-April 1993